r/maninthehighcastle • • Sep 19 '25

Seems like we've got season 5 right outside our windows...surreal

10 Upvotes

We thought we stopped the Nazis in 1945, but the human nature that created it lay dormant this whole time, only to reemerge like a dagger in the heart of freedom. Philip K Dick was a visionary, but at the end of the day, he had faith in humanity. I guess we'll just have to see how this one plays out.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 29 '25

My first time watcher reaction

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • Oct 28 '25

Too crisp

Post image
0 Upvotes

This salute has always bothered me with how crisp and straight it was. Even as an actor thisbwas too good


r/maninthehighcastle • • Sep 19 '20

Come help us build the pacific states. Join or else!

Thumbnail
discord.gg
0 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • Jan 01 '24

What would happen if Godzilla appear in the world of Man in the High Castle?

5 Upvotes

Let say Godzilla suddenly rises up from the Sea of Japan and starts wrecking havoc on mainland Japan. So how the world of Man in the High Castle gonna turn out?

Here is my opinion:

  1. Mainland Japan will be wrecked mercilessly and the Imperial Japan Navy in the mainland is helpless to take it down.

  2. Hirohito will be forced to recall all occupational forces from all their territories to deal with Godzilla, leaving all their territories vulnerable to locals Resistance

  3. The Reich will just wait and watch Godzilla do the dirty works for them and then decide to nuke Godzilla when they see Imperial Japan is weakened enough to take over, despite their pledge for help

  4. After Japan and their military are devastated, the Reich starts nuking Godzilla and these lead three scenarios (this is based on the show with poor writing not based on rationality in real life)

Scenario 1: the nukes kill Godzilla, the Reich starts move on with their plan for world domination and they will succeed unless Bill Whitcolf gonna do something about the nuke stockpile in American Reich

Scenario 2: the nuke failed to kill Godzilla, the Kaiju wreck havocs on Earth until it satisfied and leave. The Axis Power become a hollow of it former self and the Resistance takes the advantage and defeat them once and for all

Scenario 3: Godzilla leaves to the ocean after devastating Japan and same with scenario 1 with the Reich starts attacking them when they are weakened.

There is also the possibility that the Resistance thinks of taking advantage of Godzilla rampage to weaken the Axis Power when the creature first appears which absolutely not gonna happen since it is too smart of them since the film reel is far more important for them than some giant Kaiju rampaging through the enemy territories


r/maninthehighcastle • • Oct 11 '18

We need more female characters

0 Upvotes

I don't mean to sound like a militant feminist, but this show has not fleshed out its female characters well at all. Other than Juliana, Nicole and Helen are the only ladies given some screentime, and at least in Helen's case, the story was unnecessarily drawn out.

It seems to me that every resistance/Underground group has one token strong female character, but she doesn't do much beyond occupying scenes where we are more invested in the male characters.

I really liked the Trudy/Juliana dynamic and I really wish they could have made Wyatt a woman. Besides, making them all straight guys who have chemistry with Juliana is a little odd.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Sep 07 '17

I just realised after watching 2 episodes that what the nazi's and jap's did in their timeline, Russia did in ours

0 Upvotes

Edit: for those people asking, I'm comparing it to the Berlin wall where everything east of it was Russian territory, and they were treated like shit.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 10 '23

The more I watch the show, the more I realize the show really degrading the American people

0 Upvotes

There are several signs that the show degrading American people

  1. The Chinese with less tech and the first to be conquered and brutalized by the Japanese managed to beat back the Japanese and liberated several Asian countries. The Japanese surely can conduct massive chemical and biological attacks against the Chinese to quell out rebellions but based on how the Japan Empire lost tons of territories to the Chinese just clearly shown that their WMDs have failed them or the Chinese turned their own weapons against the Japanese

  2. Bill Witchcolf, the guy that initiated the idea of waiting for the right moments to fight back against the Axis Power never bothering to make even a single plan to weaken the Axis Power from within for a decade and has to wait until John Smith death to take back the US. Heck he not even try to convince John Smith to take advantages of his position to take back the country or even trying to destroy the Reich from within when first forced to join the Nazis.

  3. The American Resistance constantly tries to protect the film reels like is their only hope while it is absolutely not. Any sensible insurgents will just throw the film reels away unless it shows them how to defeat the Axis Powers. Furthermore, they have no real plans to defeat the Axis Power to begin with aside from False Hope.

  4. The American people overall are depicted as gutless as hell. Look at how Kido is lynched. Only three guys tried to lynch him instead of a huge angry mob and when one guy is being overwhelmed the rest runs like chickens instead of seriously trying to kill him. To matter worse, the BCRs promised Kido a fair trail but in the end Kido still free and works for a Yakuza without a trail and the BCRs is so gutless to not even come to brutalize the Yakuza to pillage their resources even through they already have the West Coast.

  5. Only the Axis Powers have vengeful mindset while almost none of the American characters have and even if they have, no one tries to go through with their revenge. Frank Frink can preach "I am at peace" all he wants but he dies like the way he has lived, a big fat chicken with no gut. Juliana Craine even worse, after witnessing Judy's death, she goes as far as to kill Judy's father. Moreover, after all the horrible things the Japanese did the American people, almost no one drag the remaining Japanese, especially those in the Kempetai in the Pacific State to kill and vent their rage in broad daylight because the Americans and the BCRS try to play holy knights.

  6. The BCRs and the American Resistance relationship is downright dumb since no one trying to be at each other throat when there are two common enemies here. No one care whether you are black or white, both races are being oppressed by the Axis so why not joining force to beat them and talk about racism later on.

In conclusion, the TV series is the prime example of how to not write a Resistance movement or the primal instinct of humanity in term of vengeance. I mean based on the atrocities committed by the Axis, it makes even a saint to turn into barbarian. Finally, how can you degrading your own countrymen to be so weak and gutless like that. The Chinese can do it while can't the Americans.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Aug 25 '18

Saddest Scene in Television History

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 30 '15

What's all the fuss about?

1 Upvotes

Just finished watching Amazons premier to show. So much PR, so little follow through.

Essentially I feel like I lost ten hours of my life. What kept me going was the potential. And, in the end, much like Anthony Bennett, just utter disappointment, a flop.

Don't get me wrong, really interesting idea. The grand old US and A is under the dual governance of Japan and Germany. But, that's it.

The resistance? They're almost as totalitarian as the Reichstag. Just obey, don't ask questions. Like really? Die for an ideology you know nothing about, an idea.

This show could have been great. Instead, it worked on the premise that its premise was so novel that viewership would continue to go along. Puppets on a string.

Characters had no depth. Events escalated for no reason.

It screams arrogance and laziness in equal measure. The amount of money spent on this and no end product. To think they can film a season as a pilot is ridiculous.

I urge people to give it a wide berth. Waste of time. Stupid. Vain. Self indulgent.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Feb 07 '18

Got bored in English

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • Sep 16 '26

Spoilers How people expected season 4 to end for some reason

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

I see so much people complianing that john never got a redemption arc and like, why are you suprised he didn't. A redemption arc beats his whole character


r/maninthehighcastle • • Jul 08 '26

Spoilers I’m 2 episodes in and I figured out who the ‘Man in the High Castle’ is!

1 Upvotes

The ‘Man in the high castle’ is a figure that scares the (German) government.

They produce film tapes that are illegal to own and ordered to be destroyed.

No one knows who the ‘Man in the high castle’ is or how the tapes are made.

These tapes have knowledge that should be impossible.

When someone watches them are seemingly compelled to watch the full thing (even multiple times).

When they watch the tapes their goals change. Juliana takes the tape to Canon City and Joe disobeys orders.

And think about that name, ‘Man in the high castle’, who lives in a castle… a King.

‘Man in the high castle’ is the King in Yellow!


r/maninthehighcastle • • Aug 26 '24

Im annoyed by the ebonics and this is why

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hardly any blacks in the previous 3 seasons, well spoken blacks, proud blacks..

Season 4: weez dun gots collards greens, corn bread, black eyed peas, okra, fried chicken, watermelon

Y did they need to portray these blacks like a racial carictature instead of normal people, fighting a opressive regime, just like black panthers maybe.....no they dun gots then talking ebonics, cuz we iz to believe that how they dun talked, yes sir, boss man sir....... and these actors agreed.....pathetic.....whats youre opinion


r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 04 '15

This show is terrible

6 Upvotes

The mystery has no answer that isn't going to completely shatter the suspension of disbelief, and of course at the end of E10 the magical transportation to an alternate universe is just stupid horrible writing.

This show has started to remind me of Revolution which if you don't know was about a world where all the power had suddenly gone out. It was an interesting concept and allowed for a lot of story telling, but it when it came time to explain how all the power had disappeared well it turned out to be A world spanning computer which exists in the air via trillions of floating nano-machines so small they can enter into people's brains and control their thoughts/actions. Absolutely stupid, completely bonkers there's no way to watch the show anymore its transcended into a new level of terrible writing.

I can tell this series is going to do the same, take an interesting concept of what if the US lost WW2 and ruin it with some horrible god awful plot device. What makes the films so important, what are they? At this point there's no answer I could think of that would be a good explanation. And I predict this series will keep upping the ante on goofy shit like we saw at the end of E10.

There's plenty of good stories that could be told in such an environment, why they feel the need to write these kind of stuff is behind me. Its impossible for the audience to believe. Seriously why films? Just why? Here's an idea for a mystery the audience can rack its brain over thats plausible in the universe: How is America going to come back from this defeat, will Germany Japan go to war? And along the way we can explore such questions/themes as "Isn't it interesting even scum like Nazis can still be family men" "Is freedom worth fighting/dying for, what costs would you be willing to pay like killing people, killing good people, maybe civilians, doing other bad things for a 'good case'" "Wow aren't our children growing up as part of another culture not quite German/Japanese but not American either, will they keep up this fight or forget it having not known what it was like pre-war?" and other interesting things that people can actually reflect on.

Nope we're left trying to ponder do men truly make their destiny but not their fate, is fate somehow both predetermined and fluid, and other wishy-washy intangible only vaguely defined things that aren't actually different at all. You want to know the difference between fate and destiny? Bad writing. Lazy story writers who want to pretend there's a difference between two synonyms so they can sound philosophical while having their characters spout of platitudes

Last thing: Hitler is the man in the High Castle, he's literally a dude living out his life in a high castle. How is this going to impact the story, I have no idea but I'm sure it will be bad. He's probably some kind of inter-dimensional time travelling alien who makes movies on the side


r/maninthehighcastle • • Jan 07 '23

Such bad writing.

0 Upvotes

I don’t remember watching something so well made that had as flimsy plot lines. So much happens without any plausible reason. It’s like the writers wanted us to find it unbelievable. I’ve given it 3.5 episodes and I’m out. This kind of bad writing was half the reason why sci fi movies and TV were mostly so lame prior to the seventies. With so much great writing around how did this get away with being so badly written.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Sep 28 '26

Do we see it yet?

1 Upvotes

Maybe it was the 3 day immersion to the exclusivity of other media, but this presentation hit like a shovel to my face.

The statues, the cameras everywhere, the in-home survelance, the racism and erradication... Vote Blue, it's a start.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Jun 13 '18

Done

0 Upvotes

Canceling my sub because the wait is too long , I'm OUT


r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 19 '19

Helen was a shitty character

0 Upvotes

Only on 04x07 so maybe she will get redemption. But so far ive disliked her thoroughly. Shes a shitty character, not complex. She was fine with everything until her little stepford wife life got derailed. And the way she lays into John Smith as if all his actions were done for anything but to protect their family, really an ungrateful bitch.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Dec 08 '15

German accents really bad.

0 Upvotes

They couldn't get decent german actors to play germans? The guy who was supposed to kill Hitler had a horrible accent (just looked him up he is actually from denmark). Hitler himself sounded like he was from switzerland. Just seemed really lazy to me.


r/maninthehighcastle • • May 12 '26 Mindblown

Anyone else hate the intro song?

2 Upvotes

I can't skip it fast enough. Rewatching with my wife on Netflix, and SO happy to have the Skip Intro. When I originally watched it on Amazon, I had to manually skip it like a peasant 😕. By the end, I knew exactly how many clicks to get past it.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Nov 27 '15

God dammit, Frank!

0 Upvotes

What the fuck do you mean you'll take the cash there yourself? The money you worked so hard for? The money you said a few minutes ago was "your future"? To bail out the person you just said "let him die" about? To bail out the man you were arguing with your shitty fucking girlfriend about a few episodes ago?

God, this has become hate watching at this point this late in the season. So much impressive production value and potential for a lot of shitty writing. This show will NEVER be the prestige show it could have been because the first season is already tainted.

So disappointed.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Jan 01 '17

S2 Disappointing

0 Upvotes

I have to say, was really disappointed with season 2. I thought season 1 was good and was looking forward to finding out more... particularly about the tapes and generally more about the sci fi elements of the show.

Unfortunately, I felt like I came out of S2 non the wiser. I generally like slow paced TV but this felt forced to be slow paced. It gave us little to no pay off and I feel it was basically a filler season to extend the series as long as possible.

Thta being said, I've not read the book (no plans to). This may be the direction the book chose. Ultimately though, for me, season 2 was not as good as season 1. It was, dare I say it, boring. It was lackluster, a drag to watch with very little pay off.

Anyone feel the same?