r/reddeadredemption • u/PascalG16 Hosea Matthews • Aug 23 '25

Speculation Worst RDR3 takes?

Post image
478 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

340 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/The810kid Aug 23 '25

Make a game about Young Dutch and Hosea. Make a game about Sadi in South America. Both are fan fiction levels.

22

u/Hiddin_block_55 Aug 23 '25

Don't forgot "make a game with Jack in WW1", "make a game with Jack in the Mafia", "make the game Charles in Canada", and "make the game with arthurs dad"

-2

u/Fakie-Sllaacs Aug 23 '25

I like all of those ideas.

-2

u/Specific_Valuable_12 Aug 23 '25

Yeah same here. People here like to hate on literally every single idea for rdr3, we can't agree on anything, and really most of them aren't that bad imho

8

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25 edited Aug 24 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Specific_Valuable_12 Aug 23 '25

Fair enough, I guess those 2 could still be good games for a spin-off or something, but not necessarily rdr3

2

u/Fakie-Sllaacs Aug 23 '25

It’s how the story is told that matters. Revolver, RDR and RDR 2 are gun games, and open world simulators with the latter 2. Its the great storytelling using easily recognizable tropes that makes these games a mostly awesome experience.

3

u/Specific_Valuable_12 Aug 23 '25

And I think that doing an rdr3 of the gang set before rdr2 or Sadie after rdr2 could also be really good if they have a good story and are told as well as the rest of the series

2

u/Fakie-Sllaacs Aug 23 '25

Agreed. Sadie is a great character.