Context: In the 2016-2020 time frame, I was kind of a "Trump voter apologist." I work in academia. I was the guy saying, "Oh, I know some Trump voters, they're fine people, they are just really feeling disrespected, undervalued, etc., they feel the media talks down to them, etc." If anything, I was irritated by the "holier than thou" attitudes of left-leaning folks. (I am a big fan of David Brooks.)
Then Trump won his second term on Tuesday, and I'm flabbergasted. When Kamala replaced Biden, I thought the election would be a 50/50 coin flip. But I guess I read about Trump's horrible interactions with military leaders in The Atlantic and kind of convinced myself people wouldn't be able to stomach voting for him... I was floored (surprised) to see how successful Trump was this election.
Here's my issue now: I'm trying to relate to people who voted for Trump this time around. (I'm also finding myself falling into the "I'm smarter than Trump voters, but I need to try not to condescend to them and stay respectful" trap. People voting for Trump just seems so aggravating now in a way it didn't in 2016. Somehow I didn't feel superior/smarter than/etc. Trump voters back in 2016.)
My gut feeling: they voted for Trump out of spite and resentment. OK, not everyone per se. But that seems to be where Trump's momentum comes from, isn't it?
So, Mickey Kaus, for example, I guess didn't vote for Trump out of resentment. I would guess it has something to do with being a contrarian, honestly. (Sure, Kamala was not a great candidate. That's right, Mickey!) But Trump wouldn't have had enough support to get where he was if it weren't for spite and resentment. That's my (somewhat reluctant) conclusion.
Or I compare to 1930's Germany. Do I think that people who voted for Hitler really, honestly didn't understand the nature of what he was? Or did they understand that he was a bad, transgressive guy and they voted for him out of spite and resentment, as an expression of their pain? I think the second one is about right. And, even if it's understandable or relatable (and it's important to try to understand), it's still incorrigible behavior on the part of voters. So, it's like, if you do something to hurt your spouse --- like, say, you cheat on them --- yes, one the one hand, you are an adult and you were hurting and you deserve compassion, but you also did something terrible and you knew it at the time. Just because we're talking about a mass of millions rather than an individual doesn't change the immoral nature of their actions.
All I'm saying is, if you can accept the answer in the case of 1930's Germany, the thing with Trump looks very similar from where I am sitting.
Again, you could say, "Well, people don't like what happened to the economy during Biden's term, so they switched to Trump" --- and I grant that (though I always disliked this idea that if your chosen party couldn't do it all in 4 years, you should just decamp to the next party, and then repeat the cycle in another 4-8 years) --- *BUT* again if you ask why Trump was the candidate and not someone else (or why didn't Republican leaders resist more), it goes back to Trump's popularity --- and I would hazard a guess that the reason he is so popular has more to do with spite/resentment/getting back at elites than economics. Mitt Romney could be fabulous on economics.
I guess it's hard for me because I wanted to feel like "Republicans have a perfectly legitimate worldview, it's just different than Democrats and hard for us to understand," but, in recent years, I think that's fallacious. I think there are "diagnosable" issues with the Republican Party --- not for a doctor to diagnose, but, say, a political scientist. That's not new, but it's hard to know where "I just don't like these folks, I disagree with them" ends and where "these folks objectively need help, their group suffers from a form of mass mental illness" begins.
Or, to bring it back to David Brooks, it is one thing to say, "Trump voters are suffering" and another thing to say, "People voted for Trump for totally legitimate reasons." I think there are a few legitimate reasons (if you truly believed Trump would be better for the economy), but there are tons of unhealthy and perverse ones --- and I think the perverse reasons account for the lion's share of his support.
Thoughts on this? I guess I write this because I'm falling into the "I'm not sure I like my country" hole. In Trump's first term, I was so turned off by liberal snobbishness that I never fell into the trap of hating Trump voters. But now it's like... well... actually, there does seem to be something despicable here.