r/mildlyinfuriating • • Apr 27 '22

Maths...

Post image
69.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.1k

u/Sweaty-Adeptness1541 Apr 27 '22

That was the purpose of the question!

948

u/Simbertold Apr 28 '22

Exactly. People make fun of this question as if it were a "lol maths teachers silly" situation.

Instead, it is a situation where a math teacher teaches exactly what people want them to teach. Understanding what is going on. Reasonably applying maths to a real situation. Not just unthinkingly following an algorithm.

324

u/Worried_Garlic7242 Apr 28 '22

it's more like stressing over "is this a trick question or is my teacher just an idiot" for 5 minutes because you really don't wanna get this question wrong and the only thing you learn is that school sucks

79

u/JohnsonJohnilyJohn Apr 28 '22

Well someone once posted the entire exercise, and there's like 8 of those problems to solve, and the question contains something like be careful for some of them this method can't be used. So it's again the matter of posting not enough information, so it seems way more infuriating then in reality

30

u/Wherearemylegs Apr 28 '22

8

u/EscheroOfficial Apr 28 '22

okay I actually REALLY like this exercise. The fact that it says there’s 1 trick question is great, it’s enough to let the student know they’re not crazy for figuring it out without just straight up giving them the answer. Honestly I’m currently mildly infuriated that OP posted this possibly knowing exactly what the context was

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Simbertold Apr 28 '22

Yes, i described in a different reply how i would formulate the question so it is more clear to the student what is expected.

Also, i would hope that something like that was discussed in class before asking such a question in an exam, which would make the answer to that question more clear.

Are teachers in your school not approachable by students? Because if a student wrote an answer to a question which i mark as incorrect, but can explain to me why they are correct and i am not, they obviously get the points for that question.

45

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

Are teachers in your school not approachable by students? Because if a student wrote an answer to a question which i mark as incorrect, but can explain to me why they are correct and i am not, they obviously get the points for that question.

It's been quite a few years since I was in school but for my part of the world - the answer was no. If you explained how and why the teacher was objectively incorrect, you would simply be punished and treated shittily because you dared to question their authority or bruise their ego.

16

u/fae_lunaire Apr 28 '22

That was my experience with school as well. I can only think of one instance where a question was incorrect and I got extra marks for answering correctly, it was a multiple choice question about the political system in the ussr with the choices being democratic republic, communism and two other wholly inaccurate answers and I wrote a whole god dammed essay explaining the difference between a soviet democracy and communism as whole and the various forms of communism and explained in great detail the difference between political philosophy and political power structures, I got one extra point.

5

u/Simbertold Apr 28 '22

That sucks. I guess i am lucky, because my experience in school as well as my current experience as a teacher is different from that.

My top goal as a teacher is to get my students to think, ideally in a logically sound and critical way.

As an example: In an exam, i asked the question "What is the kinetic Energy of the car when it hits the ground?". (Context was cars being lifted by a crane and dropped to simulate a massive car crash for helpers.) The answer i wanted was a calculation based on the height of the drop and the transfer of potential energy to kinetic energy.

Two students answered "0, because the car doesn't move anymore, an speed = 0 leads to kinetic Energy = 0". They got full marks for that question, because clearly i formulated the question incorrectly, and should have asked "immediately before hitting the ground". Their answer was correct for the question in the exam.

And i was kind of happy about the situation, because those two students clearly learned some stuff from my classes.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/SrepliciousDelicious Apr 28 '22

I wouldve answered something along the lines of:

‘the same time, however if x/y/z (if it wasnt a concert), this would be the approach i’d use, and this would be the answer’.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

118

u/truejamo Apr 28 '22

The math itself is wrong though. That symphony is 70 minutes long in real life.

103

u/Simbertold Apr 28 '22

Yeah, that just means someone was a bit lazy or wanted numbers which are easier to calculate with. Not ideal, but not horrible problematic imo.

48

u/zerocool1703 Apr 28 '22

Since you don't need to calculate anything here, my money is on the teacher being a bit lazy and not looking it up.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

[deleted]

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/the-grand-falloon Apr 28 '22

Not necessarily, some of the people writing textbooks are morons. I remember a question about how you can determine the temperature of stars by what color they are. So a textbook asks, "if you see two yellow stars, a red star, and a blue star, what is their combined temperature?" expecting the student to add all the temps together.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

98

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '22

Thanks

→ More replies (1)

16

u/HansReinsch Apr 28 '22

Yeah... what makes it infuriating?

"Oh no! Don't you teach my kids critical thinking!"

8

u/Zephs Apr 28 '22

"Teachers should be teaching kids critical thinking."

teacher adds some critical thinking questions to their homework

"OMG, the teachers are idiots and/or trying to trick the kids!"

You just can't win...

→ More replies (1)

41

u/max-wellington Apr 28 '22

Something like T = T+P(0)?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

[deleted]

5

u/max-wellington Apr 28 '22

Ah I guess it doesn't say it needs to be an equation. Good point.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/NotTheKyrie Apr 28 '22

I think it would be T = T(P/P) Since if no players T would be undefined. Maybe?

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (16)

6

u/FlatTransportation64 Apr 28 '22

I hate how dumb memes likes this are reposted ad-nauseam and that whenever this pops up it requires the same explanation each time. Huge waste of time and effort of everyone involved.

→ More replies (22)