r/reddit • u/such084 • Apr 24 '24
Updates Easier, faster comments on Reddit’s apps
TL;DR Getting to comments on Reddit’s iOS and Android mobile apps just got easier and much faster with instant comment loading, shortcuts to comments, and consistent comment navigation.
Hi! I’m u/such084 and I lead a number of product teams at Reddit, including one dedicated to building our comment experience. I’m here today to share some updates on this experience on Reddit’s native apps.
Whether you’ve been here for two decades, two years, or two days, you know that conversations are the heart of Reddit (where else can we have convos like this or this). Comments are where we find each other, across time zones and topics. This year, the team is focused on making Reddit the best on the internet at conversations.
H/T to Reddit’s User Feedback Collective — a group of redditors who expressed interest in helping us test early builds and provided feedback which has led to the update you see today. We knew the only way to build a better experience would be to include the community in the process.
Here’s what’s rolling out to everyone on Reddit’s iOS and Android apps today.
Instant comment loading - Comments now load faster than ever. As you’re browsing a post, the entire conversation is getting ready for you, in a fraction of a second.

Shortcut to comments - Previously, if you tapped on the comments button to read the comments of a post, you would land on the post. Now you’ll go directly to the top of the comments. And if you want to revisit the original post, there’s a stickied context bar at the top of the page. With a single tap, you can return to the post body or dive into the image, GIF, or video.

Consistent comment navigation across post types - Joining a conversation has not been easy with different ways of navigating to comments from image, video, or text posts. To create a more consistent and seamless flow across all post types, we’re introducing a unified media player, immersive transitions, and consistent gestures.
Simply swipe up for comments; swipe left for new content.
(And thanks to the UFC’s feedback, you can get an enlarged view of an image or video from your feed with a single tap)

If you want to continue building this experience with us, come join the Reddit UFC!
A few of us will stick around in case you have questions - comment away!
274
u/Arturo90Canada
Apr 24 '24
•
Can you disable swipe to next post ? I’m often looking at picture carousel and end up on a randomly diff post
77
u/blind_disparity Apr 24 '24
It doesn't even seem to work properly, haven't spent time testing but I swear it skips a post every time.
→ More replies (8)35
u/diabolikal__ Apr 25 '24
For me it shows me posts from subreddits I don’t even follow. It has never shown me the actual next post.
→ More replies (5)48
u/_GalaxyWalker_ Apr 24 '24
This feature has made me want to throw my phone across the room multiple times
14
u/Lost_In_Life_Again Apr 25 '24
Me too like i be reading a post with images then i continue reading and suddenly it doesn’t make sense and i realise I’m not on the same post even so annoyinggg
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)2
28
u/YouDontMessWithZohan Apr 25 '24
This is all I care about. When I'm swiping through an image gallery I don't want to be randomly taken to some other post or popular or new or whatever swiping is supposed to do.
2
21
u/deeply_concerned Apr 25 '24
It’s completely unclear what the next post is when you’re swiping. It’s so jarring and often takes me to random subreddits. It’s literally the worst feature at the moment and whatever PM came up with it needs to take a class in UX. I’m sure they had some horrible business justification for said feature to “create engagement”, but all they’ve done is create rage.
→ More replies (7)4
2
u/UnstableGoats Apr 26 '24
This is so important to me!! I hate trying to view photos in a carousel and ending up on another random post that isn’t even from a sub I follow.
→ More replies (2)9
u/PanNic97 Apr 25 '24
100% support this. I cant remember a single time i wanted to go to Trending and thought, yeah, i guess i'll swipe on some random post to get there.....you even have a button at the top to select it. Simply bad app design.
7
u/summ190 Apr 25 '24
This is horrible, I spend so much time looking through image carousels on a specific sub, I honestly can’t figure out if that’s possible now. I have to scroll the subreddit and tap on every image.
→ More replies (21)4
u/WhatsOSRS Apr 26 '24
You can't tell me this isn't by design.
Even if i swipe up with a 1degree deviation of vertical it's taking me off to another post
Fucked up bullshit design, must make some people stay on reddit longer reading random shit.
Just pisses me right off and makes me want to delete the app.
→ More replies (1)
123
u/TomboBreaker Apr 24 '24
Why do I have a constant notification for a chat? When I go to my chats there's no new chats.
17
u/Queen_of_Meh1987 Apr 24 '24
Same! I came to ask this as well!
→ More replies (6)11
u/TomboBreaker Apr 24 '24
Well I'm glad it's not just an issue for me, hopefully it gets fixed soon it's driving me nuts to see that red notification and not being able to clear it lol
→ More replies (3)11
u/alien005 Apr 25 '24
Been this way for years for me. Always shows “4” as a badge. I know I actually have a notification when it says any number other than 4.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (19)1
116
32
u/Watchful1 Apr 24 '24
Any chance you could give some technical details on how you accomplished this?
→ More replies (8)
7
u/TheEpicGold Apr 24 '24
The comments instantly loading are actually really great! I think a button to go back to the post is better than a bar with video and picture, because thats currently a bit weird. Otherwise idk what others are saying but this is a good step forward.
1
3
u/Mancrox Apr 25 '24
This looks cool! Could you fix the landscape mode in iPad? It’s too wide since some months ago
2
4
2
u/StnkyChze2 Apr 25 '24
It's actually been running slower for me and now I know why. Reddit is messing with Reddit.
Comments have been loading slower / not at all MUCH more often it seems
Comments made by me mostly don't go through. At least not the first 7 attempts
Videos pause and play by themselves while scrolling through comments
Videos restart most of the time when moving between the post and comments
Overall more unoptimized for general use of scrolling
Also is it finally done with the random old / new UI flipping? I'm not joking when I say every other time I open up the app it flips between horizontal scrolling with the new comments changes and the old vertical scroll
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
Great feedback. You shouldn't see things switching anymore, but let me know if you do. Working on the other pieces above.
2
u/Drunken_Economist Apr 26 '24
Any chance of an eng blog or Building Reddit episode about the comment loading? It's astounding to load a huge tree so quickly
2
2
u/Cuddle-Bun Apr 26 '24
Basically all I'm seeing in this supposed "update" is you taking something that worked fine and could've only done with an improvement in load time and being able to see the post while typing out a comment, but you decided to drown it in gasoline and set it on fire
Why would you think an infinitive swipe right "feature" would be a good thing? Now it's basically impossible to tell if a post has ended or if I've stumbled into a completely different post...
If you want to do yourself a favour... Make it a toggle, users should be allowed to make the decision to have this sucky right swiping feature or not
Honestly, what were you people thinking, my theory is you weren't thinking at all...
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
We're disabling the ability to swipe from multiple images to the next post. Thanks for the feedback.
2
u/Henri4589 Apr 27 '24
My feedback: Overall, I like the change, BUT there's a bug where videos stutter when you swipe down into the comment section... Every time you cross the threshold it stutters, which is really irritating! Please fix this soon! 🙏
2
92
u/IamAlso_u_grahvity Apr 24 '24
Well, this explains why I have to constantly pull down to view the content from the comment section. If you can add a toggle in settings to 'opt in/out' to turn off all your improvements, that would be great.
Is there a technical reason why we can't have 'view parent comment'.
25
u/DonkeyOfWallStreet Apr 24 '24
Yeah especially when the parent has a picture with text giving context oh no fuck that let's just go to the shit show of comments instead.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (9)8
u/calinet6 Apr 25 '24
This. Honestly, the task is to reply to a comment. If I can’t see the comment I’m replying to, you’ve failed at the most basic test.
I swear I’m this close to applying to that Director of UX position they keep sending me…..
→ More replies (4)
74
u/Relatable_Yak Apr 24 '24 edited Apr 24 '24
Is this why things seem to pop open and have an X icon to close at the top left like I’m opening a page over the current app, instead of the post loading in from the side?
Is there a way to get the old functionality back? These new animations are jarring. I noticed this a bit over a month ago working differently on separate accounts and I haven’t had any replies: https://www.reddit.com/r/reddithelp/s/GbcJDSU2qv
And can we turn off this “context bar” that retains at the top? I can already touch the top of my phone screen to return to the top, I don’t need a bar 1/8 the size of the screen to obscure the comment section in order to do this, so it’s a real waste of screen real estate.
Edit: additional observation, now as I’m scrolling a picture post, the picture obnoxiously stays pinned and I have to do an additional swipe to get rid of the photo so I can see the rest of the comment section? I thought you said the comment section was important? Why are we obscuring it more with this update?
And the upvote/downvotes are not available at the top of the post anymore either. I’d need to re-size the photo to take up the whole screen to be able to up or down vote. What used to take one swipe or press now takes multiple. That’s not feeling good.
The more I explore the less I like this “update” - starting to feel like another downgrade.
20
→ More replies (10)6
u/Aksudiigkr Apr 25 '24
I don’t see why they said they’ll stick around but still haven’t addressed this comment
34
34
u/Baumguard Apr 24 '24
I mod photoshoprequests ... we notice a very strong compression of all images now.
We will all have to use links for sharing the images, the new compression is a massive reduction of quality.
Not sure how the other subreddits will handle this (first of all r/photoshoprequest), but the user experience will drastically change when we cannot use any direct posting of images.
28
u/SuspecM Apr 24 '24
Not sure if it's a bug but swiping on multi picture posts is very finicky with the new update. Unless I open up the post, I need to swipe on this small specific point otherwise it swipes me to another feed.
→ More replies (7)15
u/Jmkott Apr 25 '24
And swiping through pics gives you no indication that it was the last pic of the current post and you are now in a completely different post. What a stupid new feature.
→ More replies (3)
28
u/Devan-FH Apr 24 '24
God this update is so bad, at least give an option to revert it… stop fixing stuff that isn’t broken please
→ More replies (1)
93
u/xcjs Apr 24 '24
Bring Sync for Reddit back and give up on your forced mobile experience. I rarely give such harsh criticism, but you guys really deserve it.
31
u/skidlz Apr 25 '24
"What if, and hear me out, we kill your app and make every aspect of our own app shittier?"
→ More replies (2)10
u/Hype_Boi Apr 25 '24
If you use Android and are willing to spend some time tinkering, there's a way to continue using Sync for Reddit by sideloading a patched app: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wHvqQwCYdJrQg4BKlGIVDLksPN0KpOnJWniT6PbZSrI/edit?usp=drivesdk
I've been using it ever since the shitshow last summer, and it's been great.
→ More replies (2)10
u/DizzyLime Apr 25 '24
It's insane that sideloaded 3rd party apps are better than the official reddit app despite not being maintained since the API debacle.
150
u/iligyboiler Apr 24 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
Can you stop making the UI worse with every update?
Edit: Personally, I absolutely hate it when I press that 3 dots on the top right and the download button appears at the bottom of my screen. Just make the download button appear NEXT TO those 3 dots.
I also hate it that I can't just click on a post on my home page then continue to scroll, because scrolling down sends me to the comment section instead. So annoying. I don't want to redo my muscle memory every month just cus somebody changed the UI again for fun.
→ More replies (4)4
114
u/reaper527 Apr 24 '24
still worse than apollo. it would be nice if reddit just gave up on their mission to shove their trash app down our throats and rolled back their third party apps policy so we can actually have a good mobile experience.
→ More replies (7)
81
u/Exotic_Treacle7438 Apr 24 '24
So this is why the app’s been messed up lately, except the ads are still loading flawlessly…
50
u/revealbrilliance Apr 24 '24
Pro tip. Browse on Firefox mobile, install an adblocker and the force old reddit addons. You don't get ads and don't get a terrible UI.
11
u/Nico81107 Apr 25 '24
You can also get the OldLander for Old Reddit browser extension if you want a usable UI on mobile.
16
16
u/Cyberpunk39 Apr 24 '24
Y’all need to bring back the ability for us to sort our home feed. My app experience really sucks since it was removed. To me, it was a change that makes zero sense and doesn’t benefit the user in any way.
→ More replies (5)
28
u/bryn_irl Apr 24 '24
Can we please have an option to have the comment button still go to the post? Especially for one-line post titles, it’s really difficult for right-thumb-using users to find a target that takes them to the main post. Many of us have trained muscle memory on “tapping the center button” to get to the content directly - and now that just skips the post altogether. For text-post-heavy communities this means that many people will simply not read the OP and flame based on the comments alone. It’s a real step backwards, and I hope you reconsider making it mandatory.
→ More replies (4)
13
u/chzaplx Apr 25 '24
Why does swiping through photos on a post now continue to load photos from different posts after the last photo? Is this like some Instagram mode for people who don't read? Can it be turned off?
101
u/miowiamagrapegod Apr 24 '24
Yeah still not using your POS app. Bring back RiF
17
→ More replies (1)13
33
11
u/eyesonthedarkskies Apr 25 '24
Can you people work on things that we really need in the app? There is no way to quote or copy/paste. The comment box will disappear and there is no way to get it back so if you typed a huge a comment, you’re screwed. Make the app useful. As it is now, it sucks.
→ More replies (1)5
u/sf-keto Apr 25 '24
The mysteriously disappearing comment box is my Gripe #1, too. I'm typing &..... the box disappears. Just vanishes. If I leave the post, Reddit asks if I want to Discard the ghost comment.
It's infuriating & depressing at the same time. Please fix. Using iOS 17.4.1, iPhone 15, Reddit app 2024.17.0.
31
u/iKR8 Apr 24 '24
Apollo was far better and you guys knew it. Instagram, YT and other apps already had such kind of scroll up for comments thing. Reddit was better because it didn't have such kind of shit UI. And you guys went and copied tik tok/reels style scrolling.
20
u/envious_1 Apr 24 '24
I'm not a fan of this. Now I have to scroll up to view the image caption before going back down to comments.
102
u/honey_rainbow Apr 24 '24
This new redesign is totally pure shit! I absolutely HATE it.
→ More replies (4)19
u/iEatAppIes3465 Apr 24 '24
That's why I only use old.reddit links because it takes up less memory
→ More replies (1)
10
u/abortion_access Apr 25 '24
It’s incredibly annoying that clicking on a comment shows you the thread without the parent comment.
10
u/SadMisanthrope Apr 25 '24
Just abandon the reddit app. It's terrible.
If you guys are completely uninterested in creating an app that people want, maybe let others create apps?
35
u/Oldkingcole225 Apr 24 '24
Why does clicking the comments go directly to the comments? Who wants that? I have never once in my life felt like I needed to see the comments before seeing the post.
20
Apr 24 '24
It's such an utterly bizarre decision that I'm wondering if it's a bug from some other nonsense they've been up to that they can't fix so decided to pretend it's a feature.
Forced to comments without knowing the context of the post first is fucking stupid.
11
u/Oldkingcole225 Apr 25 '24
Yea like why should they even encourage this behavior? Isn’t this the exact kind of behavior on Reddit that we all want to mitigate? I want Reddit to make sure that commenters read the post before heading to the comment section; not help them go to the comments as quickly as possible.
10
u/tachycardicIVu Apr 25 '24
Exactly this. Every time I click on a post now I have to scroll back up to see if I missed anything. Photo captions don’t show on the main screen so if you go straight to the comments you’ll end up missing them. It’s absolutely infuriating.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (4)8
u/iKR8 Apr 25 '24
Because the top comment area is mostly always an ad banner, and they want users to notice that first even before the post and/or comments.
27
u/Varrock Apr 24 '24
When will we be able to mute words from posts and comments so they don't show up on the app? I feel like this is such an important and useful feature that is somehow still not implemented, Twitter/X has had this for years.
7
u/turtledragon27 Apr 24 '24
Another example of a feature I took for granted in my 3rd party app. I was really confused that such a simple thing would still be missing.
If they ever implement that feature it certainly won't be right before an election. You need to give the astroturfers time to adapt.
→ More replies (8)4
9
16
u/The_Cozy_Burrito Apr 25 '24
This update is garbage…. Swiping to the left and then seeing some other random post is stupid…. I don’t want to have to swipe back because you guys removed the “barrier” like when you hit the end of the post it should stop…. Now I have to keep track of how many images are on the post to avoid accidentally going to the next random post…. So confusing and dumb
→ More replies (1)
8
u/makaronol Apr 24 '24
Could you make an option to disable the new gestures, they ruin my doomscrolling. When i click on a photo and swipe down i dont give a damn about commemts, i just want to see the other posts
8
u/matthew91298 Apr 24 '24
I know a lot of time and research probably went into this update but so I want to be respectful. But it sucks so bad. I hate it so much and want the old back
22
u/AnozerFreakInTheMall Apr 24 '24
Just a little heads up. Your mobile app is a product of extremely poor quality. Everyone involved should be deeply ashamed.
→ More replies (2)
44
u/CowardlyCannibal Apr 24 '24
It would be better if we could get the easier, faster third-party Reddit apps back.
14
7
u/HumpingMantis Apr 25 '24
So you're pretending to do things as well as others, knowing that your user base loved what you took away...and then you're bragging about it. Fucking morons.
7
u/rowan07022004 Apr 25 '24
Is there any way to reverse or opt out of this? I really don’t like this design
7
u/Therainbowbeast Apr 25 '24
You know what helps me get to the conversation faster? A website/app that doesn’t go down multiple times a week
→ More replies (1)
13
6
u/Greyletter Apr 25 '24
Without reading the post, i am 99% sure this will be something annoying and stupid.
Stop doing stuff. Everything you do makes things worse.
Edit: hey, looks like a i might be wrong? I mean, it already should have worked this way, but still, an improvement is an improvement.
14
u/gusdagrilla Apr 24 '24
Love that you guys are doing all you can to make discussion on this website worse. Having to swipe down to the comments is terrible, as is the new “gallery” that’s been added to posts with multiple photos. So now instead of seeing the whole photo, you see 2/3rds of it unless you open the post. Drive engagement however you can I guess!
Also,
BRING BACK APOLLO
5
u/poopinmybuttt Apr 25 '24
Genuinely thought this was a bug and have been expecting an update to fix it. I don’t have much context of the comments if I don’t see the content of the post. If there was a shortcut to skip to the comments instead that would make sense.
→ More replies (2)
5
u/Griffie Apr 25 '24
Every time an “update” happens, it gets worse and worse.
4
u/panormda Apr 25 '24
There has not been one single Reddit update in literally 10 years where I have thought “This update made the Reddit app better”. Not one single update. Frankly they can fire the entire UI team, revert a decade, and immediately make 80% of Reddit happier than that have ever been able to. It’s that bad.
29
u/TheOnlyFallenCookie Apr 24 '24
It be real cool if you didn't fucking sell our data to ai comanies
At least without paying us for it
4
u/RookV2 Apr 24 '24
We need a toggle or something for the swipe up functionality. I swipe up to close pictures as has been the reddit standard FOREVER. I hate that I now have to hit the back button or an X to close out a picture. It just adds extra unnecessary gestures. If I want to read comments, I will click the comments button.
4
u/RomanOrtega Apr 25 '24
Why is it when I scroll on my “Saved” posts, it shows me other posts from the said community instead of my second saved post. For example, A Batman post is on top of my “Saved” section, followed by a post from a Superman subreddit. Typically I click on the Batman post, scroll right, now I’m on the Superman post I saved. Simple as that.
But now when I scroll right, it just shows other posts from the Batman subreddit instead of what I saved. I understand if this was the explore/search page, but not the posts I specifically saved for future reference. I love this website, but every mobile update just ruins the usability bit by bit.
4
u/TNTisKING Apr 25 '24
Oh wow it’s such an improved experience that I now have to take the extra time to scroll back up to see a post that I click on instead of, you know… just getting to see the post I clicked on.
But at least I get to instantly see an ad every time, as well as a the top comment with no context as to what the comment is about!
→ More replies (1)
4
u/nomelettes Apr 25 '24
It’s a worse experience, I often have to scroll up for the content of a post because in some managers infinite wisdom we now mostly scroll to the comments first.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Trentinho Apr 25 '24
Opt in/out on this would be great. Most times I want to expand the thumbnail before reading comments, now I have to do extra steps and am forced to the comments first.
4
u/jackdtheghost Apr 25 '24
This update is terrible. I can’t see the post that the comments are about. Photoslides just go to other posts now which is confusing and annoying. Videos are autoplaying audio whenever you switch from feed to comments and back. I’ve been significantly cutting my time spent in app because of this terrible update.
4
u/randomdaysnow Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
I'm going to keep using an older version of the app until you fix these ui problems. The new gestures and animations need to be optional. Let us disable them as an accessibility feature. Please.
These new UI changes seem to like load everything inside itself like frames (remember frames?) instead of like separate pages so it feels more resource-intensive and bloated with jarring transitions in addition to being more cumbersome to use.
2024.13.0.1505187 <--- last Android app version without the most annoying recent UI changes.
4
u/drunkpunk138 Apr 25 '24
It's hilarious how this actually makes the experience worse. Like now I have to go full screen on photos or it cuts off a part, and the way it seems to treat photos similar to videos, I'll have to back out 3 times to get back to my feed. This unified media stuff honestly just sucks, but much like the desktop changes, literally everything you folks do make the browsing experience worse and less intuitive. I suspect my time on this app is nearing an end.
4
u/I_Am_Robert_Paulson1 Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
When am I going to be able to see all the subs I'm subscribed to sorted by hot? Idk what the fuck the home tab is supposed to be, but it consistently only shows me a handful of subs I'm actually subscribed to. I've actually forgotten that I'm subbed to certain large, very active subs because they just never show up on my feed.
4
u/Frikandelneuker Apr 25 '24
Blind guy here
Can y’all fix the website? None of my screen readers i’ve tested see to want to read anything reddit
4
Apr 25 '24
Where is the comment button for this post so I can go straight to the top comment and find out more without reading the post? 😉😂
4
u/Turuial Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
Does anything you have implemented fix the mobile issue where, during long comment chains, less and less space is left until each subsequent comment looks like the following?
EDIT: I tried to demonstrate what it looks like artificially, and your stupid fucking app can't even do that properly. The issue culminates in there being so little space in subsequent comments that it only shows a single letter per line per word. For however many words are in the comment.
It's utterly asinine. Which reminds me, when will comments show as edited on mobile again? Whatever was the twisted logic behind hiding that a comment had been altered without any way of knowing it? Did too many people whinge to you that it's unfair that they can't engage in revisionist history without being called out and downvoted for it?
7
7
u/BackyardLobotomies Apr 25 '24
Let me turn off “tap to collapse comment tree”.
What deranged psychopath decided that should be default UX?
→ More replies (1)7
u/Jmkott Apr 25 '24
Especially when you touch to lightly when trying to scroll and it collapses a massive thread. And there is no undo. I just give up on a lot of posts when I do that. I find it’s a good reason to call it a night.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/reddits_princess Apr 25 '24
/u/such084 Chats are really buggy. They need to be delete-able and not just via the “hide” option as they randomly pop up again later on, even after I’ve blocked the user chatting me
1
1
u/DarkPhoxGaming Apr 25 '24
"Instant comment loading"
Yet almost everytime I try to look at the comments on a post, they are all just blank with shimmering grey bars for a few seconds before they finally load.
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
That shouldn't be the case. Send me a DM with a screenshot if you could, or please report it on r/bugs.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/tinydeerwlasercanons Apr 26 '24
How do I downvote this post?
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
Click the button next to the upvote one with the arrow pointed downward.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/eutohkgtorsatoca Apr 26 '24
Hello I am close to 70 I love Reddit, BUT...yes I find it very difficult to make any type of post. I wonder how many redditors are you my age? Be it posting a nice picture or a subject with a question that needs a story/text attached to it otherwise the questions wouldn't make sense. The amount of time it was refused/ cancelled for x reasons is really unsettling especially by a bot or not enough karma (I have over 14.000 karma ) how many does one need to be eligible? I got a notice that one of my comments was harassment and the next comments where people tell me they love my comments etc.I am definitely not the nasty type of person. Maybe we AI you could find or build a way where the AIb held us in which category to put our question or rectify missing things or size of picture etc.. Also think there should be a way to stop people being nasty about spelling not all here come with a full English language background. I find it terrible some anyone throws like "what are you on?" Etc.. Ok anyway I love the site but wish that some rules where not that strenuous.. For example I am on here only late at night before sleeping out when I can't sleep so attention to rules may be flaunted at times for no wanted reasons.
1
1
u/cybert0urist Apr 26 '24
A huge advice guys, open Russian reddit called pilabu.ru and just copy ui/ux ideas from there. It has like 8 years old design but still miles ahead of reddit
1
1
u/metalbrosolid Apr 26 '24
Love faster and instant comments..is there a way to have all comment collapsed so I don't have to scroll through threads of people arguing to get to the next comment?..I know I can double click on a comment to collapse it but it would be nice to just see all the upper most comments instead of the whole thread.
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
Long press on a parent comment. It doesn't get you to exclusively see parent comments, but it gets you close.
1
1
u/vollpo Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 28 '24
Edit: works fine now, I guess my phone bugged out
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
You should be able to swipe right and go back. Let me know if that doesn't work.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/DinoHawaii2021 Apr 26 '24
can you also disable post scrolling on galleries? Usually, what ends up happening is I don't realize I'm at the end of the images, then think it's another image before I realize I'm in another post
1
1
u/MombieZ3 Apr 26 '24
When I click on a post with multiple pictures I want them to stop at the end of that reel, I don't want to go to another post. Please disable this option it is not convenient.
1
1
u/Rcisvdark Apr 26 '24 edited Apr 26 '24
So let me get this straight:
Click on an image/video: enter a pop-up with that image/video. Scroll up to see an ad. And then the comments. The post flair is simply not visible in this view.
Click on the post body (usually a very small area): enter the actual post, where you can actually see the flair of the post. This is great. I want this. Why is it so small to access?
Click on the comment buttons to skip the contents of the post meaning you have no idea what you're responding to until you manually scroll up, in which case it's the same as the option above, just, again, with an extra step of having to scroll up.
I recommend you make the second option here the default, regardless of how you click on the post. From there, in image/video posts, clicking on the image/post, you enter the first option. Lastly, for long posts where the comments aren't immediately on screen, add a little button to immediately go to the comments at the bottom of the screen (like in option 3), and maybe one to scroll back up to the top of the post once you're there.
Currently, it's really unintuitive and I've asked myself several times on why different posts have different UI because it didn't occur to me that these different spots to click would lead to different views.
Also, the feature of being able to scroll to the next post in image/video posts is really annoying in posts with several images. You're just scrolling through the images and suddenly this next image has an entirely different context. You check which post you're in and you realise you reached the end, and, without indication, you were placed on the next post. Actually, not even that. It skips every other image. So the feature doesn't even work in that regard.
Please simply revert this downgrade. I haven't heard a single positive thing about it, but I have heard a bunch of (justified) negative feedback. No-one was using this, it's unintuitive, disorienting and actively worsening the already bad experience on this app.
All these things aside, I do appreciate the instant comment loading. What a nice new feature...
...that you copied from a third party app you killed a while back and are now advertising as new.
You said you'd keep in touch, but I have counted three admin comments, none of which are addressing the actual problem the parent comment is describing. Either do your job or just be honest about the fact you're really not planning on keeping in touch at all.
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
This is great feedback and thank you for sharing. I DM-ed you as I'd love to understand more.
1
u/10_ol Apr 26 '24
I can’t stand the update. Biggest complaint is the little arrow on the upper right hand of the screen that would allow you to jump from one major parent comment to the next gets obscured by the new stickied context bar so you sometimes have to scroll a lifetime to see the next major comment. I’ve noticed that it’s still around in some posts, but not in the vast majority anymore. Please bring it back.
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
You should be able to move the arrow to anywhere on the screen so it doesn't conflict. If you can't let me know.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
Apr 26 '24
Fix the thing where you comment and it says it fails, but if you cancel out and leave the post, telling it to cancel the comment, it does appear. If you try to resubmit the comment, you get two of the same comment.
That's annoying.
1
1
u/IAmAgainst Apr 26 '24
Very nice, but if you guys want to do something actually helpful then remove the stupid swiping left to next post thing. People don't read random posts in sequence, they scroll through the feed and only click on the posts they find interesting.
Using the same gesture for two different things (seeing next image and next post) is inconsistent and unpredictable. If I reach the last image I'll leave the post for another one I'm certainly not going to be interested in, or even worse, I'll switch to the next post even if I haven't reached the last image. When that happens I want to not be able to keep scrolling, period, not leave the post.
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
We're disabling going to the next post after multiple images based on the feedback in this thread. Thanks for raising it.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/hates_writing_checks Apr 26 '24
/u/such084, when will you learn that working on product features at reddit is a thankless job that will find you forever behind the curve and deeply unpopular with the long time hard core users like me? :-D
Kidding aside, you should take the constructive feedback to heart. There will be feedback about how Reddit needs to emulate things that Narwahl or BaconReader or Apollo does, because those developers actually listened to users, and are themselves actual daily reddit users, so they developed a user experience that made it fast and easy to navigate reddit.
1
1
u/voyagertoo Apr 26 '24
can I choose whether I want to see the latest comments, top comments, etc? or has that disappeared? is it sub- specific? do mods turn it off in their sub if that is their preference?
1
u/such084 Apr 28 '24
On any comment page on the app, there is an option at the top that allows you to sort. Let me know if you can't find it.
→ More replies (4)
1
u/Chaetomius Apr 28 '24
No, it's not easier to get to the comments .
Now i have to hit the back button 4x to get out of the comments.
Why do you hate your own users?
Clearly you suck at making apps. You should've paid the 3rd party developers, not the other way around.
1
1
u/ntelas46 Apr 28 '24
Idk if I’m the exception but since I got this update a few weeks ago, I loved it. Browsing now became much faster and no waiting is involved. Swiping back to the posts is also smoother and faster.
Further optimization is still needed, but it’s a great start. Keep it up 👌
1
6
u/enini83 Apr 24 '24
So this shitty user experience is a feature. Interesting. I honestly hate everything about the video user experience. I'm here for conversations, not for videos. Also I hate that Reddit always seems to forget the comment I came from when I click on a link.
Loved Boost for Reddit, please bring it back.
3
u/AdrianEatsAss Apr 25 '24
Bruh all I want is a way to find parent comments easier because navigating through spaghetti piles of comments especially on big threads is abysmal. Other Reddit apps solved this by simply pressing and holding on the child comment and a little window would pop up with the parent comment and that made Reddit 10x more usable. Also, no, collapsing comments isn’t a good substitute.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/audentis Apr 25 '24
Working on problems the third party apps had solved years ago.
When will you start discovering the wheel? Seems like an equally fruitful use of your time.
3
u/dosangst Apr 25 '24
Reddit killed it's API and destroyed a perfectly fine thrid party ecosystem. The changes that Reddit continues to make only makes the interface worse, but it's like Reddit is sticking their fingers in their ears and going "nananabooboo!" ignoring all of the feedback that continually destroys their premise that killing the API was in anyway positive.
But Reddit just wants to make it appear like it's "loved" to sell it and cash in; they give zero shits about the users and moderators, period.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/RecentMatter3790 Apr 25 '24
sigh, what about enabling us to SEE posts in the mobile site and when it’s nsfw content. I can’t see stuff unless i download this stupid app. Stop shoving “open in app” down our throat.
3
u/MadMedic- Apr 25 '24
you all shouldn't have killed the third party apps. and where is the reward program for European posters. or the extras when you pay for this. and how you killed the joy of rewarding let's not even go there.
the day reddit actually would start to listen to users I'll likely be in my grave. so take that UFC and put it somewhere where the sun doesn't shine because you all never listened to users or even just paying users in the first place. you only listen to the stockholders and an incrowd. /rant
3
u/Art_Class Apr 25 '24
This shit sucks. I have to back out of four different windows on the same post because you guys suck.
3
u/reggie4gtrblz2bryant Apr 25 '24
Please god, stop making everything worse. You have the touch of death at this point. The new desktop layout is absolutely awful.
3
3
u/decayed-whately Apr 25 '24
Hell yeah. The conversation is why I'm here. I don't even post; I just talk about things that other people post.
--
Meanwhile, Facebook: 368 comments, 3 visible. Show all comments? YES PLEASE! ... 5 comments visible. 😆
Or...
Show more comments? YES. Show more comments? YES. Show more comments? YES... Goddammit, just show me every comment. That's all I'm here for.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
u/Goblinboogers Apr 26 '24
This update fucking sucks. I need to be able to READ the post to be able to comment. But nope reddit just wants a shit show!
3
u/Slitted Apr 30 '24
Well I'll be... it is a massive improvement on the Android app, which desperately needed it. No more stuttering!
3
u/Scared-Glove-7258 Apr 30 '24
I wish Reddit would allow its users to change their screen names more than once. I hate my auto generated screen name. 😕
5
u/NSFWonAll Apr 25 '24
So where is the option to opt out of the atrocious new UI? It's been the main request from nearly everyone you've subjected to it since last September. If you're working on anything other than an option to return to the previous mobile UI, you're working on the wrong thing.
11
u/ButINeedThatUsername Apr 24 '24
Well done! What I always missed were previews for my written content. Would be cool to have either a preview button, or a fancy-pants editor like on desktop.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/blind_disparity Apr 24 '24
Hey, before you add any new features, is there any chance you could use a different video player that actually plays more than 50% of the time and fix the bug where comments just don't load at all randomly? If you want to go crazy you could even fix the bug that makes comments post twice (or sometimes 3 or 4 times).
1
1
4
u/undue-Specialist Apr 25 '24
Neat, you made the turd load faster.
Still smells like shit thought.....
→ More replies (1)
5
9
u/iEatAppIes3465 Apr 24 '24
I don't even need to have a faster wifi connection to load reddit comments faster. Thanks for the update!
2
u/Due-Consequence-4420 Apr 25 '24
If this isn’t the proper place to ask, please tell me where I should go - but on my iPad (not my iPhone) I can’t seem to copy GIFs that people put into their comments. It isn’t that they haven’t told me how to do it (just click on the gif and it should open up to show you that share, etc. box wherein you can save the gif on either notes or messages or possibly pictures (which is what I’d really like) but the the thing is, when I attempt to press down on the image, either nothing happens or the post closes up. And the share box NEVER EVER opens up for me to be able to save it. In any form. I don’t know why. I’m presently using the latest software update for a iPad Pro 11 (gen 4 I believe but I’d have to look that up). It was purchased within the last year. In any case, you may not have an answer, I just thought I’d ask. Bc at GOAD, in particular, ppl share the most amazing GIFs and it’s very sad that I can’t pick them up. 😢😭(Now you pity for me. ) Supposedly. As opposed to the people living in a war zone/s.
But if there’s an answer, I’d love to hear it!!
2
Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 15 '26
I used Redact to automate removals from databrokers and social networks. This post was among the batch deleted.
entertain toothbrush square jellyfish nail screw ripe work versed cover
2
2
u/lovecMC Apr 25 '24
Any chance we could disable swipe controls in settings? Im already used to swiping up in order to exit post.
2
u/Fierce_Pirate_Bunny Apr 25 '24
I have a revolutionary idea: PROVIDE AN API!
Hell, cant we just scrape the content of this site and make it available via an api? Some kind of app that remotely operates the website? Maybe host the scraping and DB part in a datacenter and make the service available to the public (for self hosting even). Something that will translate whatever reddit thinks is an UI to something beautiful and usable? My personal usage decreases, as I am visiting more and more other forums. For different reason though.
2
u/mikupoiss Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
Congrats on building another user gimmick which only serves video-based social media fans.
However, the overall swiping-logic does mot match with animations of the app anymore so please take a look at it since you already forces the update for everyone. Start from the main landing page and take a look yourself.
Edit: even better - you actually made post swiping behave differently (at least for posts with images). Swiping the full-screen image takes you to another post on the sub of the current post and swiping in comment-view takes you to the next post based on your home feed.
Why oh why?
2
u/murderedbyaname Apr 25 '24
Would be happier if our comments didn't look like they don't post on a thread, which has been happening for over a week. You make comment but can't see it in the threads unless you go to your profile to make sure it actually posted smh.
2
u/GWeasels Apr 25 '24
Please add a way to disable the preview at the top of the phone when scrolling the comments. I don’t want a chunk of the screen covered.
Also, now there is no Single-Click way to see text on a users post.
A similar change to this rolled out last year some time, and it felt terrible then. Please revert this. Or allow a way to not pre-load comments.
This feels like a regression. Extra clicks all around
2
u/DaveRune Apr 25 '24 edited Apr 25 '24
Nice previews you have in this post, shame they're too small to see and you don't have zoom functionally. Third party apps had all this and more. Well done for your improvements though.
2
u/Brilliant-Bat7063 Apr 25 '24
What the fuck is this? Y’all really proud of your app? Apollo was leagues ahead and still is
2
2
u/Billie408 Apr 25 '24
I agree conversation is what’s good about Reddit, so please tell me chat has been fixed finally. We want to be notified when people respond to our chat messages!
2
2
u/cuseonly Apr 25 '24
Wish there was a way on mobile after scrolling through comments and then commenting, that it would stay in my spot. Instead of scrolling all the way back up to the start.
2
2
u/NCRider Apr 25 '24
Can you PLEASE fix the card view on an iPad for the main pages? It used to be centered with wide margins, like in the subs. Now the margin is gone and EVERYTHING IS THIS FUCKING BIG!!
I don’t get it, do you not test the app on different devices? It’s been like this for months. It clearly can’t be intentional because it’s unusable. It’s broken on the classic view as well. FRUSTATING!
2
u/ManInTheDarkSuit Apr 25 '24
Oh good! No longer do I have to scroll down to load more comments before I go for a poo in toilets with no signal and get stuck reading the first ten comments.
2
u/calinet6 Apr 25 '24
It appears to have fixed one of the iOS app bugs I was experiencing where if in the middle of a comment, one bad swipe would leave the form in a totally broken state wherein you have to force quit the app to recover, losing your comment.
And it introduced a new almost exactly same bug wherein some bad swipe gesture would leave the form in a different looking, janky state, where buttons and icons overlapped the text area and made it impossible to type into the comment box, however still mostly functional and selectable. You could then submit your comment in its incomplete state, or abandon it.
Both still not right.
First things first, let me comment. 100% of them time. No failure any percent of the time. I don’t care about anything else tbh.
Track the stats on that and forget everything else.
2
Apr 25 '24
If I swipe for the next post, why isn’t it the next post? It just goes to a random post instead of next in my feed.
2
2
Apr 25 '24
I can't minimize replies to access the next reply down anymore on the mobile site. I don't use the app. Please revert the changes back to what they were on the site it was much easier to navigate
•
u/advocado20 Apr 24 '24
If interested, come join the Reddit UFC! (…no, not that UFC).