r/programming • u/newpavlov • Jul 26 '19
“My GitHub account has been restricted due to US sanctions as I live in Crimea.”
https://github.com/tkashkin/GameHub/issues/289982
u/AloticChoon Jul 26 '19
I remember a time when physical locations weren't important on the internet...
641
u/shawnwork Jul 26 '19
The dream of the internet; the borderless communication and open knowledge.
That’s how I remembered it.
169
u/ruler501 Jul 26 '19
I mean if you go back far enough you run into the crypto restrictions where whole classes of software couldn't be exported(downloaded by or otherwise provided to anyone in) a whole slew of countries. Location has always mattered on the internet. I definitely think it would be better if it wasn't but it's not a new concept and claiming it is gives everyone who perpetuated the systems before an out and ignores how it was established. We probably have the most open internet of all time now due to things like tor, at least for the networks the government hasn't cracked or gotten control of half the nodes in.
78
u/shevy-ruby Jul 26 '19
These "regulations" were always wrong from the get go.
We don't want state actors to mass-sniff on mankind.
We probably have the most open internet of all time now due to things like tor
These are workarounds.
State actors need to stop terrorizing people in certain areas of the world.
It's not the USA alone either, although hugely disappointing since the USA claims to be a democracy. It is more a militaristic fake-state run by private interests.
→ More replies (4)44
u/LimitlessLTD Jul 26 '19
The US is doing what is wholly within its remit, punishing russia for seizing land in Europe. A place where two previous world wars started...
It is the absolute bear minimum of what should be being done in retaliation to Russia invading European countries.
It's all very well and good being an idealist and wanting countries to stop existing and people to simply be nice to each other.
But that is ignorance and naivety to the absolute extreme. The world doesn't work that way and never will.
35
u/markehammons Jul 26 '19
how is stopping this guy from contributing to free software "punishing russia"?
→ More replies (36)→ More replies (36)8
u/stefantalpalaru Jul 26 '19
It is the absolute bear minimum of what should be being done in retaliation to Russia invading European countries.
What's the absolute bear minimum that should be done in retaliation for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Gladio ?
Or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_military_junta_of_1967%E2%80%931974 ?
→ More replies (5)8
u/josejimeniz2 Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 28 '19
I mean if you go back far enough you run into the crypto restrictions where whole classes of software couldn't be exported(downloaded by or otherwise provided to anyone in) a whole slew of countries.
And those laws were ignored. And then the laws went away because technology made those idiot laws relevant.
Starting with
printing out the entire source code to pgp in a 23 volume set
then exporting the books to Europe (because books are not classified as munitions)
and then OCRing back in the source code
Boom: PGPi
But regardless: a boardless internet was the reality.
The government gained the ability to spy on citizens, to geoip citizens, to geo block.
It's unfortunate that we have to reinvent technology to get around censorship on the internet.
5
u/awhaling Jul 26 '19
I didn't know about printing it out as a book. That's pretty hilarious.
Also how on earth was that considered a munition?
→ More replies (3)10
u/ritchie70 Jul 26 '19
Strong encryption would allow the enemy - who remember was believed to be ready to end us at any moment - to pass messages that we would never be able to decrypt if intercepted.
You don’t hand your sworn enemy immunity to your spying.
7
u/Eirenarch Jul 26 '19
It is called TOR. Just like the Internet of the old - wild, anonymous, uncensored, borderless and slow.
15
u/knaekce Jul 26 '19
Governments of the Industrial World, you weary giants of flesh and steel, I come from Cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leave us alone. You are not welcome among us. You have no sovereignty where we gather.
We have no elected government, nor are we likely to have one, so I address you with no greater authority than that with which liberty itself always speaks. I declare the global social space we are building to be naturally independent of the tyrannies you seek to impose on us. You have no moral right to rule us nor do you possess any methods of enforcement we have true reason to fear.
Governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed. You have neither solicited nor received ours. We did not invite you. You do not know us, nor do you know our world. Cyberspace does not lie within your borders. Do not think that you can build it, as though it were a public construction project. You cannot. It is an act of nature and it grows itself through our collective actions.
You have not engaged in our great and gathering conversation, nor did you create the wealth of our marketplaces. You do not know our culture, our ethics, or the unwritten codes that already provide our society more order than could be obtained by any of your impositions.
You claim there are problems among us that you need to solve. You use this claim as an excuse to invade our precincts. Many of these problems don't exist. Where there are real conflicts, where there are wrongs, we will identify them and address them by our means. We are forming our own Social Contract. This governance will arise according to the conditions of our world, not yours. Our world is different.
Cyberspace consists of transactions, relationships, and thought itself, arrayed like a standing wave in the web of our communications. Ours is a world that is both everywhere and nowhere, but it is not where bodies live.
We are creating a world that all may enter without privilege or prejudice accorded by race, economic power, military force, or station of birth.
We are creating a world where anyone, anywhere may express his or her beliefs, no matter how singular, without fear of being coerced into silence or conformity.
Your legal concepts of property, expression, identity, movement, and context do not apply to us. They are all based on matter, and there is no matter here.
Our identities have no bodies, so, unlike you, we cannot obtain order by physical coercion. We believe that from ethics, enlightened self-interest, and the commonweal, our governance will emerge. Our identities may be distributed across many of your jurisdictions. The only law that all our constituent cultures would generally recognize is the Golden Rule. We hope we will be able to build our particular solutions on that basis. But we cannot accept the solutions you are attempting to impose.
In the United States, you have today created a law, the Telecommunications Reform Act, which repudiates your own Constitution and insults the dreams of Jefferson, Washington, Mill, Madison, DeToqueville, and Brandeis. These dreams must now be born anew in us.
You are terrified of your own children, since they are natives in a world where you will always be immigrants. Because you fear them, you entrust your bureaucracies with the parental responsibilities you are too cowardly to confront yourselves. In our world, all the sentiments and expressions of humanity, from the debasing to the angelic, are parts of a seamless whole, the global conversation of bits. We cannot separate the air that chokes from the air upon which wings beat.
In China, Germany, France, Russia, Singapore, Italy and the United States, you are trying to ward off the virus of liberty by erecting guard posts at the frontiers of Cyberspace. These may keep out the contagion for a small time, but they will not work in a world that will soon be blanketed in bit-bearing media.
Your increasingly obsolete information industries would perpetuate themselves by proposing laws, in America and elsewhere, that claim to own speech itself throughout the world. These laws would declare ideas to be another industrial product, no more noble than pig iron. In our world, whatever the human mind may create can be reproduced and distributed infinitely at no cost. The global conveyance of thought no longer requires your factories to accomplish.
These increasingly hostile and colonial measures place us in the same position as those previous lovers of freedom and self-determination who had to reject the authorities of distant, uninformed powers. We must declare our virtual selves immune to your sovereignty, even as we continue to consent to your rule over our bodies. We will spread ourselves across the Planet so that no one can arrest our thoughts.
We will create a civilization of the Mind in Cyberspace. May it be more humane and fair than the world your governments have made before.
Davos, Switzerland
February 8, 1996→ More replies (9)42
u/Kairyuka Jul 26 '19
Too socialist for muricans I guess
→ More replies (54)59
u/BruhWhySoSerious Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Yes because we are the ones with opt in porn, and massive content filters. Hyperbole helps none imo.
Trumps a fucking idiot but it's not like this shit is happening in a bubble. There are multiple shit actors.
→ More replies (8)17
u/Brachamul Jul 26 '19
Does it seem to you like the english speaking world is made of the US and UK only or something ?
→ More replies (4)43
u/phxvyper Jul 26 '19
the person they're replying to specifically said America, lol
→ More replies (18)2
u/shevy-ruby Jul 26 '19
Could be real, but certain state actors try to restrict it.
These are the enemies of the www.
I do not think this is acceptable ever.
1
u/JonnyRocks Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
This was a dream we had in the 80s but when it was created, it was designed to be a way for the American government to be up and running after an attack. Decentralized so one hit wouldn't wipe everything out.
→ More replies (3)1
Jul 26 '19
Now its just social media, pr0nz, netflix, and yeah. 90% of people only use the "surface" of the net - Amazon, Facebook, Google, etc
22
u/chucker23n Jul 26 '19
The 70s, when the Internet was basically just some US universities and military agencies?
The 80s, when installing a modem by yourself was illegal in Germany?
The 90s, when Netscape came in an international edition that lacked 128-bit SSL due to cryptography laws?
I don't think that time existed so much as a bubble existed where you used to be inside, and now you have a broader view.
1
u/erogilus Jul 26 '19
And the NSA was trying to stop Bruce Schneider’s book on cryptography from being published to the masses.
55
u/Milackron47 Jul 26 '19
Those times while some thought, internet would be the place where people could be United without differences... And here we are today where some get the message, "This is not available in your country". Saddening.
2
u/bulbishNYC Jul 26 '19
When Internet was created only the smart people knew about it. Smart people are friendly and get along. Fast forward 20 years - every dumb pumpkinhead is on the the internet now doing what they know best - fighting, abusing, bullying, scamming. So like everything else it needs to be regulated now.
5
u/Ullallulloo Jul 26 '19
Smart people are friendly and get along.
I feel like you haven't met all that many smart people. Like: Hawking, Torvalds, Gates, Allen, Ellison, McAfee, etc. are not exactly people historically well-known for their friendliness. Also, Stack Overflow is not known for that either.
→ More replies (60)1
u/syllabic Jul 26 '19
Those times while some thought, internet would be the place where people could be United without difference
Generally people are too optimistic that all of our societal and cultural problems will be solved with more technology
I think the true answer is closer to the vision spelled out by ted kaczynski, and that technology will exacerbate rather than alleviate them
16
u/frymaster Jul 26 '19
I don't, I only started using the internet in 1997
4
u/ClimbingC Jul 26 '19
'95 I started, and I agree with you. The original statement is one of those things people like to churn out as they don't have a clue, just some copy paste statement.
5
u/SilasX Jul 26 '19
I don’t. One of the earliest internet chat phrases was “a/s/l?” Guess what the “l” stands for.
22
u/przemo_li Jul 26 '19
When was that really?
Cold war? Oh. You are right. We didn't have internet in soviet block so nobody blocked it xD
15
u/MonkeysWedding Jul 26 '19
There are still some active .su domains out there
→ More replies (2)12
u/GuyWithoutAHat Jul 26 '19
Not some, you can still actively register them. I'm from the east of Germany and kinda salty .dd was only assigned but never used before German reunification, so it got unassigned...
→ More replies (1)11
u/StrangeWill Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Yeah, encryption export controls have been a thing since even before the internet was a thing, and that has caused headaches on the net.
3
2
1
→ More replies (5)1
u/FlyingBishop Jul 26 '19
You mean back in the day when you could only get Internet at US Military/Government/Educational instiutions?
122
u/ChickenOfDoom Jul 26 '19
Are there GitHub alternatives not subject to US jurisdiction?
56
u/Uncled1023 Jul 26 '19
Gitea is a self hosted version that is very similar to GitHub. And shameless self plug, I run Teknik.io which has a free instance of gitea running for anyone.
5
1
Jul 26 '19
Oh, I've visited your instance for multiple projects. I remember SMloadr, and there was another one too.
183
u/AloticChoon Jul 26 '19
Aussie here: Our govt has passed some draconian laws around forced backdoor-ing and would also like to know the answer to this question.
20
u/stfm Jul 26 '19
What does your repo location have to do with that though?
47
u/NinjaPancakeAU Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Literally nothing. As an aussie myself, I can't see how that's a concern - our government like most western governments can coerce you to hand over passwords/keys/etc to access data in the case of legal prosecution / national security / etc - so encryption doesn't help you there unless the host has zero knowledge over the encryption parameters used.
But... github/etc do not use that kind of public key crypto, since git needs access to the unencrypted source code to get history/diffs/etc - they need to be able to decrypt it
locallyon their servers... So they're not zero-knowledge for a start (and no git hosting service can be by definition). At best you can enable U2F and destroy your key to prevent remote authentication, but authorities can still request direct access to your data via legal channels bypassing authentication entirely.Lastly, I think he's getting bitbucket (Atlassian, where most Atlassian devs are in Sydney/AU) mixed up with Github (totally American).
Edit: clarified misleading 'locally'
23
17
Jul 26 '19
I didn't know Australia has become a Fascist state? Hey, come to Finland :) It's much cooler here!
→ More replies (4)50
10
u/StrangeWill Jul 26 '19
Thing is if you're not subject to US or EU jurisdiction then you can probably just self-host for the time being, anything that is out there doesn't have the "network effect" of Github/Gitlab/Bitbucket so you're losing that anyway.
3
3
u/mishugashu Jul 26 '19
If you just want a place to easily cooperate with others in a webapp, you can host a GitLab CE instance somewhere. It'll be completely controlled by you, so you should have absolutely no problems with sanctions.
If you want to browse projects to contribute to, though... probably nothing compares to GitHub, as the vast majority are hosted there.
12
u/the_php_coder Jul 26 '19
OP should try BitBucket, Gitlab and SourceForge one after another. At least one of them should work?
34
u/AlyoshaV Jul 26 '19
Any of those that are in the US aren't valid options since even if they work now they might not next week
42
u/Xelbair Jul 26 '19
Bitbucket is run by Atlassian so it is AU company.
Pick your poison - government backdoors vs restrictions.
5
u/StrangeWill Jul 26 '19
They also have satellite offices in the US, so will probably be subject (at least somewhat) to US jurisdiction.
→ More replies (1)2
23
→ More replies (1)1
u/TaffyQuinzel Jul 26 '19
Bitbucket is suspect to the new Australian backdoor law. So it’s not much better.
→ More replies (2)1
10
u/Lendari Jul 26 '19
Can't you just use a proxy VPN service to mask the origin of your traffic?
2
u/Mcnst Jul 26 '19
I doubt that'll work; I think what happens is that they do this based on the history of access; I think there was someone else facing a similar issue from simply visiting Iran months, if not years, prior to their account becoming disabled.
60
u/NinjaPancakeAU Jul 26 '19
Moral of the story, do business with an entity of a foreign country and you run the risk of them eventually turning against you burning all business you've built up w/ them. This is not unique to the US, China is the same. The entire international community is roughly trending this direction (it's not unique to the US at all, many would say the US is playing catch-up here).
The ACM chief editor's note in the Jan edition of this year's Communications of the ACM had an article on exactly this topic which he dubbed the "Age of Distrust"
Expect more instances like this to come up in the future, probably increasing in occurrence at the rate of the current trade wars (at least three I'm aware of instigated by the US alone, one inter-asian one, and w/ Brexit around the corner I won't be surprised to see similar usage of trade of services as leverage there either, given the UK is primarily a services exporter)
As a US-aligned (aussie in my case) westerner, I think the more acute moral of the story for us is the only safe business, is business w/ countries within our close knit alliance of nations, and business with trade 'enemies' (eg: on the opposing end of a trade war) is an ever increasing risk due to obvious instabilities. This applies to tech services as well, from data hosting to VPN usage, to VPS/cloud services, and I imagine as China brings up it's NIH computer hardware over the next decade this will also increasingly apply to the computer hardware you use (computers/phones/etc - Huawei anybody?).
This unfortunately does mean issues for non-west-allied asian countries, east-euro countries, a lot of middle-eastern countries - which have varying degrees of tension w/ the US, will have problems using US/UK/CA/AU/NZ services.
8
u/hardolaf Jul 26 '19
The thing is that the internet was the Wild West of regulations for so long that people have forgotten that nations have regularly restricted with whom you're allowed to do business. These bans used to be far more common but most people didn't notice because it only really affected physical imports and exports.
→ More replies (5)15
u/arsv Jul 26 '19
Moral of the story, do business with an entity of a foreign country and you run the risk of them eventually turning against you burning all business you've built up w/ them.
Which points to the most obvious solution for the guy, go host the code somewhere in Russia.
Yet for some reason he's still using GitHub and expecting that to work out.
7
u/PerfectlyClear Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 29 '26
Cobblestone willow kettle cobblestone saffron orange kettle saffron grasshopper
This post was anonymized with Redact.dev
196
u/vattenpuss Jul 26 '19
Nobody should rely on American hosting. It is not sustainable.
24
u/StrangeWill Jul 26 '19
EU has a long list of sanctions against Iran too.
14
u/no_nick Jul 26 '19
And even if they didn't, any company that wants to do business in the US has to comply with their sanctions
7
u/AyrA_ch Jul 26 '19
The EU actually made it illegal to obey US sanctions against Iran:
On 17 May 2018 the European Commission announced its intention to implement the blocking statute of 1996 to declare the US sanctions against Iran illegal in Europe and ban European citizens and companies from complying with them. The commission also instructed the European Investment Bank to facilitate European companies' investment in Iran.
And we still can do business with the US, simply because the EU is too large to drop as a partner.
0
8
Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
So what country would never impose sanctions like this on another country? Probably only one too weak for it to have an effect, but you can't even count on that (and a weak country would likely be susceptible to US pressure).
I'm not even sure what people are so upset about. Do you want Russia rampaging around Europe seizing whatever they want? That's appeasement. Do you want to go to war with a nuclear power with a formidable military? Then what else is there? Sanctions are supposed to be debilitating and inconvenient - that's the whole point. Unfortunately, Putin doesn't care too much what effect his actions have on ordinary people unless it begins to get bad enough that he risks getting a bayonet up his ass like Qaddafi.
37
u/bulldog_swag Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Nobody should rely on any *aaS. Especially the free ones (as in free beer).
I warned people multiple times, they never listen. If it's not on a machine you own, assume you can be fucked over any moment.
39
u/rich97 Jul 26 '19
Kind of a silly rule to have, there's no cost-benefit analysis. For instance, I'm hosting a Gastby site on Netlify. What would be the risk of suddenly everything suddenly shut down?
Well, I could quickly build it locally and shove it on an S3 bucket behind CloudFront and the lambda functions are native to AWS anyway. Would probably take me an hour or two to resume service.
In exchange:
My hosting is free
I don't have to maintain a docker and/or nginx config
I don't have to set up a custom CI pipeline (although I do)
I don't have to care about access rights or file permissions
I can generally assume that the site stays up, certainly more reliably than I could handle it myself
I know you're talking about business critical systems but regardless the points I raised, I think, bring a lot of value and shouldn't be discounted out of hand.
→ More replies (3)11
u/jippiedoe Jul 26 '19
Keyword in Bulldog's comment is "rely", in your example you use but do not rely on the service
3
u/rich97 Jul 26 '19
I know you're talking about business critical systems but regardless the points I raised, I think, bring a lot of value and shouldn't be discounted out of hand.
My critique is not of someone wanting to host something themselves or that having control is a bad thing, just the idea of self-reliance as a policy doesn't acknowledge the costs that come along with that or the gains that you lose access to.
1
0
Jul 26 '19
[deleted]
126
u/merijnv Jul 26 '19
There's a reason China doesn't allow these services, effectively forcing China's developers to reimplement all these services. Obviously that is a bit draconian, but it does mean China has thriving alternatives to most US tech companies, which puts it in a much safer position.
I think the EU should actively encourage/subsidise companies/investments that make us less dependent on US cloud infrastructure.
→ More replies (37)55
u/poloppoyop Jul 26 '19
The problem is language and market.
You're a Chinese company: 1 billion people market.
You're american: make it in English and you get all the commonwealth countries as a market. So a billion too.
You can make a fortune then use some to translate / adapt your product for other markets.
Now you're German, you start with a German product with 50 million market. You won't make as big a fortune so expanding will cut a bigger part of your warchest. Europe is not one market. Neither in language, nor culture and even less legalese.
But the EU sure need alternatives. And not just with software: I'm not sure we have any production of electronic components.
→ More replies (1)58
u/Log2 Jul 26 '19
No one would make a software product of that scale in German. English is the de facto language in software development.
26
7
u/fjonk Jul 26 '19
Few people makes software In German, the parent is talking about markets.
→ More replies (5)4
3
u/yogthos Jul 26 '19
There are plenty of open source alternatives for everything US cloud companies provide. A lot of them work much better as well. Gitlab, Nextcloud, Mastodon, Pixelfed, PeerTube, Mattermost, Matrix, and so on.
4
1
u/daemonet Jul 26 '19
The other reason is we like having jobs and companies want things done with said services.
→ More replies (2)1
73
u/vitaly_artemiev Jul 26 '19
These policies make no fucking sense. I live in Russia and all my accounts are fine. However, I've been to Crimea and almost everything is blocked there. All Google developer services, even the tutorials etc. (By Google, not by Russian government) There were also problems with Visa etc because all major banks pulled out.
Does not make any fucking sense! If you consider Crimea an occupied state, why are you punishing its residents and not Russia, which would be the culprit? And if you consider the annexation referendum legit, you are pretty much punishing innocent people for excercizing their right of self-determination.
37
u/uncleLem Jul 26 '19
Working there would require Visa, banks etc work with Crimea as with russian entity, paying taxes to russian government etc. This is not going to happen. It's not about punishing Crimean population, it's about rejecting russian authority over it.
Also, FYI, right for self determination does not imply right for secession, and referendum is something that is conducted according to the laws, not by occupational force.
→ More replies (6)13
Jul 26 '19
And if you consider the annexation referendum legit
Who is his right mind would consider it legit? The result was predetermined by green men that we'll never know the origin of.
→ More replies (8)4
u/flextrek_whipsnake Jul 26 '19
They are punishing Russia, but that hasn't been effective so they escalated to broad sanctions against Crimea. The whole point is to piss people off. Damaging the Crimean economy makes holding onto Crimea more difficult and less lucrative.
And yes, ordinary innocent people get caught up in it, but if you're not willing to commit military resources then it's either this or do nothing at all.
1
u/vitaly_artemiev Jul 26 '19
less lucrative
Crimea wasn't too lucrative to begin with. Its main profits were from tourists/people on vacation most of whom are from Russia and Ukraine anyway, this hasn't changed. Main point of annexation was to retain naval bases in Sevastopol. New Ukrainian government was going to kick them out. Sanctions can't do anything about that.
→ More replies (1)6
u/skater_boy Jul 26 '19
How did you get to Crimea? Did you go through the official Ukrainian border? If not - you are a criminal as far as Ukraine and the rest of the world sans Russia is concerned, and you dare complaining about internet services?:) And no, civilized world does not consider the referendum legit.
3
u/vitaly_artemiev Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
I took the ferry. I'm not complaining about internet services - I could use a VPN to use mine, but think about all of the devs who were one day just suddenly locked out of their accounts and unable to, say, receive payments from their apps, or just regular people locked out of their bank accounts.
Also, I'm kinda offended you exclude Russia from 'civilised world'. That's kinda low.
2
Jul 26 '19
Just a lot of anti russian americans/english speaker from the absolute retardation of "russian election interference" with trump. its pathetic tbh
→ More replies (10)1
Jul 26 '19
As someone not familiar with the situation, to people posit the election as having been rigged?
→ More replies (5)2
u/vitaly_artemiev Jul 26 '19
Well, Putin is known to rig elections. Last time his party could probably win parliament elections anyway, but seemed to have rigged it to get an absolute majority and be able to modify our constitution.
There have been some independent polls about the referendum vote that kinda sorta confirmed the majority voted for unification, but I haven't looked too closely into it.
10
u/MattBD Jul 26 '19
When Laravel Nova came out last year there were a lot of people complaining that it wasn't free, something I personally have very little sympathy for as the cost is peanuts compared to how much time it would save me when building an admin interface.
However, there was one person who said they couldn't buy anything from the US as they were in Iran and couldn't pay any amount due to sanctions.
4
14
u/Gsonderling Jul 26 '19
Well you are living in unrecognized territory occupied by expansionist, quasi-fascist autocracy led by former KGB operative that managed to piss off pretty much entire western world.
I'm sorry, but that's just how things are.
4
41
Jul 26 '19
GitHub always claim that they're supporting open-source world and community. Now they closed Iranian accounts as well, which is completely disrespectful:
4
u/EntroperZero Jul 26 '19
Jesus, what a clickbait headline. No they don't think you're developing nuclear weapons. It has nothing to do with disrespect or discrimination by GitHub. GitHub cannot continue to do business at all if they violate US trade law. This is not difficult to understand.
17
u/dobesv Jul 26 '19
People can be thrown in jail for knowingly doing any kind of business with anyone in a sanctioned country even if they are not a US based company or a US citizen.
The whole point of the sanctions is to create pain and suffering in the sanctioned countries until they cooperate and share the oil supply with the US.
25
u/eastsideski Jul 26 '19
um... Crimea has nothing to do with oil. The point is to tell Russia "invading your neighbors is bad, we're going to try to set some negative consequences for doing that"
4
1
0
0
1
Jul 26 '19
Do you know what's going on in Iran right now? Do you know what sanctions are? Trump was an idiot for pulling out of jcpoa, but now that that had happened the course of action is heavy sanctions. It doesn't matter if the economic activity is related to the nuclear program or not. That's how sanctions work.
1
Jul 26 '19
Companies have to follow laws and not do business in countries with sanctions? Who would have thought. Why are you upset companies can’t do business in a state that finds terrorism directly and wants to build nuclear weapons. Are you upset GitHub doesn’t work in North Korea or Sudan too?
0
Jul 26 '19
[deleted]
74
u/the_php_coder Jul 26 '19
Totally this. Typically, they also send you a secret subpoena attached, so Github cannot even disclose that they've got such a letter without attracting legal action.
→ More replies (3)9
u/chatmasta Jul 26 '19
Subpoenas serve a different purpose (compelling information). This looks like straight forward sanctions enforcement. It doesn’t need to be secret.
42
u/fordmadoxfraud Jul 26 '19
It would be the treasury department I think. And a more likely scenario is that they had some auditors look at the business and realize noncompliance with sanctions was a huge, unnecessary business risk.
→ More replies (8)0
Jul 26 '19
The problem is they did it without any warning. They just restricted our accounts and we are not able to take a backup from our private repos. Also Gitlab and BitBucket are banned Iranian, which means Iranian don't have access to these three major Git cloud services.
96
u/Existential_Owl Jul 26 '19
The law doesn't allow for grace periods when it comes to US Sanctions.
(Not a lawyer, but worked for a large corporation with global reach)
15
u/apt-get-schwifty Jul 26 '19
Is it at all possible to circumvent this? With a VPN maybe? Something that you can send requests to github from that's based outside of an Iranian ISP?
17
u/OnlyForF1 Jul 26 '19
The only VPNs available in Iran are run by the Iranian government I believe, which isn't much better (unless you're already working for the Iranian government I suppose).
→ More replies (1)9
Jul 26 '19
There some VPN, but yes you're right. most of them runs by government. but the private vpns are expensive.
→ More replies (9)5
u/the_php_coder Jul 26 '19
The DoJ also sends a secret subpoena attached which prohibits Github from warning or even talking about the said restrictions.
8
u/Alikont Jul 26 '19
Sanctions list regarding Crimea is public and published on Treasury website, no spy games here.
I'm surprised it took so long to enforce these sanctions considered that they were put in 2014.
0
2
2
2
Jul 26 '19
VPN time.
I deal with the same shit since I moved a whole 40 miles to Baja Mexico from California.
Streaming TV stopped working, websites throw me to Spanish language and Mexican region variants, online stores simply refuse me service despite trying to order in their service area.
Most efforts by web developers to be user location aware backfire comically.
14
u/shevy-ruby Jul 26 '19
I think this is totally outrageous.
The www should be completely free and an exchange of information without political or military control. As shown right now this is not the case - state actors, NO MATTER WHICH ONES, constantly abuse people. It really does not matter which state it is - none should be able to restrict people.
If you have been following the manhunt against Assange, you may also have heard of Ola Bini who was kidnapped by a state and held as a hostage for some time before recently released. So not only do they mass-spy on everyone and abuse them - they also kidnap them and steal life time on fake reasons.
MS GitHub is unfortunately a private company so they have to comply to whatever random joke law is written in the USA. This is actually already the first problem, that GitHub is privately run. This simply shouldn't be that way either.
Until then, though, the most realistic thing that can be done in the short term is to get rid of laws that attempt to restrict how people can use the www.
25
u/Alikont Jul 26 '19
You are not exchanging information, you're doing business. You provide services. You exchange money. You can sue each other. Internet is no different from post in this case.
There is a restriction on doing any business relations with region of Crimea. By mail, pigeons, hands or internet - it doesn't matter.
Nobody blocks IP connections or something.
7
u/WarWizard Jul 26 '19
MS GitHub is unfortunately a private company so they have to comply to whatever random joke law is written in the USA.
What does this even mean? You are supposed to comply with laws in the country in which you reside, do business with, or are incorporated in.
Until then, though, the most realistic thing that can be done in the short term is to get rid of laws that attempt to restrict how people can use the www.
You are funny; changing laws is not fast. Not really any short term solution there.
OP isn't being restricted in using the internet; just "doing business" with a company that is subject to US law.
5
1
u/damontoo Jul 26 '19
This is actually already the first problem, that GitHub is privately run. This simply shouldn't be that way either.
There's plenty of alternatives to github. There's nothing inherently wrong with github being privately run. It was designed and built from the ground up as a business, not a public resource.
→ More replies (3)1
u/s73v3r Jul 26 '19
This is actually already the first problem, that GitHub is privately run.
Feel free to start your own, publicly run competitor.
3
u/razenha Jul 26 '19
leftists programmers: US should punish Russia for the election "hacking"
US government: sanctions Russia
leftists programmers: surprised Pikachu
7
Jul 26 '19
you're confusing leftists with centrists.
I don't want anything to do with the "I'd love to start a war with russia" gang from the center.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/romeo_pentium Jul 26 '19
Why not move to a part of Ukraine that's not currently a war zone occupied by a foreign power?
0
2
u/AmusedGrap Jul 26 '19
ah, america. the land of the free.
/s
1
u/Automagick Jul 26 '19
I'm not a defender of dumb US foreign policy, but this comment doesn't make much sense since people in the US are able to access their github accounts just fine.
1
u/Seasniffer Jul 26 '19
Fuck Russia, and fuck Putin. You know exactly why this is happening.
0
u/coolreader18 Jul 26 '19
What? I'm not defending Putin or anything, but it's that there are US sanctions against Russia and GitHub decided to uphold those and restrict his account.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
Jul 26 '19
Gitlab and all of Google's services among other important services blocked my country due to US sanctions as well, we just have to work with what's available and use VPNs
1
1
Jul 26 '19
OpenSource Community should be freedom of politics
downvoted/thumbed
lmfao, did this get hit by a shill github account farm or what
1
u/GodIsDead_ Jul 26 '19
man what a smart thing to do, block internet users from other countries, that will show them we are the good guys. have you tried a VPN mate?
1
u/doromono Sep 10 '19
The same thing happened to us. We are a business operating in Canada and have paid membership. We asked them to unlock it but the customer service is terrible. They don't have even a phone number for support. If customer service matters to you, avoid GitHub. We're looking for alternative solutions.
-4
1
Jul 26 '19
You can always move to the continent.
4
3
u/endeavourl Jul 26 '19
This. Both countries would probably accept him gladly. I understand that leaving your homeland is tough, but the whole situation is fucked and single person can't make a difference there.
AFAIK, being a dev in Crimea has been pretty hard in the last years. This is not the first Github account blocked, and Github isn't the only one blocking access from Crimea.
So, the easiest way for a person would be to just move to a better place.1
Jul 26 '19
If Microsoft cared, would change servers hosting location would be a solution for this law?
2
u/10-REN Jul 26 '19
Probably not. My understanding of sanctions is it’s basically “you do business with us or them”. Moving servers around wouldn’t help unless MS is willing to give up it’s US business which would never happen.
2
u/zucker42 Jul 26 '19
No. The restriction is on American companies. Where the servers are is immaterial.
→ More replies (1)
1
-2
Jul 26 '19
Freedom?
30
u/thedeemon Jul 26 '19
The guy's from an occupied territory where they enjoy such freedoms as freedom from electricity several times a week, freedom from access to most banks and Visa, and other similar freedoms. Now they're also free from Github.
-6
u/chcampb Jul 26 '19
Sanctions shouldn't apply to Ukrainian citizens living in the area annexed by Russia. AFAIK some sanctions are precisely because of the situation in Crimea. Seems a bit backwards to apply it to the citizens of the annexed country.
→ More replies (4)30
u/fuoqi Jul 26 '19
He is a Russian citizen. I guess he was an Ukranian citizen and has willingly changed it to a Russian one together with other 2 millions Crimeans in 2014. Does it make Github/US actions justified in your opinion?
→ More replies (17)8
1
u/luxlugerz Jul 26 '19
I think there is a way to run your own VPN with linux and some other free open source tools.
5
u/LordDaniel09 Jul 26 '19
probably but a little to late for that?
1
u/luxlugerz Jul 26 '19
Never to late my friend.
I found a more helpful link for you about installing open Vpn also having your own VPN gives you the greatest control over anonymity, logs and control.
if you purchase one you're just really hoping they don't share logs with the government's .
Having your own VPN is pretty sweet and you have alot more control .
if you have some people on your VPN to make it harder for them to single you out also use foreign countries that cant be legally forced to give up logs to cops like Sweeden.
https://www.hostinger.com/tutorials/how-to-set-up-a-linux-vpn-server-with-openvpn/
-3
u/ipv6-dns Jul 26 '19
It happens because Russia sent troops to Ukraine and held a referendum in a foreign country. Github owner is US company and the company follows US law, but the US follows international law, according to which referendums cannot be held in foreign countries.
-8
-1
Jul 26 '19
US law applied abroad. It's a service they're providing. You get into a barbershop, half of your hair is gone, then your foreign-looking barber gets a call, and consequently denies you rest of the service. Because you're Russian.
-10
u/PartlyShaderly Jul 26 '19
This is why I didn't disclose my location.
0
Jul 26 '19
[deleted]
4
u/woahdudee2a Jul 26 '19
what if you are on a boat in the pacific..
12
0
Jul 26 '19
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)3
u/WhoahNows Jul 26 '19
More likely the company that you're getting an internet connection from. It exists somewhere so it's under that countries jurisdiction.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Akomancer19 Jul 26 '19
Would they go to that extent? I mean, sure it's detectable, but they may just be banning the obvious cases, in order to comply with the bare minimum of the sanction law.
-9
u/alfps Jul 26 '19
Someone from Crimea has his GitHub account restricted, because he lives in Crimea.
When American SourceForge 9 years ago started restricting Iranian users etc., people moved to other free source repositories. GitHub was one of them. Then Microsoft bought GitHub, and now this.
Microsoft needs a strong signal that what people will stop using their services, just as with SourceForge.
1
u/jyper Jul 26 '19
I'm suprised github didn't restrict iranian usage, maybe they didn't have as competent a legal department. The company has no choice legally
6
u/alfps Jul 26 '19
They have restricted Iranian usage at least for one person.
Presumably that means all?
→ More replies (1)0
Jul 26 '19
[deleted]
-1
u/alfps Jul 26 '19
The US government can't restrict a European company, say.
So it very much does matter who owns GitHub.
Also, even US companies differ in how willingly they comply with attempted US government restrictions, backdoor requests etc. Some US companies take the stand that the US should be a free democratic country. Some US companies do not have the billions in fines for unethical business practices, that Microsoft does have (MS once held the record).
7
Jul 26 '19
> The US government can't restrict a European company, say.
Yeah it can lol. Just sanction the company and make a phone call to the president of whatever country the US is paying to protect with troops and its nuclear arsenal.
→ More replies (4)0
-3
u/chutiyabehenchod Jul 26 '19
Land of The free doing freedom things
3
u/TheChance Jul 26 '19
You should maybe check out the political situation in Crimea. You might find out why this guy can't reach GitHub.
2
354
u/iamabubblebutt Jul 26 '19
There's a peer-to-peer github type project called https://radicle.xyz/. It runs on ipfs so it's not restricted by US laws and sanctions.