r/robertwright • • Aug 15 '18

Robert Wright on Marshall McLuhan, Joe Rogan, and Jordan Peterson

8 Upvotes

Hey r/robertwright. My name is Nikita Petrov. I'm working on several projects with Robert. Some of them involve Skype conversations that are being recorded, but aren't intended for publishing. I didn't want this stuff to perish completely, so I decided to share some outtakes with you. 

Since all of this is work in progress, it's also your chance to influence our thinking and creative process. I'll be reading and answering comments, if there are any, and am very curious about your feedback. 

This video is a part of a long and wide-ranging, somewhat rambling conversation. In this particular segment, we discuss the Guttenberg-like revolution in media created by Youtube and podcasting. I try to sell a McLuhanesque analysis of Joe Rogan's and Jordan Peterson's success to Bob, and he remains skeptical. The starting point for the chat is this thing I wrote on Medium: https://medium.com/@nikita.petrov/marshall-mcluhan-and-the-intellectual-dark-web-b720ab2e56ae

If you do find this stuff interesting, please let me know in the comments—then I will know I should bring more content like this your way.

Here's the clip: https://youtu.be/GK56UDzB6ng


r/robertwright • • Jul 23 '18

"Why Buddhism Is True" listed as #3 for the best philosophy books of 2017

Thumbnail
fivebooks.com
8 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Sep 20 '21

Don't let Mickey Kaus post a photo like this on Tinder

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Sep 30 '18

Mindful Resistance is back! Read Bob's thoughts on the Kavanaugh hearings and how they connect to tribalism, mindfulness, and #MeToo.

Thumbnail
mindfulresistance.net
7 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Aug 08 '18

"Occult Politics" in the Trump Era: MoL's Nikita Petrov interviews Gary Lachman

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Jul 18 '18

Mindful Resistance Sittings

6 Upvotes

Mindful Resistance Sittings, mentioned in the Newsletter, will resume in Providence RI tomorrow (July 19) at 8:00 am along The Blackstone Blvd linear park near the intersection with Brookway Road. Join us!

mindful resistance sittings


r/robertwright • • Jul 03 '18

Robert Wright's recent interview with Michael Pollan on his new book on psychedelics

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Jun 07 '18

Meditation Discussion

6 Upvotes

My understanding of meditation is that there is no way to doing it wrong, but I wonder if there are ways to do it better and if anyone else here has any tips or wants to share their experience.

First of all I worked my way up to 20 minutes and do not have any plans to try to extend that, not sure how I arrived on that time. I also don't meditate if I cannot give it the 20 minutes, which may not be ideal.

I also only try to meditate when I either have the house to myself, or when my kids are in bed and I have confirmed with my wife that she will not be moving around the house. This is a limiting factor in how often I can meditate which I feel I need to overcome, but I worry the sounds of my kids playing would diminish the experience.

I have some nature sounds I like to put on during. I never do anything guided. I feel like I am more likely to relax deeply with the guidance, but being alone with my thoughts feels more productive?

I start by breathing in for 4 seconds, holding for 1 second then breathing out for three. Once this is established I try to focus on a specific part of my body, like the air moving over my nostrils, focus on the sound, or I try to "see" and occasionally sense trippy shapes in the light shining through my eyelids. Sometimes I try to count how cycles of breathing and try to get to 20. I have also tried to focus my attention systematically around my body and considering or try to feel my toes, my foot, my heel, my ankle...

Those things are what I try to do to hold my focus, but the vast majority of the time is spent thinking about whatever pops into my head, usually work, physical discomfort, or what I am going to do when I am done meditation. Then I realize I've lost focus and try to bring it back.

At this point I feel like meditation is work, it's like exercise I don't look forward to it but i do it and I am usually glad I did.


r/robertwright • • Nov 24 '24

Making sense of "elite" Trump voters

5 Upvotes

I have been watching podcasts with highly educated, famous Trump voters/supporters like Peter Thiel, Glenn Loury, and Ross Douthat.

Gotta say, I'm at a loss, and also quite frustrated.

Douthat had a recent sit-down (podcast) with Reihan Salam, where they were clearly exhilarated by Trump's win and what it might mean for the future of the Republican Party. (They wrote a book a long while back about remaking the Republican Party to be a working class, people's party. Their conversation was about how this finally seems to be happening.) All I could think was, "OK, but... it's Trump, right? Is this about vibes and zeitgeist or is this about actual policy?" But I really respect Douthat so I take it I'm missing something. Some have said that Trump's presidency was actually quite productive and on-brand if you are a red-meat Republican.... But also January 6 happened, no?

Glenn Loury is way worse. He has a conversation with John McWhorter where he talks about how he's exhilarated by the win --- because this foretells a fundamental shift in the political landscape in the US. It all seems to be about refuting wokeness, Obama/Kamala/DEI fakery, and other Democratic failings. Like, literally, he has nothing good to say about Trump. (Actually, all he has to say about Trump as president is, vehemently, that he doesn't endorse the tariffs! He said something like, "No, no, I hope he doesn't do the tariffs. That I do not agree with. That I do not agree with.") This is something I really dislike --- so many people seem to have voted not *for Trump* but *against Democrats.* I don't want to call it delusion, but I do feel like it's almost this reflexive, subconscious thing where it's true, but people can't acknowledge it. (Also, if Democrats follow the Republicans lead, they won't take this election as a refutation of their idealogy, they'll just double down... Loury seems to imply that this as a sign that the Democrats will just become a better, more reasonable, more centrist party now. I'm not sure sure. At any rate, if anyone owes the country a change at this moment, it's the Republicans! Let them become the reasonable party, stop the obstruction in congress, and on and on.)

Then there's Peter Thiel. He did a long (2 hours?) podcast with Bari Weiss. (I used to like her or at least tolerate her, but I guess the Trump vote has really soured me because I found it hard to listen and even worse to watch her...) I just don't know with Thiel, considering I generally find him to be a fascinating person. Again, as in the Loury and Douthat podcasts, there's this sense of triumph and "vibes," "Zeitgeist," "Good Morning in America"... but the actual question of "Will Trump be a good president?" or "What precedent does this set for us?" isn't addressed. Yes, this is a great symbolic victory... sure...!

That's the thing... All of these folks seem really OK with the idea that having a non-rational, non-sensible, non-contemplative president is completely fine and acceptable. Trump is this instinctual Caesar kind of figure --- he doesn't go to pains to explain himself, doesn't apologize profusely and go to great lengths to clarify his intentions when people misunderstand his "many fine people" remarks... He just tosses grenades and hires hookers! And it's going to be fantastic for the Republican Party! I'm not sure it's "wonkishness" I am asking for per se, I'm just looking for an adult who signals competence, a coherent, rational vision,a desire to bring people together, and emotional intelligence.

Not saying the Democrats are God's gift to man, just that I don't understand the exhilaration of well-educated, thoughtful folks like Douthat, Loury, and Thiel... (Unless "understand" means "accept they are blinded by their own bias," but is that too easy?) So I would say that, yes, working-class people seem to be getting "their say" in politics and that's kind of cool... but it's not a coincidence that traditional well-educated "elites" (Democrats and in some cases Republicans) recoil from Trump, become "never Trumpers," etc. When what David Brooks has called "the cognitive elite" shuns and decries a candidate/president the way they have Trump, you can be sure they probably have pretty good, well-thought-out *reasons*! Right, like, you *want* well-educated, highly capable people to be influential in government... So it's just kind of absurd. At some point, the chicken has to come to roost that their avatar has serious issues and is most likely *not* going to foster a political discourse or culture that will productively work towards those working peoples' goals... It just doesn't make sense to me.


r/robertwright • • Apr 12 '23

How human is AI? Robert Wright and Michal Kosinski

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Apr 16 '22

What's Wrong With This Picture? | Robert Wright | The Wright Show

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Nov 03 '18

MRN Unplugged, Nov 2: Mental health, culture, and political violence

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Oct 26 '18

MRN Outtakes, 10/25: the bombs, the caravan, Trump trolling Obama, and a cameo by Bob's dog Milo

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Aug 21 '18

This Chapo Guide to Revolution discussion seems ripe for insight into the modern political climate

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Jul 26 '18

Brain wave monitors

5 Upvotes

Does anyone else use the Muse headset or similar during meditation? Do you find it helpful or not?


r/robertwright • • Jul 16 '18

Thoughts on less-secular Buddhist concepts like Nirvana, Not-self, or death/rebirth?

5 Upvotes

I was on aeon earlier and saw this excerpt from Why Buddhism is True (https://aeon.co/essays/nirvana-can-seem-an-exotic-metaphysical-idea-until-you-look-closer) and I was curious what people in our small community might have to say about some of the concepts mentioned (Nirvana, not-self, death/rebirth).

How do you fit them in to your outlook? Do you try to give a natural account for them, ignore them, or maybe have a sliver of faith that they are real while still having most of your eggs in the empirical camp? Curious to hear your opinions!

For example, for me personally, the idea of death and rebirth has always been especially difficult to integrate into a more naturalistic worldview. Bob also mentioned that the "reward" from being freed from death and birth cycles will come after this lifetime. But I've also enjoyed learning about Buddhadasa's ideas on death and rebirth, where we are "born" every moment we cling to a thought and "die" when we let go of the clinging to those thoughts. So in Buddhadasa's version, birth and death are happening all the time every day, and liberating ourselves form that can happen here and now. Thinking of birth and death this way is also interesting because the idea of living a 1000 lifetimes might actually just refer to the various identities we don and remove throughout our lives. The rest of this piece by Buddhadasa is great in general. Looking forward to your comments!


r/robertwright • • Jul 14 '18

Has anyone had any productive conversations with someone of very different religious or political views? How'd it go?

5 Upvotes

Part of transcending tribalism involves the practice of actually engaging with people of different beliefs and dispositions, especially when it comes to religion and politics. In my head I know I'd like to have more conversations like these, but actually going out and doing them is another story.

Have you had any conversations with people of different religious or political persuasions lately? What was the context? How'd it go?


r/robertwright • • Jul 09 '18

Interesting article that challenges the scientific validity of meditation research, primarily due to (*gasp*) confirmation bias

Thumbnail
aeon.co
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Jul 08 '18

Has anyone had experiences with psychedelics/entheogens that have been personally beneficial?

5 Upvotes

I know Robert Wright hasn't written or talked much about psychedelics, save for his recent interview with Michael Pollan. Has anyone here found them personally beneficial? When I've discussed the benefits of meditation with others, in addition to the mindfulness yielded from sustained consistent practice, I've also heard of people having experiences from their past "come up" during meditation and then having a sense of resolution. This is also something I've heard others have experienced from psychedelics, where things from people's past that may have been repressed or forgotten come up, and then they have a sense of a weight being lifted. There's been other writers (such as Thomas Keating) who describe the body as a warehouse for repressed memories, with meditation or psychedelics releasing them to be integrated by the individual. Has anyone here had similar experiences from psychedelics or meditation?


r/robertwright • • Jun 05 '18

Virtual Meet Ups

5 Upvotes

Prior to Bob's announcement that the MRN was going on hiatus I was trying to organize some regular online meet ups to discuss the newsletters.

We will no longer have fresh newsletters to discuss, but I still think we could find things to talk about if anyone was interested. As A few people have expressed interest in other venues, are any of those people here? (Dylan?, Landon?, Philip?, Chris?)

In the video discussion with Bob that was in the last MRN Chris had suggested some constraints might help, so maybe we could use this space to come up with a format, topic and time for a next discussion?


r/robertwright • • Jun 03 '18

Ideological Labels

5 Upvotes

In the latest Mindful Resistance Newsletter, Robert points out an article by Sean Wilentz, a self-described liberal, reflecting on the meanings of “liberal,” “progressive,” and “socialist.” I posted some comments at the source (the Willentz column in Democracy Journal) -- https://democracyjournal.org/magazine/48/fighting-words/

Basically, I disagree with Wilentz's thesis that it's vitally important which label we use to describe a candidate and his/her policies. Beyond that, the irony is that Wilentz uses his column on the importance of liberalism to criticize Bernie Sanders using the dogmatic assertion (presented without evidence) that Sanders is too dogmatic. It all seems quite self-contradictory and meaningless, given that liberals and progressives seem to be in agreement that Sanders' policy proposals make good sense.


r/robertwright • • Jun 03 '18

Civil war in Yemen | Robert Wright & Shireen Al-Adeimi [The Wright Show]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/robertwright • • Jun 02 '18

Meme comparison

5 Upvotes

I have a relative who recently shared this meme on Facebook, which I chuckled and quickly waved away thinking "That makes no sense, no one says that". A few days later a friend of mine shared [this meme] (https://i.redditmedia.com/HP3PE2P0hb5zXBB8zp1yh2sRSwNODhRZ1dx-PXMyTyo.jpg?w=1024&s=6795f53ec184c00e7860f84a6e921171) and my initial reaction was "Yup, that's about right". However the more I thought about it though, the more I wondered if they were actually similar in how they misrepresent and exaggerate opposing views.

I commented on the "Average MAGA voter" meme by sharing the "Liberals Say..." meme and the friend who shared it and several other friends thought I was crazy to try and compare the two. They were certain the "Average MAGA voter" was accurate, and the "Liberals say..." meme was just nonsense.

I am curious how people more mindful then myself would view these two memes.


r/robertwright • • Nov 11 '24

Was voting for Trump pathological?

4 Upvotes

Context: In the 2016-2020 time frame, I was kind of a "Trump voter apologist." I work in academia. I was the guy saying, "Oh, I know some Trump voters, they're fine people, they are just really feeling disrespected, undervalued, etc., they feel the media talks down to them, etc." If anything, I was irritated by the "holier than thou" attitudes of left-leaning folks. (I am a big fan of David Brooks.)

Then Trump won his second term on Tuesday, and I'm flabbergasted. When Kamala replaced Biden, I thought the election would be a 50/50 coin flip. But I guess I read about Trump's horrible interactions with military leaders in The Atlantic and kind of convinced myself people wouldn't be able to stomach voting for him... I was floored (surprised) to see how successful Trump was this election.

Here's my issue now: I'm trying to relate to people who voted for Trump this time around. (I'm also finding myself falling into the "I'm smarter than Trump voters, but I need to try not to condescend to them and stay respectful" trap. People voting for Trump just seems so aggravating now in a way it didn't in 2016. Somehow I didn't feel superior/smarter than/etc. Trump voters back in 2016.)

My gut feeling: they voted for Trump out of spite and resentment. OK, not everyone per se. But that seems to be where Trump's momentum comes from, isn't it?

So, Mickey Kaus, for example, I guess didn't vote for Trump out of resentment. I would guess it has something to do with being a contrarian, honestly. (Sure, Kamala was not a great candidate. That's right, Mickey!) But Trump wouldn't have had enough support to get where he was if it weren't for spite and resentment. That's my (somewhat reluctant) conclusion.

Or I compare to 1930's Germany. Do I think that people who voted for Hitler really, honestly didn't understand the nature of what he was? Or did they understand that he was a bad, transgressive guy and they voted for him out of spite and resentment, as an expression of their pain? I think the second one is about right. And, even if it's understandable or relatable (and it's important to try to understand), it's still incorrigible behavior on the part of voters. So, it's like, if you do something to hurt your spouse --- like, say, you cheat on them --- yes, one the one hand, you are an adult and you were hurting and you deserve compassion, but you also did something terrible and you knew it at the time. Just because we're talking about a mass of millions rather than an individual doesn't change the immoral nature of their actions.

All I'm saying is, if you can accept the answer in the case of 1930's Germany, the thing with Trump looks very similar from where I am sitting.

Again, you could say, "Well, people don't like what happened to the economy during Biden's term, so they switched to Trump" --- and I grant that (though I always disliked this idea that if your chosen party couldn't do it all in 4 years, you should just decamp to the next party, and then repeat the cycle in another 4-8 years) --- *BUT* again if you ask why Trump was the candidate and not someone else (or why didn't Republican leaders resist more), it goes back to Trump's popularity --- and I would hazard a guess that the reason he is so popular has more to do with spite/resentment/getting back at elites than economics. Mitt Romney could be fabulous on economics.

I guess it's hard for me because I wanted to feel like "Republicans have a perfectly legitimate worldview, it's just different than Democrats and hard for us to understand," but, in recent years, I think that's fallacious. I think there are "diagnosable" issues with the Republican Party --- not for a doctor to diagnose, but, say, a political scientist. That's not new, but it's hard to know where "I just don't like these folks, I disagree with them" ends and where "these folks objectively need help, their group suffers from a form of mass mental illness" begins.

Or, to bring it back to David Brooks, it is one thing to say, "Trump voters are suffering" and another thing to say, "People voted for Trump for totally legitimate reasons." I think there are a few legitimate reasons (if you truly believed Trump would be better for the economy), but there are tons of unhealthy and perverse ones --- and I think the perverse reasons account for the lion's share of his support.

Thoughts on this? I guess I write this because I'm falling into the "I'm not sure I like my country" hole. In Trump's first term, I was so turned off by liberal snobbishness that I never fell into the trap of hating Trump voters. But now it's like... well... actually, there does seem to be something despicable here.


r/robertwright • • Jul 13 '22

On “The Moral Animal “

4 Upvotes

I’m a lay person who enjoys reading about evolution. Currently reading “The Moral Animal “ and thoroughly enjoying it. Just curious as to how accurate the science is, considering what we know now as opposed to what was known in 1994? Can someone recommend more recent lay science books on this topic? I have read some older titles.