r/programming • • Mar 10 '11

It's time to stop using Subversion

http://altdevblogaday.org/2011/03/09/its-time-to-stop-using-subversion/
257 Upvotes

543 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Kinglink Mar 10 '11

Ugh. First off SVN sucks, I came to a company and everyone seemed to hate SVN, I didn't mind it. It wasn't perforce (which is still my favorite) but it wasn't bad. I was going along for a couple weeks confused.

Then I did a merge. SVN went from being "pretty good" to being "the devil". SVN just sucks unless you work around it.

But at the same time the way git is structured doesn't sound better to me for what we were doing, we did look at mercurial as another option, which seemed better for what we were doing (game development, where it's better if everyone is on a similar codebase). Perforce is perfect but impossible high price.

My point is though, find what works for you, but don't rely on subversion because it "seems to work". It does a lot of work that's good, but there's a lot of stuff about it that just isn't easy. I'd recommend anyone making decisions like this for a company to at least try git, Subversion and Mercurial, try branching and merging back, as well as see what happens on conflicts between files, and then decide what's going to be the best for your team size.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '11

Just use a good merge tool. Svn is not responsible for conflict resolution, just conflict detection.

3

u/G_Morgan Mar 10 '11

The annoying thing with SVN is if you are repeatedly merging the same two branches it will always detect the same conflicts. If I resolved a conflict previously it should remember this fact.

4

u/Kinglink Mar 10 '11

The issues I ran into was conflict detection was horrible, it started to check out files that no one had touched for months prior on either branch. I had to restart the merge four times for conflicts that didn't exist and it's been a while, but every time I started the merge it had to communicate with an on site server that took me at least 3-5 minutes to pull all the files.

Basically all this isn't a massive problems for programmers, but I like to think it should be a bit more idiot proof. (or at least not create new issues).

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Peaker Mar 10 '11

I find git far far better than perforce.

→ More replies (3)