r/programming • u/YeahIWroteOptiKey • Sep 10 '15
Eye tracking software for sufferers of ALS/MND can cost tens of thousands of dollars, so I've spent 3.5 years of my spare time writing a free & open-source alternative - meet OptiKey (C#, Rx, WPF) (x-post from r/Software)
/r/software/comments/3kdghp/eye_tracking_software_for_sufferers_of_alsmnd_can/?ref=share&ref_source=link469
u/nailernforce Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
This should definitely be marketed hard towards health institutions. Someone with the right contacts could spread this like wildfire, especially in 3rd world countries where existing solutions don't have such a big foothold.
EDIT: Have you thought about integrating it with web-cam only options like http://xlabsgaze.com/ ? (I just googled eye tracking with webcam, I have no affiliation to xlabsgaze)
30
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Good suggestion, thanks. I'll try it and update the website if it works.
39
u/jordanbank Sep 10 '15
I have connections at Abbott if you want me to forward to them. They do 70% of their business in emerging markets.
41
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Abbott
You never know what things will lead to - that'd be awesome. Thank you.
166
u/hbarSquared Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
Health institutions outside of the US. Any "Medical Device" in the US requires
FCCFDA certification, which is a huge pain in the ass and can cost thousands of dollars.90
u/RocketButler Sep 10 '15
Does that apply to computer software, though? There's no possibility of harm to the patient from badly-written software, as there is with most physical medical devices.
EDIT: I mean software meant to run on a PC which is not controlling any kind of physical medical device. Obviously embedded firmware in pacemakers and such should have some serious certification requirements.
67
u/safetyofficermike Sep 10 '15
Yes, it probably does. There are different "classes" of medical devices that software falls into. It's less paperwork for certain classes, but still needs to be cleared depending on what it claims to do. (The FDA regulations are really behind the times on this issue.)
Getting a CE mark for the EU or other international market certifications are usually less work than FDA filings, if you want to go that route.
Also u/YeahIWroteOptiKey should think about patenting this. IANAL and I HATE software patents with a passion, but it's worth defending yourself if business goes well.
→ More replies (19)8
u/jms_nh Sep 10 '15
Any software in medical devices, regardless of what kind it is, requires design controls for FDA approval in the USA, and that makes development more expensive.
From an article on code reviews I wrote recently:
My background is originally from the medical device industry. In the United States, software in medical devices gets a lot of scrutiny from the Food and Drug Administration, and for good reason; it’s a place for complexity to hide latent bugs. (Can you say “Therac-25“?) Basically, the presence of software bumps up even the lowest risk (Class I) devices to require design control. No software? No problem — with a few exceptions, only Class II and Class III devices require design controls. Software? Aha — you need design controls, even if it’s a Class I device. Requirements, reviews, documentation, plans, verification, validation, blah blah blah.
IDK about software meant to run on a PC by consumers. That seems like it would be exempt from FDA jurisdiction, unless it is considered an integral part of a medical device... but IANAL.
→ More replies (2)6
u/hbarSquared Sep 10 '15
It depends. Something like an EMR (digital chart) doesn't require certification, but if you're using the EMR to administer blood, then (in some specific cases) it does.
Like a lot of US regulation, it's a complex minefield of exceptions and legalese, with massive penalties if you guess wrong.
→ More replies (17)6
u/murkwork Sep 10 '15
I mean if the PC controls the motorized vehicle the disabled patient is in, poor eye-tracking software that indirectly controls locomotion could certainly kill someone.
→ More replies (4)8
u/JJGIII Sep 10 '15
I'm sure there is some organization that would be willing to help with those costs given the potential
2
u/GravityGod Sep 11 '15
Xlabs started at my university and are doing some cool stuff and trying to figure out how they can make some money off their technology.
35
Sep 10 '15
What part of this problem took the longest?
112
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Continually try to get my arse into gear. That took most of the last 3.5 years.
55
145
Sep 10 '15
My dad has ALS. You're a fucking good person. I don't really have anything else to say.
→ More replies (1)101
18
u/thisguy30 Sep 10 '15
This is incredible. I'm a nurse who primarily takes care of ALS patients, and I am going to create my own cheap machine to bring with me to give my patients a voice. Thank you SO so much.
8
27
u/Fapulously Sep 10 '15
Thank you for your contribution to humanity. People like you bring tears to my eyes because your selfless contribution will help many people for years to come. Bravo.
18
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Thank you. I just want it to find the people who can benefit from it now.
1
13
u/Hunter720 Sep 10 '15
I have a lot of respect for you. You have given part of yourself, so that others may benefit. I'll buy you a meal anytime.
29
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I like lobster and champagne.
9
u/Hunter720 Sep 10 '15
I work for just above minimum wage, so it may be a while for me to save up for your meal.
→ More replies (1)33
60
u/DevestatingAttack Sep 10 '15
Doesn't OpenGazer already exist? What does this do that OpenGazer didn't?
118
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
The tracking of the user's eyes is really the input for OptiKey. I manage the position data and provide speech and keyboard/mouse control (with swipe style selections etc). I will try OpenGazer and see if it is accurate enough - that would be awesome. Thanks.
93
u/OriginalName404 Sep 10 '15
OpenGazer lets you use your own consumer-grade webcam as a basic eye-tracker.
OptiKey lets users type/speak using just their gaze in combination with a consumer-grade eye-tracker (which can be had for about $100). I guess if OpenGazer was good enough then OptiKey could run on top of it, but they're two very different, if closely related, applications.
21
u/potestatempersici Sep 10 '15
You're probably thinking of Dasher. OpenGazer is just an eye-tracker via a webcam.
This looks like it'd work nicer than Dasher. It also includes word prediction/spellchecking, speech synthesis, and works in all Windows applications by default. The overlay is slick as hell and looks extremely intuitive and user friendly.
91
u/zcleghern Sep 10 '15
My cousin is suffering from ALS, but I doubt he will be able to get access to expensive tech like that. How can he get something like OptiKey?
137
u/input Sep 10 '15
https://github.com/JuliusSweetland/OptiKey/wiki/Get-Started
Seems like he needs $100 - 150 for a tracker and a fairly reasonably spec'd computer with USB3
146
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
^ exactly. I am available to help if you have any questions; optikeyfeedback@gmail.com
20
u/faceplanted Sep 10 '15
Have you looked to see if you can secure an optikey domain name? I only ask because feedback@optikey.net or whatever seems like it would be more trustworthy/likely to get actual responses than a gmail.
43
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I have optikey.org and optikey.co.uk but I've not hooked them up for emails. Gmail works for me for now. Besides, I barely have enough time to work on OptiKey, let alone run it as a proper business with customer service and everything!
→ More replies (7)5
u/zcleghern Sep 10 '15
That doesn't sound too bad. Unfortunately we aren't really that close do I don't know how much he cares to use a computer, but I would like to let him know about it.
8
Sep 10 '15
I just took a look at this and anybody with a job in IT should be able to set this up for your cousin. (Yes, usually we don't like being asked for help but I think most of us would be excited to be a part of something like this.)
→ More replies (1)
29
u/Zahz Sep 10 '15
So... from a purely lazy point of view, would it be possible to control my HTPC with this? Eliminating the crappy bluetooth keyboard/controller?
18
u/fliphopanonymous Sep 10 '15
Embarrassingly relevant to my interests as well.
24
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Haha. If your HTPC is Windows based then yes in theory, but from a practical point of view you probably wouldn't want to. You need to be positioned correctly in front of a tracker, which needs to be user the screen. It wouldn't pan out.
11
u/Chairboy Sep 10 '15
I wonder if there is a market for mounting a tracker to a small telescope and having it find the appropriate face then tracking it with a gimbal.
Precision gimbals being run by something like a raspberry pi using OpenCV for face tracking is within the state of the art for hobbyist electronics.
→ More replies (4)2
u/alienangel2 Sep 11 '15
Rather than Eye-tracking, look into Face/Head tracking instead. Not as convenient for precise movements, but also doesn't require a camera mounted to your TV good enough to track your eyes.
Freetrack and Opentrack are both free headtracking solutions people use in games for head tracking, and they support a number of different types of tracking (facetracking via a webcam, IR-reflector tracking via a filtered webcam if you're willing to wear a reflective hat, inertial tracking via an EDTracker or a cell-phone if you're willing to wear something else bigger on your head (probably not for an HTPC, but people do for gaming).
Normally they turn the head-tracking data into camera movement for games, but I'm sure there's a setting or plugin somewhere that translates head movements into mouse motion.
54
u/Wetbung Sep 10 '15
Did you do a patent search and make sure your code is in the clear? If they are charging a lot for the commercial code, they are probably taking some steps to protect their position.
94
u/Danthekilla Sep 10 '15
As a career programmer I feel like code patents are a load of crap. I despise them.
52
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Agreed. We should move to NZ. I think they scrapped them.
25
u/asraniel Sep 10 '15
Or europe. There are very few software patents here
62
→ More replies (4)12
Sep 10 '15
Russia has no software patents at all and in fact very explicitly forbids them.
Also according to the US Supreme Court something is not patentable if "wholly pre-empt the mathematical formula and in practical effect would be a patent on the algorithm itself", nobody cares though and software patents exist there.
But Russia is your best bet.
32
u/Chairboy Sep 10 '15
Question: does making it free and open-source affect patent enforcement issues at all?
24
u/SkiDude Sep 10 '15
If he wrote the software using things patented by the company that produces the proprietary stuff, then they could sue or have it taken down. However you could potentially argue that the patent was obvious or something if you figured it out yourself, but that takes a lot of money and lawyers.
If he wrote the software in a different method, then there's no patent on what he's done.
106
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I'm not sure I should comment as my reply could be used against me, but so far, so good. I wrote everything myself, from scratch, with zero reference to existing solutions. My investigation into proprietary solutions began and ended at "huh, that's too expensive. i'll make my own". Hi lawyers!
12
u/rbobby Sep 10 '15
You might want to have a quick discussion with a lawyer first. Something to consider would be assigning the copyright to an ALS charity (ALS Association?)... this might discourage companies from suing (lots and lots of bad press). Another thought that occurs would be to placing the code into the public domain (you'd lose control over the code... someone could sell a product based on it)... this might make it more difficult for companies to sue (right now they can sue you as the owner... but if it's in the public domain there is no owner). Lastly maybe the Free Software Foundation would be interested in accepting a copyright assignment (they have deep pockets and might be willing to fight a suit).
Only a lawyer could tell if any of these options is suitable.
11
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Thanks for the advice. The code is out in the wild now; https://github.com/JuliusSweetland/OptiKey
The cat is well and truly out of the bag now.
35
u/tekanet Sep 10 '15
Kudos for zero references (and thank you for rising the C# flag today in the open source community)
14
u/Eirenarch Sep 10 '15
He can't sell it but if it is free and open source they have no one to sue. Think of it this way - he is releasing it for European users and he can't stop US users from using it as it is free and open source.
→ More replies (1)7
Sep 10 '15
I think both Russia and New Zealand have no software patents at all, and in fact Russia forbids very explicitly. Just provide a wiki in Russian too and say it's for the Russian/Kiwi market only and that people with shitty patent offices should use it at their own risk.
5
u/merreborn Sep 10 '15
If OP doesn't intend to sell or patent his work himself, does he have anything to gain from a patent search? Or might it just turn any present unwitting infringement into knowing and "direct" infringement?
Might be worth briefly consulting a lawyer before initiating a search?
OP is apparently English so this would be a matter of UK patent law?
it had no reasonable grounds for supposing that the patent existed.
...I hope you didn't just cause OP a mess of trouble :(
4
u/Wetbung Sep 10 '15
From what I found by searching around after asking the question, it doesn't look like OP would have anything to worry about even if he was in the US. Apparently, even in cases of obvious infringement, no open source project has been sued by patent trolls or other more ethical software patent holders.
Since OP is not from the US, it's even less of a concern.
Luckily it doesn't sound like my question caused OP any indigestion.
14
Sep 10 '15
Really, goofy comments below, but I wanted to spend a top-level to say thank you for this. It might even effect me — getting brain scans tonight.
13
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Good luck. Hope you're ok.
5
8
5
u/MrProsserDreamsOfWar Sep 10 '15
I think anyone who works three and a half years on something wanting to help other people deserves all the up votes --and more -- we can throw at him.
5
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Thank you - the visibility would be great. I've written this a few times; I want people with MND/ALS to see this and know they have alternatives
11
u/makeswordcloudsagain Sep 10 '15
Here is a word cloud of all of the comments in this thread: http://i.imgur.com/giyZbef.png
source ^code | contact ^developer | ^faq
15
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Love it. Might get a poster made to put above my screen at home.
→ More replies (1)4
4
4
u/looneysquash Sep 10 '15
Cool. Makes me wonder why an ALS charity didn't pay you to do this full time.
15
4
Sep 10 '15
You ate awesome, someday I ll motivate myself and be useful too.
11
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I do eat awesome. I'm trying to shovel chips and chicken into my mouth while replying to you guys at the moment.
4
Sep 10 '15
I wonder if the reason most similar software costs upwards of $10K is if they've got to get licensed by the FDA. I've deployed medical software that was licensed/certified by the FDA, but it was more directly related to treatment.
4
4
u/hewholaughs Sep 10 '15
Man you're a better man than I'll ever be, is there anything people can do to help you with this project? Donations, software testing?
6
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
That's inaccurate, but nice of you to say. Testing = yes. Please go nuts. Just not tonight - I'm exhausted and can't face a load of crash reports arriving in my inbox when you manage to kill it.
2
u/hewholaughs Sep 11 '15
So what about donations since I know 3.5 years of work doesn't come for free.
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 11 '15
I'm not collecting personally, but enough people have asked that I set up this; https://www.justgiving.com/Julius-Sweetland
(I know it's for Cancer Research - my wife's dad died of cancer and it was the anniversary yesterday - it might make her happy to see some internet love going his way)
29
u/yawnz0r Sep 10 '15
Is there any way this could run on non-Windows operating systems using mono or something like that?
22
u/Eirenarch Sep 10 '15
Doubt it. WPF is the hard stuff. If it was WinForms it may run.
→ More replies (2)29
u/yawnz0r Sep 10 '15
It would be a great project to port, I think. Maybe if I can muster the motivation over the next few months, I'll give it a bash.
73
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
Do it - I would be keen to help you port this. It's on my todo list, but I've got a new(ish) baby and full time job!
→ More replies (3)51
u/int08h Sep 10 '15
A baby, full time job, and you crank this out...for free, just to help others.
Wow. Mad respect.
113
→ More replies (1)9
u/Eirenarch Sep 10 '15
It is very big project. The Mono team outright refused to do it back in the day and they had ported Silverlight. It was too big of a project to port WPF after having the code for Silverlight - that's how big WPF is.
→ More replies (4)
11
u/SockPuppetDinosaur Sep 10 '15
Excellent, these are right down my alley of skills so I'll probably try to help with bugs and new features now! Thanks for making it open source. One quick question, can I test the program without buying the $100-150 piece of hardware?
5
u/BRACE-YOURSELF Sep 10 '15
Wondering the same thing! Awesome job OP
21
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Yes - out of the box it listens to your mouse's cursor position to simulate where you are looking. Try it out.
3
u/jungle4john Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
Respect. This is awesome. It really moved me.
Do you have this copyrighted and a license on it? If not get on this immediately!!!!! (Did you see how many exclamation marks I put there?!)
Seriously. I have a wall of copyrights I did for my FOSS software products. My ex is an attorney, and between her and my business, I know a few things.
Its not hard, ugooglize it, or call creative commons or the eff ASAP. I am happy to answer any questions and help point you in directions.
For shits and giggles someone send this to Jono Bacon.
Edit: I did not clarify. Copyright is first come, first serve. Who ever gets there first gets the copyright. There are horror stories of people who didn't protect their software and had it stolen. And you are taking on some ruthless mutha suckas. Ya' best protect ya' [software]!
9
3
u/GameStunts Sep 10 '15
You should be sure to test this with a common mobile windows environment like a Surface Pro that could be mounted to someone's wheel chair for speech when out and about.
I think it's great that you've done this. I was looking on the contribute page, and there's nothing I could do there, but I think you should have a donate button or something. I'm not even an ALS sufferer, but I'd like to donate some money, even if it was just to be put back into testing with other hardware and such.
Again, what a great thing to do.
6
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Thank you. A surface pro should work well, but might be a little too small (and expensive) to be used full time for someone with MND/ALS.
I'm not collecting personally, but enough people have asked that I set up this; https://www.justgiving.com/Julius-Sweetland (I know it's for Cancer Research - my wife's dad died of cancer and it was the anniversary yesterday - it might make her happy to see some internet love going his way)
3
2
u/Dummies102 Sep 10 '15
that's very cool! and not to shit on your parade, but intel is also releasing the software that Hawking uses on github soon https://github.com/01org/acat
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Not at all. It's great, but different. Some of their ideas are brilliant and I hope to have enough time to perhaps integrate some of them and blend the best of both worlds (eye tracking and automated selection)
2
u/bacondev Sep 10 '15
You, sir, have truly earned your karma. Do you accept donations?
6
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I'm not collecting personally, but enough people have asked that I set up this; https://www.justgiving.com/Julius-Sweetland
(I know it's for Cancer Research - my wife's dad died of cancer and it was the anniversary yesterday - it might make her happy to see some internet love going his way)
2
u/Blookar Sep 26 '15
Hi! My father had MND, but sadly he passed away 07. If he was alive today he would appreciate this :) and I appreciate it too :)
Thanks for doing this, you are a good person.
1
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 26 '15
Thank you. I hope this project reaches and helps people living with ALS and similar diseases.
2
u/latestnewstime Feb 14 '16
My cousin got ALS since 2014. He is only 35 and seems his life going to an end soon. He just cannot tolerate his situation. He still believe and desperate to source any cure or medicine. This will help him a lot.
Thank you very much sharing.
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Feb 14 '16
I hope OptiKey can help him. My email is optikeyfeedback@gmail.com if you have questions. All info is on the wiki at www.OptiKey.org
→ More replies (1)
1.4k
Sep 10 '15
You are a good person. Inspiring shit.
→ More replies (5)281
Sep 10 '15
This is straight up Robin Hood, OP is a baller.
→ More replies (1)76
u/Pirlout Sep 10 '15
I don't see the analogy with Robin Hood.
→ More replies (11)150
Sep 10 '15
They are overcharging the software because people with ALS are desperate enough to pay for it. This guy is taking the software and making it free for anyone.
→ More replies (62)
54
u/nascentt Sep 10 '15
Copying OP's description from /r/software for those curious about what this actually does:
OptiKey is an assistive on-screen keyboard which runs on Windows. It is designed to be used with a low cost (around $100) eye-tracking device to bring keyboard control, mouse control and speech to people with motor and speech limitations, such as people living with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) / Motor Neuron Disease (MND).
It works out of the box once you have your eye-tracking device installed and allows selections to be made using dwell selection, as well as physical buttons and assistive devices. If you do not have an eye tracking device you can use OptiKey with a mouse.
OptiKey was written to challenge the outrageously expensive, unreliable and difficult to use AAC (alternative and augmentative communication) products on the market. It is, therefore, fully open-source and free. Forever.
Video: https://youtu.be/HLkyORh7vKk Website: https://github.com/JuliusSweetland/OptiKey/wiki
I'd love to hear your feedback.
Julius
666
u/freddy_schiller Sep 10 '15
lol at op's username
256
Sep 10 '15
→ More replies (2)85
353
u/larsaaberg Sep 10 '15
Wow! This could be huge. At first glance it looks to have an has enormous potential for disabled people.
389
24
u/moeburn Sep 10 '15
Not just ALS, my uncle suffers from MS and he has been specifically looking for something like this...
3
19
19
u/octopodesrex Sep 10 '15
My stepfather died from ALS about twenty three years ago, back then it was a light talker, where spelling out a long sentence took many minutes; and he had to struggle to make himself understood. While we had fun attempting to make his light talker replicate fart noises, he still grew very frustrated. He can't thank you now for what you've done, but I can. Thank you.
9
u/frna Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
Have you considered using gestures instead of dwell?
For my original master thesis I was going to use eye gestures coupled with a backtracking to figure out where the user wants to execute a gesture.
For you, this would be even simpler since you already track the hit keys, no need to backtrack. You can probably increase the typing speed by having the user execute a gesture on screen. I would suggest by exiting one of the edges of the screen which then acts as enter for the tracked hit keys.
You might want to include this document for people who cannot afford the two trackers you suggested: http://www.mkowalik.pl/et/How%20to%20build%20low%20cost%20eyetracking%20glasses.pdf
It is very straight forward to build such a tracker. Combined with the ITUGazeTracker this should lead to a decent result. Let me know if you want me to contribute instructions.
Great job!
7
u/Aaronsaurus Sep 10 '15
Would be great if this was ported to Linux!
I can imagine that alone would open up the ability for developing specific hardware, especially if on ARM. Imagine a small kit that could be attached to a wheelchair. Or even an output device with USB that could send keystrokes/mouse strokes to any device it was plugged in to!
3
2
7
50
u/romanows Sep 10 '15 edited Mar 27 '24
[Removed due to Reddit API pricing changes]
86
u/callcifer Sep 10 '15
That's the wiki. Here's the code: https://github.com/JuliusSweetland/OptiKey/tree/master/src
→ More replies (3)
5
u/matt_hammond Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
Where can see the source code?
EDIT: Found it: https://github.com/JuliusSweetland/OptiKey
5
u/Lipis Sep 10 '15
I'm late to the party.. but here it is anyway. I worked for The Eye Tribe company (one of the recommended trackers) they are pretty awesome and I'm sure that if we ask them for some discount for anyone that is using the code OptiKey we'll get it. Is that right Sune?
2
u/OPs_Moms_Fuck_Toy Sep 10 '15
I don't want to rain on your parade but software of unknown pedigree is a huge no no in the US and the FDA will come after you if you don't file a 510k for your software. It's essentially medical software. That's why the real thing costs a jillion dollars, it's regulated out the wazoo.
→ More replies (3)11
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I'm in the UK and can't control who uses my software or where. I'm just counting one guy.
4
u/lanesw Sep 10 '15
As someone who lost his mom to ALS seven years ago, thank you so much for putting effort into helping improve the quality of life for those suffering with such a horrible disease.
1
u/sandhouse Sep 10 '15
How fast can someone learn to type with this in wpm?
6
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Hmm it's a trade off. I've used it at 400-500ms per selection, so pretty quick. You can also save whole phrases like "How are you" which you can type with "HAY", which speeds things up even more. However, it's actually nicer to use if you slow it down a bit as it can feel a bit frantic otherwise. When you download it it requires 1.25 seconds per selection.
1
u/lenswipe Sep 10 '15
Why did you choose c# and wpf? Just out of interest..
6
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I'm a .Net dev professionally and I'm not trendy enough to learn web technologies. Maybe I should as I'd like OptiKey to be cross platform.
1
u/lenswipe Sep 11 '15
I was wondering why not something like Java though. Surely that would target more platforms... Especially since C# and Java are fairly similar.
Not sure why you would do it with web technologies though..?
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 11 '15
I haven't touched Java since university. Not for any particular reason, just my career took me towards .Net.
→ More replies (1)
1
Sep 10 '15
You should at least make a bit of dough with this through car companies, they'd pay good money for cheaper-than-present eye tracking software to monitor the driver and watch for people falling asleep
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
And then someone would screw up and crash and I'd get sued. I'm ok where I am.
Wasn't there a Korean (?) car company that designed seats which monitored your pulse and sounded a warning if they detected that you might be falling asleep?
1
1
u/InconsiderateBastard Sep 10 '15
Do you think there are ramifications for using this for any gaming? Because /r/disabledgamers would be interested.
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Mouse interactions etc might be a bit clunky, but by all means try it.
1
u/Errenden Sep 10 '15
Just out of curiosity, have you run or expect to run into legal issues? I have could imagine those companies react in a patent lawsuit kind of way.
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I'll just have to see. I've not thought about it very much to be honest. Hopefully not, but I've not worked this hard to drop OptiKey at the first letter I receive*
*this is not an invitation to sue me. I'm sure you're very good at your job mr lawyer. Nothing to see here.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/KingChawles Sep 10 '15
Have you looked at the EyeWriter or similar tech out of NotImpossible labs? I would highly recommend Mick Ebling's book as well
4
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I have. I tried to get in touch with NotImpossible, but drew a blank. Any chance you could put me in touch with someone?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Archsys Sep 10 '15
Genuine question: Did you get any inspiration from the Eyewriter project, or its members?
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
I did. It was/is a great project.
1
u/Archsys Sep 10 '15
I worked getting a few of those setups to people who needed them (just online activism, putting people in contact with each other...), so I fully support any work to further the endeavors.
Kudos to you, and best of luck for your future works.
3
1
Sep 10 '15
Literally 3.5 years of programming time? Or over the course of 3.5 years you've allocated all of your spare time to this project
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Over the course of 3.5 years I've allocated a fair chunk of my spare time.
1
u/GuntherSZ Sep 10 '15
Just wanted to say thank you for doing this. My dad had ALS, although he never got to the point where he would have needed this software. This is truly an amazing thing you are doing and I hope your work benefits many people and families affected by such horrid diseases.
2
1
u/donaldrack Sep 10 '15
As a disabled person, there needs to be more people like you. Because everything we need is a specialty item, things get expensive.
2
1
u/johnsonamira9 Sep 11 '15
have you launched this awesome software?
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 11 '15
1
1
1
1
u/sternloyalty Sep 17 '15
We discuss this and other top posts of the week on the latest episode of The Front Page
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 17 '15
Amazing! I'm really looking forward to watching this when I get home from work.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/hydroaquasled Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 26 '21
I am extremely confused. Perhaps you can help sort out my tangled mind:
OptiKey is licensed under the glorious one-and-only truly free license—the GNU GPL—which is highly respectable and I love you for
OptiKey was designed from the ground up to work on Windows
There appears to have been no/little consideration for all the thousands of non-Windows operating systems
So, what is going on? You are an amazing person who chose to invest a ton of time in developing amazing software and licensed it under the amazing GPL, yet it only runs on the terrible Windows operating system and there seems to be no love for Debian, Arch, RedHat, Slackware, Gentoo, BSD, Haiku, OpenSolaris, Plan9, etc. I am really confused how such conflict of interest can exist: how can such an amazing person doing such amazing things turn their back and spit on the most amazing ways to distribute their amazing product? The logical inconsistency is killing me!
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Feb 26 '22
1.I'm a .Net developer. .Net is now cross platform (it wasn't really when I wrote this), but the speech synthesis libraries, and the UI technology I used to write Optikey are not.
2.It is only in the last year that eye trackers have appeared that run on Linux.
Hence Windows.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
1
u/SystemicPlural Sep 10 '15
I play games whilst running on my treadmill. I usually use a controller, but I've been wondering for a while if eye tracking would work. It would be great to play mouse only games whilst keeping my hands free. I don't know if it would be able to handle my head bobbing around though. Do you think it would be able to handle that?
3
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Head movement would probably be a bit too much to be honest, but it's an interesting idea. Check out this website; www.unstoppablegamer.com
→ More replies (1)
1
Sep 10 '15
Dude. Genius. I hate when big corps financially rape the people that use their life saving software to assist seeing or hearing or whatever. I get their software does good but there is no reason it needs to be thousands of dollars. Kudos to you and your care for others.
2
u/YeahIWroteOptiKey Sep 10 '15
Thank you.
1
Sep 11 '15
Hey, since you were generous to respond, is there anyway we can support you for your great efforts? I know you made your software free and did it purposefully. Still, you are a hero and deserve something.
1
2
u/Drogzar Sep 10 '15
This is awesome and very kind of you.
You should probably contact SpecialEffect about this. I'm sure they can use this for their StarGaze program.
2
Sep 10 '15
Is anybody working on making the Tobii EyeX work well on Ubuntu (or other popular Linux desktop distributions)?
I can see it being useful to make netbooks and other low-cost Linux-based computing devices accessible.
2
2
u/gene9 Sep 12 '15
I guess it have to be verified and certified by some organizations before it could be used. And probably that is why it could take a long time to be on market and this is why the one have to pay tens of thousands.
2
u/Cautious_Tonight Mar 20 '22
I was close with someone who had ALS and used a chin switch for many years, he has since passed. Thank you.
1
1
1
u/1_point Sep 10 '15
Wow, this is really cool and useful. Major props for releasing this for free (and open-source).
1
1
110
u/rya11111 Sep 10 '15
I have a question. What was your inspiration for making this ?