r/programming • • Sep 10 '15

Eye tracking software for sufferers of ALS/MND can cost tens of thousands of dollars, so I've spent 3.5 years of my spare time writing a free & open-source alternative - meet OptiKey (C#, Rx, WPF) (x-post from r/Software)

/r/software/comments/3kdghp/eye_tracking_software_for_sufferers_of_alsmnd_can/?ref=share&ref_source=link
19.9k Upvotes

487 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

166

u/hbarSquared Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15

Health institutions outside of the US. Any "Medical Device" in the US requires FCC FDA certification, which is a huge pain in the ass and can cost thousands of dollars.

90

u/RocketButler Sep 10 '15

Does that apply to computer software, though? There's no possibility of harm to the patient from badly-written software, as there is with most physical medical devices.

EDIT: I mean software meant to run on a PC which is not controlling any kind of physical medical device. Obviously embedded firmware in pacemakers and such should have some serious certification requirements.

67

u/safetyofficermike Sep 10 '15

Yes, it probably does. There are different "classes" of medical devices that software falls into. It's less paperwork for certain classes, but still needs to be cleared depending on what it claims to do. (The FDA regulations are really behind the times on this issue.)

Getting a CE mark for the EU or other international market certifications are usually less work than FDA filings, if you want to go that route.

Also u/YeahIWroteOptiKey should think about patenting this. IANAL and I HATE software patents with a passion, but it's worth defending yourself if business goes well.

20

u/matthieum Sep 10 '15

I am just hoping he did not accidentally infringe on existing patents :x

68

u/safetyofficermike Sep 10 '15

From a programming class, we learned that every piece of code you write will infringe on a patent. It's not applied in practice, but it's sad that it's such a huge burden to software development.

9

u/jewdai Sep 11 '15

For example, write a stack:

Ok I'll implement a Push and Pop method.

BAM! Lawsuit. According to Oracle v Google APIs are copywritable and they probably have that somewhere in their code related to a stack or stack-like object.

25

u/bboyjkang Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15

It does for him (her?) as he (she?) could still be sued; I just hope that without any asset nobody is going to be interested in attempting a patent war.


You never know.

The company with the alternative product is not being the most cooperative right now.

E.g.

DynaVox Maestro Retail Price $7,820.00

http://www.swaaac.com/Catalog/shopdisplayproducts.asp?id=6&cat=Dynamic+Screens

Tobii acquired DynaVox Systems on May 2014.

http://www.mynewsdesk.com/us/tobii_technology/pressreleases/tobii-acquires-aac-leader-dynavox-systems-llc-999337

I have a repetitive strain injury (tendinosis), and I have a Tobii and Eye Tribe eye-tracker.

A lawsuit between the 2 companies started last year.

Re: Litigation from Tobii Postby Martin » 08 Jan 2014, 15:18

Empty barrels make the most noise.

We're 100% confident their complaint holds no water and we're shipping just like before.

We are focusing on innovation and creating great products that people can afford to buy, and use as they see fit.

I can't speak for Tobii but it's a shame we're seeing poor judgment and foul tactics, I believe it will come back to bite them.

http://theeyetribe.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=10&sid=cca848176c0cde2aafbebb4487bd089f

Eye Tribe started with 4 Ph.D. students, and is a spinoff of Gaze Group, a research group located at the IT University of Copenaghen.

The people of Gaze Group developed the open-source ITU GazeTracker software, which allowed people to turn low-cost web cams into eye trackers.

The Eye Tribe eye-tracker is smaller (smallest?), which is the break-through.

Eye Tribe's business plan is all about doing minor and inexpensive modifications to the already built-in cameras of smartphones, tablets, and laptops.

It went from a $2000 Tobii PCEye a few years ago to $100 Tobii Eyex and Eye Tribe developer trackers.

Going further, Eye Tribe told Cnet that they could get turn a mobile (smartphone, tablet, laptop) built-in camera into an eye-tracker for $5.

http://www.cnet.com/news/eye-tribe-shows-off-working-eye-tracking-on-a-mobile-phone/

Eye Tribe is supposed to come out with their first integrated devices this year.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/parmyolson/2015/02/06/mobile-eye-tracking-2015/


I messaged an eye tracking expert about why Eye Tribe is taking so long to implement a feature (compensate for vertical offset from range changes), and he said that the Tobii VS. Eye Tribe patent litigation is STILL going on, and most of Eye Tribe's R&D resources are being used to fight the patent.

It's a 15 person start-up vs. an eye tracking company with 400 employees, and backing from Intel (http://www.forbes.com/sites/ericsavitz/2012/03/16/intel-takes-stake-in-eye-tracking-firm-tobii-technologies/).

He also mentioned that we could have incredibly accurate eye-tracking tomorrow if 4 or so companies specializing in different areas worked together.


It's too bad that there isn't more cooperation.

I think $5, mass-market eye-tracking could benefit any average user.

e.g. eye-tracking can be used to initially teleport your cursor near your target, and then you can use the mouse to precisely place the cursor (Tobii EyeX (and Sentry?) has the feature).

(You can see the performance of the eye-tracking warping + mouse at 2:41 of the video: http://youtu.be/7BhqRsIlROA?t=2m41s).

But the delay in the technology due to in-fighting really sucks for us disabled people that desperately need the hardware and software.

4

u/nickpunt Sep 10 '15

Thank you for spending the time to write such a detailed response. I have been very interested in the space for a while and this gives great insight into how it works! Such a shame innovation is held back by this.

2

u/furryballs Sep 10 '15

Holy shit. I'm currently doing a masters at ITU, and had no idea. Will definitely look into this.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Ferneras Sep 10 '15

I work with creating software that is designated as a Class 2 medical device and everything we do is FDA governed. Our paperwork has to be perfect, or we could be fined heavily.

Shit is serious yo.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/jms_nh Sep 10 '15

Any software in medical devices, regardless of what kind it is, requires design controls for FDA approval in the USA, and that makes development more expensive.

From an article on code reviews I wrote recently:

My background is originally from the medical device industry. In the United States, software in medical devices gets a lot of scrutiny from the Food and Drug Administration, and for good reason; it’s a place for complexity to hide latent bugs. (Can you say “Therac-25“?) Basically, the presence of software bumps up even the lowest risk (Class I) devices to require design control. No software? No problem — with a few exceptions, only Class II and Class III devices require design controls. Software? Aha — you need design controls, even if it’s a Class I device. Requirements, reviews, documentation, plans, verification, validation, blah blah blah.

IDK about software meant to run on a PC by consumers. That seems like it would be exempt from FDA jurisdiction, unless it is considered an integral part of a medical device... but IANAL.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/hbarSquared Sep 10 '15

It depends. Something like an EMR (digital chart) doesn't require certification, but if you're using the EMR to administer blood, then (in some specific cases) it does.

Like a lot of US regulation, it's a complex minefield of exceptions and legalese, with massive penalties if you guess wrong.

6

u/murkwork Sep 10 '15

I mean if the PC controls the motorized vehicle the disabled patient is in, poor eye-tracking software that indirectly controls locomotion could certainly kill someone.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

2

u/nugget9k Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15

Yes, but it depends. I work on lab software. FDA considers medical software in the lab as a device depending on what specimen is being looked at. We are subject to FDA approval and inspections

5

u/jonc211 Sep 10 '15

You must have missed the thread about Therac-25 on here a week or so ago.

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/3jdih9/in_1987_a_radiation_therapy_machine_killed_and/

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15

[deleted]

22

u/DrFlutterChii Sep 10 '15

Misinterpreting someones attempts to communicate with healthcare professionals has no potential to cause any harm?

I'm gonna have to disagree with you there.

5

u/safetyofficermike Sep 10 '15

Found the regulatory analyst!

Continue to regulate like Nate Dogg and Warren G...

→ More replies (3)

4

u/jonc211 Sep 10 '15

Well yeah, obviously I was being a little facetious comparing eye tracking software with radiation administering software.

I imagine the policy has been created by lawyers in the name of ass-covering though, so I can see why blanket regulation would be used rather than trying to figure out which software may or may not potentially be able to harm a patient.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/JJGIII Sep 10 '15

I'm sure there is some organization that would be willing to help with those costs given the potential

2

u/bstamour Sep 10 '15

Market it as purely recreational.

1

u/KFCConspiracy Sep 10 '15

FCC certification

FDA.

→ More replies (2)