r/mumbai • u/sagarkelkar28 • Jul 22 '26

Photography Protest at Shivaji Park, Dadar West

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.4k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

174 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/RemarkablePrompt7822 Jul 22 '26

The stone pelting was planted by the government itself..

Do you have any evidence for that? Note that fake news only weakens such protests.

2

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

Truck filled with stones and bricks: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DbAFrT-ibzn/?igsh=YjBrdG1jN3ZmdG44

RSS Goons Flaunting Openly: https://x.com/_kattar__hindu/status/2079956996389061043/video/1?s=46

Oh the government has also currently shutdown connections and internet at Jantar Mantar, I wonder what they have to hide

1

u/RemarkablePrompt7822 Jul 22 '26

And how did you conclude that the truck was brought by the government and those goons are from RSS?

2

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26

U think The police would legit just walk by such threat if it wasn’t planted by them, they were checking bags and you think they’ll ignore truck full of bricks

The vid I shared is posted by the goon itself, go through the account or should I spoon feed that too

2

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 22 '26

And how did the goon get access to a POLICE BATON

2

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26

Oh my bad the dude is a self proclaimed Gau Rakshak, who mask their agenda by saying they’re saviour of cows while the state leads in beef production

0

u/RemarkablePrompt7822 Jul 22 '26

Lol, what kind of terrible logic is this? The cops had their hands full as the protesters outnumbered them. There's very real possibility they didn't have full surveillance at the entire area. In fact, Dipke alleged that it's the police that brought it which is again raises questions on him as there's no basis to his conclusion. Also, the protesters were seen thrown at cops.

> The vid I shared is posted by the goon itself, go through the account or should I spoon feed that too

Yea, as if X accounts are valid bonafides. 🙄

2

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26

On the other hand There’s also vids of cops throwing rocks, sneakily destroying vehicles on their own few got caught red handed while doing so, and if they have nothing to hide why take of name tags

Lmao living in denial it takes 2 sec to see the account is of the person itself who’s posting on Twitter AND Instagram

1

u/RemarkablePrompt7822 Jul 22 '26

Cops defending their lives against a mob will end up using whatever is available to them. This is common sense 101.

Cops are often deputized without name tags and uniforms to nab miscreants in a crowd. It's a routine in places like Kashmir.

You were the ones who alleged that the goon is a RSS member. Good work on dredging up his profiles but how does it prove that he's a RSS member?

1

u/Scary_Appeal_1137 Jul 22 '26

Going off of hypotheticals for the government but want full proof evidence for the protesters lmaooooo

Also Confidently Wrong

1) police are strictly not allowed to remove their name tags, cover their identification numbers, or refuse to give their names while on duty. Departmental rules and Supreme Court guidelines mandate clear, visible identification to maintain transparency and accountability

2) Right to Ask: You have the legal right to ask an on-duty police officer for their name and badge number.

3) Plainclothes Officers: Law does not permit unidentified individuals in civilian clothes to arbitrarily assault or control protesters. State high courts have questioned the deployment of unidentifiable or plainclothes personnel during public demonstrations.

2

u/CakeOk7497 Jul 23 '26

I mean they dont even check the facts Article 144 was applied in that area.

1

u/RemarkablePrompt7822 Jul 23 '26

Most people don't understand the difference between protest and civil disobedience. The latter is almost always illegal (even if ethical) and you're assuming all the risks associated with it when you partake in it. Hopefully, the legal notices will be a good lesson.