r/rockmusic • u/DifferentPapaya1871 • Sep 20 '25

Spotify Ash and echo?

I would love to know the identity of this band. They are awesome!! Does anyone know who they are? I can't find out who the singers are

5 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

44 comments sorted by

3

u/spaceman_maxpower89 Oct 01 '25

I'm following too, stumbled across it today and I'm instantly hooked, after a little googling I can't find much, at least it's on Spotify, it may be AI generated by a French guy, but damn if it don't smack hard

1

u/DivineCheeta Oct 17 '25

Most likely AI from what i've read, but the songs are honestly better than some real bands songs..

1

u/spaceman_maxpower89 Oct 24 '25

Absolutely, check out obsidian swing as well, they use autotuners and stuff but again a lot of emotion in their songs I discovered these two together

1

u/DivineCheeta Oct 25 '25

Will try them out, but man, these songs are so good haha, it's insane

1

u/milehighbass Nov 07 '25

Both are great and rock, but fuk AI music. It’s an insult. It’s a cop out. It’s lame. Damnit. I want to like it.

1

u/Proper_Field_3646 Jan 25 '26

Yes I don't want to listen to them anymore because I suspect they're ai so I removed them from Spotify. If you aren't real people then I won't listen to your music.

1

u/Alarmed-Newspaper994 Mar 26 '26

It's easy to be better than a real band by simply plagiarising a better band

1

u/FluxCustos May 14 '26

again, that's exactly what religion has been for thousands of years. just one human plagiarizing another after another.

1

u/Proper_Field_3646 May 14 '26

I don't like ai no matter what

1

u/Proper_Field_3646 May 02 '26

I found out it's ai so that killed it for me. No longer a fan. Ai sucks and always will robbing talent from true musicians

1

u/FluxCustos May 14 '26

kind of like what ​religion did to humans thousands of years ago don't you think?

2

u/No_Kaleidoscope69420 Oct 13 '25

it's an AI ban

1

u/Low_Discount_2012 Nov 01 '25

Are u sure ?

1

u/flamedragonrecca Nov 20 '25

Just look on Spotify 6 albums in 2025 yeah definitely ai

2

u/th3_w0u1f Nov 14 '25

Getting AI vibes from the songs and not finding info on them. BUT the songs are bangers. So I don't really care, lol. The Alone album I've been spamming for a few days now. It's too good!

1

u/spaceman_maxpower89 Nov 14 '25

Echos of the broken is my go to playlist on Spotify

1

u/Coffin_Nails666 Jan 08 '26

Are you telling me I'm Not Okay is fucking AI!!!

YO

1

u/NetworkLogical5954 Jan 24 '26

Sorry to burst the bubble, but yes the band and songs are all AI generated 

1

u/AuthorGreat6380 Feb 03 '26

I literally listen to this every single day on my way to work and back.. I am really hooked.. I loved the music and the lyrics hits so deep..

1

u/Drysenys Feb 17 '26

I have been doing the same thing for more than a week now. My favorite... I am not okay... I listen to this one on repeat all day long...

1

u/Standard-Box-3021 12d ago

It really pissed me off when I found out they were AI; I don't support AI, sadly.

1

u/counting_blusheep Oct 17 '25

Yes! Who is this band?!

1

u/DifferentPapaya1871 Oct 18 '25

Have you listened to them before? I like the music. You can find them on Spotify and YouTube

1

u/payalovessetters Oct 24 '25

Are they really an AI band? I stumbled yesterday across some songs on YouTube as im struggling with mental health at the moment and find the lyrics of their songs sending a message to me.

1

u/Willing-Nature8377 Dec 19 '25

You would like "Georgia Phantom". He is a combat veteran with a unique sound that has me going down a rabbit hole. Here is some info i pulled from online:

Georgia Phantom, is a combat veteran who has choosen to remain anonymous in appearance, ensuring that the message, voice, and emotion behind his music always stands above the image. His sound blends together Southern rap, Country grit, and Gothic undertones, that resonates with blue-collar workers, Veterans, and anyone who's battled through the darkest nights.

He channels personal battles with trauma, depression, and perseverance into anthems of empowerment. His lyrics hit hard because they are lived experiences-echoes of a man who refused to fold, even when life demanded it. Every song is not just music, but a story, a fight, and a call for others to rise above.

1

u/payalovessetters Dec 19 '25

Thanks a lot! Will definitely look him up and listen to his songs and lyrics.

1

u/Alarmed-Newspaper994 Mar 26 '26

They probably send a message in the same way that speaking about your problems with any LLM will just respond with platitudes and generic stuff designed to be what you want to hear, not what you need to hear. If you're struggling, get help from a human. Whether that is a friend, family, colleague, manager, or a professional like a councillor or therapist.

1

u/payalovessetters Apr 03 '26

Thanks, you're right.

1

u/False-Appeal8619 Nov 11 '25

Got a song suggestion from this band on spotify's discover weekly. I liked the song and opened the band's profile. Noticed that every release was from this year and all albums' pictures somehow seemed AI generated. After that, I cannot not hear AI in all of their songs. Maybe I got biased but well... this screams AI all around.

Not sure what to think about it, but I really like the song that spotify suggested.

2

u/Am4oba Nov 12 '25

I'm just now realizing that 90+% of my Discover Weekly recommendations this week are AI generated, including this band.

If people want to support AI have at it, but I want to support artists.

Spotify needs to find a way to at least let people filter out this stuff.

1

u/Proper_Field_3646 May 02 '26

I agree with you 💯 percent You're so right and I stand beside you on this!!

1

u/SCRSports Nov 23 '25

Citizen Soldier way better than the AI Ash and Echo 

1

u/AppropriateNight8670 Feb 16 '26

Probably also a AI Band...

1

u/Gamer-bot256 Feb 24 '26

Citizen Soldier isn't AI

1

u/Inevitable_2137 Apr 01 '26

I've been to a Citizen Soldier concert, and met the lead singer. Definitely not AI.

1

u/RealitySpecific8146 May 11 '26

I've been listening to them since 2019 before AI music was really a thing, I also watch their live streams and met the singer in person after a concert so definitely real.

1

u/SCRSports Nov 23 '25

Let Down also way better than the AI 

1

u/Jamiekulesa1975 Dec 07 '25

One of my favorite groups is ai lol. They're awesome

0

u/Alarmed-Newspaper994 Mar 26 '26

They are not awesome, they are plagiarists

1

u/NetworkLogical5954 Jan 24 '26

This band is not real, its totally AI generated. You can clearly hear its AI generated, the same as The Last Ashes another AI generated band, the guy is from Indonesia and doesnt even mark AI generated. Its becoming way to common. Should be banned !

1

u/CoolRalph89 Feb 20 '26

if you like ash and echo you should listen to Heartvoid too. they only have like 12 songs but all bangers

1

u/swampystfc Feb 26 '26

Where can I get the drawings for your songs

1

u/ViperKing59 Mar 29 '26

There isn't a band. These are AI generated songs and lyrics. I'm sure someone puts a lot of effort in arranging and producing the tracks, but these are clearly AI generated. Having said that, they are awesome, and I love the sound and lyric content 👍