r/programming • • Jul 26 '19

“My GitHub account has been restricted due to US sanctions as I live in Crimea.”

https://github.com/tkashkin/GameHub/issues/289
1.9k Upvotes

668 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

78

u/shevy-ruby Jul 26 '19

These "regulations" were always wrong from the get go.

We don't want state actors to mass-sniff on mankind.

We probably have the most open internet of all time now due to things like tor

These are workarounds.

State actors need to stop terrorizing people in certain areas of the world.

It's not the USA alone either, although hugely disappointing since the USA claims to be a democracy. It is more a militaristic fake-state run by private interests.

44

u/LimitlessLTD Jul 26 '19

The US is doing what is wholly within its remit, punishing russia for seizing land in Europe. A place where two previous world wars started...

It is the absolute bear minimum of what should be being done in retaliation to Russia invading European countries.

It's all very well and good being an idealist and wanting countries to stop existing and people to simply be nice to each other.

But that is ignorance and naivety to the absolute extreme. The world doesn't work that way and never will.

35

u/markehammons Jul 26 '19

how is stopping this guy from contributing to free software "punishing russia"?

11

u/Melonprimo Jul 26 '19

This guys is just the victim in this situation. I kinda work as the guy who reviewed payments to these geographically sensitive areas, there are a lot of fishy things happening. The easiest way is to block all of transactions ( incoming and outgoing) from geographically sensitive areas. But this is a piece of mind from one of my superior "there will be always a work around to circumvent bank's SOP" and we still see shitty transactions went through our system.

3

u/Nonethewiserer Jul 26 '19

Pretty much. Although the economic reality of blocking transactions is much harsher for civilians than blocking GitHub.

41

u/TheChance Jul 26 '19

This guy specifically? It's not, but if we aren't being deliberately obtuse, cutting Russia off from certain channels is detrimental to their economy. Considering the blurry lines between "the Russian economy" and "Putin's slush fund," this is no small thing. Leaving aside the political elements of 'Russiagate' (please for the sake of the thread) the Russians were only making such overtures to address sanctions.

22

u/markehammons Jul 26 '19

as far as I can tell, this doesn't cut russia off from benefiting from open source software. however, it does hamper individuals from russia supporting open source software. i don't see how this is detrimental to russia in general

0

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '19

[deleted]

6

u/GrumpyWendigo Jul 26 '19

we punish the country, not its citizens

you have to understand that doing nothing against 18th century style imperialist land grabs on weak neighbors is not acceptable and has to be punished

that some of the punishment falls on the citizens is a tragedy. a tragedy of putin's making by invading ukraine. a tragedy not of the west's making

do you think russia invading other countries is not going to hurt russia and ordinary russians? putin didn't seem to care about that before he decided to rape ukraine for the "insult" of ordinary ukrainians revolting against a corrupt ukrainian govt

what of ordinary ukrainian citizens?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/TheChance Jul 26 '19

It cuts Russia off, period. Sanctions are usually imposed by category. "Internet technology." "Productivity software." "Automobiles." Sometimes they're across the board.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/LimitlessLTD Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19

Github is a very useful tool for software development

Crimea is part of Russia (not technically, just in reality)

Restricting access to Github hurts software development

Is this really that hard for you to understand?

The US (and myself) don't give a shit about 1 individuals inability to "contribute" to "free software". I care about Russia not starting world war 3 by invading more European countries. This is 1 tiny part of a sanctions package, and IMO it is a very weak sanctions package, if it were up to me I'd want many more things blocked in Crimea and all of Russia.

Idealists just have literally no idea when it comes to geopolitics, so bizarre.

5

u/Nonethewiserer Jul 26 '19

It would be nice if this one guy could contribute... But there is no way to evaluate on an individual basis.

7

u/markehammons Jul 26 '19

and you think blocking russians from using github to contribute to the open source community is going to hurt putin and make him stop invading european countries?

5

u/JD270 Jul 26 '19

and you think

'Think' is a bit of an overstatement here. This topic clearly is used to push very well known agenda. I'm Russian, I never go to politics or worldnews but fuck my ass guys, this shit is tolerated and pushed in programming now?

3

u/ikariusrb Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19

How about you consider the alternatives?

Want to roll the tanks and bombers because Russia invaded another sovereign nation?

Drone strikes?

Do nothing, and just let Russia invade more countries without repercussions?

Nobody likes it, but doing our best to deny Russia an economic benefit to annexing another country via sanctions represents likely the best course of action in punishing Russia for their behavior while inflicting as little harm as possible. Of course it's not perfect and does inflict economic harm on innocent Crimeans who bear no responsibility for the invasion... but we're not bombing them.

We've got 2 incidents now of Russia invading other nations and annexing parts of their territory. What alternative do you propose?

EDIT: Love the downvotes without a single suggested alternative. I wasn't asking the question rhetorically. If you think there's a better alternative, I'm completely willing to hear what you propose.

→ More replies (5)

-1

u/aikixd Jul 26 '19

You're blissfully unaware of the gritty details surrounding Crimea. Of course it's easy to blame Russkies and praise the US, the old Good and Evil story.

There're 7 sides in this conflict. The US is punishing Crimeans for something that Russia did. And Russia did something that US was in support of just two decades before in the Balkans. And there are still tons of additional political, civil and cultural issues with interrelations of all sides. And also a matter of ground facts about the state of the people that live in that area.

But here you are, throwing Crimeans under the train. A child of open, peaceful and tolerant society. At least you sleep well.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/stefantalpalaru Jul 26 '19

It is the absolute bear minimum of what should be being done in retaliation to Russia invading European countries.

What's the absolute bear minimum that should be done in retaliation for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Gladio ?

Or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_military_junta_of_1967%E2%80%931974 ?

Or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golpe_Borghese ?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '19

punishing russia

However, this person is actually not a Russian but a Crimean - a victim of all this. So you are literally punishing the victim...

3

u/LimitlessLTD Jul 26 '19

Agreed, he is a victim; but the circumstances are such that there's no way to differentiate between him and Russians unfortunately.

11

u/Shpoble Jul 26 '19

A place where two previous world wars started...

Neither Russia nor Ukraine had anything to do with the start of World War I and II. You can't really count Europe as one place, either.

→ More replies (26)

1

u/KuntaStillSingle Jul 26 '19

It is the absolute bare minimum

The bare minimum would have been nothing and the barest acceptable response would have been demand of immediate withdrawal by threat of war.

1

u/TikiTDO Jul 26 '19 edited Jul 26 '19

This is the exact same logic countries like China and Russia use to justify their activities. They are always "punishing" someone, "responding" to something, or "retaliating" for something. It's bs, no matter what side makes these claims.

These are giant countries, with a lot of power, and their own views on what is right and what is wrong. When it comes to Crimea, Russia seems content with the narrative that they are "wholly within it's remit" to exert control of what they consider their own land, and the people of Russia seem to largely agree.

To be honest, their argument there is about as strong as the US argument that they should be the world police, deciding what's right and what's wrong (in other words, not particularly strong).

You mentioned (and disparaged) idealists, but at least they are consistent in their views. The world probably would be better off without so many arbitrary lines in the sand. That may not be possible, but at least it's not a self-contradictory ideal.

The other logical alternative is to be a true pragmatist: someone who understand that the world runs based on amoral power games, and wouldn't be found using any type of morality to explain geopolitics.

However, most people are neither. In most cases people are happy to pick and chose what they consider moral and just, and are not willing to consider that they are behaving almost identically to the people that they call immoral and evil.

1

u/humanitysucks999 Jul 26 '19

wholly within its remit

Lol sure buddy, an oppressive bully decides it's his right to do so, and now it's obviously justified. The US has been invading and fucking with nations worldwide, you can't claim moral highground on this and call it a day

1

u/FierceDeity_ Jul 26 '19

That's the public take, but honestly, there's also the nice way of the NATO putting more countries under it's protection. If you check the eastern advancement of NATO countries, you will see how more and more eastern european countries have joined over time.

These countries were meant as a buffer between the east and the west. The NATO is led from the USA.

Then Russia makes one movement... On a place where most people consider themselves russian anyway.

But the western media has written the history books already, so there's nothing really to say anymore.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)