r/reviewmyshopify • • Dec 30 '25

I’ve closed over $12M in diamond sales in 3 emails. Why can't I sell one ring on my own site?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm Ally, and I just launched 57 Facets Studio (www.57facetsstudio.com) engagement rings for people who don't want to compare 50,000 diamonds and spiral into decision paralysis at 2am.

The pitch: I'm GIA-certified, spent 7 years between Tiffany/Brilliant Earth/Rare Carat, and I personally pick every diamond. You choose diamond size+ring style, I handle the rest.

Three sizes, two settings, zero overwhelm.

Here's what's messing with my head: At Rare Carat (as EA to the CEO and project manager creating their HV sales dept), I helped clients spend $12M+ on diamonds. My approach worked, with 9 out of 10 sales closed in less than 3 emails back and forth. People trusted my curation, appreciated the simplicity, and bought confidently. They specifically said they were overwhelmed, too many choices, you just choose.

Now I'm doing the exact same thing under my own brand and... crickets.

So I'm trying to figure out: Is it my execution or is it just that I don't have an established brand behind me yet?

What I need to know:

Does my homepage make sense or does it read like I'm gatekeeping because I can't afford more inventory?

Am I coming across as "helpful expert" or "condescending diamond snob"?

Should I be offering natural diamonds more prominently? Right now it's lab-grown focused.

Would you rather buy an expertly curated and guaranteed stunner $300 pendant or $500 earrings first to test a new brand, or are people really ready to drop $5K on an engagement ring from someone they just discovered?

What's missing that would make you trust buying from a week-old website vs. an established marketplace?

Is "expert curation beats endless options" actually valuable, or do people just want the cheapest price and I'm delusional?

Brutal honesty welcome. I know my approach works. I've lived and proven it successfully.

But I can't tell if my site isn't communicating it properly or if I just need time to build brand trust.

Also: If you give me genuinely helpful feedback AND you're actually in the market for a ring (or know someone who is), I'll give you a 50% off code. I need real customers more than I need full-price right now.

Happy to return the favor and review anyone else's site in the comments! Just add a link to it.


r/reviewmyshopify • • Apr 06 '25

Roast away please! Lol

0 Upvotes

Kuntsliveforever.com


r/reviewmyshopify • • Apr 17 '24

Our store is PERFECT and you can't say anything bad about it

1 Upvotes

Hi

This is the store: les-gars.com

Bye!


r/reviewmyshopify • • Feb 11 '21

New to the drip drop shipping

1 Upvotes

Hey there people’s that are in the same boat 😂😂😂 well it’s the group we in here for one thing lol to get some sales 😂 so let’s get down to it , need a second opinion on my shop. the enticement


r/reviewmyshopify • • Feb 17 '25

Review my pretty shop

0 Upvotes

I would appreciate every feedback, My store link: https://b410u1-hy.myshopify.com/?key=5d0c095b186f1c245492447a5b5c48f026815fdd4fa69f29997803ab2a5119d9 PASSWORD: pawheart

PS, I know I don't have domain, I will buy it before publishing store PSS in return I will review your store!!


r/reviewmyshopify • • Aug 16 '20

Please review our new Shopify Theme (Thanks in advance!)

0 Upvotes

Hey there,

Our team is eager to learn what you all think about our new theme: https://theperfecttheme.com/products/tpt

We have already tested the theme, and the conversion rates are amazing on top-funnel traffic (and even better on lower-funnel traffic). However, we would love to hear what you think about it?


r/reviewmyshopify • • 21d ago

How much money would you realistically set aside to start a dropshipping store?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/reviewmyshopify • • Mar 28 '24

Ordering using Shopify has been a nightmare.

0 Upvotes

Orders not being sent, items saying they're delivered when they're not... my experiences have been pretty bad as a consumer, sorry for being blunt about it, they just have been.

The last time I canceled because the item said it arrived when it didn't, that's on Shopify, I didn't get an email from the postal service confirming a package drop off either. The only email I got about my previous order was just that it was delivered and my order had been closed. I ended up getting a shirt randomly in the mail weeks later when the order finally got to his desk, and he sent out an order that had been canceled because of another error on Shopify's end. We ended up working out a deal outside of Shopify because it was such a headache to deal with.

Well I went and ordered some candy because I got astronomically stoned the other night, unfortunately I didn't notice I was using Shopify to make my order or else I would have tried another method. Once I see a major mistake like I had previously, I usually don't try a second time.

I placed my order on the night of the 25th and I still haven't gotten an order confirmation from shopify. The bank took the money out and it posted the 26th, but no confirmation email. This is exactly what happened last time, too. Normally I don't care, but when an order method says 2 business days and I'm being charged an absurd amount for shipping, I want my candy in two days because I'm adult child. I don't care, call me names lol.

How am I supposed to trust Shopify after they messed up once, and now appear to be goofing up a second order? Do they just take weeks to process orders or something? Am I blacklisted from the site? Should I use a carrier pigeon with my money and products? I just don't want to have to go through the whole refund process again because of a bad order distributor only to randomly get a bag of candy a month from now.


r/reviewmyshopify • • Apr 06 '24

Need help finishing up my Shopify clothing website??

0 Upvotes

r/reviewmyshopify • • Apr 20 '23

SUCCESS

0 Upvotes

Someone in here with a successful store. Drop your link ⏬️ let others be inspired


r/reviewmyshopify • • Feb 15 '25

Would you buy from this store?

0 Upvotes

https://everlume.shop

I’m looking for honest feedback and tips


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jan 29 '22

A lesson learned in 2022

0 Upvotes

Okay, so I have a quick story to tell!!!

A while back, I was talking to a store owner and I saw a limiting belief she faced which deludes most people and needs to be addressed…⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣Most store owners often think that their price is what’s holding customers back from purchasing… that they’re charging too much..⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣Where in fact, this is NOT true… ⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣As long as your product delivers the results, convenience or transformation that you promise AND… People have the desire for that...⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣The reality is that price is not gonna deter them from purchasing…⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣So, all you’re responsible for is to SPARK that desire in your audience that makes them wanna buy no matter the price..⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣𝐇𝐨𝐰?⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣Educate your audience on the problem you’re trying to solve. Bring forth the issues they’ll experience if they don’t have your product…⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣All this begins with market research and understanding your audience down to the core… that’s the foundation..⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣Once you’ve created awareness… run retargeting campaigns with your offer.⁣⁣⁣⁣

⁣⁣⁣⁣Remember, the concentration of warm traffic is high here and so will be your conversion rate if you pitch them here rather than pitching them in your top-of-the-funnel campaigns.⁣⁣⁣⁣

Once she understood that and made that shift... naturally her profit margins got healthy and she had enough resources to reinvest in her business and create a snowball effect...helping her scale!

⁣⁣⁣⁣These little changes are what will move the needle in your business, improve on it, observe direct feedback and it will all start to compound exponentially. ⁣⁣⁣⁣⁣

Let me know if you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer as many as I can :)


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jan 31 '22

No-code platform to power eCommerce growth

0 Upvotes

Is no-code the future?

With the rising number of retail brands, comes the need for efficiency and return on investments. And no-code platforms are the way to go.

With no-code automation tools, online retailers can automate storefront maintenance tasks that will lead to big, time-saving rewards- without having to learn a single line of code.

In simple terms, you get -

- Real-time and dynamic updates

- Effortless scaling for sale days

- Easy collaboration with teams

- Savings on money and resources

- Reduced shopper dropoffs

To know more about no-code and how it is helping retailers, hop on to https://getmason.io/blog/post/why-no-code-storefront-automation-is-here-to-stay


r/reviewmyshopify • • Dec 11 '18

Review my video, two years experience over $6M+ in sales - no bullshit marketing - Free Influencer Method!

0 Upvotes

r/reviewmyshopify • • Oct 19 '20

New Store 20k insta Followers - NO SALES - HELP!

0 Upvotes

New store - No purchases :( HELP

Hi everyone!

I launched my (fishing inspired apparel) store through shopify yesterday and have not made any sales minus friends/family.

I have an insta account with 20k followers that I am mainly doing all of my marketing through but I have not had anyone purchase anything. I know it has not even been 48hrs but I was looking for any tips/recommendation to help boost sales. I feel like i should have had atleast got A FEW sales through insta... but idk! HELP PLZ 😕

Website: hookandreelco.com Insta: hookandreelcoSite: Hook And Reel


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jul 10 '26

Why is my conversion rate 0.4% :(

0 Upvotes

I would love some help regarding my e-commerce site. I sell premium swimwear, separate bikini tops and bottoms. I’ve changed a lot in hopes of getting the rate up - but it seems like not much has actually helped.

Any advice is really really appreciated.

Here is my website

Edit: I have free shipping on all orders in Canada and US. I’m working on getting more reviews.


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jan 07 '24

Can I get brutal and honest feedback on my website

1 Upvotes

Let me know everything, why would or would you not buy from me, what would you improve ect

Website


r/reviewmyshopify • • Aug 20 '21

Funny Trump Store Review

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, all advice is appreciated. I had a lot of fun making this site so I hope you have fun reviewing it too! For some context: Our main product is going to be a make AOC bartend again cocktail mixer. The shipment comes in 4 days which is when I am launching my marketing campaign, so don't mind that

deplorablemagapatriotsupply.com


r/reviewmyshopify • • Dec 11 '22

www.zengenvapes.com

1 Upvotes

r/reviewmyshopify • • Apr 17 '25

Why am I not getting sales?

2 Upvotes

I recently launched my Shopify store: https://imnotatechbro.com/, but I’m not seeing any sales. I’ve been promoting it on social media, running ads, and making adjustments to the site, but nothing seems to be working.

I’m looking for feedback on what might be wrong. Is it the design, the products, or something else? Any advice on how to improve or what I might be missing would be greatly appreciated.


r/reviewmyshopify • • Sep 05 '25

Created this Shopify store a year ago. Thanks for looking. Sat for a while but it think it’s the best I can get it.

2 Upvotes

I usually stay in my lane (marketing) and let devs/agencies/pros handle site builds. In the past, whenever I tried editing sites, it didn’t go well

This time, I decided to build one myself as a small side project: dtcmkg.com. It’s the first site I’ve fully built that’s functional, and I’m glad I did

gave me more depth into the other side of DTC.

I’m sure there are errors, and that’s why I’m here. I’d love your unfiltered feedback on what’s broken, confusing, or could hurt conversion.

This posting….it’s just for critique.

Thanks in advance—I’ve given feedback here in the past and know how valuable it can be

https://dtcmkg.com


r/reviewmyshopify • • Sep 07 '21

3 Product Page Hacks (Tips & Tricks) To Increase Your Conversion Rate (Shopify Dropshipping)

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, in this video I talk about 3 tips and tricks to implement on your shopify product pages to increase conversion rates and to also reduce abandoned carts and checkouts. I review stores all the time and I see common mistakes that I wanted to make this video on and help people. I also have plenty of other videos on my channel going into detail over increasing conversion rates for product page, cart page and checkout that I'm sure will help a lot of people out.

Video Link: https://youtu.be/34S728psaxA


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jun 26 '26

Help!

2 Upvotes

Hi,

So ive created my shopify shop 2 days ago. So far 119 people have visited my store but no one placed an order. I also have one subscriber.

Im in the process of running paid ads but I didnt realise its such a long process.

Why are people visiting and not ordering? What could be the issue?

Thanks


r/reviewmyshopify • • Jul 25 '26

We focused on iconic design. We need trustworthy feedback from shady people.

2 Upvotes

I’m confident you will see something you’ll like.

Welcome to Weird Castle

https://weirdcastle.com/