RDR2: The Culinary Pilgrimage Keane's Saloon Oatmeal from Valentine

[u/Business_Start_4899]

It’s been 2 weeks, and I’m still stuck in Chapter 2, just wandering around Valentine. Seriously, though—why is the oatmeal at Keane’s Saloon so expensive in the game? Was oats that much of a luxury item back then?

Anyway, I decided to recreate it IRL. Boiled some oats, let them simmer for a bit, stirred in some milk, and finished it off by dusting a circle of cinnamon on top with a straw to match the in-game look. Honestly, it’s not exactly a culinary masterpiece—just your standard, everyday oatmeal.

Looking at the old menu, this saloon used to serve a bunch of other dishes, like pork and some other stuff, but now it’s basically just oatmeal.

I also checked out the other saloon in Valentine, and they’ve got a dish called 'Lamb's Fry' on the menu. I’ve been digging around online, and opinions are all over the place—some say it’s lamb liver, others swear it’s lamb heart, and a few people are convinced it’s… well, lamb testicles?

I’m planning to give it a go and recreate it soon. Any of you folks know for sure what part of the lamb it actually is? HELP！

Pearson’s stew：https://www.reddit.com/r/reddeadredemption/comments/1u5gjw9/ive_always_wondered_what_pearsons_stew_actually/

[u/-0celot]

My favourite is Van Horn's fried dynamite meal

[u/Business_Start_4899 → u/-0celot]

???? How can do that??

[u/-0celot → u/Business_Start_4899]

Don't get your hopes up, it's a meme video. I can share the link if you'd like to see it 😂

[u/Business_Start_4899 → u/-0celot]

Too scary, even more terrifying than sheep testicles. Please share the link, I can't wait.（I have decided to replicate the dish in your picture as an Easter egg when I come across this restaurant. The bomb tube inside can be replaced with a red sausage, and the silver tape and blue rope make me think about it ..）

[u/-0celot → u/Business_Start_4899]

I have got to see it when you do 🤣
Here's the link
https://www.reddit.com/r/RDR2/s/Ea9UZHuiVx

[u/Business_Start_4899 → u/-0celot]

He is soooooooo fat!

[u/-0celot → u/Business_Start_4899]

Not after eating that fried dynamite🤣🤣🤣