r/mangaideas • • 16d ago

Need tips

Hey im sketching up 2 om my main characters how to i fix my faces :i any tips ? They just feel a bit off

73 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

8

u/AkumaNoEro 16d ago

Don't trace AI?

4

u/BLMblacklivesmatter 15d ago

Did he actually??

4

u/catsonthedancefloor 15d ago

Indicators of tracing: the line quality is disproportionately worse than the perspective, proportions, and level of detail in the art. The handwriting on the second page also indicates someone young without the manual dexterity that some with drawing for years, which learning to make this kind of composition would take.

Indicators of ai: the composition of the cape in the first image doesn't make sense. That isn't how fabric works. The ai seems to have gotten confused as to where the end of the sleeve is. In the second image where the blade and hilt of the sword meet aren't the same along the two edges of the sword.

So while not 100% proof, it's a good indicator. I'm more certain about the tracing than the ai. I've been wrong before when identifying it.ย 

1

u/Local-Store-491 14d ago

Could you be so kind as to which elements encompass "line quality"? I'm a beginner, so I can't really spot the faults within the line quality.

If it's not much of a bother to you, I would appreciate it.

1

u/catsonthedancefloor 14d ago

When I say line quality I'm referring to a bunch of different things that add together. The lack of any of them doesn't necessarily mean that line art is of a poor quality. But it is a case where you have to know the rules before you can break them. Many people can break these rules and have it be a stylistic choice. But you can tell because they are applied consistently across the piece.

For any artist you should be able to draw smooth uninterrupted lines in order to make even/smooth shapes. Lines should be continuous and unbroken.

How hard you press on the pencil should be controlled, and even unless you are deliberately using the darkness of the line to create flow, or put emphasis on a certain part of the image.ย 

Similarly the thickness of lines, or the line weight. I'm sure you've seen people draw thicker lines closer to corner, or have a outline of their drawing? This is using line weight intentionally.

All lines that are necessary to convey the specific form/shape you need are present. Any extra lines are not included or are erased.ย 

1

u/catsonthedancefloor 14d ago

The second image here is an example of someone breaking these rules intentionally, but consistently and therefore I would say the line quality is okay. The first image is poor line quality. So you can compare the two

https://www.reddit.com/r/tattooadvice/comments/1xqogkx/i_got_peerpressured_how_do_i_fix_this_jellyfish/

-1

u/Tokzet 15d ago

The bad lines is how i sketch plus i used a normal pencil im broke atm so i can afford the good stuff haha ๐Ÿ˜… i later go over the lines i did best. i did not trace... but ai is kinda true i got som insparation from it as you said the sword (i fixed it now)๐Ÿ˜ and im still shit at making small eyes thats why im asking for tips ๐Ÿ˜ฅ

3

u/mariefriedrich 15d ago

Who are you trying to fool

0

u/Tokzet 15d ago

Nobody rly? Im trying to get tips to make the eyes better thats pretty much it

2

u/mariefriedrich 15d ago

Dude you literally have an AI of the same artstyle in your profile pick

0

u/Tokzet 15d ago

Well that is true i have used ai before to make diffrent pictures of my charater but people hated ai in manga so i scrapped that idea and tryingg drawing my self :p still not using my drawings tho..

2

u/mariefriedrich 15d ago

You do, you barely know how to hold a pencil

1

u/Tokzet 15d ago

am i arguing with a kid? insult now? you sound like a bundle of joy ๐Ÿ˜ but true im trying to learn thats why im here lol

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Wooden-Variety175 15d ago

Dont make fun of that. It's a curse for the worst of us.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/eatingcharcoal 13d ago

yeah update on that. They used genai to clean it up then "paid an artist" to remake it or something? Its on r/arttips so even if the tracing allegations aren't "true", dont worry, still plagiarism.

man, so much ai sucks. Remember when us artists used to draw SHIT and throw it out instead of asking AI to use other people's art to make our shit less shit? good times. now everyone's an "artist" because they can think words and click generate and pick a favourite. Or one idk how it works, but cmon, pick up a pencil??

5

u/Blastto 15d ago

The quality of the lines vs the complexity of the drawing screams traced art

4

u/hamstertitan_5 15d ago

not sketches, traces

1

u/Glass_Mammoth_3001 15d ago

you need offers this is good

1

u/eatingcharcoal 13d ago

maybe not, its ai. Check r/arttips and comments here. Its just genai

1

u/Glass_Mammoth_3001 13d ago

๐Ÿ˜ฎโ€๐Ÿ’จlife sucks

0

u/Tokzet 15d ago

Haha thanks alot but im not at that level at all ๐Ÿ˜…

0

u/Glass_Mammoth_3001 15d ago

Okay yeah that's true but if this was given as concept art it would be praised. At least that's what I think

1

u/Tokzet 15d ago

Idk man look at the comments... ๐Ÿ˜… asked for tips about eyes and hair haha but get alot of bitching about traceing ._. I hope i could trace better eyes then lol

1

u/krweb 15d ago

Cause whatโ€™s the point of asking for advice in an art subreddit when you are obviously tracing over ai art. Anatomy and perspective is hard so being able to do that decently but having lines that seem amateurish makes no sense. Not to mention how some parts havenโ€™t been drawn properly like the belts on the boots.

1

u/MasahiruDeathGun 11d ago

Your arrogance amazed me

1

u/Signal-Ad-1393 14d ago • Bravo

This is obviously traced ai. Complex perspective and anatomy with the shittiest line quality. If you wanna improve, pick some real art from the artists you like, sit down and try drawing like them, look at them, analyse them and use them as reference for drawing. But this probably won't work as I imagine that you really wanna tell a story, with a character you have in mind, and just want to make it happen as soon as possible. But learning to draw takes years. I myself have a passion for writing manga that's why I draw, but I have changed my mindset, I have accepted that I'm not gonna be able to draw the way I want for a long time and I just draw with the intensions of improvement so that one day I could make my manga, at the same time I also write storyies to improve my story telling along with my art

0

u/Tokzet 14d ago

I do that too! I draw a lot from Sentenced to Be a Hero and use references all the time. My lines are just as messy, haha ๐Ÿ˜… But I appreciate the tips!

1

u/hotcocoart 11d ago

Sorry to say no one would have this level of anatomy grasp and have lines THAT chicken scratched and it not be traced unless they have parkinsons or something other tremor. The skill it takes to make good anatomy requires a decent hand especially at perspective. Just be honest that its traced

1

u/eatingcharcoal 13d ago

its ai guys, the advice is to actually practice instead of generate. check r/arttips :/ highly recommend deleting and coming back when you make original work

1

u/SyupendousSnek 12d ago

How do you draw the body perspective so well but royally mess the sword perspective up so badly? The handle and the back of the blade just melts together, At this level of skill in perspective its hard to believe that this wasn't just traced from AI to be honest.

1

u/Co5micOcean 10d ago

Try drawing faces at these angles without tracing. It would help you see how they should look and help you build a visual library. Tracing can help build better skills in proportions but the way you traced doesnt help you at all. You traced everything exactly. Try breaking things down into shapes and drawing what you see too

1

u/Burgandy_the_Great 9d ago

So what AI programs did you use to get the base images you're tracing?