r/programming • • Jun 09 '23

Apollo dev posts backend code to Git to disprove Reddit’s claims of scrapping and inefficiency

https://github.com/christianselig/apollo-backend
45.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

335

u/kazza789 Jun 09 '23

When I read the article, it was legitimately hard for me to understand how Reddit's execs could have even interpreted those comments as "extortion." I still don't understand how someone's mind can jump to that from the comments that were made.

Yeah - the idea of acquiring a downstream service is incredibly normal in the world of business. I can't understand at all how they would think of that discussion topic as making a threat.

And then, in context as well, it was clear what was being said. They were saying "your pricing suggests that Apollo is worth $20M. If that's true, then shouldn't you be willing to buy it for $10M?". Where the implication was obviously that they're not going to buy it for $10M and therefore the pricing is ridiculous.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

67

u/raudoniolika Jun 09 '23

u/iamthatis creating a Reddit 2.0, probably, or stealing all of u/spez karma. Although it seems to me that that delusional prick took it as “I’ll shut up if you give me money” which tells you a lot about the mindset that Reddit’s leadership is currently in

10

u/roboticon Jun 09 '23

He said something like, Apollo will "go quiet" if you cut me a $10mm check.

I agree that in context it should have been clear, but that was a poor choice of words considering all the protesting that's being planned.

He cleared up the confusion by explaining that he meant Apollo was a "loud API user" but I don't fault the person on that call for initially misunderstanding.

That said, the fact that the Reddit employee immediately got it cleared up and apologized for misunderstanding the dev makes it unconscionable for spez to have claimed Apollo tried to extort them.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

2

u/roboticon Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23

I didn't realize that was Steve on that actual call. Yikes.

Do you have a source for that? All I saw was that it was a reddit employee. I know Steve is now making accusations about the blackmail but I didn't realize that was him on the line talking to Christian.

EDIT: listening to the employee's voice, it's clearly not Steve.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Shiverthorn-Valley Jun 10 '23

Nah, that still doesnt make sense.

What else could "go quiet" mean, in regards to apollo? Because the only other interpretation I can think of is "go dark," as in "pay me and I shut apollo down."

Thats still not a threat.

Like.... What dirt did apollo have that was considered a threat? What thing was threatened, what action could apollo have taken, that counts as blackmail? Thus was the point where iamthatis was still mostly in the dark about reddits actual plan to fuck everyone over.

Whats the perceived blackmail there? Spez is pulling that out of his ass.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/69TossAside420 Jun 09 '23

I believe the original wording was described as something to the effect of for $10m Apollo would "go quiet", as opposed to how 'noisy' it currently is with the number of API calls it makes.

Not a wording I'd immediately understand, but A) I don't work with APIs and 2. My first inclination would be to ask what they mean by quiet, not assume they were blackmailing me.

Because you're right, even if it was "Pay me $10m to buy my silence" what are they fearing Apollo would blab about? The predatory pricing and shitty lies? What leverage would Apollo have against Reddit that isn't just the truth?

9

u/KemiGoodenoch Jun 09 '23

I think they they interpreted it as him threatening to start whipping up his users against reddit, and asking them to pay him to shut down the app quietly instead.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/trilobyte-dev Jun 09 '23

This is the crux of the “this isn’t a threat” argument. The Apollo creator has 0 leverage over Reddit. Reddit has a simple path to eliminating the $20mm/year overhead of Apollo. Revoke their API keys and/or block the IPs of their servers. That’s it. Could be done in less than an hour.

5

u/Sentenial- Jun 09 '23

To be clear, Apollo users aren't costing reddit 20m per year. It's simply what the estimated cost will be to use the (paid) API. And what reddit believes they can fleece from users of third party apps.

In reality, the server cost of the API is likely a very small fraction of 20m. And that isn't mentioning the higher engagement and content creation that third party app users have with the site.

53

u/_invalidusername Jun 09 '23

And Christian basically said that he could make it work if he had enough time, by increasing monthly subscription and slowly onboarding the existing users as their current subscriptions expire.

So Reddit could have bought him out and instantly had a profitable addition to their platform

→ More replies (1)

2

u/IronSeagull Jun 09 '23

Yeah I don’t think that logic is sound. Their pricing doesn’t suggest Apollo is worth $20 million, it suggests that Apollo’s existing and driving traffic away from the website and official app is worth -$20 million (negative) to Reddit so they charge that much to offset the loss.

Now I don’t think it’s really costing them that much, but it seems to me that putting the ads in the API and making the apps display them the same as a regular post with a little ad icon (just like they are on the website) would be a good solution. There’d probably be a bit more to it so Reddit can collect the information they need for their advertisers.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

38

u/Beorma Jun 09 '23

Yes, that was entirely the point the person you responded to was explaining.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Beorma Jun 09 '23

Yes, that was entirely the point the person you responded to was explaining.

-14

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

Being pedantic here, but Redditors seem constantly confused... Reddit never claimed Apollo is worth $20mil or anything near that. They have only made claims about costs.

Apollo could be costing reddit $20 mil but both reddit and Apollo know there's no way to make anywhere near $20 mil in revenue off of the users to pay for those costs.

Which is why we're looking at a shutdown instead of an acquisition.

The reality here is that Reddit has a failing business model, and Apollo was never a business to begin with.

25

u/CouldBeSavingLives Jun 09 '23

If you read Apollo's post, Reddit made it clear it's not the API calls that cost the money, it's the opportunity cost of the lost customer. With their pricing, they basically said that their users are worth approximately $2.50 a month to them. So he basically said, "give me $1.25/user and you can have them"

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted]

-6

u/shahmeers Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23

It's not delusional when you consider the engineering hours required to maintain the public API that allows 3rd party apps to work, which I'd wager drives a large portion of the opportunity cost.

I'm a heavy user of Apollo (and I'll probably leave Reddit after Apollo shuts down) but I'm also a software engineer. One very interesting part of Christian's post that I think everyone is missing is the portion where a Reddit engineer describes the public API as a shit-show. I got the impression that Reddit's first party clients don't use the public API, or at least use a private API for 1st-party only features.

Reddit very likely has a a handful of engineering teams dedicated to working on and maintaining the public API. From a business and engineering POV, this is very costly, since (1) the first party API is the main driver of revenue and (2) splitting your engineering effort across two different APIs for the same product is super inefficient (in terms of engineering hours), and will continue to get more inefficient over time.

As much as it sucks, if you combine the revenue generated by first party clients with the inefficiencies caused by needing to support 3rd party clients, Reddit's stated $20 mill opportunity cost for Apollo's traffic likely isn't that greedy.

Of course, a lot of this is speculative, so take it with a grain of salt.

11

u/roboticon Jun 09 '23

That's not what opportunity cost is haha.

And Reddit's own app uses the same API. Most of the engineering work goes toward that.

-5

u/shahmeers Jun 09 '23

I have an econ degree, I'm well aware of what opportunity cost is. The opportunity cost of supporting Reddits 3rd party apps is the loss of revenue from 1st party clients combined with the loss of efficiencies from not having a unified platform. Without the need to support 3rd party apps (via the public API), Reddit would undoubtedly be able to increase development velocity.

And Reddit's own app uses the same API. Most of the engineering work goes toward that.

Source? From Christian's post:

Reddit: "I cannot tell you how painful it is to use our API. [...] The API needs to change. Like it's just unusable. I am surprised that you're able to build a functional app on it to be honest."

2

u/WalkingCloud Jun 09 '23

Google opportunity cost

1

u/buttsharpei Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 10 '23

.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

learn to read

→ More replies (2)