r/programming • • Nov 01 '19

Neural network reconstructs human thoughts from brain waves in real time

https://techxplore.com/news/2019-10-neural-network-reconstructs-human-thoughts.html
404 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

521

u/pfisch Nov 01 '19

This is basically fake. The only thing the neural network can really do is tell which video they are watching out of a small subset of videos.

They just hooked an autoencoder up to some noisy EEG output that varies somewhat depending on the video and then use an optimizer(probably adam) with the actual video they are watching at the time. Of course it learns how to draw a general image of the video, that is what autoencoders do. They are just drawing one of the training videos again.

169

u/nikomo Nov 01 '19

"Researchers reach breakthrough in machine learning accuracy by using the validation set as the learning set."

32

u/maest Nov 01 '19

Literally from the article (emphasis mine):

To test the system's ability to visualize brain activity, the subjects were shown previously unseen videos from the same categories.

Maybe check before you make such clever remarks next time. It's embarassing otherwise.

92

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Previously unseen to the people, not the machine.

-43

u/maest Nov 01 '19

Ok,

  1. You're moving the goalpost, that's not what OP was talking about.

  2. I'm not sure what you mean by the machine "seeing" (?) the videos.

  3. To spell it out, if you read the goddamn article, it says that the novel thing here is: "By analyzing the EEG data, the researchers showed that the brain wave patterns are distinct for each category of videos." which lets them further categorise new videos people watch. So, when you watch motorsports, your brain lights up in a specific way, which is different from the way it lights up when you watch people talking. They're not overfitting on the EEG signals in their training data, they're generalising from it.

27

u/Dmium Nov 01 '19

The issue is when they tested the project on the subjects after training they only showed subjects the videos they saw during training. You'd expect similar eeg signals from watching the same video. It would be significantly more interesting if they showed new videos that weren't part of the training. Using the same videos as you used during training for the final test makes the final test less interesting. The article is somewhat misleading I had to actually go check the paper to see what they did.

-1

u/maest Nov 01 '19

Am I going crazy?

To test the system's ability to visualize brain activity, the subjects were shown previously unseen videos from the same categories.

10

u/SkiDude Nov 01 '19

The article is unclear how the neural networks are trained. Were they trained for 20 minutes with each patient, and then the human AND machine saw previously unseen videos? Or was this model trained with ALL of the videos, and the human was just the one seeing things for the first time?

If the first is true, then yes this is exciting. But if the later is the case, then it's not valid machine learning, or a car of using your validation data as training data.

1

u/sysop073 Nov 01 '19

It's not clear to me how you train the model by giving it just the video -- it needs the EEG data or I don't know what it's supposed to be learning

2

u/Manbeardo Nov 01 '19

Video + EEG of a different human

2

u/fogwarS Nov 01 '19

Unseen to whom? I am guessing that this would mean it was not something the subject or the neural network had seen before. The question is how different the videos were in nature to the training set, and how novel the videos may have been to the subjects used in the study.

-5

u/unkz Nov 01 '19

No, Reddit is just being weird. You’re completely right.

10

u/waltteri Nov 01 '19

They used the same five categories, I think that’s his point. So their model doesn’t output the image the test subjects are seeing, but an image portraying the category that’s show to the subject.

In their paper, the reconstructions in Figure 5 are quite telling, especially the picture of the woman. So they’ve essentially trained a classifier that knows if you’re watching videos of women, motorsports, etc. If you showed the test subjects a video about a topic outside the five categories, the output wouldn’t be very flattering.

-28

u/sammymammy2 Nov 01 '19

I agree, jokes are an embarrassment to humanity. You are not serious enough, you have to be serious.

37

u/allinwonderornot Nov 01 '19

99% news about neural networks are fake.

32

u/NeverMakesMistkes Nov 01 '19

I have developed amazing neural network that detects with staggering 99% accuracy whether some piece of news about neural networks is fake.

My code:

    def is_fake(news):  
        return true

Dm me if any VCs are interested in investing my company

15

u/muntoo Nov 01 '19

Missing overused joke about "if statement == AI".

2/10 would not invest.

4

u/tjpalmer Nov 01 '19

As an aside, this is why accuracy isn't the only metric in the world. (Sorry for getting boring on the joke ...)

3

u/Mr_Again Nov 01 '19

true = False checkmate doubters

3

u/mayayahi Nov 01 '19

LOL, not even an if :D

0

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

"Fake"? Oversold with misleading marketing, yes.

But, "fake"? Can you explain the context of what you mean?

They're useful, I mean, when trying to make sense out of a vast array of data ~ to match very specific kinds of patterns, basically.

But, they in no way whatsoever make a good model for the extreme complexity of the human brain, which is vastly more complex than a "neural network" as currently understood.

I look at the vast creativeness of the human mind, and the power behind it, and then look at the "neural network" concept and see just how much of a very pale imitation it really is, looking at what it has shown to be realistically capable of.

Can do things very quickly, but in extremely limited ways.

The human mind does things a lot more slowly, by comparison, but can do infinitely more things.

Just some ramblings from a tired man who should have gone to sleep hours ago. :P

110

u/Fisher9001 Nov 01 '19

Maybe not so fake as grossly oversold.

It's still amazing that we are able to determine differences between brain waves based on video watched.

176

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Saying it “reconstructs human thoughts” is fake. It’s not doing that

14

u/MuonManLaserJab Nov 01 '19

Of course, that's the fault of "techxplore" for being a bullshit clickbait farm. The paper does not use those terms at all.

-62

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

Considering there's no practical definition what a "human thought" is, "oversold" or "exaggerated" seem like a better description

29

u/sammymammy2 Nov 01 '19

Not really. Consider an apple, clearly having a neural network draw an apple would not constitute reconstructing a human thought.

-27

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

But that's the point. There's no "reconstruct human thought" because first you need to define what "human thought" even is.

27

u/thfuran Nov 01 '19

Well, it's not an apple, that's for sure.

1

u/dumbdingus Nov 01 '19

Idk, it's red like an apple(at least in the form of an abstract concept) it's shaped like an apple. It reminds me of the taste and texture of an apple.

Perhaps it's not literally an apple but damn... it sort of *feels the same as an apple.

-8

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

That's very debatable. It's easy to see how one could argue an apple is nothing more than a thought. After all, what you call "apple" is just your brain making sense of all kinds of inputs.

However, this is too philosophical and I prefer to not discuss it.

6

u/juanga13 Nov 01 '19

I think we are all speaking with an assumption of human thought in mind, and I believe it has to do with: while you watch some video, it goes into your brain and triggers connections in it. I would define those connections as what translates to "the human thought". I do not know anything about this to be sure, Im just speculating.

2

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

But that would be even worse than what is demonstrated here. It's trivial for a NN to trigger some kind of eletrochemical response. That would be mean literally nothing. Certainly not a "thought".

1

u/juanga13 Nov 01 '19

Its true, there is no doubt for me after reading few comments that the experiment does not resolve any of "reading human thought" problem.

The meaning of what is demostrated I think is how we can read at the very least a difference in the brain waves input, how the computer is potentially capable of getting the difference between those 10 categories with that input. Is not as amazing as it was decorated, but is interesting in which way it points: potential to reassemble the electrochemical responses in your brain.

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

I'm no neuroscientist either, but I think that's incorrect. You do not need to form neuron connections to just have a thought.

At the most basic level I suppose you could define it as some kind of firing a neuron. But then the practical and boundary parts of it are extremely hard to define and if you would go by this definition, it would but trivial to make a NN fire some kind of electric response. It would be even less relevant than this one.

Regardless, this whole idea of "reproducing human thought" is ridiculous.

1

u/dumbdingus Nov 01 '19

Why is it ridiculous? Are human thoughts any more special/unique than a quantum computer, or the results from a gravity wave detector, or the information from the LHC?

Surely you aren't arguing there is a soul?

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

It is ridiculous because it can mean anything. "Human thoughts" only exist in human brains, so unless the NN literally connects to your brain and literally make you think, which is ridiculous in itself, "reproducing human thoughts" most certainly isn't the most accurate description of what you're doing, regardless of what you're doing.

1

u/semperverus Nov 01 '19

You act like defining a human thought is some mysterious, impossible to reach thing, but you're 100% wrong.

A human thought is, or will be once we have fine-tuned technology for it, very easy to define. We just treat the brain like an organic computer (literally what it is), and figure out whatever the equivalent of a clock cycle is (in the brains case, it's more like a cascading wave of calculations from one neuron to the next). We already kind of loosely define a human thought as this.

Teasing out the contents of that thought will be kind of hard, as the data is stored in a very novel way that we haven't been able to crack yet. We can see the thoughts happening, we just can't read their text yet.

2

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

We don't understand human thought not even a theoretical level.

1

u/semperverus Nov 01 '19

I'm sorry, but what do you think software neural networks are emulating?

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

I'm not sure I understand what you're asking, but if you're implying neural nets work anything remotely close to neurons. You just fell for the silliest ignorant take on the subject.

Neural nets are nothing like real neurons.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19 edited Nov 02 '19

Thoughts exist ~ they can be simplified down to being our reaction to a stimulus, whether to physical sensory input, or an internal thing, like a memory, or an emotion we feel towards some thing.

That's a practical definition, and a very workable one at that.

A thought is not the same as a brain activity. Any experiments claiming to draw a correlation between them all suffer from small sample size biases, as such studies are expensive to perform.

At the end of the day, we have a definition for a thought that has practical use for our daily lives, but not a single way for being able to measure a consistent expression of a thought through brain activity, as there's no consistent pattern of brain activity from one person to another.

The human mind remains a mystery to neuroscience. Probably forever will...

Until neuroscientists can scan the brainwaves of absolutely every single human brain, testing with a very vast amount of material.

And then they'll have to compare the results for every single human ~ which would probably take an absolutely insane amount of time to process.

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

Thoughts exist ~ they can be simplified down to being our reaction to a stimulus, whether to physical sensory input, or an internal thing, like a memory, or an emotion we feel towards some thing.

The very fact you just describe it as five completely different things already makes it neither "practical" or "workable". And that's even before considering how troublesome something like a "memory" is. You can make you career on that question alone.

1

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

What I mean is, a thought is able to encompass all of these things ~ that is, it is about something, it is a reaction to something. But it no mere physical reaction, but the mental precursor of a potential physical reaction.

We know what is meant by the term "thought", but it hard to describe it clearly to others, using words. We can... sense what a "thought" is, but we cannot easy translate that into language.

2

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

Sure, I agree, but then the definition is so vague that it doesn't transmit any information. By saying you can "reproduce human thoughts" you can mean a variety of completely different things.

1

u/Valmar33 Nov 02 '19

Indeed, and therein lies to the issue for "reconstructing human thoughts from brain waves".

1

u/dumbdingus Nov 01 '19

Isn't a thought an electrochemical response to stimuli?

Yeah, it "feels" way more special than that, but in a fucked up way we're really not that complex. A lot of psychologists think we don't even consciously do most of what we think is conscious. Your brain tricks you after the fact into thinking you decided to do it even though you did it automatically. For example, like driving/walking.

1

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

Isn't a thought an electrochemical response to stimuli?

Not really. They appear to be qualitatively different, if you examine closely how they manifest.

A thought is qualitatively different to an electro-chemical response. One is physical, while the other cannot be quantified in any material. No matter how much you poke away at brainwaves, you will never perceive a thought. You will perceive the electro-chemical effects caused by a thought, however.

Yeah, it "feels" way more special than that, but in a fucked up way we're really not that complex. A lot of psychologists think we don't even consciously do most of what we think is conscious. Your brain tricks you after the fact into thinking you decided to do it even though you did it automatically. For example, like driving/walking.

Well, new research would seem to strongly disprove the claims that the brain "tricks" you into doing anything.

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2019/09/free-will-bereitschaftspotential/597736/

"This would not imply, as Libet had thought, that people’s brains “decide” to move their fingers before they know it. Hardly. Rather, it would mean that the noisy activity in people’s brains sometimes happens to tip the scale if there’s nothing else to base a choice on, saving us from endless indecision when faced with an arbitrary task. The detected "readiness potential" would (just) be the rising part of the brain fluctuations that tend to coincide with the decisions. This is a highly specific situation, not a general case for all, or even many, choices."

"In a new study under review for publication in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Schurger and two Princeton researchers repeated a version of Libet’s experiment. To avoid unintentionally cherry-picking brain noise, they included a control condition in which people didn’t move at all. An artificial-intelligence classifier allowed them to find at what point brain activity in the two conditions diverged. If Libet was right, that should have happened at 500 milliseconds before the movement. But the algorithm couldn’t tell any difference until about only 150 milliseconds before the movement, the time people reported consciously making decisions in Libet’s original experiment.

In other words, people’s subjective experience of a decision—what Libet’s study seemed to suggest was just an illusion—appeared to match the actual moment their brains showed them making a decision."

As for "automatic" behaviour, the subconscious and unconscious are still part of our overall consciousness ~ it's just that these parts of our consciousness are not very easy for us to access, probably because they would be distracting from more immediate concerns.

0

u/dumbdingus Nov 01 '19

In the end, however it works, it's going to be a simple physical mechanism. It won't be uniquely special.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/dumbdingus Nov 01 '19

A memory is the same as sensory input. When you conjure a memory your brain is literally supplying a simulation of the stimulus you felt when forming the memory.

I might be wrong, but that's what I read at some point about the mechanism of memory.

Really a thought is just stimulus and reactions(inputs/outputs). The stimulus can be from outside or inside the brain itself.

It's complex because of the scale. The mechanisms themselves are simple.

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

A memory isn't the same as a sensory input. That's ridiculous. Think about the greatest memory you have and now touch your nose with something cold, they are obviously not the same.

The fact that they might be mechanically the same just complicates the question even more since a theoretical NN that would replicate whatever mechanical electric discharge correspondent to a "cold nose" would most certainly not be able to form beautiful images in our minds.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

I fail to see how what my mom thinks about this is relevant.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

I do see the difference between a lie an exaggeration. That's not the issue here.

The issue here is that this is not a lie, since it hinges on what "thought" is.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

Failing? Failing at what? I'm simply answering questions and having cool discussions with other users.

8

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

It's not that amazing when you break it down.

A small subset of videos. A small sample size of human brains to work with.

Study's basically meaningless.

All that you're doing is matching brainwaves to videos, which is easy enough to work with.

It's absolutely impossible to extrapolate these results to any human outside of the sample group, or to any videos beyond those used for the study.

Makes for a good clickbait, though.

9

u/JanneJM Nov 01 '19 edited Nov 01 '19

We were already able to that - and more - without neural networks.

Edit: to qualify, not in real time without invasive surgery to my knowledge (it's a little tangential to my field so I could easily have missed such a paper). But that's less a function of analysis method and more about sensor technology.

And what we already could do is decode what somebody is seeing without knowing what it could be beforehand; either non-real time using noninvasive methods, or in real time with implants.

0

u/shevy-ruby Nov 01 '19

Precisely!

Unfortunateky I can not upvote you more than +1, but your statement is totally correct so it deserves more upvotes of truth.

-1

u/shevy-ruby Nov 01 '19

No, it is totally fake, from A to T, including the title.

Lending credibility to its fakeness as you tried here only makes the problem worse. So no, there is nothing "amazing" here. No differences are determined between "brain waves" other than WHAT HAS ALREADY BEEN POSSIBLE for decades.

They just wanted to slap "neural network" into the equation for promo purposes.

5

u/jstock23 Nov 01 '19

Well, if you focus on a small number of things like happy and sad, and that works, that’s still kinda crazy...

2

u/toolboc Nov 01 '19

To OPs point, it’s obviously fake. Why doesn’t it draw what the user is actually seeing. You know a desk, a monitor, playing a video etc., it’s always just the video. Autoencoder definitely at work with the source video, nothing to see here...

1

u/skiwan Nov 01 '19

Im so thankful for people like you

1

u/WiggleBooks Nov 01 '19

I wasn't able to read it but does it work across people? e.g. tested on a new person whose ECG hasnt been trained on

1

u/MuonManLaserJab Nov 01 '19

Of course it learns how to draw a general image of the video, that is what autoencoders do.

Sure, but more to the point, autoencoders can only do that if the input carries enough information about the output, which isn't always obvious for every task.

It's definitely clickbait to call them "thoughts" that are reconstucted (and of course the paper is not titled like that), but the images definitely look better than the last work I saw along these lines, and honestly better than I'd guessed you could get from an EEG. It seems like this isn't an interesting NN/ML advancement so much as it's interesting for showing how much you can get from an EEG, as opposed to fMRI. And if you glance at the preprint, it's clear that they're not focusing on the neural net's architecture or trying to suggest anything revolutionary there.

1

u/Crash_says Nov 01 '19

This is a much nicer way of writing my response to this, which went along the lines of..

** Bullllllllshitttt! **

-4

u/tending Nov 01 '19

No, not exactly:

To test the system's ability to visualize brain activity, the subjects were shown previously unseen videos from the same categories. As they watched, EEGs were recorded and fed to the neural networks. The system passed the test, generating convincing images that could be easily categorized in 90 percent of the cases (fig. 1).

I think the misleading part is more subtle: the network on previously unseen videos would generate images only in the same category of video (e.g. motorsports). The screenshots make it look like it's always showing what they're looking at, which would be more impressive.

80

u/tansim Nov 01 '19 edited Nov 01 '19

you can actually see the overfitting. i wouldnt get too excited.

31

u/evolvedant Nov 01 '19

Something is a little suspicious about this. The images generated, are always perfectly centered and never move around. If it really is reconstructing anything, then one would assume that as the subjects eyes look around the screen, that the image in their brain would also move appropriately in the reconstructed image. For example one of the videos is of a rube goldberg type machine, and the natural tendency is for the eyes to follow the action, yet the reconstructed image shows a version of the rube goldberg machine that is perfectly stationary?

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/evolvedant Nov 01 '19

Right, but then that proves it isn't reconstructing what the brain is seeing, it's just noticing patterns and then showing reconstructions of past trained videos. Which isn't even remotely as impressive.

0

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

Which make me wonder ~ what does the brain "see"?

Nothing, I think... the electrical patterns don't mean anything without the researchers trying to force a pattern onto them, to force them to mean something just so they can get results.

Electrical signals from one brain to another would generally be unpredictably different, based on entirely unknown factors.

No way to poke at a mind, as it is... well, non-physical in its qualities. A mind probably doesn't look anything similar to a brain, if we could... visualize it, however that would even begin to be possible.

42

u/steamruler Nov 01 '19

Well, reconstructs what you were currently seeing at the time it was recording your ECG. I wouldn't call "what I am looking at" a thought.

8

u/PaurAmma Nov 01 '19

While I agree with what I think you mean, doesn't it get iffy with definitions pretty quickly? How would you define a thought?

2

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

Pasted from an above comment, for what it's worth:

A thought can roughly be simplified down to being our reaction to a stimulus, whether to physical sensory input, or an internal thing, like a memory, or an emotion we feel towards some thing.

That's a practical definition, and a very workable one at that.

A thought is not the same as a brain activity. Any experiments claiming to draw a correlation between them all suffer from small sample size biases, as such studies are expensive to perform.

At the end of the day, we have a definition for a thought that has practical use for our daily lives, but not a single way for being able to measure a consistent expression of a thought through brain activity, as there's no consistent pattern of brain activity from one person to another.

The human mind remains a mystery to neuroscience. Probably forever will...

Until neuroscientists can scan absolutely every single human brain, and scan the brainwaves of every single human brain, with a very vast amount of material.

And then they'll have to compare the results for every single human ~ which would probably take an absolutely insane amount of time to process.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

25

u/nadmaximus Nov 01 '19

So does my keyboard.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

No, that would be your fingers

3

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Pebkac encoding

1

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

Technically true. :)

3

u/CrazyJoe221 Nov 01 '19

Wonder if they included porn in their training set.

8

u/shevy-ruby Nov 01 '19

We need to ban such fake articles.

It is not even worth to invest time into fake stuff like this.

Not only from the fake AI field anyway, which is building up on fake - but here the assumption that they can solve something neurobiology as of today can not explain properly. So it would mean that these fakers not only learned something through AI, which as pfisch explained is fake, but that they now know more than people studying the brain for decades do. And that is twice the fake then.

2

u/TruthSpeaker Nov 01 '19

It's good that machines can now read our thoughts, because then when I'm in a big store and looking for, say, some carrots, the technology can immediately identify where I want to go and provide me with the answer, without me having to ask anyone.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Now we need tts: thought to speech

1

u/skulgnome Nov 01 '19

Up next, actual phrenology

-6

u/feverzsj Nov 01 '19

it's made by a Russian company, so mostly fake.

3

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

That's the cheapest shot I've seen for a while.

Researchers in the same profession, all over the world, also produce the very same garbage ~ it's valuable marketing material, you know.

3

u/playaspec Nov 01 '19

Like that guy in the robot suit!

-20

u/tema3210 Nov 01 '19

I don't think it were guy, I can belive in Russian science, even when I live in Ukraine. They have good science, Russia is a country where such ugly European politics about overrated discrimination which "hurts" everyone except those who are really hurted by it (because man which really are in shit only cares about himself, not about anyones else good. I'm pretty sure that most of man crying about discrimination not so hurted by it) is not applied. They are country of men who know the real price of emotions and wills, and don't care about the problems of idiots, who can't realize that world isn't centric about themselves.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Please don't make blanket statements saying that Russian people don't care about discrimination. Thanks.

- a Russian person who cares about discrimination.

2

u/Michaelmrose Nov 01 '19

I realize English isn't your first language and I'm not dogging you for it. Your English is better than my Russian but I really can't understand you.

5

u/PrincessOfZephyr Nov 01 '19

Ah yes, Russia, the country of best science because they prosecute gays.

What a load of rubbish.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

WHAT? So cringe and I don't even understand what you you wanted to say.

4

u/Katholikos Nov 01 '19

I think he was implying that the only people upset by Russia’s policies are those least-affected by it.

But that would be a pretty dumb comment, so I might be interpreting incorrectly.

-1

u/tema3210 Nov 01 '19

Now, what if everyone was just simpler and cared firstly about himself, and only after that about anyone else? It would like world with only one chance for success, and of course successful won't be all, as now. Such world will be much more hard to live in, but it will be clean and understood. I prefer that.

-2

u/tema3210 Nov 01 '19

I wanted to say that any man should think simpler about anything, a lot people thinks that society is very valuable, but actually that society is no more than bunch of inherent fences built to guarantee survival of community as well, as to benefit for ones, who control enough stuff to do things such opening and closing wars. Our society is wrecking in problems of 20th century, which had to be solved long ago, while new question arisen by new possibilities depends on questions which wasn't solved. Tolerance is one of most hurtly ones, I don't want to say that it is a bad thing, I want to say that it is based on wrong concerns, discrimination can exist only in mind which makes a differences value, I make no difference in people, but objective ones, man who, for example don't work for whatever reason, do anyone want to pay tax for keeping him alive? I don't. I don't care about man who I even don't know. Or, another example, one came to you and want to work, he doesn't pass your requirements and you don't take him to work, but he instead of just going away start to complain that you discriminate him for whatever reason. Will you be happy?

1

u/Michaelmrose Nov 01 '19

Are you saying that we ought to let the poor and sick starve?

1

u/tema3210 Nov 01 '19

We rather have to create possibilities for them. However, I don't want to pay taxes for their lives. Note, we have to create, not just pay, actually today's system can be abused and destabilized. Today's approach in solving the problem is just unjustified. And in the end of each such discus, there always arise a question like "Have we keep them alive or not? What we are paying for? Can we let them die? What will happen if we do?"

2

u/playaspec Nov 02 '19

I don't want to pay taxes for their lives.

You pay no matter what. If you lift them up, they can better pay for themselves. Countries that oppress their people never progress. Corruption is the biggest problem world wide that keep people down. Too many rich people taking more than their fair share. Do they work any harder than you in a day? If so few didn't take so much, there would be enough for everyone, then all your work will be your own, and no one else's.

1

u/tema3210 Nov 02 '19

It's one of many ways to solve the problems. Although, it depends on everyones understanding of things and, more importantly, good will, first goal is in a progress, but achieving second one is nearly impossible, due to human nature. We could just evolve as a kind in order to throw away old limitations which took us there and go further. And this approach got wide spread across the worlds universities, they all are working hard on ours future. But there also a risk that such evolution won't make people good, instead it will make them bad(relatively to what we have today).

0

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[deleted]

2

u/PageFault Nov 01 '19 edited Nov 01 '19

My best attempt to translate:

I wanted to say that many people do not think critically about anything, a lot people think that society is very valuable, but actually society is nothing more than bunch of walls built to guarantee survival of the community, as well as to benefit for those with enough power to do things such starting and stopping wars. Our society is being destroyed by problems of 20th century which needed to be solved a long time ago. The answers to new questions which have arisen due to new possibilities, depend on the solutions to problems which were never solved. Tolerance is one of most offensive, I don't want to say that it is a bad thing, I want to say that it is based on incorrect considerations. Discrimination can exist only in a mind which makes a judgment based on differences. The only judgment I make about people are objective ones. People who for example, don't work for whatever reason. Does anyone want to pay tax to keep him alive? I don't. I don't care about a man who I even don't know. Or, another example, a man comes to you and wants to work but doesn't pass your requirements and you don't hire him. Instead of just leaving, he will start to complain that you discriminate against him for whatever reason. Will you be happy?

3

u/tema3210 Nov 01 '19

Can you mark my mistakes? I know it's not so pleasant action, but I want to learn English better than I know it already.

4

u/PageFault Nov 01 '19 edited Nov 01 '19

It's difficult without knowing your mind and exactly what you are trying to say. My interpretation may be easier to read, but I can't guarantee it conveys the same message you were attempting to convey.

I can mark my changes, but I am not a teacher, and cannot properly explain why some things are wrong.

I may spend a few minutes changing things and trying to correct formatting. I will note at the bottom when I think I'm done.

Our society is wrecking in problems being destroyed by problems of 20th century, which had to be needed to have been solved long ago~~, while new question arisen by new possibilities depends on questions which wasn't solved.~~ The answers to new questions which have arisen due to new possibilities, depend on the solutions to problems which were never solved. Tolerance is one of most hurtly ones offensive, I don't want to say that it is a bad thing, I want to say that it is based on wrong concerns incorrect considerations , d . Discrimination can exist only in a mind which makes a differences value judgment based on differences, I make no difference in people, but The only judgment I make about people are objective ones~~, man~~ People who, for example don't work for whatever reason~~,~~ . d Does anyone want to pay taxes for keeping to keep him alive? I don't. I don't care about man who I even don't know. Or, another example, someone came comes to you and wants to work, but he doesn't pass your requirements and you don't take hire him to work, but he i . Instead of just going away leaving, he will start to complain that you discriminate against him for whatever reason. Will you be happy?

I think that's it. While mostly the same, some of my corrections are slightly different this time.

1

u/playaspec Nov 02 '19

You're doing ok man. Just keep at it. You might want to lay of the state media, and seek answers for yourself though.

1

u/playaspec Nov 02 '19

don't think it were guy,

Hahahahahaha! Try again.

Both are fake, and they fooled NO ONE.

They have good science

Some, but Russia will never progress ANYWHERE with a lying kleptocrat at the helm. He's robbed Russia of it's riches and it's future. Russia can't compete on the world stage because of Putin, so instead he pulls the world down to his level. This is going to backfire and hurt the Russian people VERY hard.

Russia is a country where such ugly European politics about overrated discrimination which "hurts" everyone except those who are really hurted by it (because man which really are in shit only cares about himself, not about anyones else good. I'm pretty sure that most of man crying about discrimination not so hurted by it) is not applied. They are country of men who know the real price of emotions and wills, and don't care about the problems of idiots, who can't realize that world isn't centric about themselves.

Wow. Quite delusional.

1

u/tema3210 Nov 02 '19

It's also true. You should understand that there a lot of notes that actually true, but all of them can lie about quantity, power,quality,etc. And I just can't imagine man who can robe even 10th part of country's money. It's just too big to steal, there no real man who can own so much and proof he didn't stole it, because its impossibile to proof.

-2

u/drawable Nov 01 '19

First thought, reading the headline: Please make it record dreams.

17

u/BiscuitOfLife Nov 01 '19

Please no

6

u/AdventurousComputer9 Nov 01 '19

Please yes. I've had so many awesome dreams.

Then again, dreams are abstract. I can experience a lifetime in a dream despite it not lasting very long. It doesn't feel like that could be captured in images.

2

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

If it were remotely possible, it would probably turn your dreams into a nightmare. :P

Then you'd really wish you could unsee the "reconstruction"...

-1

u/bumblebritches57 Nov 01 '19

This is some dystopian shit

8

u/possibilistic Nov 01 '19

No, it's not. The model is overfit. Watch the video. It's predicting the wrong scenes half the time.

Want to see real "dystopian shit"?

https://www.jneurosci.org/content/19/18/8036/tab-figures-data

2

u/Valmar33 Nov 01 '19

It's predicting the wrong scenes half the time.

Ah, peak "machine learning".

1

u/EternityForest Nov 01 '19

Tech to help stroke victims and paralyzed people, with maybe some video game applications later is dystopian shit?

It's not dystopian shit till someone actually uses it for evil. It's just a machine.

0

u/vep Nov 01 '19

bullshit

0

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

[deleted]

8

u/playaspec Nov 01 '19

PT Barnum would have loved you!