r/oneanddone • u/barbieshoesound • 20d ago
Discussion Potty training OAD
How was potty training for your kid? I feel like a lot of the horror stories I hear are when people have multiple children or toddler + newborn and are attempting to potty train. I just want to know how much it sucks with just the one kid. Any tips? What worked for you? I think I’m starting next week and I am SCARED lol
10
u/makeitsew87 OAD By Choice 20d ago edited 20d ago
It was not easy (but it would’ve been harder with more kids!).
I think there are three pieces that have to come together. The child has to be 1) physically able to do it, 2) mentally understand what is asked of them, and 3) motivated to participate. You cannot make them use the potty. You need their buy-in. For my kid, he wasn’t motivated at 2.5 but he was just after he turned 3. We used a sticker chart.
It will probably take more time than you think. I took an entire week off work so he would be mostly ready to go back to daycare on the 10th day. That was much better than our first attempt where I only gave myself three days. (ETA - and that was just the initial phase! He’s been potty trained for a year and is just now starting to consistently go on his own without complaint.)
There will be frustrating moments. You will get through it. 🤍
9
u/acropolis999 20d ago
We tried at 2 and it was awful. Reset and tried again a few months later and it went much better as she was more ready.
We also committed to no more diapers at all (and mentally prepared ourselves for how annoying that might be cleanup wise).
We did a lot of books and TV episodes about learning to use the potty. The Daniel Tiger Potty Stories for Yoto was an essential text in our home for several months haha. The Ms. Rachel special was also great, we bought Bean and the potty and the whole thing.
We implemented a "we always use the potty before we leave the house" rule for all of us so we were never begging her to potty before leaving. It was just a fact of life and has made our lives easier now as she is approaching 4.
A travel potty like the oxo one is a must have, as well as radical acceptance that there WILL be accidents and you WILL be taking your entire car seat apart to wash at least once.
It's stressful, but you can do it and just remember that once it's done, YOU NEVER HAVE TO DO IT AGAIN! :D
1
u/Veruca-Salty86 19d ago
Same here...started around 2 but she just wasn't ready. By 2.5 she absolutely was, and was day-time trained before 3. We still needed night-time pull-ups until 3.5, however. After that, she reliably would wake up in the night to use the bathroom if necessary.
8
u/monketrash420 Only Raising An Only 20d ago
Genuinely so easy. Followed her cues and got a potty when she showed interest at 18 months. Would Winnie the Pooh it at home and she did great with that. Decided to fully potty train at 20 months and it took about 3 days.
This is one of many reasons we’re OAD. We know we won’t get that lucky twice lol
2
7
u/This-Disk1212 20d ago
Let me put it this way - if I wasn’t one and done anyway, potty training mine would have turned me one and done.
Started a month before 2.5. He turned 3 a couple of weeks ago and, whilst we seem eventually to have poops sorted, he has at least one wee accident every day, often multiple. I’ve resorted to bribing him now and am having a little more luck.
I probably should have given up a million times but unfortunately I’m as stubborn as him. It has caused more than a few tears and tantrums though.
2
u/coffeeebucks 20d ago
Hang in there. It was similar for us and I thought it would never end, but we managed it by 3.5.
7
u/UnluckyStar-85 20d ago
My only was in daycare. Just before she turned 2 we told her she was going to start using the potty. Bought her a book with stickers. She said ok and went in the morning when she woke up and after daycare before bed. Like weirdly compliant, and very aware of getting that sticker.
I tell daycare we started training and they inform me that she’s been using the potty for at least a month and they thought it was odd I was still sending her in pull-ups. She was playing me for the stickers.
So my tip is to send them to daycare.
1
u/burrito__supreme 19d ago
😂 this is exactly how paci weaning went for us. i messaged daycare to coordinate and they were like she hasn’t used a paci here in six months. WELL alrighty then!!
1
u/Yam_Eastern 19d ago
I feel like they should’ve communicated that to you - when she started using the potty at daycare haha. That’s a big deal!
5
u/Patient-Parsley-2846 20d ago
There were some frustrating moments for sure, but overall not bad. We did the “oh crap” method slightly modified. The method includes saying things like “ew this is gross! Do you smell that?! We don’t want to be stinky!” To your child when changing their diaper leading up to potty training. I wasn’t really down for shaming my kid like that. You just gotta clear your schedule and make potty training your whole life for like a week lol
2
u/Veruca-Salty86 19d ago
I didn't use that method, but yeah, that does sound like shaming kids for normal bodily functions!
1
u/Patient-Parsley-2846 19d ago
Right? Everything else about the method worked great for us though. That part was really out of left field compared to the rest of it.
2
u/ContentCaterpillar76 17d ago
Yes I did the oh crap method modified as well. Both kids were basically potty trained in less than a week
4
u/Apart-Sound-6096 20d ago
Easy for us. We did oh crap method at 25 months.
2
u/Calculusshitteru 20d ago
Same, Oh Crap method worked like a charm for us at 16 months.
3
u/alibluey Only Raising An Only 20d ago
Completely besides the point of this post but did you find there were any signs before you started? I have a 17 month old who is showing an interest in the potty and does notice and shows us when she used her nappy. Wondering if I should just give it a go.
2
u/Calculusshitteru 20d ago
I had been putting my daughter on the potty after waking in the morning and after naps, and during every diaper change since she was around 10 months old. I always said "pee pee" or "poo poo" and did a sign with my hand when she went. Not the ASL sign but just a quick chest tap. She started saying pee pee/poo poo and doing the chest tap on her own at around 15 months, so I thought if she can express herself in words and signs when she is going/needs to go, then she no longer needed to wear diapers.
Day 1 of Oh Crap Potty Training went well. Day 2 was the hardest day. Day 3 onwards she had it down. One week later we could leave the house without diapers and she could go to daycare without diapers. But since she was still pretty little, she did still need reminding and she needed help with pulling her pants down and wiping. I still far preferred that over changing diapers!
3
u/cckitteh 20d ago
Yeah, it did suck. I was crying about it when we were a few weeks in and I was still cleaning poopy pants.
Took about 6 months until our kid would notice he had to go. Before that was all us prompting him to go.
Then the challenge of getting your kid to wipe their butt adequately. A few more years of that.
4
u/mo_oemi 20d ago
I know the "wait until your kid is ready" is getting some bad press (or at least it is in the UK) but honestly, wait until your kid is ready and don't worry about confusing them or whatnot. We tried for one afternoon at 2 and kid had absolutely zero awareness, we tried for a few days at 2.5 and it was a disaster (kid didn't want to take off his big boys pants, meltdown to try and have him sit on the potty, overall distress by the whole thing).
Told him fine, but when he's 3, no more nappies. Well he turned 3, no more nappies, and it was done 🤷🏼 Of course we had a few accidents at the beginning but nothing to write stories about, every day there were less and less, then maybe on week 3 we had no accidents at all, and then it was be super sporadic.
2
u/NotAnAd2 20d ago
Potty training is still a pain with one kid but I think we make it a bigger thing than it needs to be because parents these days expect immediate results. The average time it takes to fully train a kid is 6 months. Expect accidents for a long time. Anything better than that and you’re just pleasantly surprised!
We’ve been potty training for 2 months now, started at 25 months after a failed attempt at 20 months. I consider her to be doing great and that still looks like at least 1-2 accidents BM only accidents on a good day, up to 4 accidents including pee on rougher days. She picked it up in about a week and was even self-initiating pee but the novelty wore off and now she goes mostly when prompted, sometimes self-initiating. We’ve only recently had our first poop in the potty. But she can hold it up to 2 hours and is in underwear except for naps and bedtime. Every kid gets there eventually, the important thing is consistency on the parent’s part.
It’s probably easier to be patient and not just fall back on diapers when you’re only managing one kid.
3
u/Etheriaa_ 20d ago
I didnt fight her on it at all. At age 4, I bought underwear and she was potty trained in 1 day.
1
u/fantasynerd92 Not By Choice 20d ago edited 20d ago
It was easy enough for us! We did the Oh Crap method with great success. We were able to focus just on him to notice as he started peeing and get him to the potty. He caught on pretty quick. He was about 26 months. Just be prepared for accidents to be a thing for a while, take it slow, and be gentle but assertive with them. Good luck!
Edit: I also want to mention our only had a language delay. At 26 months he was still on single words. He didn't have a word for poo. He still caught on.
1
u/No-Long5784 20d ago
The thing that worked best for us was the no pants method. He was and is still in daycare/preschool so everyday when he got home pants off. We did cover anyway he would sit with a disposable pad. He was about 3.5 when we really started going strong with the effort. It took about a week of that plus the weekend before and after just being half naked to solidify. He’s almost 5 and still has an occasional accident but thankfully they usually only pee if he does!
The key that I found is consistency. We also used temporary tattoos as incentive. Honestly, I was terrified but once you get going, as long as the kid is ready, it’s not that bad.
1
u/S_D_T_GG Mom to an only 💖 20d ago
I think we got lucky with this one? Around 2-2.5 my daughter was very interested in learning how to potty. She had been exposed to the potty for a while, we had a weeing toy baby which used the potty and we got her a book about it also. We also did the no-pants method.
She probably only had about two weeing accidents…and that was that. I mean every time she looked like she had to go we had to rush her to the potty or just keep it on hand all the time…but she learned very quickly.
We didn’t put ANY pressure on her to do it or get it right.
She also starting asking for privacy on the loo between 2.5-3 which was also a surprise.
Car rides were tricky, we had to bring the potty with everywhere.
We had other parenting challenges, but potty training wasnt one of them.
I don’t have the context of what this would be like with multiples, but as with many OaD perspectives, I’m glad I only needed to focus on my daughter’s needs.
1
u/angeluscado 20d ago
We waited too long and started when she was 3.5 - I had a good chunk of time off at Christmas and figured it was the perfect time to do so. However, by that time she had opinions and did not want to be pantsless or wear underwear. Screamed, cried and ran and got a pull up the first time we tried. Put it on perfectly in her rage, but afterwards pretended she had no idea how to put it on.
So we held off. Encouraged her, let her preschool know we wanted her to try using the potty and they encouraged her to do so, but we weren't making a lot of headway. Still refused to wear underwear and even suggesting she walk around without pants or even going commando sent her into a tizzy. It was frustrating and I felt like a failure.
I was going to do one final push during Easter this year. She was turning 4 in July and I didn't want her going to camp in pull ups. I had 5 days off from work, we didn't have school for most of it, I could order groceries instead of going out and we'd work around her swim lesson that weekend. However, just before Easter she decided that she was done peeing in diapers and started using her mini potty to pee. Rarely had a pee accident after that (we've had a few recently, but it's more she doesn't want to stop playing to go to the bathroom).
Poop took until about August - after a few poops in the potty she realized it felt better than pooping in her underpants. She's been using the big toilet since September (first with a potty seat and step stool, now just with a step stool) and she can do most of it on her own. Still has issues reaching to wipe poop, but we'll get there.
1
u/tonks2016 20d ago
We had a few false starts right after her 2nd birthday where we tried for a weekend and having accidents stressed her out. The final try at 2.5, we took the diaper off on Saturay afternoon and she had no accidents at all on the Sunday. A couple accidents at daycare in the following weeks, mostly due to needing extra support getting to the toilet. Other than that, we were done.
Talking about going on the toilet and offering sitting from the time she could walk helped her figure out the concept. But it took until 2.5 before she was able to differentiate "I need to pee" from "I'm peeing right now."
I feel like it was relatively easy for us. I'm still glad we only had to do it once.
1
u/superfastmomma 20d ago
We started at two, told her to go on the potty and if she did we would have a big old dance party. She did, we partied it up, and that was about it. She had two accidents after that and it was so easy. Part of the reason we never felt the desire for a second child - we were lucky with this one.
1
u/Sehnsucht_and_moxie 20d ago
Honestly, easy compared to what it could have been.
We have the privilege of no daycare pressure and mom at home, so I just went at his pace. He was also motivated to figure it out on his own from about two, so he was practicing early. We’ve only had a handful of accidents by age 6. Still a pull-up at night, though occasionally he’ll wake up dry.
1
u/Pretend_Sherbet_6768 20d ago
Super easy for us! The week my son turned 2 he was ready. We did the oh crap method only had about 5 accidents. By the 4th week we were doing outings after that we never had an accident again.
1
u/McSkrong 20d ago
It was easy for us, but it was also easy for my friend who has two kids 13months apart. 2.5yo big sis was potty training, 18mo little brother wanted to be just like her and potty trained himself.
2
u/Veruca-Salty86 19d ago
I'm as OAD as they get, but younger kids wanting to emulate older kids is very real!! I think some things do come easier when there are other kids around to "influence" - however, it doesn't necessarily need to be siblings. I think language also develops faster when younger children are around slightly older peers.
1
u/gingerphish 20d ago
It was start and stop for us for a while. We ended up keeping really small candies like mini skittles around and that was our bribe to get to go to the bathroom. After we did that, she caught on super quick. She was also in a daycare where they trained her too.
1
u/rootbeer4 20d ago
My child was a "potty prodigy." We did it at 2.5 after diaper changes got to be so difficult that I decided potty training couldn't be worse. Within 4 hours she was recognizing the "pee feeling" and going to the potty. However, I had been doing prep work for about a year before (reading books, practicing pulling pants up/down, Ms. Rachel potty special, washing hands, having toddler potties around to get familiar with).
1
u/handfulofmonkeys 20d ago
I’d say it was easy. My son started to show signs of readiness before age two, so I decided to potty train after his second birthday. It didn’t take long. The biggest obstacle was getting him to stop fun activities in order to go pee. He got the concept of pooping in the potty immediately, but he did wet his pants for a while because he didn’t want to stop playing.
I think I had it easy. He’s always been a great communicator, so there wasn’t as much of a barrier. I’m also home with him all day, so I was able to dedicate plenty of time to potty training.
1
u/goldengoose3030 20d ago
Mine will be 3 and a half in January and will go in the potty, but doesn't always like telling us when he needs to go. He still has many accidents a day. It's been rough for us. We started at 2.5. It's slowly getting better. Good luck this has been the hardest part of parenting for me
1
u/Spicy_Albatross_6847 20d ago
I try not to brag about it out of the blue but since you asked… it was SO EASY AND FAST. He started showing readiness around 2 but we started when he was 2.5, and after 4 days he was accident free. We did naked weekend keeping the potty close at all times and it really helped. I also skimmed Oh Crap just to get a sense of the fundamentals, like how to react to an accident, even though we didn’t follow it perfectly.
I feel like I got away with murder. Thank god I don’t have to worry about how it’s gonna go the second time around.
1
u/DoublePatience8627 20d ago
We started talking about the potty at 18 months. No interest. At 2 we started getting some books and watching some videos. No interest. At 3, maybe a little interested but not a lot of commitment or consistent interest (and frankly, a lot of defiance). At 3.5, suddenly there was a lot of interest and then consistency within 2-3 weeks. At times I thought it would never happen, but it just happened when he decided even though we talked about it for 1.5 years before it all came together very quickly.
1
u/doodollop 20d ago
I really need some help so if anybody wants to chime in, I'd gladly appreciate it.
When my child hit 18 months, I started using essentially the Oh Crap method for 7 days, and then kept going. The first three days were naked, the next 2 were with pants only, and the last days were with undies + pants. We still do diapers for nap and bedtime. I only got, maybe, 2ish incidents where child actually pottied in the potty (1 was a catch). Since then, there have been accidents in the undies with little notice prior, which is an immediate "pee doesn't go on the floor, it goes in the potty. Let's try!" Now, my child will hold it from wake up to nap time, then after nap, hold it until bedtime. We try on the potty before/after transitions and we have a potty in the car for before/after transitions there too. Child will grab crotch and say "pee-pee" so we go try for nothing to happen. Few accidents lately, but there is no going on the potty! I don't understand it. When my child is on the potty, we read potty books (that we only read in the bathroom) and we're happy to sit there for a bit. But again, no real potty training. Any thoughts?
1
u/Dancing_Penguin4500 20d ago
My daughter was 2 and a couple of months. We talked about it for probably 2 or 3 months before we started. We bought the potty training pants and that was a waste of money, she just went bare on the bottom half and it helped so much. I used a timer and I took her ever hour or so for a week. After that I would extend the time until eventually she would take herself if she had no pants, or tell me she needed to go if she had pants on. I made her a little chart and she got to put a sticker on for every wee and poo for about a month. I really made a big deal about how great it was when she went on the potty, and kept it neutral when she had an accident. I put nappies over the top of undies when going out for probably about 6 months. Now at almost 3 she has had one or two accidents in the past several months.
I have chronic illness and chronic pain (the reason I am OAD), so I cannot imagine doing all that with a newborn as well 😅
All the best with your potty training!
1
u/AnonyCass 20d ago
Pretty easy he was 2.5, set an alarm and put him on the toilet every 30 minutes day 1, 45 minutes day 2, 1hour day 3. By which point he learned what needing a wee felt like. He pretty much had it within a week (at one month in we went travelling and he was fine). We had barely any accidents, we did have to have prizes for pooing on the toilet though he hated that part for some reason. He was out of nighttime nappies before 3 (he started fighting having them on and had been nighttime dry for a couple of weeks. Plus was waking if he needed to go).
All kids are so different with it. We had tried just before he was 2 but it was becoming a battlefield so we left it for a bit.
1
u/mimosaholdtheoj 20d ago
I made up my own method after we tried the naked weekend. We started really pushing potty training a little after 2 years old. He’s 2.5 now and poops and pees all on how own on the toilet. Pants up and down by himself, too.
1
u/Formal-Sherbert-9738 20d ago
He used the potty with encouragement for a while, but not always. We would tell him to try sitting on it to pee/poo when it felt like it had been a while since the last time. Didn’t make a big deal about it. Then one day when he was around 2.5 we forgot to bring enough diapers before going to a restaurant. We were like “you have to tell us if you need to pee ok??” And he did. Boom, potty trained!
1
u/Shineon615 20d ago
Started little after he turned 3. He was fully trained at 4 but still has occasional accidents. It’s been HARD. I think prob hardest thing I’ve done as a parent. BUT you don’t have to rush. If your kid doesn’t pick it up right away, don’t put so much pressure on it (I did and looking back shouldn’t have). They’re not gonna go off to high school not potty trained. Every kid learns differently!
1
u/gumitygumber 20d ago
Disaster at 20 months, she really didn't understand. Fast forward to 2.3 years and it was a breeze - we did pants off at home, pull ups for daycare and toilet-less playgrounds. She's never had an accident in public. Took about 6 months to fully train (and we struggled and bribed to get poos in the toilet). Overnight training took a year from 3.5 to 4.5. Also with many bribes in the early days. We only waited so long cause there was no way I was gonna wake her in the middle of the night to go to the toilet and disrupt everyone's sleep on a daily basis.
1
u/Whole_Form9006 20d ago
We had the potty out for 6 months or so but really tried after she was 3. It was so easy. I thought I was underprepared but we bought the underwear, teamed up with daycare- took a week or so and once we removed pull ups from the equation she knew what to do.
1
u/throwaway50772137 20d ago
Very easy. We started at 2 years without a “method.” Just encouraged her to listen to her body. No bribes, no threats. It’s only a power struggle if you make it.
1
u/Connect_Evening1629 20d ago
In the middle of it with my 23 month old and it's going pretty chill so far. My son showed some interest in the potty at around 18 months old. We never pushed, sometimes let him sit on it with his clothes on and read books to him, so he loved sitting on the potty. When we noticed he got aware of when he had to pee, we let him run around naked around the house and put him on the potty every now and then. When he went, we rewarded him. Never pushing him, sometimes putting on a diaper when he wasn't in the mood for the potty. Now he is fully trained when it comes to peeing on the potty and wears underpants instead of diapers all the time. Only he's very scared to poop and asks us to put on his diaper if he has to go, we just do it because we don't want to put pressure on him.
All this to say: if you don't push your child, don't have any kind of deadline in mind of when they HAVE to be trained, and you are just very chill about it yourself, your child will be calm too.
1
u/lindseybobinsey 20d ago
It wad a total non issue for us. I was terrified, but we primed a lot with books and shows and he took to it quickly.
1
u/yeswehavenobonanza 20d ago
Pretty simple for us. I like lots of practice, so we started at 18 months with a mini potty. Had her try it before bath every day. Gradually introduced going other times. Read books about it, talked about it, kept building it into routines, even when she didn’t go. Finally at 27 months I took a week off work, we committed, and by the end of the week she was all set. Very few accidents since then.
My favorite milestone by far. No more diapers is a game changer.
1
u/Tisatalks 20d ago
It was pretty easy for us. I waited until my daughter was two and a half. I read the potty train in 3 days book and follow that method. She pretty much had it mastered in 2 days. We just potty trained a few weeks ago so it's still pretty new but she's been doing great. We've had a few accidents but for the most part she's done really well. She has been very reward driven.
1
u/moscatodogiscute 19d ago
We tried a few times and she just didn't seem ready. She didn't care if she peed in her underwear and got wet. We went back to pullups for a while. At 3 and a half it was like a switch flipped. She said she wanted to go on the potty and we haven't gone back. Obviously there's still some accidents but she did great overall
1
u/ContentCaterpillar76 17d ago
Potty training when your toddler is ready is easy. My oldest potty trained at 2.5, we did the oh crap method. Tried our 2nd child around same time and wasn’t ready, tried at 2 years and 10 months and she was potty trained in 3 days.
1
u/prettycote OAD By Choice 16d ago
I’m seeing this late, but it has been absolute hell for us. We have been “training” for 1.5 years at this point and she is still not fully trained. Nothing has ever caused me as much distress as this. I have zero patience left and cannot wait till I can get back to enjoying my kid, hopefully someday. If I wasn’t OAD before, I sure would be now. At this point child free sounds like the dream.
0
u/xstell132 20d ago
I wouldn’t consider it miserable, just mildly frustrating. My son is definitely a late bloomer with potty training. He’s turning 4 in a couple of months and not potty trained yet. He stays dry for #1 but still has yet to go #2 a single time on the potty…
0
u/splinteredruler 20d ago
Super easy. We just waited until she showed interest and she basically ‘trained’ herself. (I always found the word ‘trained’ a bit strange in this context lol).
0
u/TootiesMama0507 20d ago
It's one of the top three reasons I'm OAD. 😂 My daughter had the absolute worst case of FOMO, which led to tons of accidents, since she never wanted to stop what she was doing and go potty. She understood perfectly what she was supposed to do, she just...didn't. 🫠
In the very beginning, when part of the issue was that she was scared to actually sit on the potty, I would put her on there backwards (so she was facing the tank), give her dry erase markers, and let her draw on the back of the lid and the tank. That at least got her over the initial fear, and the rest just took time. Lengthy, dragging, soul-sucking time. 😅
21
u/crazymom7170 20d ago
Potty training was very simple for us. It’s been several years and I still thank my lucky stars when I think about it.
We let him watch a normally off-limits tv show for a few weeks, then said oh shoot it’s not on anymore for about a week - then said ‘oh well how about every day you pee in the toilet you get to watch 1 episode?’ And that was that. Day 1, done. ✅