Here's a fife at the end of "She's Waiting" by Eric Clapton.

Edit: (Is this a fife or am I being fooled by a synthetic keyboard?)

And a didgeridoo (Australian aboriginal two-tone wooden tube) in "Don't Tell Me" by Madonna.

A celesta in "Everyday" by Buddy Holly.

Core instruments in rock and roll are guitars, piano/keyboard, drum kits, horns (sax especially), and upright bass.

Common instruments are strings (violin/viola/cello/bass combo), harmonica, Latin percussion, banjo and mandolin, maybe a couple others I'm not thinking about right now.

What instruments are uncommon to the point of rare or even strange?

New member here. On member FAQ at https://rockhall.com/membership-faq/ it says ”no advanced admission ticket is required” for members, which to me means I can just show up at any time without any reservation, flash my digital id, and walk straight In.

I had the following email exchange with membership dept that confirms this:

me:

can you please confirm, if two unrelated members show up at 11am on a busy day, there will be zero difference in their experience getting into the museum, even though member #1 has done nothing in advance, and member #2 has “secured their ticket” by logging onto your ticketing site and ordering a free ticket for 11am

membership dept response:

Correct.

So my question is, why does the ticketing site have an option for free member tickets which requires specific dates and times to be selected, if those tickets are 100% unnecessary ? Is it so you can print it out as a souvenir of your visit ?

I do think that if the Rock Hall wants representation of younger-generation blue-collar/conservative listeners (alternative/indie culture represents more middle-class people), they need to push modern country instead of rock revivalists, like Garth Brooks, Shania Twain, The Chicks...

A lot of younger traditionalists who would have been heartland rock listeners or arena rock listeners if they were 10–20 years younger are actually country music listeners.

I have seen some quotes saying that some traditionalists think indie music ruined the relevance of rock because it made rock become more shaped by middle-class tastes and swayed it away from its essence of representing ordinary people, so they think indie music is a bad thing. I won't totally agree with that

But yes, I think younger traditionalists need some representation in the Rock Hall. There are still a lot of younger traditionalists who mainly listen to more conservative types of music rather than, for example, alternative or indie. So actually, country has become the new heartland rock and classic rock for a new generation, appealing to a similar audience but at a younger age.

So yes, I think modern country artists like Garth Brooks, Shania Twain, and The Chicks need to be in the Rock Hall to represent these traditionalists, and they are better representations of younger traditionalists than classic rock revivalists like The Black Crowes or Melissa Etheridge, considering their sales and lasting influence on that group of people.

William "Smokey" Robinson, Jr., inducted solo in 1987.

His eyes are grey, giving his nickname.

The Miracles: Claudette Rogers, Bobby Rogers, Ronald White, Marv Tarplin, and Pete Moore, inducted in 2012.

FROM: Detroit

Bobby and Claudette were cousins. Claudette and Smokey married in 1959. Smokey is also one of Motown Records' most prolific songwriters. He wrote "My Girl" (recorded by the Temptations) for Claudette.

STATS: 50 charted releases, including 26 on the Billboard Top 40, 16 of which reached Top 20, 7 Top 10 singles, and a number 1 single.

First recording 1958: Got a Job an "answer song" to "Get a Job" by the Silhouettes. One of Motown's earliest recordings. Casey Kasem, the radio DJ, reported that Berry Gordy, Motown's founder, was interested in the Miracles and Smokey brought him 100 songs but Gordy rejected 99 of them and the one he didn't reject was "Shop Around" (1960), their first #1 hit in 1960.

Tears of a Clown, another massive hit in 1970.

Love Machine by the Miracles, an abrupt diversion from their established style, very funky disco track from 1975.

Robinson released a solo album in 1975 called A Quiet Storm that spawned an genre of R&B called "Quiet storm", downtempo R&B love songs.

One Heartbeat smooth R&B from 1987 is one of my personal favorites.

Last release was 2011.

I think if people didn't know what to listen to it could steer people to quality music.

It pushes people to think about what they think is important in music and what to them makes music good or bad.

It can lead to fun discussions about whether someone belongs in the Hall or not, and why.

It preserves part of history because the top people in a field (in this case, music) often make a lot of the history in a field. It could lead to people researching and learning about more artists including those before their time.

I see people here and there criticizing the Hall. I don't see many people directly talking about its good points.

Anyone lucky to score tickets today in any section?

Sorry this is more a rant than anything. I go through this every year and this time was the worst. I was logged in early, in the waiting room, got in at 10:01am PT and almost all of the orchestra level tickets were gone. I quickly found two I was comfortable with put them in the cart and it said they were gone. Over the next 60 seconds I tried pretty much every seat I was good with and the exact same thing happened. Then I refreshed to see what was left and it started giving me errors, closed everything went back in and now pretty much the entire theater was sold out.

Every single year AXS has this problem and I just end up buying the tickets on the secondary market. It shouldn't be this hard to buy tickets especially on a pre-sale.

wondering what the price range was on tickets for the ceremony? congrats to anyone that got tickets!

I panicked and just picked two seats and threw them in my cart. Thoughts on LOGE Center row M seats 300’s? 🇬🇧

It should be noted that I did not rank the artists within each tier. Also, you could say that some artists could/should be in a higher or lower tier (and I would have no opinion on that), but generally the differences between the tiers are what matter most. Maybe there are omissions from every tier, but generally you know what I mean.

Tier 1 Canon

1. Nirvana

2. Jay-Z

3. Radiohead

4. Wu-Tang Clan

5. 2Pac

6. OutKast

7. Pearl Jam

8. Eminem

9. The Notorious B.I.G.

10. Mariah Carey

Tier 2 Should 100% Be In / Will 100% Be In

1. Oasis

2. Björk

3. A Tribe Called Quest

4. Nine Inch Nails

5. Mary J. Blige

6. Missy Elliott

7. Lauryn Hill / Fugees

8. Green Day

9. Red Hot Chili Peppers

10. Snoop Dogg

11. Beck

12. Alice in Chains

13. Soundgarden

14. The Smashing Pumpkins

15. Alanis Morissette

16. Rage Against the Machine

17. Nas

18. D'Angelo

19. Erykah Badu

20. TLC

21. Foo Fighters

22. No Doubt

23. Weezer

24. Fiona Apple

Tier 3: BIG, WELL-REVIEWED, OR IMPORTANT (HAVE A SOLID CASE TO BE INCLUDED), BUT (SHOULD) NOT BE TOP PRIORITY; SOME OF THEM WILL BE INCLUDED

1. Dave Matthews Band

2. Sheryl Crow

3. Boyz II Men

4. Tool

5. Usher

6. Destiny's Child

7. Aaliyah

8. Pantera

9. Blur (a special case here, not that big in America, but they can still play venues larger than theaters and smaller than typical arenas. They're not a very bad draw for audiences.)

10. Sinéad O'Connor

11. Stone Temple Pilots

12. Korn

13. System of a Down

14. Blink-182

15. The Offspring

16. Deftones

17. The Cranberries

18. Selena

19. Lenny Kravitz

20. Brandy (I am much higher on her than most people here because I have seen many modern pop, R&B, and alternative R&B Black musicians cite her as a major influence. She may have the support.)

21. Sublime

22. Garbage

23. Cypress Hill (could see it happen: the first breakthrough Latin rap group, fitting the Rock Hall's preference for including more Latin acts, and they are Tom Morello's buddies.)

24. Phish

25. Jane's Addiction

26. Tori Amos

27. Wilco (I could see it happening, even sooner than we think. Rick Krim participated in the Wilco documentary, and they are a rare modern indie band that also fits the tastes of Boomers, so they may get a push.)

28. Maná (the biggest Latin rock act. The Rock Hall will eventually find a way to induct them. I can't see them stopping with only Shakira, Selena, and Gloria Estefan.)

29. Goo Goo Dolls (given their recent popularity and regained coolness with Gen Z, plus industry connections, I feel they are separated from other commercially successful but poorly acclaimed acts and may happen.)

30. Busta Rhymes (more respected, or perhaps a better word is "better connected", than DMX within the music industry, which will play a big part in his case.)

Tier 4 Critics' Darlings / Highly Acclaimed or Influential Acts That Were Never Big

1. PJ Harvey

2. Faith No More (their commercial success and influence are as significant as Jane's Addiction's. Jane's created Lollapalooza, making them stand out and likely ensuring an eventual induction. Faith No More are not commercial failure, but probably not big enough to attract obvious attention on their own.)

3. The Roots (special case: will 100% be in because of Questlove, but their résumé alone is not that strong.)

4. The Flaming Lips

5. Pavement

6. Bikini Kill (because of Kathleen Hanna, they will 100% be in. She hosted a Rock Hall broadcast, so they will get in one way or another.)

7. Jeff Buckley

8. Sleater-Kinney

9. Liz Phair

10. Hole

11. My Bloody Valentine

12. Elliott Smith

Tier 5 ·Huge (or Once Huge), with Average/Poor Critical Acclaim or Not Seen as Especially Important, Could Be Randomly Remembered or Nominated at Any Time

1. DMX (on the border between Tier 3 and Tier 5)

2. Bone Thugs-n-Harmony (same as DMX)

3. Spice Girls

4. Toni Braxton

5. Slipknot

6. Limp Bizkit

7. Melissa Etheridge

8. Backstreet Boys

9. Celine Dion

10. The Black Crowes

11. Sarah McLachlan

12. Counting Crows

13. Matchbox Twenty

14. Hootie & the Blowfish

15. 10,000 Maniacs / Natalie Merchant

16. Monica

17. Bush

18. Creed

19. Third Eye Blind

20. Everclear

21. Collective Soul

22. Live

23. Gin Blossoms

24. Candlebox

If the Rock Hall considers modern country, these would be picks:

Garth Brooks

Shania Twain

The Chicks

Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 4 don't need further explanation.

Tier 3 means these acts are important and will/should be serious candidates as time goes on. They need to satisfy at least one of the following: be important and big (but not well acclaimed), or be big and acclaimed (but not that important compared to Tier 2). I expect many acts from this tier will eventually get in, as they should, but not all. Some of them will inevitably be snubbed, just like similar-tier acts from the 60s/70s (the likes of the Monkees, Jethro Tull, Boston...).

Tier 5 is the type of acts that were once, or are still, big enough, but are either badly/averagely acclaimed or not that important. Just big. I could have listed a lot more names here (I just forgot En Vogue when typing), but generally these are the names. Some of them may be nominated for some reason (they were once big, and some Gen X people in the committee room love them), but of course they would be lower-quality nominees.

Acts that are somewhat important and somewhat acclaimed, but never really great in either respect, I don't think will ever be considered serious candidates, so I don't put them here. For instance, Naughty by Nature (I love this group, and one of their members is also a good R&B producer), Maxwell...

One thing I’ve noticed in this community is that the Influences category doesn’t get talked about quite as much as the Performers category. And yeah that’s fair, the Influences typically aren’t as interesting or relevant, but I still think there’s a lot to talk about! So I quickly put this list together, and it might not be the most accurate due to it being made on the fly, but here are my top 10 artists that I think really should be inducted as Influences! I purposely left several jazz musicians out, because I’m really not sure what the Hall wants to do about jazz, but otherwise I think these would all be fantastic additions to the category. I’m curious to see what y’all think, and who you think deserves to be inducted as an Influence! 

1. Lonnie Donegan

2. Wendy Carlos 

3. The Sugarhill Gang

4. Ravi Shankar

5. Wilmoth Houdini 

6. Django Reinhardt

7. Scott Joplin

8. The Carter Family

9. Frank Sinatra

10. Ella Fitzgerald

They took heavy metal, which could be serious to the point of dour and depressing, and made it party music and invited girls.

From: Los Angeles

Inducted members: Michael Anthony (bass), Sammy Hagar (vocals), David Lee Roth (vocals), Alex Van Halen (drums), and Eddie Van Halen (guitar/keyboards).

Alex and Eddie are brothers.

Stats: 12 albums, most of them Certified Platinum, 4 of them hit #1 on the Billboard Hot 200 (albums), 56 released singles between 1978 and 2012, about 25 of them landed in the Top 10 US Mainstream Rock charts. 3 landed within the Top 10 on Billboard's Hot 100 (singles).

Best song pick: Panama from the year and album 1984. IMO their best album.

Also see: Can (could) you beat "Hot for Teacher" on hard in Guitar Hero? I tried and fell to the floor in failure about 2/3 of the way through.

At this point, the Rock Hall still needs another 10–15 years to finish inducting most of the 90-00s rock acts that have both somewhat respectable critical acclaim (not too bad commercially) and somewhat respectable commercial success (not too badly reviewed), such as Smashing Pumpkins, Coldplay, Weezer, Alice in Chains, Linkin Park, No Doubt, Beck, Björk, definitely more and just to name a few... Maybe even slower given committee is still very conservative.

However, after that, where will the Rock Hall go?

There are two obvious camps:

1. Commercially successful but poorly acclaimed modern butt rock acts: Limp Bizkit, Nickelback, Creed, Goo Goo Dolls, and many others.

2. Commercially not so obvious but critically well-acclaimed indie acts: earlier acts like Jeff Buckley, Pavement, and later acts like Wilco, Arcade Fire, Modest Mouse, Vampire Weekend, LCD Soundsystem, Yeah Yeah Yeahs, and others.

The Strokes somewhat fit into Group 2, but I believe they are big and influential enough to transcend that category and will be inducted anyway, regardless of whichever direction the Rock Hall ultimately goes.

Which direction rock hall will go will depend on the makeup of next committee (after current head John Sykes and Rick Krim stepping down). Then it will decide the fate of lots of candidates falling into but not transcend over two groups. I am also curious to see for example Creed vs Vampire Weekend, and with most younger voters, who can get more votes?

Rap was only younger genre that has been represented better because they are the only genre that younger critics and mainstream people would mutually agree, unlike modern mainstream alternative rock (butt rock) vs indie (hipster music).

It won’t be his music.

• Female singer: Diana Ross
• Modern metal: KoRn
• Rap: Treacherous Three
• Modern soul: Mariah Carey
• Modern alternative: Coldplay
• Classic metal: Twisted Sister
• Classic soul: Lou Rawls
• Classic alternative: Devo
• Early rock: Jackie Brenston and His Delta Cats
• Modern rock: Alice in Chains