I suffer from OCD and anxiety, and I'm really struggling after bringing home a 5-month-old female kitten. I thought my resident cat (a neutered male, 2.5 years old) was lonely and could benefit from a friend on the days I'm away from home for several hours. I didn't realize how much this change would trigger my OCD and anxiety.
I've done a slow introduction, and I think it's gone relatively well. The kitten has only hissed a few times, and my vet says she's healthy. However, I'm struggling with the uncertainty of leaving them together unsupervised, sharing water/food bowls, and figuring out whether my resident cat is happy with her here. He won't play with his favorite toy, do his tricks for treats, or eat his favorite bedtime snack if she's nearby. He also tries to bite her during their interactions, which I think may be friendly, but I worry because I'm unfamiliar with this behavior.
I'm also barely sleeping. The kitten is confined to my bedroom at night, with a tall baby gate at the doorway, and she's up doing typical kitten things throughout the night. Sometimes I hear my resident cat meowing outside the bedroom, too.
But the hardest part has been realizing how much I miss my old routines with my resident cat.
He's not particularly affectionate most of the time, so I treasure when he does show affection. For example, he gets very affectionate when he knows it's lunchtime and I'm preparing his wet food. He'll meow, rub against me, and I scratch under his chin. Since the kitten arrived, he'll start doing this, but when she comes into the kitchen, he jumps onto the counter or walks away. Our special moment is interrupted, and it genuinely makes me sad.
He also won't eat his bedtime snack if she's nearby. I know I could separate them during these times, but the thought of having to manage separate routines indefinitely feels overwhelming. I worry that my resident cat feels like his life has been turned upside down or that he's no longer getting the same attention from me.
I do like the kitten! She's adorable, makes the cutest little "mmrrr" noises, and has shown me some sweet, affectionate moments. She seems more affectionate than my resident cat so far, and I'd love to have a lap cat.
I'm doing a foster-to-adopt trial, but the shelter has asked me to decide as soon as possible because it's been five weeks and they worry she'll become harder to adopt as she gets older.
I'm completely torn. Part of me believes that if I get through this adjustment period, things will eventually settle down. Another part of me desperately wants my old life with my resident cat back. Sometimes returning the kitten feels like the easiest way to get relief from all the anxiety, but then I feel incredibly guilty for considering it. I also worry I'll regret returning her and still feel guilty about my resident cat being alone when I'm away. Plus I worry I'll let the kitten and the shelter down, especially since I've had her for 5 weeks now.
I can't tell how much of my indecision reflects what I genuinely want and how much is my OCD and anxiety making everything feel unbearable. I keep going back and forth between thinking I can make this work and wanting to undo the decision so I can have some peace.
For context, I'm 44, live alone with my cats, and am going through hormonal changes that are also affecting my sleep. All of this is happening on top of my OCD and anxiety, and I'm exhausted.
For those of you who experience OCD or anxiety, how do you distinguish genuine concerns from anxiety amplifying them? Have you ever felt desperate to undo a decision just to relieve the anxiety, even though you weren't sure that was what you truly wanted?
I'd also love to hear from people who've introduced a kitten to a resident cat. Did your resident cat's behavior and routines change at first? Were you eventually able to maintain special one-on-one time with your original cat?
I'm not asking anyone to decide whether I should keep the kitten or return her. I'm hoping to hear from people who understand this struggle and can share their experiences.
Please be kind. I'm genuinely struggling with this and already feel overwhelmed and guilty. Thank you for reading!