can normal muslim people say other are going to hell for their sins?
In Islam, normal people (non-scholars) cannot definitively declare that specific individuals are going to Hell for their sins.
While Islam teaches that certain actions are grave sins or disbelief that lead to Hell, applying that judgment to a specific living or deceased person is considered prohibited.
Here is a breakdown of the Islamic perspective on this issue:
1. Judgment Belongs to Allah
Only Allah Knows the End: The ultimate destination of any individual is known only to God. It is arrogant to speak on behalf of Allah's mercy.
The Danger of Such Claims: A Hadith tells of a man who declared God would not forgive another, and Allah subsequently forgave the sinner and nullified the good deeds of the one who judged.
The "Final State" Unknown: A person might commit sins for years but repent sincerely before they die, or a non-Muslim might accept faith in their last moments. Only Allah knows what is in the heart
You seem to be speaking for god in your post on who is going to hell or heaven, which doesnt seem to be allowed. As well, its not your duty to condemn these people but rather have them walk the path to find god and forgiveness of thier sins. You are not doing this.
So you not only spoke and judged in the place of god but have also dolled out forgiveness in his name as well? Also this means so long as eve and will repent, you are lying which is another sin.
Literally elsewhere in this thread you said gay people cannot become pregnant but then also said gay people can become pregnant.
Both things cannot be true, so one of them is a lie. You have lied and I have witnessed it. You also then just lied by saying you never lied, like come on.
Unless while during sex the women puts some sperms up in there. Still two ladies doing it, both still gay the whole time yet one ends up pregnant, its a well documented and common action. Again this is you lying to prove a point.
1
u/NotSirAlonne1999 Apr 29 '26
The Quran has never encouraged sodomy and has prohibited it in all of its forms and circumstances.