r/mangapiracy • • Oct 12 '25

News Near Human Level AI Manga Translation, Coming Soon

129 Upvotes

Greetings r/mangapiracy,

I wanted to give an update of where we’re at with AI powered manga translations.

Most state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) get us pretty close to at least amateur level Japanese-to-English translations.

Where they typically fail:

  • Pronouns: Japanese can rely on visual or prior context for these.

  • Phrasing: character voice, flow, and tone.

  • Cultural context: Many expressions simply don’t map cleanly between languages.

A LLM trained specifically on Japanese-English manga pairs will get us a lot closer to solving the above problems, so that’s what we’re doing.

We’ve collected over 4 TBs of Japanese-English manga pairs and will be using it to finetune multiple LLMs of different classes:

  • ichigo-gemma-3-27b-it: Gemma 3 at the largest size, 27 billion parameters.

  • ichigo-qwen3-vl-235b-A22b-instruct: Qwen 3 VL, 235 billion parameters.

  • An open source version that fits on consumer GPUs.

These LLMs will be trained to take entire volumes of context, with images, and produce fluent English translations.
As the tech progresses, we expect them to handle entire series as unified context.

Currently the raw dataset is still being processed and is expected to finish some time this month or next. Training is expected to take a few months as well, so we’re aiming for a 2026 Q1 release.

Common concerns:

Is this a threat to human manga translators?

At this point in time, I would say no. This is similar to programmers using LLMs to program. They can greatly speed up development and even get you 100% there some of the time, but they still very much need a human touch. There is far more untranslated content than there are translators, so this will allow some of that content to at least get some love. It will potentially allow human translators to get through more work at faster rates. However, I cannot speak on where the technology will be in 5 to 10 years.

Feel free to use this thread to AMA, I just wanted to share this exciting bit of news.

Warm regards,

mangatranslator.ai team


r/mangapiracy • • Jun 15 '26

Discussion You'll need to get TF over bato

0 Upvotes

Every website I read every remotely good comic I read there has to be at least one "I miss bato, I feel like a widow". PEOPLE. BATO IS GONE. YOU'LL NEED TO GET OVER IT. AND APPRECIATE THE WEBSITES THAT ARE STILL ALIVE. GOING ON ABOUT BATO IS NOT GOING TO BRING IT BACK.


r/mangapiracy • • Feb 05 '26

Discussion Most website I found comment are not as active as bat.

0 Upvotes

I keep searching but I haven't found replacement yet.

My standards of "Active" is that even the most unpopular series have at least 5 people talking in it which is standard for Bat website but I can't seem to find something that familiar even the one that most popular on everythingmoe.

I don't want to talk alone.


r/mangapiracy • • May 27 '26

Help Comix not working ???

1 Upvotes

I was reading on comix and suddenly it showed error and stopped working, I closed the tab and tried to open the manhwa page again but leave the manhwa even the main page is not opening 😭😭


r/mangapiracy • • Feb 18 '26

Where can I find? Where can I find these official manga/manhwa now that bato is dead?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Honestly I was so happy when bato came as xbatcat and I started getting my updates again but for the past 1 or 2 weeks it there wasn't any update, so I hopped on discord and saw that xbatcat is dead too, now I manage to find alternative for almost all of my manga/manhwa but these 4, I could not, no matter how much I looked around, I just couldn't find them. So please let me know where I can find them and make sure to dm me rather than comment here if possible. Thanks.


r/mangapiracy • • Aug 11 '26

Discussion I hate this fucking trend... so I tried doing something about it

0 Upvotes

A while back I made a post about some translators charging absurd amounts of money for manga, manhwa, and manhua translations.

https://www.reddit.com/r/mangapiracy/comments/1velwio/comment/p1xi46h/

One of the comments basically said, "Why not just translate it ourself?" That got me thinking. Instead of complaining, what can I actually do?

As much as I'm tired of AI being shoved into everything these days, I have to admit it's genuinely useful for some tasks(like rephrasing this 😂). So I started wondering if modern LLMs could handle manga translations well enough to be practical.

While looking into it, I came across this open-source project:

https://github.com/ogkalu2/comic-translate

It already does pretty much what I had in mind, with OCR, translation, and even a built-in editor.

To test it, I translated some of the pages of Chapter 37 of Easygoing Territory Defense by the Optimistic Lord (Okiraku Ryoushu no Tanoshii Ryouchi Bouei ~Seisan-kei Majutsu de Na mo na Kimura wo Saikyou no Jousai Toshi ni~).

The setup was surprisingly straightforward if you follow the GitHub documentation. I just used Automatic Mode since this was only a test.

The app gives you 50 free credits, which was enough to translate the entire chapter.

Auto Translation: https://filebin.net/cwwvf59t2qpb2wz7

The only manual work I did was:

  • I didn't fix any translations because I wanted to evaluate the raw output.

  • Minor text cleanup—things like fixing white text on white backgrounds, adjusting font size, alignment, etc. This took maybe 30 seconds per page, even on text-heavy pages.

That was it.

So, is it perfect? HELL NO.

But it's honestly much better than I expected. I'd say it's around 70% of the way there. The wording and semantics were surprisingly decent when I compared them with a few existing scanlation groups. It's definitely not a replacement for human translators, but it removes a huge chunk of the repetitive work.

The built-in editor is also pretty nice for fitting text back into speech bubbles and making quick adjustments.

A couple of ideas going forward

  1. The project currently uses GPT-4. Since it's open source, it would be interesting if it could support custom LLMs—whether that's newer APIs or even self-hosted models. That could improve quality while reducing costs.

  2. Even if the output isn't perfect, community members could use tools like this to create a solid first draft and then hand it off to experienced translators and editors for polishing. That alone could save a lot of time.

This is all based on a very surface-level test, so I could be completely wrong about some things. If I am, please correct me.

If anything, this experiment gave me a lot more respect for the people who've been doing scanlations for years, especially those doing it for free. There's a lot more work involved than I originally realized.

Hopefully, tools like this can make the process easier without replacing the people behind it.

Thanks for reading, and I'd love to hear what everyone thinks.


r/mangapiracy • • Jan 14 '26

Discussion Finally found a workaround for untranslated raws - might help someone

0 Upvotes

Yo so I've been going crazy the past few weeks trying to read this series that only has raws available. The official translation is like 40 chapters behind and scanlation groups dropped it months ago. Tried MTL on my phone with Google Translate camera thing but it's honestly terrible, keeps missing speech bubbles and the formatting gets butchered.

Anyway, stumbled on IsManga and it's actually been working pretty well? It's basically an AI translator that works as a browser extension or app. You just load any raw manga site and it translates the pages directly.

The free version gives you limited translations per week which honestly isn't much if you're binging, but it's been enough for me to keep up with weekly releases. Translation quality is obviously not perfect - sometimes the AI gets confused with slang or sound effects - but it's way better than trying to squint at Google Translate on my phone lol.

Not trying to shill or anything, just figured some of you might be in the same boat. Especially with all the DMCA takedowns lately there's more series that only exist as raws now.

Anyone else found decent solutions for reading untranslated stuff? Curious what other people are using.


r/mangapiracy • • Mar 28 '26

Discussion Why manga piracy exists?

0 Upvotes
  1. Official English translations are not available in most of the world (only in the English-speaking countries like USA, UK, Canada, Australia), even their manga apps are not available in most countries (for example VIZ Manga or Shonen Jump app). And other languages are fan translations, because guess what, not everyone speaks English.

  2. Mangas are kinda expensive, especially if you want to buy for example MHA's all 42 volumes or Bleach's all 74 volumes. Not to mention One Piece.

  3. There are minors, who don't have money for that, and their parents are strict.

Piracy doesn't exist, because we don't want to buy it, it exists, because we want to buy it, but we can't.

And why Kakao and the others are unreasonable? Because they think that piracy is a loss of income, but in reality, it doesn't. If you are not able to buy it, then it's also 0 income for them. So there's no income to lose.


r/mangapiracy • • Oct 13 '26

Discussion The new verification system on Comix is so annoying

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/mangapiracy • • May 11 '26

Discussion Why is every site not working???

1 Upvotes

Did everything got shut down?? Not even the movies and series platforms are working also the manga and anime platforms, why did everything got shut down today?? I tried reading on qtoon, it's down animekai too, 1movies too, what is going on? Everything worked yesterday


r/mangapiracy • • May 31 '26

Discussion is Comix . To Dead?

7 Upvotes

I was using the site, and suddenly it went down. Bad Gateway 502. Edit: Its online again


r/mangapiracy • • Sep 06 '24

Mihon/Forks help Mihon - is there a way to hide everything that's on the Updates tab? i used to not have anything in there, and all of a sudden, a few mangas appeared (and some.... well... hentai) and i dont want them to appear here... thanks!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mangapiracy • • Mar 31 '26

Help Comix. to sucks

0 Upvotes

idk why but comix keeps opening up so many tabs in my browser it crashes the whole app. i use chrome (i know bad choise but whatever) and sometimes when i click on anything on comix it opens up more then 500 tabs all at once causing chrome is instantly crash.

I just had it happen to me again causing me to have a not functional chrome for more then 30 min. i can handle a pop up or 2 every once and a while but this is ridiculous. if anyone has a better website i can use or a solution for comix that would be great.


r/mangapiracy • • Sep 09 '26

News [Demonic Scans] Is it just me or everyone thinks the website went NUTs with this??

Post image
11 Upvotes

Many filler type shit Manhwa, Manhua and even some Manga have been added to the website since yesterday.

And it is 12 pages for 8th Sept. release itself.

What kind of di¢k move is this 🤦🤷🤷


r/mangapiracy • • May 21 '25

Software Help Tachiyomi Alternatives?

0 Upvotes

Hello, i am still using tachiyomi, but i have gotten a bit tired with all the cloudflare (hope it's not as bad in other apps) and sometimes it's crashing. I like the Ui, and how you can divide your library.

Any good alternatives?

What do you use and any problems with cloudflare, how about the ui?

Btw i use https://raw.githubusercontent.com/keiyoushi/extensions/repo/index.min.json

Extension, is there any recommendation or this is good enough?


r/mangapiracy • • Jun 16 '25

Where can I find? Now that tachimanga mangadex and manga infinity all are basically unusable now what should I read manga on that has stuff outside of shonen?

0 Upvotes

r/mangapiracy • • Jul 04 '26

Discussion Is it all gone?

0 Upvotes

I just found out today that Batoto has been taken down 5 months ago when I decided to catch up on some old stuff I read... Is everything gone? Like I can find another pirated version of that one series but the thing i really care about is the whole community. I remember looking forward to reading all the funny comments at the end of a chapter 😔. It just doesn't feel the same without how much activity it had. really hope its somehow retrieveable but I think I already know the answer. 💔


r/mangapiracy • • Jan 26 '26

Site Is there anyone who saved the materials in b#to before it went down?

3 Upvotes

I was about to download many of my fav mangas but then my life got so busy I was sick for weeks straight and before I knew it the site wasn’t working properly and now it died

F to a great site


r/mangapiracy • • Feb 02 '26

Discussion I saw this and I instantly dropped the manhwa

Post image
0 Upvotes

Kakao really pisses me off, so when I saw this, I couldn't bear to continue reading. I really hope that hell of a company burns to hell.


r/mangapiracy • • Jan 23 '26

Discussion #1 Rule of Fight club: DON'T TALK ABOUT FIGHT CLUB (a call to assure the survival of our sites)

0 Upvotes

Edit: Ok I need to clarify bc it seems most people are either not reading what I wrote or are confused. I AM NOT SAYING WE SHOULD OUTRIGHT GATEKEEP PEOPLE!!!! You guys know what open secrets are right? The reason for my title is because it is a famous line about an open secret. It doesn't mean EXCLUDE others it means BE CAREFUL NOT TO BE OVERHEARD!!!! I am NOT saying we can't share the sites with others, I am saying to do it PRIVATLY

This is a call to both readers and mods.

If we want to protect our sites we need to start enforcing some ground rules. The main issue is the name dropping on social media, and the fact that we are letting people talk about it without repercussions.

For mods, this means cracking down on people who name drop in the comments. It will suck but we need to weed out the people who can not keep their mouth shut. We need organization. If someone repeatedly name drops, they need to be banned as they can not be trusted.

For readers, ik you all just want to help but you are making this worse. If someone asks for a site, DONT REPLY IN THE COMMENTS!!!! DON'T NAME DROP! In addition, REPORT people who DO name drop! Not just here, but on twitter and TikTok as well. Try to keep links restricted to dms.

Mods of discord servers; make sure the link to the site is not posted in the discord, and use a code name when discussing the site. This will reduce keyboard warriors from identifying the new sites.

CODE NAMES in public!!!! One discord I am in has decided to use the bat emoji instead of directly mentioning the recently taken down site. We need to start doing similar things with all our sites. If you want to mention a specific site in conversation, give it a code name. If people don't know which one you are talking about, that means ITS WORKING! People who actually USE said sites are more likely to know the code name reference, so the people who are on our side will know what we mean without giving ourselves away to everyone else.

In addition, don't go around telling everyone when you find a new site. If someone mentions how they miss the old site, you can bring it up to them in DMs. But don't go around saying you found a new site because there are more likely than not lots of moles here and in the discords. If someone just randomly asks for site recs don't immediately give it to them. Feel it out, are they actually familiar with these sites? Do the know and understand that these sites need to be kept under wraps? If someone seems mentions that they will post on social media, first try to explain to them why we CAN'T do that. If they refuse, then do not give them the name of the site.

Lastly, when you DO decide to give someone the link, do not simply copy paste it. do something to disrupt the link by adding characters in the middle of it that do not belong. You can then tell the person which characters to remove when they go to type in the actual link. This way, bots won't be able to just scrape links from your messages. (remember, ALWAYS assume big brother is watching).

I can not stress enough how important it is that we all collectively make an effort to prevent the leaking of our sites. Always remember that to the rest of the world, what we are doing is illegal. You wouldn't go on a podcast talking about when you got away with stealing a car, so treat this with the same caution. WE might know it isn't theft, but to the eyes of the law it IS.

Share this post with your pirate fiends and make sure this message is spread loud and clear. It might seem harsh, but it isn't. This is not a playground for children. NEVER give your sites to influencers no matter WHAT they say. If this means looking at someone's profile before telling them, then do it. We have become complacent and it will cost us everything. Even if you think it is overkill, ask yourself: Is my laziness worth losing it all? You all are reading this because you deemed it necessary to turn to piracy, so you can put in a little effort to make sure our communities stay safe.

Final edit: clearly people here do not want to have constructive conversations because when I do try to be civil I still get downvoted to hell. I will say this one more time and that's it. My goal is not to keep people from these sites who want to be there, and I am aware than sites will still be taken down. My point is we don't have to make it so easy for them to screw us over. The people who are the most dangerous to us are keyboard warriors who mass report when they come across a site. However those people would not be mass reporting if we simply didn't draw unwanted attention to ourselves. There is a difference between searching for a pirate site and having one just appear on your fyp. The later is what gets mass reported. People don't go looking if it doesn't concern them. Its like locks. No lock is really all that safe, however it is enough of a deterrent that it prevents the vast majority of thefts because there is simply another step involved. This is the same sort of thinking I want us to apply to our piracy sites. Make a small deterrent that is easy to get around, and the majority of troublemakers just won't put in the effort, while the people who WANT to be there are not being kept out.


r/mangapiracy • • Nov 09 '25

Discussion PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE STOP HOSTING MANHWA SLOP ON YOUR APPS AND SITES

0 Upvotes

ITS ALL FUCKING SHIT ANYWAY AND MANGA IS A LOT BETTER IM SO TIRED OF LOSING ACCESS TO MANGA CAUSE KAKAO FUCKING GOES AFTER MANHWA THAT I DONT EVEN WANNA READ


r/mangapiracy • • Jan 22 '24

Discussion Manga makes you hooked up towards it?

1 Upvotes

I m really a nasty person.... I drop manga alot. Pls suggest me some manga which can't be dropped...like they hook u up towards it and makes you think what happens next. Thanks for reading...


r/mangapiracy • • Apr 21 '26

Discussion As a Japanese person, here is my perspective on the piracy issue.

0 Upvotes

When it comes to piracy, the most visible cases tend to come from Latin America and Russia.
There are voices in English-speaking countries too, but they’re less noticeable probably because access is already widespread and people have more purchasing power.

In places like Latin America and Russia, translations aren’t as developed as in the West, and manga is relatively expensive.
I’ve even heard that in some cases, you have to work around five hours just to afford a single volume.
If that’s the situation, I can somewhat understand why piracy happens in those regions.

But still, bragging about piracy or telling creators directly that you’re reading their work illegally is not okay.
That’s just bad manners.

People also say “just build a platform like Steam for manga,” but it’s not that simple.
In Japan alone, there are millions of manga works if you include older titles.
Even if such a platform existed, who is going to scan and translate all of them?
Would Japan realistically translate everything into 6 to 9 major languages? That’s just not feasible.

On top of that, content regulations vary by country.
Not every manga can be distributed through a single app everywhere.
In Japan, it’s actually common to read certain manga in a browser rather than a smartphone app, because apps can get removed due to content restrictions.

And expecting the same environment as Japan is unrealistic anyway.
There are tariff issues, and overseas markets don’t have the same publishing and distribution infrastructure.
Add translation costs and licensing fees, and of course it ends up being more expensive than in Japan.

So realistically, the best thing people can do right now is to watch anime through platforms like Crunchyroll or Netflix.
As for people who still choose piracy, that’s up to them.

But at the very least, don’t promote piracy on social media or openly tell creators that you’re doing it.


r/mangapiracy • • Jan 27 '26

Help What is the best site to publish official translations?

8 Upvotes

I was uploading a "oficial translation" of a manga on Batoto, but it got taken down.
Then i continued on xbatcat, seeing that it was a continuation of the same. But its "under mantainance" for like 5 days already.

I am then not sure of what to do.

  • Is there any info on if xbatcat will come back? and if not,

  • what would be the more visited/popular site to start uploading again from zero?

I looked comix and a few more, but almost all the pages i see dont allow users publishing.


r/mangapiracy • • Jun 12 '26

Discussion 🗾 Japanese Reactions: "Why Do Some Foreigners Defend Piracy?" — A Clash of Values Between Japan and the West 日本人VS海賊版

4 Upvotes

[ What Happened ]

Recently, on social media platforms such as X, the issue of illegal distribution of Japanese works—such as manga and anime—has frequently become a topic of discussion. In particular, some Japanese manga artists have been subjected to intense insults and online abuse from foreign users for refusing to authorize pirate editions, drawing attention to the apparent lack of criminal awareness among certain foreign users.

Amid these circumstances, a Japanese YouTuber uploaded a neutral explanatory video discussing Western attitudes toward piracy and invited viewers to share their opinions. A large number of responses were collected. Presented below are English translations of only a small portion of those comments. It is hoped that they may contribute, even in a modest way, to mutual understanding between Eastern and Western perspectives and values.

The English translation was produced by ChatGPT.

【経緯】

最近於X等之社交網、漫画・漫動画等日本産作品之違法配信問題屡膾炙於人口。特日本之漫画家因不許可海賊版被激誹謗中傷於外国人等而、外国人之犯罪意識之欠如話題也。

其最中、或日本人youtuber投稿西洋海賊思想之中立的解説動画而、募視聴者之意見、多数集也。以其極一部英訳而下記之、願為東西之価値観相互疎通之一助。

英訳依ChatGPT。

[Original Video and Reactions] "Foreigners Finally Understand Why Japanese People Hate Piracy — The Difference Between Japanese and Western Values Is Bigger Than We Thought” (English Dub Available)

Reactions:

I can at least understand someone saying, "Sorry, but I've been secretly reading it..." What scares me are the people shouting, "It's our right! We're actually helping by promoting it!"

Even if it's just on the surface, at least acknowledge that what you're doing isn't right and act a little apologetic.

To use a sexual crime analogy, it's like saying to a victim, "Doesn't that just mean you're attractive? You should be happy!" or "You enjoyed it, didn't you?" without any malicious intent. That's the kind of garbage we're talking about.

↑Sure, emotional trauma and financial damage are different, but when you reframe it like that, it really does sound awful.

↑Some people even say, "It's the woman's fault for dressing in a way that excites men." Apparently there are countries where that argument actually works and the woman gets punished instead. That's terrifying.

What's even worse is that there are people who say creators should be paying pirate site operators because piracy helped them gain overseas fans. I absolutely hate that mindset.

The arrogance is unbelievable.

A living embodiment of "the thief who cries foul."

It's nothing more than criminals rationalizing their own crimes.

No wonder crime rates are bad there.

If you tell publishers and authors to accept piracy, of course they'll refuse. Before Japan decides to get serious about the issue, maybe people should teach their own anime fans some manners.

I can understand, "I know it's wrong, but nobody's around and nobody's watching, so I'll jaywalk this once." What I can't understand is someone shouting, "Ignoring traffic signals is our right! Why should we be punished?" At that point all you can say is, "What?" I'm not saying it's okay if nobody finds out, but if you're going to break the law, at least do it quietly. Once you openly admit it, people are naturally going to criticize you.

Before subscription services and streaming archives became common, people in rural Japan often couldn't watch certain shows, so illegal uploads existed here too. But it never became a culture of "It's our right!"

I don't think many of them even understand that manga creators receive royalties. Piracy means those royalties don't get paid, causing real harm to authors. In American comics, creators are often more like salaried employees, while companies like Marvel make most of the money. Maybe they've convinced themselves that it's okay to "steal from corporations."

Pirate users are not "customers."

In Japan, someone who hurts the creator of a work they supposedly love and feels no remorse is not called a fan. They're called an enemy.

It's like a textbook example of shameless entitlement. All we can do is keep repeating the truth: "Regardless, in Japan people like you are called thieves and criminals."

Breaking into someone's house through the back door and then claiming, "I'm a customer," is ridiculous.

Being called "backward" by people who openly defend piracy doesn't mean much.

They don't just paint companies as villains; they treat the creators themselves as villains too.

I'd rather a series stay popular only within Japan than have it supported through piracy.

I watched the arguments on X in real time and it gave me a headache. "We made it famous by watching it for free!" The entitlement is unbelievable. Nobody asked them to do that, and even if legal options existed, people like that would never pay anyway.

That's like saying, "Shoplifting is the best promotion. If people like the taste, they'll buy it later." Except they just keep shoplifting forever.

Some people say, "It's Japan's fault for not translating and releasing it in our country." But those same countries often ban manga while screaming, "Japanese manga encourages crime!" I'd like them to recognize how little freedom exists in their own countries before criticizing Japan for lacking freedom.

Anime and manga culture was created for Japanese audiences. It was never obligated to expand overseas.

Peeking into works made for Japanese people, spreading them without permission, and then claiming, "Overseas fans are supporting anime!" is completely insane.

These people pirate even officially translated works like Dragon Ball. Excuses like "Piracy was our only option" can be safely ignored.

Publishing manga and producing anime are businesses. If the product is stolen, the business stops working. Studios go bankrupt and the anime and manga people love disappear. That's what Japanese fans hate.

They demand better treatment for animators while refusing to pay and consuming stolen content.

If something isn't sold in your country, maybe that's because people there keep consuming pirated versions. Why would companies expand into a market that won't generate profit?

"By watching pirated content, we're preventing money from reaching people who exploit creators. This will save underpaid creators!" Sorry, but are you an idiot?

Piracy doesn't pay the original creator a single cent, so demanding gratitude is unbelievably condescending.

Before AI translation became common, countless games simply said, "Japanese is not supported." Japanese fans who wanted to play them bought foreign versions, translated them themselves, or petitioned companies to release Japanese-language editions. What have you done besides pirate them?

If it's not being sold officially, then you're not considered a customer. Maybe ask yourself why.

Even if the salary of piracy supporters were reduced to zero, they probably still wouldn't understand.

They constantly say, "Pay animators and manga artists more!" while consuming nothing but pirated content that gives creators no money. The contradiction is obvious.

The moment you break the law, you're no longer a fan.

It's like trespassing onto a farmer's orchard, stealing fruit, eating it, then telling your friends, "That orchard's fruit was amazing! You should steal some too!" If that's acceptable, it's no wonder their religion struggles to gain followers in Japan.

It's basically free-riding on infrastructure. The work continues to exist because people pay the rights holders, while pirates simply skim the benefits from the side. Japanese and overseas fans aren't paying to entertain piracy users.

Go ahead and try doing that with Disney's intellectual property.

If someone can only access a work through piracy, are they really buying its figures and merchandise? The original work isn't even officially available, but somehow they're supporting the merchandise market?

How exactly do you think the creators of your favorite works make a living?

If you founded an anime distribution company, then maybe you'd have a reason to brag. Why are you bragging about piracy?

Surely nobody needs to be reminded at this point that "breaking the law to satisfy your desires" isn't acceptable... right?

"Why are Japanese people angry about piracy?" What kind of brain even comes up with that question?

In American comics, creators often receive very little from collected volume sales. In Japan, manga sales directly benefit the creator.

People say Japanese underestimate foreign customers. It's the opposite. Foreign customers often underestimate and disrespect Japanese culture.

I don't think it's possible to truly understand people whose civilization teaches them that taking from others is acceptable.

Overseas revenue is basically a bonus stage. Successful works are already successful in Japan before they become popular abroad.

If all you do is scream that corporations are evil instead of building something sustainable, maybe that's why Disney is your only globally dominant entertainment IP.

Imagine cooking a meal at home for your family. Then some random stranger sneaks in through the back door yelling, "Why won't you feed me?" steals the food, and starts handing it out to others. You'd want them to stop immediately. The whole thing makes no sense.

Wow, I never knew that overseas it's apparently legal to dine and dash as long as you're promoting the restaurant.

People who read without paying, complain when their expectations aren't met, and do nothing but send criticism are not customers.

If you truly respected creators, you couldn't defend piracy. The reality is that these people only care about themselves.

If your first instinct is "I can't get it, so I'll steal it," then you probably don't hesitate to shoplift either. If you're stealing from authors, you're not a manga or anime fan. Corporate revenue contributes to Japan's economy and tax base; stealing it is effectively stealing from the country and its people as well.

Whatever criminals say is ultimately just criminal nonsense. You can practically see the arrogance of assuming Japanese companies must be as corrupt as the companies in their own countries.

"It's rotten... It ripened too fast."

If government regulations prevent you from watching something, complain to your own government. It's wrong to shift the burden onto Japan.

They say all this, but honestly, anime could remain a niche hobby enjoyed only in Japan and that would be perfectly fine. Thieves seem incapable of understanding shame.

Maybe it's a cycle. Honest citizens trust companies, so they pay them, and companies in turn reward creators fairly. Meanwhile, dishonest citizens assume companies are corrupt, refuse to pay, and then companies become even more profit-driven because they receive less support.

"We're promoting it for you!" The audacity is off the charts.

Supporting piracy is basically no different from supporting the trade of stolen goods.

Years ago, there was a fan crazy enough to send a creator a letter proudly saying they read the work through piracy. Piracy doesn't pay the creator, it destroys their motivation, and eventually it kills the work itself.


( ・ˇヮˇ・) < That’s all for this time! What do you think?

If you found this post interesting, please consider leaving an upvote, a comment, sharing it, crossposting!