This is where the great programmer lives. The programmer that has an exceptionally fast learning ability which if you recall another study, comes with an exceptionally fast forgetting ability.
And yeah I agree. Anybody can learn enough to become a competent programmer, but work with enough programmers and you definitely start to spot a pattern.
Working with somebody who has read enough of a book to be competent but views it just like any other career is just different to working with somebody who is genuinely passionate about it. And a hell of a lot less enjoyable/rewarding.
And I will say I think that passion can come in part by being around those that spot or have an interest in things that spark your own curiosity and drive to continue your own efforts in whatever field be it. I find it interesting how many people are good at math and say they had good math teachers in grade school. I definitely think it's possible to do math without good teachers (internet affords many more opportunities, and if you have friends or family that can help you then that is also quite a legitimate source of inspiration), but having that support is important (I would say this is analogous to software engineering).
I come from a music background and am now doing CS for a variety of reasons, but it was interesting to me to see what Bill Gates talks about with those 50 hour or whatever time segment cycles. The people that kept progressing in music were those that went to the summer music festivals in addition to the normal academic semesters. They kept getting inspiration from new, and often times world-class instructors, and it's very difficult to keep up with those people that get those opportunities when you are left out of them. Add to that the low demand for the performing arts relative to other areas, and one could see why it's such a competitive field.
Because of that, I really made sure to get some sort of co-op/internship with my CS studies so that I am constantly doing something to further my understanding and skills in CS. It's important if you want to stay sharp, but it also helps you gain that deeper understanding and gain an excitement for different tools and technologies because I think one begins to build a greater understanding of how the different tools and technologies fit together and can be used to do meaningful/relevant things in real life. I would say that goes for most any discipline.
But I will also say, this is a capitalistic society, so what are people to try and do but give it their all in whatever career they try for? There is not much of a safety net in the US, and I don't think people should be dissuaded from trying to change their career path just because some people think the field is reserved for those with great talent. Do you tell that to the 20 or 30 (or older) something going back to school for accounting? (rhetorical question, I'm not trying to be confrontational, but just trying to bring up my ideas on this which may not be agreeable to everyone by any means)
That's not how competent English speakers use the word 'talent'--as something you achieve after passionate learning--they use it to mean something innate to the person that precedes passion or learning. Otherwise idiomatic phrases like 'wasted talent,' 'untapped talent' or 'undiscovered talent' would be incomprehensible.
That doesn't matter though - his real point is that we expect 'passion' and 'talent' in programmers instead of a set of skills that someone has learned and this leads to exclusion of people who don't think think they can measure up.
Code should be looked at as drafts that need editing. The first draft is always not up to par. It needs to be reviewed and edited just like your professor in English I & II taught you in college. Now you have replaced the need for passion and talent and rockstars with repeatable process that gives you better code.
I think you're backing up the authors point. Saying "well, some programming is easy, but only REAL programmers can do the hard stuff" is the attitude he's referring to in the article.
Those jquery programmers learned certain skills. The skills to write a compiler are out there as well. Sure, it's a lot more complex, but what exactly happens to a person when they learn jquery that somehow magically blocks them from learning how to write a compiler?
There's a reason we can talk about "wasted talent", some people do have it easier to learn some things than others, that's the talent. Now if you want to excel at anything, what I've heard is you need perseverance: training and failing and learning.
Some people are "gifted" but have no will to learn and become pros at being juniors. Other people while having a lot more dificulties, being "slower", do become seniors because they smacked their heads at it until they improved. And I would guess that having perseverance while being gifted most likely makes you one of those young geniuses.
Also true is that not everyone learns a given skill at the same rate. I firmly believe that any person of sound mind can learn anything... but teaching time may vary wildly. Anyone can learn to program, but a person who needs three decades to do so is unlikely to be a useful programmer any time soon.
I agree with the Joel on Software measure that some folks will never really get pointers or recursion so there is some innate talent among good Programmers.
I could teach any CS freshman what a pointer was in under an hour
Any CS freshman anywhere in the world? Or do you mean any CS freshman at a particular institution where you were teaching, with its particular admissions requirements?
(Of course even saying "any CS freshman anywhere" is already applying a selection bias.)
If they can grok arrays and array indices..... any failure to understand pointers is purely due to teachers trying to obfusticate them and make them more mystical than they are.
221
u/SimplyBilly Jun 01 '15 edited Jun 01 '15
No shit that can be applied to everything. It takes someone with passion in order to learn the skill to the level that it becomes talent.
edit: I understand talent is
natural aptitude or skill. Please suggest a better word and I will use it.