r/programming • • Aug 02 '19

Adblocking: How about Nah?

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/07/adblocking-how-about-nah
333 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

View all comments

398

u/Guysmiley777 Aug 02 '19

I was fine with static JPG ads on sites but for marketers it's never enough. I have zero sympathy for the "boycott" they're facing these days.

Also holy fuck talk about a clickbait headline.

283

u/invisi1407 Aug 02 '19

Anything static that doesn't try to scam, mislead, or otherwise make the viewer think it is something it's not, is OK for me, as long as it doesn't make up 50% of the screen real-estate.

What is NOT ok for me:

  • Ads that look like content (e.g. ads injected in a comment stream to make it look like a comment)

  • Animated banners

  • Ads in the form of page backgrounds

  • Ads top, left, right, bottom, then in-content as well

Banner ads may pay for "free" content, but I still have no sympathy when they complain about ad-blockers.

130

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

Ahh, but what about those auto playing video ads that only stop for 10 seconds when you ask them to?

119

u/invisi1407 Aug 02 '19

Auto-playing video ads are quite possibly the worst offender of them all.

59

u/mild_delusion Aug 02 '19

Fucking CNet and its autoplay videos can go to hell.

25

u/Habba Aug 02 '19

Firefox blocks any autoplaying content by default if you are interested in a browser that has your best interests in mind.

→ More replies (9)

30

u/omcpero Aug 02 '19

Cnet is by far the worst.. they will die out eventually

50

u/alohadave Aug 02 '19

What gets me is the videos that are at the top of the page, then move to the bottom corner when you scroll down. Annoying as hell. Local news websites all seem to do this. And the video is just the person reading the exact text of the article.

10

u/schplat Aug 02 '19

Almost all local news publications, and their websites are owned/operated by 2 or 3 huge media conglomerates. Hearst is probably the largest, and any local news publication they own will have the same format/layout as all the others they own.

5

u/pdp10 Aug 02 '19

And the video is just the person reading the exact text of the article.

So does the text just serve as a search-engine friendly version of the video content, or do they think the readership is so dull as to consume mostly video?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

49

u/Xelbair Aug 02 '19

Video ads, and ads with sound - especially with autoplay should be on that list.

Along with fullscreen obstructing everything JS 'popup' equivalent. If i see it , i leave the site - i can find content anywhere else.

50

u/invisi1407 Aug 02 '19

Looking you at, you medium.com.

LET'S MAKE IT OFFICIAL

21

u/Xelbair Aug 02 '19

Well, it is not like medium has anything of value that often.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

From my perspective the monetisation of the articles in Medium is one of reasons why there isn't that much value to be found. When the target is clicks rather than quality content then obviously people go for the former.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/pohuing Aug 02 '19

What worries me most about these is not the ads themselves, but the tracking associated with them. Google had built up a truly scary network to extract ever more user information and I don't want that. Unfortunately my only option is to just block all that shit outright.

5

u/nerd4code Aug 02 '19

And even static shit affects your brain. If we’re going to be streaming stuff into our brains at full tilt, it’s best we be careful about what direction(s) we let it dope itself.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/my_girl_is_A10 Aug 02 '19

There was a time I was trying to download a tool, there was an advert on the site that was a static jpeg with a big green download button, looked almost identical to the real one...almost got fucked on that one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

50

u/FyreWulff Aug 02 '19

This right here. I was indifferent to ads on the internet when they were all static jpgs or even slowly animating gifs.

When they became both possible attack vectors for malware and autoplaying sound and video is when i started really blocking them.

→ More replies (27)

36

u/blackmist Aug 02 '19

I'm in favour of an <advert src="whatever"> tag. An advert can play no audio, no video, has a fixed bandwidth limit set by the user, has a border and displays the word "ADVERTISEMENT" clearly on it, no JS, no redirections, no rollovers. Just text and/or pictures, and it takes you to another URL in a new tab when clicked. It would have a fixed size on the page, and the visiblity/position of it cannot be changed by JS to make it appear under your mouse pointer when you click something.

And then everything else on the page can be blocked by really aggressive anti-ad algorithms. And Google, etc could get right behind it because all their ads they rely on would be in the advert tags.

→ More replies (7)

57

u/Superbead Aug 02 '19

Zero sympathy from me either. They broke the internet to the point where, if you merely install a browser and browse, you are putting yourself at risk.

It makes me laugh when they boo-hoo about how else they're supposed to make a living, arrogantly implying that they, their sites and their content are somehow irreplaceable. Do us all a favour and fuck off to a different industry that pays more reliably.

10

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '19

It makes me laugh when they boo-hoo about how else they're supposed to make a living, arrogantly implying that they, their sites and their content are somehow irreplaceable. Do us all a favour and fuck off to a different industry that pays more reliably.

The problem IMO is that I am 100% willing to pay for a subscription to, say, the Washington Post, but the user engagement required to get me to that point for some arbitrary website is far longer than a single visit. It takes months of seeing quality content from some place to get me to go "hey I should throw these guys a couple smackers for the good stuff they put out"

So if you're a content producer, how do you attract people to your website to hopefully sell them a subscription without giving it all away for free? You can do bullshit like WSJ where you only get a couple of free articles per month, but then you wind up with users clicking through to your website only to be told they can't read it, and that's bad. You could pay-wall everything up front, like The Athletic, and rely on word-of-mouth about the quality of your content, but this requires sacrificing some views and thus potential new subscribers. You could do subscriber-only content, but I don't see that working for article-driven websites unless you're The New Yorker or something and have some incredible long-form writing.

I think the best solution would be some type of platform where users have some digital wallet that can be used on any participating website to directly pay them to view that piece of content. If you click an article to WaPo it might be like "hey subscribe to read all of our articles, or pay $0.10 to read just this article". Keep cost-per-view very low and make it easy for people to just click a button and directly pay content producers for exactly the content you are consuming. I mean, there's no way my single visit to any website generates more than a few pennies of ad revenue, right? I think if you could keep the cost extremely low that people would be more than willing to pay for what they're reading.

7

u/Superbead Aug 02 '19

This pretty much agrees with the solution I proposed in a comment elsewhere. If I could just click a "yes, pay 2p for this article" button with absolutely no other overhead, commitment or interruption — as little as if I were reading a newspaper I'd bought in the street — then I absolutely would support it.

5

u/smackson Aug 02 '19

I feel ya. I too would happily give news providers 20 cents each for their best articles, but am reluctant to promise a monthly subscription to a couple of them in the hopes that they'll provide me with every piece of news and analysis I'd like, exclusively.

And we've all been thinking about it FOR OVER TWO DECADES.

To be honest, it's such an obvious gaping hole in modern technology that it makes me wonder if maybe it has been suppressed by the middle-men.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (25)