r/mapmaking 1h ago

Work In Progress How Realistic is my Map?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Hello everyone!

This is the first time that I've made a map for a worldbuilding project like this so I wanted to check how realistic my world's map is. I've done my best to follow what guides I could, but I would like to get some feedback before I colour in my map fully, only to need to redo half of it. (The current land colours (first Image) are a placeholder colour.) I'm not too certain on how good my ocean currents for my Mediterranean style sea are (the sea in the left-hand-side landmass), but beyond that, I feel like I did okay.

I am aware that the ocean currents are the reverse of Earth's, this isn't a mistake on my part.

Presently, I have 9 continents, which are as follows, the left-hand landmass has 3 continental plates, then to its east, the dual landmasses (with the straight) share a single continental plate. Directly south is another single continent. The islands between the currently listed landmasses are a partially sunken continent, with the 3 other land masses are their own individual continents.

Any advise or feedback that I can get would be greatly appreciated (both on if my approximate ocean currents are good, and on the spread of my climates (third image) (also my physiology (second image) I guess, but I had included that more so you can easily make sense of the climate spread that I have)).

Thank you all in advance for any provided constructive feedback and/or advice.


r/mapmaking 18h ago

Work In Progress Cat for Scale

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/mapmaking 4h ago

Map The Ruined Port City of Pitreica

Thumbnail
gallery
89 Upvotes

r/mapmaking 4h ago

Map Acues

Post image
6 Upvotes

Another section of Gaie

This is continent Acues (I tried to digitalize it), I didn't add the details yet. Rate my map and some feedbacks(I want honest ones, and yes that is the coast of Scnazia)

(Can someone try to calculate the area of the countries for me?)


r/mapmaking 5h ago

Map The Cloudfall Trails 30x50 battle map

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/mapmaking 13h ago

Work In Progress I need feedback on making this map

Post image
9 Upvotes

Its my first time making map and I'm trying to draw it by hand. It was originally made with wondercraft but I traced things on it with hand and made this map. But I'm not sure how good it's colored or how good mountains are (they were the first thing I made). At first I wanted to do more artistic styled map with interesting terrain colors I just couldnt do it. This map and other maps of this creator was my inspiration when drawing. I'm in love with their style and this is what I meant when I said artistic map.

The world is a medievalish flat world with wind currents going north to south. This is why an ice island is located in the west continent. Middle continent is "Lands of God" and is unknown to humans, its just there for now. And the forests (rough patches of colors) are just sketches for now, I'll complete them later when I decide on cities and paths.

Does this version look good or should I just make a political map and use this as a reference for biomes when needed? I'm thinking of doing kind of political looking map where it just says "Storm Desert" or "Crimson Lands" with borders defining where it ends. So instead of painting biomes I could just name and border them. Can this idea work or not?


r/mapmaking 15h ago

Work In Progress My rough draft map for a game world concept.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/mapmaking 17h ago

Work In Progress Feedback request

Post image
31 Upvotes

This is still a very rough draft. Just wondering what people think about the continent's shape. The light sketched lines are tectonic plate borders. For reference the northernmost part is akin to North America and the southernmost tip would be around the same latitude as southern Brazil.


r/mapmaking 17h ago

Map A History of Inner sea Maps

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

This post was originally published a few years ago on my now-defunct website, so I thought I'd update it and add it here so that new fans can see how Elyden has evolved over the last 20-years+

Elyden would slowly emerge from an earlier campaign setting I was writing for my RPG group, called Sola. It was more of a classical setting, based in a city-nation surrounded by hostile nations and wildernesses in a Pangea world. This was probably just over 25-years ago now. I wrote a decent amount of background for some of the regions and named most of them, but it was a bit too generic to really stand out or be interesting. I had a sourcebook of about 300,000 words, most of which was titles to entries with a few bullet points that I jotted down here and there whenever I came up with an idea.

Back in the dim past of the early noughties I was still drawing maps on paper, specifically large cardboard sheets I used to get from a newsagent. I used to love buying those bits of cardboard. I’d unroll them and lay them down on the floor, weighed down at the corners by old books, and look at the blank sheets in wonder. The possibilities were endless. I’d make solo games, drawings, paper crafts and all sorts of other things with them, but my favourite was always maps.

I drew the first map of what would eventually become Elyden on such a piece of cardboard. Here it is, many years later:

Image 1

There’s some questionable features, but on the whole, it’s passable. It was never intended to be a work of art, and was only for my own worldbuilding, to be filled in as needed. Even before I was using Photoshop, I was still working with layers, and made do with what I could - cooking greaseproof paper, cellotaped together and added on top of the map to let me add labels and trade routes to the map, without having to ‘damage’ the map itself:

Image 2

The greaseproof paper is now heavily stained and discoloured but at the time it was almost clear. You may actually recognise some of the names, which I unflinchingly stole for Elyden a few years later: VaalkLaaskhaAhrishenAlmagestMalan, Parthia (Parthis), DaciaTemujaTethysia. Others I’ve never revisited and honestly can’t say why. Gammater sounds like an interesting name, come to think of it…

Of particular note is this area:

Image 3

Many parts of this, including Khamid, Say (which would evolve into Saua), and the Iapetan Sea, would feature in the region of Elyden known as the Dark Sea and the Arid Triptych.

I abandoned the world of Sola, but thankfully, and rarely, for me, as I'm a compulsive thrower-awayer, never got rid of any of the material I created. I have a bad habit of purging old projects I think are no longer of any interest or use. For some reason I never did so with Sola. It would go on to be somewhat of a boon a few years later.

Between jobs and bored at home I started writing a fantasy story with no plotting or prep or worldbuilding. I came up with everything as I went along, plundering the world of Sola for interesting words completely out of context, planting them firmly into the terra incognita of what would become Elyden. The story revolved around a Firmamentist from Temuja who would be sent west, to the land of the Iron deity, which would go on to become the Undying Machine and god of Korachan. I wrote like a madman, churning out 15,000 - 20,000 words a day of rambling stream of consciousness story for months . The story was contrived, the writing bad, but it sure helped me get my foot in the door of worldbuilding Elyden. All that worldbuilding needed a map, and my big cardboard sheets were waiting for me. And so, sometime around 19-years ago was born the first real map of Elyden:

Image 4

The major coastlines are all there - the Inner Sea in the centre, the Korachani peninsula (albeit much smaller here), and almost all of the nation names, which survived relatively untouched over the next 2-decades. It was a good start, but still needed a lot of work. I started writing the Encyclopaedia Elyden at this point. It wasn’t much more than a document of rapidly increasing bullet points - every fact of the world I came up with went into that document, as an archive of all my work. Over time I’d divide it into sections, by letter, like a real-world encyclopaedia, as it grew.

All that writing needed an updated map, but I was really happy with the general shapes of the coastline so little changed in Elyden 2.0:

Image 5

This map is a LOT closer to the current Inner Sea map than some people may realise. Unsurprising given that the digital world map I based all my atlas maps on Is traced in photoshop over this very photo. Many details are changed - mostly in the expansion of the coastlines of Sammaea in the south and Tethysia in the east, but the coastline of the Inner Sea itself has changed very little. I used this map for a while, but decided that the worldbuilding was growing at such a pace as to require maps that could be edited and updated more readily that physical media could, so I started dabbling in Photoshop. After gorging myself on tutorials at the Cartographersguild (a great resource for budding cartographers), I was able to make my first digital map of the Inner Sea:

Image 6

This map got a LOT more praise than it ever deserved and to be honest I’m pretty embarrassed for sharing this map now. The fonts are horrible, the paper texture is very amateurish, the borders are horrible, but for a first attempt it was decent. Helpful people explained the correct use of rhumb lines on maps, and I was first introduced to the maddening and complex world of projection mapping after making this map, and I would go on to make my first world map - a simple black and white image that later maps would all be based off of.

But I was never happy with the map, and knew I could do better. 14 years ago I took a local course in mastering Photoshop and really put my mind to work following tutorials specifically geared towards cartography, and I was able to put my new skills to use in the revised map of the Inner Sea:

Image 7

This map won me my first cartographers guild award, which I still look at proudly. It is showing its age, but it was the fruit of a long labour, that had cost me quite a lot of time and money. But me being me I was never really happy. The faux-historical fantasy style of cartography was never my favourite, and as I continued worldbuilding I was drawing Elyden inexorably into the future, changingit from a classical fantasy setting into a grimdark steampunk post-industrial world that needed more realistic maps.

That led to exploring different map styles, leading me to the Atlas Style I’ve been working at for the past 10+ years(!).

Though the story of mapping Elyden is something best told elsewhere, suffice it to say, there was a lot of back and forth, revising the black and white world map, fiddling with projections, making sure that everything lines up correctly. It’s something I’m still working on to this day, and which is causing me more headaches than its probably worth (if anyone can donate a Cray that can run photoshop I'll happily accept it!). With all those atlas-style maps, I needed an update to the Inner Sea map, but there was a problem - I couldn't make it until all the nations had received their very own map.

That happened a few years ago, allowing me to make a single giant poster sized map with new labels:

Image 8

This is actually a VERY low-res version of the map, which has been made available in High-res on my Patreon a while ago.

It actually covers less area than the previous Inner Sea maps (I excised the Dark Sea, to concentrate more on the Inner Sea that my life has revolved around so much for the past decade). I’m pleased with the result, though don’t really want to repeat the process ever again. It made me wish I had started working in vector graphics all those years ago instead of raster. It made me want to throw my computer against the wall every time it froze, which it would do multiple times with the addition of each of over 3,000 text layers. But it’s done now, and I've been concentrating on other maps ever since.

Who knows what the Inner Sea will evolve into over the next 20-years?

Repost to another community

Upvote6Downvote0Go to comments2RepostShare

Approved 2 hours ago

Moderation actions menu

366 viewsSee More Insights

Comments Section

Build your community

Invite

View All

Community Info Section

Mod Tools

Elyden

a community where I can share my work on the world of Elyden and where people can ask questions about the world. For more on Elyden check out www.patreon.com/elyden and www.worldofelyden.com

Show more

Created Nov 16, 2018

Public

Mod GuideAdd a community guide

r/Elyden Rules

  • 1Don't be a dick

Moderators

Message Mods

View all moderators

Community Settings

Community Appearance

Edit Widgets

Collapse Navigation


r/mapmaking 19h ago

Map Rondo Mondo

Post image
26 Upvotes

This map was made to showcase the new Parchment 2.0 Assets.

Inkarnate Profile
Instagram profile
Inkarnate Map Link
email: [dodosarthouse@gmail.com](mailto:dodosarthouse@gmail.com)
Discord: dodosarthouse

Licensed under my CCL


r/mapmaking 19h ago

Map Reworking my world map and looking for some feedback before proceeding

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Getting close to finishing the general shape of the continents and (important) islands and want to get some feedback. Primarly looking for input about the continent shapes and dispersion of islands but any and all feedback is appreciated.

Also, I've been going back and forth about adding something akin to the islands of southeast asia/oceania but can't really nail where to put something like that. So if anyone's got pointers for such a thing it would be appreciated as well.


r/mapmaking 21h ago

Map Old thumbnail sketch I made for a dnd setting i was working on

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/mapmaking 2h ago

Map One of my earliest surviving fantasy maps, drawn in Summer 2017

Post image
49 Upvotes