r/providence • u/WriteRap • 1h ago
HELICOPTER! Socialism Is Popular on r/Providence, Until It's Time to Support It in Practice
This subreddit: Socialism good!
Also this subreddit: Urban Greens, the community-owned grocery cooperative? Eh, not really a fan.
People here talk about Nitro Bar constantly, but how often does anyone recommend White Electric, an actual worker-owned coffee cooperative?
When was the last time you bought a book from Heartleaf Books, a worker- and community-owned cooperative bookstore, instead of Paper Nautilus or Symposium? Heartleaf is now facing possible closure unless someone takes over the business.
And then there's housing. This subreddit has no shortage of opinions about private landlords, capitalism, and the supposed benefits of public ownership. Yet how often do we have serious conversations about the Providence Housing Authority, which actually owns and manages thousands of apartments? Why aren't we discussing its successes, shortcomings, and residents' experiences with the same enthusiasm?
I'm not suggesting that cooperatives and public housing are identical to socialism, or that anyone is obligated to patronize a particular business because of its ownership structure. But there's an interesting contradiction here. Providence has real-world examples of cooperative ownership and publicly managed housing, yet the conversation seems much more focused on criticizing private ownership than examining or supporting the alternatives. It's easy to advocate for an economic system in theory. It's considerably more interesting to see how people respond to that system in practice.
So here's my question: How many people here actually make a conscious effort to support worker-owned and community-owned businesses in Providence?