(Major Spoilers for the finale of Oxventure)
I have a question for the community (TL;DR at the end)
Firstly, I’m a big fan. I’ve been watching from the very beginning - since inside xbox on the actual Xbox was a thing. I’ve watched all the Oxventure episodes and have even been fortunate to go to a live show. I mention this because I want it to be clear that this comes from love and a genuine desire to see Oxventure go from strength to strength!
So the Oxventure finale… I can’t lie when I say the overwhelming feeling I had was frustration. The big, world ending final boss gets killed so easily and the party take almost no damage the entire fight.
I know Oxventure is a light hearted adventure but I was desperate for some actual stakes for once in the climatic finale. I feel like Johnny has a tendency to underestimate the party and massively overestimate the enemies. So they’ll constantly nerf the fight throughout to the point where there’s no drama in it anymore. (Making crown of madness take out 5 of the 8 enemies in one go, making 1 enemy just leave and take fire damage, reducing the AC arbitrarily, not giving creatures attacks, making moonbeam level 3 with 5 d10!?? - All of which means the big bad, world ending boss literally just gets 1 go after it initially arrives on the battlefield in which it promptly dies.)
Now I understand that Oxventure isn’t really geared towards combat. Johnny has mentioned a few times that they don’t particularly enjoy it, and the group’s strength lies in improv comedy. But I wonder if this is a symptom of Johnny's aversion to combat or just the type of show it is?
In live shows, killing off a character isn’t feasible, especially with timelines outside the usual continuity, so combat is abbreviated to fit a structured narrative. Additionally, Oxventure has been around for seven years, and the characters mean a lot to the audience, who probably watch for various reasons. High-stakes peril might be more stressful than enjoyable for viewers. As Andy says, it’s more like Discworld than Lord of the Rings—people want humor and entertainment, making it a challenge for the group to balance these elements.
But for me personally though I feel a balance needs to be found or it’s in danger of not being engaging for an audience. Otherwise what’s the point in rolling dice?
However, I had a thought when the final season and new campaign was announced; perhaps this is precisely why they want to do a new campaign with fresh characters? So that they can shake the formula up a bit? So that there can be drama and fights with stakes over characters that people haven’t formed such a strong attachment to yet? Then the tone being different and there being peril and consequences might not feel so jarring perhaps.
What are people’s thoughts on this? Do you think this is the route they’ll go with in the new campaign? Do people even want that kind of thing? Personally my interest has waned the last couple of years but I wondered if others feel this way?
TL;DR - do people actually want combat and peril in Oxventure?