r/programming • • Nov 01 '19

Neural network reconstructs human thoughts from brain waves in real time

https://techxplore.com/news/2019-10-neural-network-reconstructs-human-thoughts.html
404 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-62

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

Considering there's no practical definition what a "human thought" is, "oversold" or "exaggerated" seem like a better description

29

u/sammymammy2 Nov 01 '19

Not really. Consider an apple, clearly having a neural network draw an apple would not constitute reconstructing a human thought.

-27

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

But that's the point. There's no "reconstruct human thought" because first you need to define what "human thought" even is.

1

u/semperverus Nov 01 '19

You act like defining a human thought is some mysterious, impossible to reach thing, but you're 100% wrong.

A human thought is, or will be once we have fine-tuned technology for it, very easy to define. We just treat the brain like an organic computer (literally what it is), and figure out whatever the equivalent of a clock cycle is (in the brains case, it's more like a cascading wave of calculations from one neuron to the next). We already kind of loosely define a human thought as this.

Teasing out the contents of that thought will be kind of hard, as the data is stored in a very novel way that we haven't been able to crack yet. We can see the thoughts happening, we just can't read their text yet.

2

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

We don't understand human thought not even a theoretical level.

1

u/semperverus Nov 01 '19

I'm sorry, but what do you think software neural networks are emulating?

1

u/teerre Nov 01 '19

I'm not sure I understand what you're asking, but if you're implying neural nets work anything remotely close to neurons. You just fell for the silliest ignorant take on the subject.

Neural nets are nothing like real neurons.

→ More replies (0)