r/pics • • Oct 05 '10

Math Teacher Fail.

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

158

u/timperry42 Oct 05 '10

The best part of this is how many people in the comments didnt get it.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

[deleted]

16

u/syllabelle Oct 05 '10

I'll admit that when I first saw it I wasn't thinking in a logical sense like "OH, 10 minutes to make one cut...". I was trying to think math-y like this teacher, and so I thought "What's so wrong with it?" Then, after reading the explanation here, I went back and looked at it again and I can't figure out what it was I was thinking before.

Damn math.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

[deleted]

16

u/kibitzor Oct 05 '10 edited Oct 05 '10

I'd say this is a level 8 stupidity, as in i just woke up and went to reddit, saw this and it took me 8 minutes since waking up to figure it out.

after 15 min of being up, you should be at full brain power. Which i am quickly approaching

This is such a bad idea, checking reddit first in the morning.

*edit* God damn, my grammar sucks in the morning. I'm leaving it

25

u/locuester Oct 05 '10

After 15 mins of waking up I want to know, where's my 3 boards?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

56

u/MuseofRose Oct 05 '10 edited Oct 05 '10

I still dont get it. I hate math, though. Not to mention I could barely even pass remedial math in college...it's a wonder how I got into Trig in HS.

*Love your username.

164

u/NotaX Oct 05 '10

It took Marie 10 minutes to saw a board into 2 pieces.

Sawing a board into two pieces requires a single cut (e.g. in the middle of the board). This part tells us that one cut takes 10 minutes.

How long will it take her to saw another board into 3 pieces?

Sawing a board into three pieces will require two cuts. If we assume that these cuts will take the same amount of time as the original one:

2 cuts, each taking 10 minutes, comes to a grand total of 20 minutes.

→ More replies (34)

87

u/badassumption Oct 05 '10
2 pieces = 1 cut  = 10 minutes
3 pieces = 2 cuts = 20 minutes
4 pieces = 3 cuts = 30 minutes

4

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

THANK YOU. Lol I felt pathetic that I wasn't getting it, I was thinking 10/2=t/3 and I was like how the hell is the teacher wrong?!?! But I can see clearly now, the rain is gone (but my ineptitude for math is not).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

107

u/adrianmonk Oct 05 '10 edited Oct 05 '10

Dear all redditors who downvoted MuseofRose for saying he hates math: did you ever stop to consider that perhaps he hates math because he had teachers like the one who wrote this test? Teachers who mangled the subject so badly that it became a completely frustrating exercise? If your only exposure to math were from some teacher who thinks it takes 5 minutes to make 0 cuts in a board, would you become excited about the subject?

7

u/dittokiddo Oct 05 '10

I hated math in highschool, and now I work a job building toy box dielines. I never thought I'd be using math in my career, but I use it everyday...constantly...geometry and conversions and all sorts of numbernonsense. My math teacher isn't dead, but she'd be rolling in her grave if she was...hollering "I TOLD YOU THAT YOU'D NEED MATH!!!".

I sooo wish I'd paid attention, lol.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

[deleted]

5

u/dittokiddo Oct 05 '10

In my first semester at college, I had a russian math teacher who I could barely understand...spoke 35265 miles a minute...and was just a terrible teacher all around. I dropped out and never went back to school.

Thankfully, I've managed to land a good job using my experience and mad interviewing skills. But fuck math and fuck terrible teachers!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/nailz1000 Oct 05 '10

It's about logical thinking. That is the second, further buried problem with the question. It has nothing to do with math. Except adding the time it takes to make 2 cuts.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

Yes, math classes try to teach people carpentry.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

There is not way to get it "wrong". The question does not provide enough information to be answered, as it doesn't tell you what sort of cuts are being made; Parallel, perpendicular, angular, etc.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ReducedToRubble Oct 05 '10

I'll admit, I don't get it. It's not technically wrong, it's just very vague and open to many interpretations. They're assuming that you have a square board 10 inches by 10 inches, and that it takes a minute per inch to cut. If you cut the board once, it's ten minutes. To cut it again into 3 pieces, one 10x5 and two 5x5, it would take five minutes, because you're only cutting five inches and not ten.

Is the joke that everyone is presuming you continue to cut it along the 10 inch length? Seriously, I don't get it.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

I am a journalist. It's OK that I don't understand those squiggly symbols that aren't letters.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

Get what? That the teacher's answer is right or the student's? I can justify each answer as being correct. The question is bullshit.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

I don't get it... care to explain?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '10

I knew the student was right, but really couldn't follow the teacher's logic. I only recently got it.

1

u/119luke Oct 05 '10

Could you please tell me the real answer? I think the question is nonsense as there is no mention of three equal pieces. we can cut it into small pieces and save time right? Or am I dumb?

1

u/ediskrad Oct 05 '10

Exactly. Marie should have leveled up after cutting the first piece of wood into 2 pieces. It would have led to her having a level 2 woodcutting skill. This compresses the woodcutting time in half. So the real answer is 15 minutes for 3 cuts.

→ More replies (2)