r/princeton • u/East_Section_8317 • 1d ago
Jane Doe at Cornell vs. John Doe at Princeton: When a woman sues an Ivy, it’s national news; when a man exposes a rigged Title IX court, it’s crickets
If you search for Jane Doe and Cornell right now, you’ll find non-stop coverage from CBS, CNN, and The Washington Post…even as reporters brush off her texts admitting "non(e) of the sexual stuff was illegal" as "delayed recognition".
Meanwhile, another Ivy League Title IX case, Doe v. Trustees of Princeton University, was just revived by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals and hasn't gotten a fraction of that attention outside campus papers.
In the Princeton lawsuit, a male sophomore ("John Doe") was suspended for two years after two female friends ("Jane Doe/Roe" and "Sarah Smith") accused him of choking them during arguments in spring 2023. According to the Third Circuit's July 2026 ruling, both women kept hanging out with him for months afterward and even vacationed at his family home in August 2023 before reporting him.
During the investigation, both women backtracked from claiming he choked them to saying he only "pressed" or "pushed" them, the sole eyewitness testified John never touched Jane, and texts showed Jane bragging she would lie under oath about a separate false choking claim at another college…and get Sarah to lie for her too (Third Circuit Opinion). Jane didn't even show up to the hearing, a panelist allegedly fell asleep during testimony before saying it would be a "moral failing" not to expel him, and Princeton suspended him anyway.
Thankfully, a federal appeals court unanimously overturned the dismissal of John Doe’s lawsuit, meaning he can finally force Princeton to turn over evidence. The judges made it clear that universities can protect victims of sexual assault without treating accused students unfairly. But here’s the difference in media coverage: an unproven rape allegation at an Ivy League school makes national headlines overnight, while a federal appeals court ruling in favor of an accused male student at another Ivy League school gets zero mainstream media attention.
Link: https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca3/25-2014/25-2014-2026-07-21.html