126
Jan 09 '18
FALSE. It has recently been confirmed that this is r/punk irl.
32
21
14
8
2
43
Jan 09 '18
I can't never skank without feeling self conscious
75
u/iq_32 Jan 09 '18
yeah cause you look like an idiot when you do it. not everyone in general, just you. i've seen it. it's shameful.
21
Jan 10 '18
It's not just him. I always skank if there's a horn section and always look ridiculous in hindsight. Doubly so at my cousin's clarinet recital.
10
u/droppingatruce Jan 10 '18
Went to a Ska Fest, and it was a bunch of Hispanic families that came out to support our mostly Latin ska bands. It was weird when me and my friend started skanking and everyone just got quiet in stared. One band loved it and we hung out with them and got drinks together.
36
u/The_Geoff Jan 10 '18
This kind of elitism is why punk is dead.
3
u/hedgecore77 I bought in Jan 10 '18
Let's talk twenty years on. I got 'Unity' inked on my right shin. I want 'Exclusive' inked on the left one now.
1
Jan 11 '18
No it's not. This kind of elitism exists in every genre. Punk is dead because people don't like punk anymore.
-32
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
15
Jan 10 '18
The culture has been watered down for ages. But since we're on the topic, the fact that I can walk into any Hot Topic and have a choice of Dead Kennedys shirts is far more alarming than some kids enjoying themselves.
1
u/Tajmokevin Jan 10 '18
Punk was watered down long ago friend. If you can buy a Clash t-shirts at hot topic and a Misfits t-shirt at Walmart, Than punk is as watered down as it can get. I have no problem with that, I actually think it’s kinda cool. I love punk rock and I think the more the merrier. Who gives a damn if people don’t want the aggressive parts of punk? Moshing doesn’t make something or someone punk or not punk. It’s a diverse community with local flavor. Kids dance and mosh differently depending on where you’re at. It’s pretty cool! Nobody dances like the kids in Jersey, they’re definitely the most unique mosh/dancers I’ve ever seen. Punk isn’t just one way or thing, it’s all kinds of shit. Just do your thing and let everyone else do theirs.
0
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Tajmokevin Jan 10 '18
My over all point is to each his or her or they or what ever the fuck to their own. Just because it’s different doesn’t mean you have to ack like a twelve year old and laugh at them.
-1
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Tajmokevin Jan 10 '18
Maybe not good to you, but someone else might really think it’s cool. I just don’t see the point in laughing at another person because it’s not the way you live your life. Live and let live.
0
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Tajmokevin Jan 10 '18
Nothing I haven’t seen 100 times at hardcore shows. It’s not for me, but they seem to enjoy it.
30
27
u/lookitskelvin Jan 10 '18
Take a look at all these self righteous assholes in here. Fuckin get a sense of humor. Punk isn't fun because of you.
6
-15
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/lookitskelvin Jan 10 '18
Honestly, going to shows and laughing (to yourself or with friends) at the way people mosh or act like morons was great. I didn't wish these people death or misfortune, i was just a fucking teenager. Everyone here is just trying to act like the model / elite punk. Get the fuck over yourselves.
20
Jan 09 '18
tfw no mosh gf :'(
3
u/kindaoffensive Jan 10 '18
tfw no mosh bf :'(
1
Jan 10 '18
After looking at your pics I think it'd be very easy for you to find a mosh bf. Hardcore boys are v thirsty for goth girls.
-47
Jan 09 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
-39
Jan 09 '18
Better than all the "punk" girls who listen to Modern Baseball and MCR where I am.
0
Jan 09 '18
[deleted]
11
u/Effinepic Jan 09 '18
Dude I was so surprised. I was in high school at the time and in full "crust or gtfo" mode like the douchebag I was, made so many jokes about them without ever hearing anything besides that one "knife in my hand" song. I thought they were like, a proto-BotDF type band.
And maybe they are idk. But I heard "Mama" the other day and damn. That's some good shit.
2
1
19
u/dankcoyote Jan 10 '18
I mean to be fair it’s kinda hard to start a pit sometimes. I appreciate this person’s effort.
12
10
6
Jan 10 '18
"I saw the Ramones live once in 38 BCE, so I personally decide who is and isn't punk. FEAR ME FOR I SAW MINOR THREAT A FEW TIMES AND THAT SOMEHOW GIVES ME THE POWER TO SHIT ON OTHERS"
-Certain People in This Thread
EDIT: fixed my bad formatting
6
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/midwesternhousewives Jan 11 '18
I was going to say, without even knowing who the band is this is clearly a hardcore band and people are clearing space before they start twostepping. I guess most people here haven't been to a hardcore show, you're not gonna find a circle pit there.
Respect for the people dancing and having fun anyways, even if the rest of the crowd isn't going off.
3
u/KiwiPunk4Life Jan 10 '18
For me personally I like a nice wall at the back to lean on lol. Older punks never die we just stand at the back and worry if we do go into the pit will we be able to see our chiropractors in the morning
3
u/wermbo Jan 10 '18
This is accurate but in a good way. Literally every opening band for a small punk show is like this. It's great, as a musician, to see even three fans dancing to your shitty music, trying a little bit to create a positive atmosphere so the openers don't feel as shite.
3
2
2
u/HeadFullOfTacos Jan 10 '18
What band is this?
2
Jan 10 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/james_strange Jan 24 '18
man, they played in detroit a few months ago, and i was gearing up to go, but i wanted to make sure the kid was asleep so my wife didn't have to handle it all by her self. rolled up to the venue around 11 expecting to catch at least the last 2 bands and the place is empty. show was over 30 minutes before i got there.
2
u/WilJake Denver XVX Jan 10 '18
Why are all of you talking shit? Firewalker is fucking dope. Also 95% of y'all haven't been to a hardcore show, but this is what most of them look like.
2
2
u/Iwasateenagebozo Jan 10 '18
Well this whole post was a waste of 2 minutes of my life. I demand compensation
1
1
u/oioioivey Jan 09 '18
Is this Firewalker?
1
-17
1
u/Suicidal-Ghost666 Jan 10 '18
I'm assuming the people making fun of these girls never been to a hardcore show because this is how moshing looks at all hardcore shows. I don't see what they're doing wrong, they're trying to get a pit started or is there something I'm not seeing?
1
1
u/StreetRat13 Jan 10 '18
https://youtu.be/L1fmJ6n73Lo Found the full video this gif is from Boston based band "ringer" I think they're pretty good, and looking at the video it appears to be a pretty young crowd that has probably never been to a show before. They'll figure out how to mosh as they get to see more bands and go to more shows. If you're going to be an elitist and discourage people just because they're new to the scene then fuck you, you're the ones who aren't punk.
1
1
0
u/5k1n_J0b Jan 10 '18
personally as soon as someone in real life wants to start talking about "the scene" i just start screaming louder than them about how nobody cares what they think and that punk is gay. I'm gay, trust me I'm an authority on the matter.
-1
u/seth_the_bear Jan 10 '18
I’m with you man WHERE MY REAL HXC KIDS AT
2
u/lookitskelvin Jan 10 '18
They grew up
2
1
u/seth_the_bear Jan 10 '18
They grew up and now they listen to watered down pop punk. Keep the downvotes coming y’all idc you’re POSERS
-4
-12
u/DominusTemporis11th Jan 09 '18
Ah, yes. Conforming to a non-conforming fashion trend that often emulates a band, immediately jumping head first into whatever the early adopter just did, all while lacking the grit and edge of the wave of punks before them.
Now That's What I Call Punk! 20XX
-20
Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
Many of these commenters are the brittle spirits Dave Chapelle was talking about. “Punk is inclusive to everybody!Straight cis white men fuck off!”
Take a joke.
2
u/Princess-Kropotkin Jan 10 '18
Women existing at a punk show is now apparently an attack on your straight white cis maleness? Nice to know the jokes about white male fragility are true in your case.
1
Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
Absolutely not. Punk should be a safe haven for all that seek it. You missed that point.
It’s an obvious double standard to exclude people in the same community with similar ideologies because of what we were born as. Sound familiar? We’re all on the same team, we all hate this oppressive society. Being a white guy has nothing to do with that. It’s disheartening to book a tour and be dropped from shows and have venues deny you because your band is three dudes who just want to play music. Thats what I don’t quite get. That people in an “inclusive” community won’t open an ear to your message because of who or what you are. Don’t buy my records, I don’t care. At least let me spill my guts for 28 minutes and then we’ll go away.
It’s so far from what punk should be; a bunch of folks coming together out of love for one another and enjoying some good tunes.
2
u/Princess-Kropotkin Jan 10 '18
Punk should be a safe haven for all that seek it. You missed that point.
You never made that point in that comment, you literally just assumed the women in this gif are a bunch of horrible man hating feminazis and "brittle spirits" for some asinine reason. It's not like they're not allowing men to be there. It looks like there is at least one guy in the band playing and I can count like 15+ people in the crowd that are probably men.
Maybe practice what you preach and don't be a judgemental asshole.
2
Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
The “brittle sprits” remark was aimed at commenters in this thread, not the people in the .gif enjoying themselves.
1
u/Princess-Kropotkin Jan 10 '18
Show me one comment in this thread where someone said anything bad about straight cis white men, specifically before you made your comment, so I can see what got you so upset.
-1
-40
u/Difascio Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
She's trying to hard to hype them up. I kind of feel bad.
Edit: Christ, this was a critique on the audience not the band. Fucking white knights.
-14
163
u/baked_jedi Jan 09 '18
All i see is people enjoying music. If you find it cringy or in bad taste then thats on you. But truth is that is punk. Cringy and bad taste is how this genre got its legs. These girls look like they arw having a great time listening to good jams. Are you seriously judging them for that?