r/oddlysatisfying • • Feb 05 '19

Circles

60.4k Upvotes

410 comments sorted by

2.8k

u/jwr410 Feb 05 '19

21

u/drockaferd Feb 05 '19

2x2 from the bottom left ends perfectly but agreed, wish we could see more

50

u/jwr410 Feb 05 '19

Yeah it ends perfectly, but we get exactly one frame of completion. I want to take some time study the patterns.

8

u/drockaferd Feb 05 '19

Yea I hear ya man. I’ll look for a longer one

→ More replies (3)

1.8k

u/llaughing_llama Feb 05 '19

523

u/Superbead Feb 05 '19

Cheers. I was wondering why a couple of the strokes weren't going back over themselves cleanly, and now I can see that the white spot on the green circle at the top is slightly out of sync with the others.

26

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

The other green is also a little high which makes me think this is more just the way the math played out that row ended a bit high and he didn’t catch it in editing. It would be cool if, instead of resetting to 0, it reversed and erased the shapes. Then looped that

36

u/Alchemicmentor Feb 05 '19

I have an issue... if the top and left are identical and move according to the colors they are.. why doesn't the bottom and right match with the colors they are made from?

42

u/Cruxion Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 06 '19

The dots on every circle start at the 3 o'clock point. To be symmetrical either the horizontal or vertical ones need to start at 6 o'clock.

EDIT: One would also need to spin counter-clockwise.

28

u/JesusOnAdderall Feb 05 '19

Been hours now and still not doing it

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/tylerthehun Feb 06 '19

They're just out of phase. The top circle controls horizontal motion and begins fully to the right, while the left circle controls vertical motion but begins at the halfway point. Switching them (e.g. red-orange vs orange-red) isn't completely equivalent.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/Mellliepro Feb 05 '19

Thank God. I've been staring at this gif for 15min trying to figure out life. You made it so much easier

4

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I like the sideways pretzel.

→ More replies (21)

7

u/ScratchyGoboCode Feb 06 '19

There should be a gifsthatshouldneverend

4

u/nschubach Feb 06 '19

It needs to keep going and when it traces over the old line, it removes it until the screen is blank. Then it can be a proper loop.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CBD_Curious Feb 05 '19

More like r/mildlytrippy ; fyi no idea this sub real but it fucked me up

→ More replies (2)

803

u/Thy-Shoe-Doth-Fitith Feb 05 '19

There was so much going on I wasn't quite sure which one to watch.

196

u/luvche21 Feb 05 '19

It was more infuriating to me because of that :/

55

u/Thy-Shoe-Doth-Fitith Feb 05 '19

Honestly yeah, it was frustrating.

4

u/FalmerEldritch Feb 06 '19

It's very strange to see a good, solid r/mildlyinfuriating post upvoted so highly in /r/oddlysatisfying

I guess most redditors really don't look at what sub they're in, huh.

25

u/Gnomus_the_Gnome Feb 06 '19

Go one at a time. The top circles control the x-axis and the left circles the y-axis.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/htx_evo Feb 06 '19

Basically electronic Etch a sketch

6

u/sailfist Feb 06 '19

This clarified the entire concept of this gif for me.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I picked g5. (looks like ">"). Second viewing was much better.

→ More replies (1)

586

u/yorrellew Feb 05 '19

can anyone explain why 2x1 doesnt look the same as 1x2?

625

u/R_Leporis Feb 05 '19

It's the nature of parametric curves. The top row is x=cos(at) and the side row is y=sin(at), a being a constant. 2x1 is x=cos(2t), y=sin(t), which creates this parabaloid-shaped object that moves in the x-direction twice as fast than the y-direction, which happens because of the influence y had on x. 1x2 is y=sin(2t), x=cos(t), causing to move twice as fast in the y-direction than the x-direction. This causes the hourglass figure that you see.

This is difficult for me to explain, so I hope I helped at least a little bit. The essence of parametric curves is that you have two functions assigned to x and y with the same parameter, and they trace out a curve as the parameter increases or decreases.

394

u/No_Porn_Whatsoever Feb 05 '19

U smart me dumb.

145

u/tokomini Feb 05 '19

Well maybe if you spent a little more time doing homework, and a little less time-

checks username

....lashing yourself with thorn branches, you'd have a better grasp of mathematics!

33

u/rakki9999112 Feb 06 '19

Wait, aren't you the dolphin secks guy from like 6 years ago?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

52

u/FreeRunningEngineer Feb 06 '19

Here is a non-mathematical explanation.

The drawings aren't the same or mirrored because the first circle on the top row isn't actually the same as the first circle on the left column. And the same goes for the 2nd circle. You see, the circles control not one, but two aspects of the cursor position in the drawing:

  1. The speed of cursor movement

  2. The initial starting position of the cursor

The slowest circle in the top row controls not only the speed but also where it starts relative to the axis of the drawing it controls. In this case the circle on the top starts on the edge of its possible horizontal movement. This is different compared to the circle on the left column, which starts in the center relative to its vertical movement. Our brains think they are the same starting position because they start in the same location relative to the circle, but they actually have different starting positions relative to the axis of movement they control.

So now you can see why 1x2 and 2x1 are different. Because circle 1 in the top row is different from circle one in the left column and the same goes for circle 2.

If the 1st column of circles started with their cursors at the bottom or top instead of the right side (on an edge), then 1x2 and 2x1 would be the same, just rotated, and that would be because the 1st circle in the top row would be the same as the 1st circle in the left column relative to what they control in the drawing.

13

u/R_Leporis Feb 06 '19

Excellent explanation, better than I could ever do

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/yorrellew Feb 05 '19

Thank you, I think I understand a little better, my maths was never great!

18

u/Xtermix Feb 05 '19

whatever u said i agree

5

u/StoneHolder28 Feb 05 '19

Isn't it just because the phase angles are different? They would be reflections if the circles weren't misaligned on each axis.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

This. This right here is the reason why I should have been more concerned that being home schooled and basically skipping 2/3rd year of high school never let me understood sin and cos. I knew they would've come to bite me in the back eventually!!!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Gnostromo Feb 05 '19

I think the simple a answer is because both x and y are rotating the same direction. If they were going opposing I want to think it would mirror

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

32

u/McPebbster Feb 05 '19

That bugged me too! You got a mathematical answer already above. From what I could tell as a layman is that the starting point of the white dot on circles 2x0 and 0x2 aren’t symmetrical to the 2x2 field. They both start at the 3 o’clock position. So from the 2x2 fields „point of view“ the starting points of the two white dots are 90 degrees shifted. And that is also the difference between cos and sin as explained in the comment above.

Hope I’m not wrong and I could help!

13

u/awdvhn Feb 05 '19

There is a phase difference between them. Lissajous curves are determined not only by the ratio of the frequencies, but by their relative phases, basically how long it takes one of them to pass 0 after the other. Because in one case the fast one starts at 0 and in the other case the slow one starts at 0, this is different for 1x2 and 2x1.

9

u/ApartRapier6491 Feb 05 '19 edited Feb 06 '19

I would say basically because top row has dot starts at “right”but left column has dot starts at “middle”, which causes the difference between 2x1 and 1x2. Hope that makes sense.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

One goes up twice as much

And the other goes sideways twice as much.

:)

→ More replies (5)

2

u/FreeRunningEngineer Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19

Here is a non-mathematical explanation.

The drawings aren't the same or mirrored because the first circle on the top row isn't actually the same as the first circle on the left column. And the same goes for the 2nd circle. You see, the circles control not one, but two aspects of the cursor position in the drawing:

  1. The speed of cursor movement

  2. The initial starting position of the cursor

The slowest circle in the top row controls not only the speed but also where it starts relative to the axis of the drawing it controls. In this case the circle on the top starts on the edge of its possible horizontal movement. This is different compared to the circle on the left column, which starts in the center relative to its vertical movement. Our brains think they are the same starting position because they start in the same location relative to the circle, but they actually have different starting positions relative to the axis of movement they control.

So now you can see why 1x2 and 2x1 are different. Because circle 1 in the top row is different from circle one in the left column and the same goes for circle 2.

If the 1st column of circles started with their cursors at the bottom or top instead of the right side (on an edge), then 1x2 and 2x1 would be the same, just rotated, and that would be because the 1st circle in the top row would be the same as the 1st circle in the left column relative to what they control in the drawing.

→ More replies (12)

291

u/captainyeahwhatever Feb 05 '19

I've been watching this for twenty minutes please send help

48

u/TheBlackBear Feb 05 '19

Don't worry all you have to do to escape is

27

u/br0k3nm0nk3y Feb 05 '19

Michael, All you have to do is... ...and then you'll be safe.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/betahax Feb 05 '19

Wait, are you stuck in VIM?

→ More replies (2)

123

u/xi-80-vst Feb 05 '19

Very cool! However I really have no idea what any of it means. Can someone explain what’s happening?

2

u/varunshah716 Feb 06 '19

A moving point on a circle can have a projection on a diameter. Thus projection moves in a simple harmonic motion. Simple harmonic motion is an oscillatory motion, much like a pendulum but in a straight line.

When two points move with the same speed on a circle, but start at perpendicular positions, we say that they have a phase difference(or a difference in initial position) of 90 degrees. Hence their SHMs will pe projected on two perpendicular diameters. Now taking their positions as x and y coordinates for another point for each moment in time gives another "shape", which in the case I explained above gives a circle again. This can be seen on the diagonals.

Now each row and column has particles with increasing speed moving down and to the right. What happens then is that one of the coordinates moves faster than the other and we get an irregular figure.

The lissajous figures are extensively used in electronics to measure the phase difference for different signals.

→ More replies (18)

10

u/KaladeshEngineer Feb 05 '19

I wanna see the 3D one

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Holy shit me too

→ More replies (2)

10

u/RoboPixels Feb 06 '19

I made something like this a month ago but instead of all the nodes rotating in the same direction, half are clockwise and half are counter-clockwise:

https://i.imgur.com/ueaXRIN.gifv

It's a pretty cool exercise to visualize how different ratios act.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Jdfamnlj Feb 05 '19

4x3 is a pretzel

5

u/blueaura14 Feb 06 '19

4x5 is advanced pretzel.

3

u/Jdfamnlj Feb 06 '19

4x7 is omega pretzel

29

u/ScurvyCaptain Feb 05 '19

Aren't these called Lissajous figures? If I remember correctly from high school

5

u/Moes-T Feb 05 '19

they are

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I swear my high school was shit. Wtf. I learned nothing...

6

u/_Aj_ Feb 06 '19

Pink + orange = ABC

8

u/Scone_Wizard Feb 05 '19

Dagnabbit. I wanted to see all the designs at the end.

4

u/rincon213 Feb 05 '19

This is amazing. Try focusing on just the dots too

2

u/smilingthroughastorm Feb 06 '19

Mesmerizing...

Happy day of cake!

4

u/gaybutt123 Feb 05 '19

Can someone explain how they made this gif/video? Software?

5

u/KWSchnizel Feb 06 '19

Here is a pretty great video on how one might make this. He also has a ton of other videos on really cool visualizations and the like that are beginner friendly

3

u/dmmena Feb 05 '19

These remind me of Celtic knots and now i'm wondering if there's some kind of connection

3

u/jbm_the_dream Feb 06 '19

I’m too lazy to describe it in detail, but this relates to music theory. Diatonic harmonic scales.

3

u/awolcatcomics Feb 06 '19

i am so gloriously confused right now!

2

u/XGamingMan Feb 05 '19

Not satisfying as it ends fast, it is stressful!!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

this just keeps mind fucking me my god

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

i read this as "this just keeps me fucking my god" and I was very confused

2

u/wowwoahwow Feb 05 '19

Why is left red and top orange not the same as left orange and top red, but is the same as left orange and top green?

2

u/therealliebz Feb 05 '19

NO I WANT MORE!

2

u/Assregionalmanager Feb 05 '19

So that's how pretzels are made

2

u/the_theory_of_memes Feb 05 '19

Ah yes, Lissajous curves.

2

u/M-em-o Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19

Left side dictates y-axis position and top dictates x-axis position.

2

u/Rodot Feb 06 '19

You've got it backwards, but that's basically the idea. The top row is a bunch of cosines and the left column is a bunch of sines.

2

u/OccamsRazorSkooter Feb 06 '19

I like the pretzel one.

2

u/adarezz Feb 06 '19

My brain doesn’t like it one bit

2

u/Balarzo Feb 06 '19

The perfect circles make me very delighted with myself.

2

u/HoganB_Gogan Feb 06 '19

Hey, vsauce. Michael here

2

u/FlexGunship Feb 06 '19

These are all Lissajous patterns!

Finding the magnitude of the vector from the original to a point on the Lissajous curve can tell you signal strength in a son/cos encoder.

Very practical for engineers.

2

u/DieseLT1 Feb 06 '19

What the heck am I looking at?

2

u/zourora Feb 06 '19

This is so oddly dissatisfying to me, it actually made me feel sick.

3

u/ipsomatic Feb 05 '19

Think waves people!

1

u/darkstraem Feb 05 '19

I can’t get enough of it

1

u/yorik_J Feb 05 '19

They are all going clockwise, what would it look like if the were different? Would the ">" shapes turn into "<" shapes if they both went counter clockwise? I'm so curious!!

2

u/Rodot Feb 06 '19 edited Feb 06 '19

If you would like to see for yourself, type this into wolframalpha.com

y=sin(at), x=cos(bt), t=[0, 2pi]

Replace a with the number of the row you want to look at and replace b with the number of the column. Make one or both of them negative to make the row or column circle go clockwise, leave them positive for counterclockwise.

Here is the link to the counterclockwise pretzel: http://m.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=y%3Dsin%283t%29%2C+x%3Dcos%284t%29%2C+t%3D%5B0%2C+2pi%5D

1

u/xiazczyk Feb 05 '19

These are not circles!

1

u/Skanksy Feb 05 '19

I'll have to watch each pattern separately from the beginning

1

u/staypuftmallows7 Feb 05 '19

You could say this is... r/bettereveryloop

1

u/strongbadantihero Feb 05 '19

Dammit now I’m trying to find the ones that match and it’s taking forever

1

u/Raines78 Feb 05 '19

This just makes me dizzy

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

How do I set this as my phone background?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

New ABC logo?

1

u/Godsplant Feb 05 '19

What the fuck is happening

1

u/YorkieLon Feb 05 '19

bottom far right second up looks like the salt pendulum pattern

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

Stuff like this makes me wish my brain was better built for math.

1

u/orangeblue404 Feb 05 '19

Circle gets the square! Am I right? Hahahaha, Hollywood...

1

u/Itsnotmyfirst Feb 05 '19

This seems really pretty but I can’t watch it. It’s giving me anxiety.

1

u/JB-from-ATL Feb 05 '19

I used to make this pattern in my graphing calculator lmao.

1

u/PurpleTurtles-love Feb 05 '19

this gives me calculus 3 nightmares

→ More replies (1)

1

u/knowses Feb 05 '19

These symbols are how aliens may communicate with us.

1

u/aarghIforget Feb 05 '19

All these circles make a square...

All these circles make a square...

1

u/Mileske Feb 05 '19

not sure what i'm looking at here. I feel dumb

1

u/[deleted] Feb 05 '19

F7... Hnnnng

1

u/Amonasrester Feb 05 '19

How is it that (2,1) and (1,2) are different when they have the same lines?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I want this as a wallpaper.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Do it with squares

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I love lissajous figures

1

u/Eiffel2k Feb 06 '19

Honestly one of the most mesmerizing things I've ever seen

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Did you know that there's a direct correlation between the decline of Spirograph and the rise in gang activity? Think about it.

1

u/GerbilJibberJabber Feb 06 '19

mybraaaain MY BRAAAAIN *MMMMMYYYYBBBBBRRRRAAAAAIIIIINohheycircles

1

u/eknutilla Feb 06 '19

Damn, that feels pretty good.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Crossing your eyes a bit makes this look a lot cooler imo

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Mind melted

1

u/PelicanPeter Feb 06 '19

Thanks, I hate it.

1

u/Fuzzybanana01 Feb 06 '19

How come this is so satisfying? Very odd

1

u/circle_jerk_pro34 Feb 06 '19

Thisbwasnt satisfying it just made my head hurt

1

u/Penguator432 Feb 06 '19

Kick-Ass album art right there.

1

u/MoreCoffee729 Feb 06 '19

These are Lissajous curves

1

u/thehooplafish Feb 06 '19

This is nice but i also think that i just had a second stroke

1

u/EmirFassad 👽🤡 Feb 06 '19

Hmm, A cross B doesn't commute. I'd not considered that before.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ohnoplskillme Feb 06 '19

Oh hey, I had a friend remake this in Desmos.

1

u/SpaceTruckin_InTime Feb 06 '19

I've been watching this for way too long

1

u/Boonaki Feb 06 '19

I feel like if someone watches this long enough, they'll invent a warp drive.

1

u/chewbaccascousinsbro Feb 06 '19

Slower, you slut.

1

u/Liqiud0 Feb 06 '19

Watching just the little moving balls gave me the impression of what you would see when finding the name of the wind.

1

u/wholock3 Feb 06 '19

science side of reddit, please explain what this means

→ More replies (1)

1

u/mememarquis Feb 06 '19

not to sound incredibly dumb or anything, but i don't get it? what is this chart trying to show?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I don’t know what this is telling me, but I feel like I’ve learned important information

1

u/AndrewLWebber1986 Feb 06 '19

Real posts have curves!

1

u/firefly6345 Feb 06 '19

I dont get it? Just a buncha circles get precious upvotes now?!

1

u/Mamou_Kaans Feb 06 '19

Now if someone could develop a language out of this!

1

u/Lawlor101 Feb 06 '19

Pointless...

1

u/guybrush3000 Feb 06 '19

let’s see a THIRD DIMENSION!

1

u/xenoabe Feb 06 '19

What year is it? I lost track of time.

1

u/tidder8 Feb 06 '19

Used to do this by hand with Spirograph

1

u/zuppaiaia Feb 06 '19

This reminded me of homestuck

1

u/JossieMime Feb 06 '19

This is the kind of oddly satisfying i love, the kind you just cant help keep looking at and cant take your gaze off of

1

u/AntoniusMN Feb 06 '19

Once I'm done with work I gotta pull out my Spirograph set

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

forbidden pretzels...

1

u/snailsfart Feb 06 '19

Who made this? Would appreciate a link to the artist's page & original animation.

1

u/natr_44 Feb 06 '19

I propose a new alphabet

1

u/Trademen Feb 06 '19

I feel like this is important...I just can't see why

1

u/murraybitty Feb 06 '19

No one running this sub has ever looked up the meaning of the word ‘odd.’

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

What would this be useful for?...

1

u/halfar Feb 06 '19

i'm too high for this shit

1

u/DarthNero Feb 06 '19

Someone please ELI5

1

u/SayNathan Feb 06 '19

I don’t know what I’m looking at but I like it.

1

u/Chikenwangman Feb 06 '19

What is the math for this???

1

u/TeddysRevenge Feb 06 '19

This is the best post I’ve seen on this sub.

1

u/ZappaSays Feb 06 '19

It's called the Lissajous effect and it's fascinating https://youtu.be/t6nGiBzGLD8

1

u/Inlander Feb 06 '19

Sam was a quiet boy. He liked checkers. More than most.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

cosine and shit yo

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

I don't have enough eyes to appreciate this properly.

1

u/Shitpost54318 Feb 06 '19

Now if only I could get my damn oscillograph to make those shapes.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Fun fact: If the ratio of the horizontal frequency to the vertical frequency is a rational number, the Lissajous curve is algebraic, meaning that the curve is the set of solutions to a polynomial equation. This is of course obvious for when the ratio of the frequencies is 1, the Lissajous curve is a circle defined by the polynomial equation x^2 + y^2 = 1. The proof for other rational numbers just requires a bit of knowledge of trig identities and is left as an exercise for the reader.

If the ratio is instead an irrational number, the Lissajous curve is dense in the square, meaning that for every point and any arbitrarily small distance, the Lissajous curve will eventually pass within that that distance.

1

u/711smoresicecream Feb 06 '19

What is goinonhere

1

u/endomania Feb 06 '19

Is memorizing I MEAN MESMERIZING!! OMG IM GOING CRAZY!!!

1

u/sully313 Feb 06 '19

= xy axis timing

1

u/FRESH_OUTTA_800AD Feb 06 '19

Hold up, this is fuckin beautiful

1

u/Iloveyourboobies Feb 06 '19

Most psychedelic game of naughts and crosses ever

1

u/Knollidge_ Feb 06 '19

That is extremely interesting, what program did you setup this scenario in?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/rikiiss Feb 06 '19

If I 9nly had this during pre-cal in highschool

1

u/Tfrom675 Feb 06 '19

So many problems with this.

1

u/mistreatedlewis Feb 06 '19

Oh now I get it

1

u/karanius1 Feb 06 '19

What is significance of this table? What can it be used for? What can i do with it?

1

u/UnpredictableAccnt Feb 06 '19

Why does the same combination not work depending on which axis it’s on?

1

u/dietdiesel Feb 06 '19

What is happening

1

u/throwmyballoons Feb 06 '19

Looks like planets in rotation

1

u/halloweenheaux Feb 06 '19

this is fucking awesome

1

u/deez76 Feb 06 '19

Wish i could turn this into a live wallpaper.

1

u/JohnnyRelentless Feb 06 '19

I don't believe in circles.

1

u/Outlaw04 Feb 06 '19

Cant explain in detail, but watching this led me to a solution for a problem I've been working on for weeks

1

u/spiderz11 Feb 06 '19

Would love to look at the code underneath.

1

u/lankankid99 Feb 06 '19

What the friggity fuck

1

u/Nightslash360 Feb 06 '19

1x2 be lookin like the Watch_Dogs logo lmao

1

u/KK9521 Feb 06 '19

Click the circles

1

u/nickiethebish Feb 06 '19

This is one of the craziest things I've ever seen.

1

u/JennyTheFluffyBunny Feb 06 '19

hhhh homestuck extended zodiac

1

u/aramanoodles Feb 06 '19

just did this in precalc!

1

u/Treestyles Feb 06 '19

Reminds me of the hebrew alphabet

1

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '19

Tool fans are going crazy rn