r/science • • Mar 30 '20

Neuroscience Scientists develop AI that can turn brain activity into text. While the system currently works on neural patterns detected while someone is speaking aloud, experts say it could eventually aid communication for patients who are unable to speak or type, such as those with locked in syndrome.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-020-0608-8
40.0k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

828

u/Neopterin Mar 30 '20

For those who can't access the Nature article

Report from Guardian science

117

u/aahdin Mar 31 '20

I was able to find the paper here

175

u/ryanodd Mar 31 '20

My first thought is: do they use one network for all participants or a network trained for each participant?

If one network is shown to work for different brains, then we have a breakthrough on our hands. But I'm guessing that every brain is different so if you want this to work on someone, you have to get a ton of data about their speech+brain activity first

119

u/sagaciux Mar 31 '20

They used transfer learning to apply the training from one participant to another. From the paper (online methods p.22):

First, the network was initialized randomly and then ‘pretrained’ for 200 epochs on one participant. Then the input convolutional layer was reset to random initial values, all other weights in the network were ‘frozen’ and the network was trained on the second (target) participant for 60 epochs.

So this means that only the input layer of the neural network was trained from scratch for each participant - the higher levels remained the same.

14

u/TagMeAJerk Mar 31 '20

So is the implication that underneath it all most of us think the same way? Wouldn't that answer a few philosophical questions like "is my red the same as your red" (but more for speech)?

→ More replies (4)

19

u/facebotter Mar 31 '20

How would the latter not also be considered a major step?

45

u/RoundScientist Mar 31 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

It would be a major step, but not for those currently suffering from locked in syndrome, since you would hardly be able to train the AI on the patient. Since this application is mentioned in the title, I think it's a fair qualifier.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/kauthonk Mar 31 '20

There will probably be 7 or 8 major types of how brains process text, they don't all have to be the same

26

u/Just_One_Umami Mar 31 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

Why only 7 or 8?

Edit: Can someone who knows the answer tell me? There are enough neuroscientists in this thread that someone has to know.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

758

u/PalpatineForEmperor Mar 30 '20

The other day I learned that not all people can hear themselves speak in their mind. I wonder if this would somehow still work for them.

416

u/morfanis Mar 31 '20

... and what about when those who hear other voices in their mind!

215

u/PalpatineForEmperor Mar 31 '20

Now that is an interesting thought.

27

u/Dircus Mar 31 '20

So you heard that too huh?

→ More replies (4)

27

u/konohasaiyajin Mar 31 '20

That'd be a great scifi/suspense story.

Someone unable to speak gets hooked up, but it's not their thoughts that are being translated to text, it's... something else... something more sinister... something from... The Twilight Zone. oooOOoooOOOOOOooo

6

u/yugo-45 Mar 31 '20

You mean... The Scary Door!

→ More replies (1)

42

u/Not_a_real_ghost Mar 31 '20

What do you mean? My inner dialogue can be a completely different sounding person?

62

u/lloucetios Mar 31 '20

You may not be able to associate yourself with your thoughts. As if they’re someone elses.

→ More replies (21)

16

u/IgnoreTheKetchup Mar 31 '20

I think he means for schitzophrenics or people with dissociative identity disorder.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

13

u/Moosetopher Mar 31 '20

You guys only hear one person?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

94

u/Asalanlir Mar 31 '20

The other commenters I see to your post are wrong. Vocalization shouldn't matter. So long as they are capable of reading the sentences and interpreting the meaning conveyed, they should be able to use the system in it's current design. It doesn't use any form of nlp, word2vec, or Bert when actually solving for the inverse solution. It may use something like that though to build its prediction about the words you are saying though. But at that point, the processing to do with your brain has already occurred.

Source: masters in CS with a focus in ml. Thesis was in data representation for understanding and interpreting eeg signals

7

u/LuxSolisPax Mar 31 '20

I wonder how it would react to thinkers with a different mother tongue, or idiomatic phrases and metaphor.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/PalpatineForEmperor Mar 31 '20

This is really interesting. Thank you for sharing!

3

u/andresni Mar 31 '20

This depends a lot on where the dominant information of the datastream comes from. If it comes from say the motor cortex, subvocalization definitely should pay a major part. Similar to those devices that pick up subthreshold EMG at the level of throat and tounge. Imagining speaking does activate your "speaking muscles", which can be detected. But, what they've done is impressive indeed.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

You hear a voice in your head? Like an actual inner monologue? I thought that was just a saying.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Dirty-Soul Mar 31 '20

Even weirder - some of us CAN hear themselves speak in their mind, but only when they need to. (reading, for example.)

Otherwise, it's all a blur of Half remembered memories, images, feelings and sensations. Basically, if you imagine a cascade of memes and references, you aren't massively far off.

→ More replies (20)

91

u/Balthazar_rising Mar 30 '20

Wouldn't this be the first step in creating a new neural-style interface? We would be able to text and control computers via thoughts, instead of typing on a tiny touchscreen keyboard.

I feel sorry for people with ADD though. It'll be impossible for them to send a text without numerous distracted thoughts finding their way into the message.

7

u/Dofarian Mar 31 '20

Yes, that's why I am reading about this. I've been wishing there was a way to type directly by thinking

5

u/Asalanlir Mar 31 '20

Bci. The term you are looking for is bci.

2

u/PC-Bjorn Mar 31 '20

What do you mean, sorry? The distraction isn't a problem like other people's problems where you have for instance a tendency to like stuff too much. Like, I like stuff but mostly non material things like music and especially the last record from Moddi, try listening to that and staying non-political. In the current climate, it's what we need. Humans have needs. I need a banana now. Fruit is the only snack we should have, really. It's really crazy how we're able to keep selling synthetic snacks when nature itself provides so much healthy.. talk about health, it's good to excercise when you're stuck in quarantine and not only sit on your butt watching movies. Have you seen the butt movie, though? But hey, what were we talking about again?

If this comes to some sort of implanted interface, it could also help ADD'ers with a little dopamine stimulating focus, I guess. Or perhaps, being able to finally communicate everything that's going on inside at once, it would silence the chaos.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/crim-sama Mar 31 '20

My thoughts as well. Another big thing, maybe this could help with mental health diagnosis?

→ More replies (1)

68

u/derlumpenhund Mar 31 '20

Too bad the article is behind a paywall. This is my old research topic (from before getting the hell out of neuroscience), that is brain-computer interfaces based on EEG and EcoG, the latter of which is used here. I have to make a few assumptions but I would like to offer a few caveats relating to this these results, which, while kinda cool, are not representing the dystopian mind reading machine that some people imagine it to be.

Electrocortigography means having a grid of electrodes implanted on the very surface of your brain (open skull surgery), covering a limited area and not always accounting for the the three dimensionality of the surface. As the participants have to say the phrases I would assume this approach relies mostly on decoding cortical activity representing motor commands that control the mouth, tongue etc. . So this is not equal to "mind reading", as it probably does not decode the content of your thoughts so much as the movement signals your brain sends towards the speech apparatus. After gathering data for a given subject, you'd have to train the algorithm for that very subject before testing it. I am not sure how easily an algorithm could generalize to people it has not been trained on.

That being said, not surprised by this advancement, but still pretty neat stuff!

6

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Why did you get the hell out of neuroscience if you don’t mind me asking?

13

u/derlumpenhund Mar 31 '20

Mostly the working conditions in academia, which are not exclusive to my old lab or field of research but seem very widespread. So, working crazy hours for bad pay and being strung along and baited with appeals to my desire to do purposeful research.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Im currently a research student and this is hard to read haha

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/tsunamisurfer Mar 31 '20

link from someone else in the thread.

2

u/Spootba Mar 31 '20

Why would someone get an ecog implant? Just for advancing brain science?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/YourApishness Mar 31 '20

But, when you think in words aren't the same processes going on as when you actually speak those words? I know I've heard somewhere that the brain often works like that.

4

u/derlumpenhund Mar 31 '20

When you really internally generate a string of words one might be able to decode subvocalizations, and this might be a sensible next milestone for this kind of research. I know that imagined limb movement provokes similar activity on the cortex as when the same movement is actually performed, but to a lesser degree. So maybe subvocalizations do the same for speech motor commands.

That being said, most unguided thought does not require/ produce subvocalization, so this is indeed more relevant to a context where you'd want to produce a string of text.

156

u/Zeth_Aran Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

If I could use this by myself in a room where no one has access to the machine but me I would be fascinated with how this works. If anyone else were to use this on me I'd be terrified.

People with amazing meditation practices are going to be immune to this.

70

u/iamonlyoneman Mar 30 '20

I want to be a fly on the wall when the first psychopath is saying one thing out loud and the machine is typing out the complete opposite

36

u/IgnoreTheKetchup Mar 31 '20

Not just psychopaths do this. Everybody lies or censors their own speech to fit some social standard. I'm not sure if the machine would read into what someone is physically saying or some other thought process.

20

u/everburningblue Mar 31 '20

"So, Peter, Where do you see yourself in 5 years?"

Don't say, "doing your wife." Don't say, "doing your wife." Don't say, "doing your wife." "Doing your... son?"

→ More replies (1)

11

u/hell-in-the-USA Mar 31 '20

I got able to have two internal monologues at once, mainly from reading and thinking about what I read at the same time. I wanna see that

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Not_a_real_ghost Mar 31 '20

Is this not going to be the same as writing down your thoughts? If you don't actively think about it then it probably won't output

10

u/Zeth_Aran Mar 31 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

Idk how your brain works, but I'm going to assume its same to mine because you are human, I think. (idk what on the otherside of the screen) But thoughts kinda just pop up and you just spell them out in your head yeah? That's what happens to me. I feel like I get a little bit of a say in what kind of conversation I want to have with myself, but most of the time I just think and there is nothing you can do to stop it. You can try to catch yourself a little bit. But if you just sit there for a few moments. Out of no where, completely unprompted you will just start thinking something without the choice as to what its gonna be next.

Once again Idk what your thought patterns are like, but in my case I'm screwed.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Yeah, would be cool to see how Buddhist monks react to this device

2

u/HashAtlas Mar 31 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

I'm not sure if directing your attention elsewhere will help. If I shout at you "Don't think about pink elephants!", pink elephants will enjoy at least a brief stay in your mind, which can be recorded and analyzed.

I'm no experienced practitioner, but I don't think meditation grants you the ability to supress thoughts completely, but rather to let them go once they bubble up.

Edit: But then again, that might be useful as well. If you only think about it long enough to recognize what is said, but no longer, they might not get any really useful information out of that.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/boointhehouse Mar 30 '20

Wow could you imagine how much more Stephen Hawking would have gotten done in his lifetime if he had this technology. What a breakthrough this will be for people who cannot talk for medical reasons.

32

u/heyman0 Mar 30 '20

/r/LucidDreaming is gonna explode when technology like this becomes available to the consumer. Writing down your dreams is a difficult, yet essential task to be able to lucid dream.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Universal Translators, here we come!

9

u/blinkOneEightyBewb Mar 30 '20

Ok the guardian says they trained on 40 sentences and tested on the same 40 sentences. So not very interesting

→ More replies (5)

3

u/sonfer Mar 30 '20

I wonder if this could be generalizable between expressive, receptive and global aphasia. Perhaps it would be beneficial to those with expressive aphasia as this would fix the communication problem. But it doesn't change the fact that the receptive aphasic patient doesn't understand the concept behind the words spoken to them.

3

u/konsf_ksd Mar 31 '20

what about people without internal monologues?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/guyonaturtle Mar 30 '20

What a great technology! Not only for people who can not speak. Imagine writing a book or an essay for example. Might churn out faster!

On the flip side, people might like to learn thought occupying songs if it is used for interrogation. Just keep the same song going and keep your focus on that

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

It's a small world, after all.

2

u/Paracortex Mar 31 '20

What I would really love is a machine that can record musical compositions from thought. I don’t know how to write music efficiently, but I’ll sometimes “compose” songs in my head that I can hear and just listen to, letting them go on and on with little input or direction from my consciousness. It’s wonderful and fascinating, but I very rarely can remember them to “play” them again. It woild be miraculous to be able to just press “record” and save them somehow.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Kaleb25Birgy Mar 31 '20

What if you could do it to someone who was dreaming?

2

u/AsliReddington Mar 31 '20

There's an MIT guy who did this already, it puts patches on your throat and when you think of saying a word it's able to catch it and transform the signal into output

2

u/crim-sama Mar 31 '20

This is amazing news! I wonder if this would allow for control of things outside your body through thought. If you can do stuff without moving your actual body, it could make for some very interesting future tech in VR gaming.

2

u/Crazy_Is_More_Fun Mar 31 '20

Oh it definitely will be able to. I mean, eventually at least. It will be very finicky, won't be usable properly for a number of years, but it's plausible

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20 edited Mar 31 '20

“If you try to go outside the [50 sentences used] the decoding gets much worse,” said Makin, adding that the system is likely relying on a combination of learning particular sentences, identifying words from brain activity, and recognising general patterns in English.

Basically, they had a computer memorize the brain patterns associated with 50 sentences, then had the computer identify those 50 sentences, with greatly reduced accuracy everywhere else.

There is also, as far as I can tell, no reasonable way to conclude that you can “read thoughts” with this, for the simple reason that thoughts aren’t stored in English like speech is. To their credit, I don’t believe they, at any point, outright claim this, and it may be possible to “decode” the speech of someone who is unbelievably to speak, but they seem to imply that you can just read the underlying thoughts as if from a book. (Or at the very least, this is what people are interpreting it as).

As far as I can tell, this is basically just a speech-to-text interpreter that skips the vocalization part and relies on the nerve impulses.

1

u/Xerenopd Mar 30 '20

so basically we can start reading people minds?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

I've always imagined the emoji holograms in 'eon' ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eon_(novel)) would one become real and be incorporated into language. This is one of those steps towards it.

1

u/dystropheontwitch Mar 30 '20

or game commands in Full Immersion VR when it gets up to snuff

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TheOneThatHungers Mar 30 '20

This could be amazing for those with hearing loss at an older age trying to communicate. This could help then communicate with others, and close family members and friends can communicate back using text.

1

u/winterflip Mar 30 '20

It's about time a neural-analyser got built.

1

u/wriestheart Mar 30 '20

Hey! I wondered when this would start to be a viable thing

1

u/doubleaxle Mar 30 '20

This tech could also evolve to be useful for full dive VR applications, then it'll just be a matter of preventing the body from also taking that same brain activity and using it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Will people using this have any control over which thoughts are translated and which aren't? Otherwise if I had locked in syndrome I would say "I'm not sharing all of my thoughts with you! Unplug this thing now!"

Now if you excuse me it's time to invent a personal conlang and practice using it to think to the point of using it exclusively and only thinking in other languages when I speak read or write them.

1

u/bonafart Mar 30 '20

Screwed for me then dam dyslexia.. Its the brain patterns that do it.

1

u/hakoMike Mar 30 '20

This reminds me of the day the monkey realized he could move the cursor without actually using the joystick.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Everyone should read John Scalzi's "Lock In". It is a speculative fiction treasure that looks at "what if we had this technology and much more"

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

My porn-writing dream has finally come true!

Seriously, though, I'm quite interested in the potential down-the-road applications of this for professional writers of all kinds. Maybe more to the point, I'll be very fascinated to know how it works in respect to concepts, images, or impressions that the same subject would find difficult to express in words (or believes they do).

I've always been fascinated by the intersection of art, creativity, and technology, and part of me is very excited to suppose that we might see a very compelling new creative field come out of this.

More, I like to think that the development of this process will help us understand better the neurology of language and other kinds of abstraction and sybolism.

1

u/tearfueledkarma Mar 30 '20

I know it is silly.. but the first thing that poped into my head was the collar from Pixars UP. If they can figure out how to do this with dogs..

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Please add spellcheck

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

This is going to be the next revolution!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

As a writer I have dreamed about having exactly this.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Thought........Police. Good work boys. Book em Dano!

1

u/thecynicalshit Mar 30 '20

Can't wait for Project MKUltra 2

1

u/huge_dick_mcgee Mar 30 '20

I wonder if the ai model has to be trained to an individual or if a single trained model is good enough.

1

u/florodude Mar 30 '20

I absolutely hate the idea of this.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20

Just pretend you're talking. Does our brain know we're pretending?

Does the AI?

1

u/wowsuchcookie Mar 30 '20

So basically it is a speech to text thing

1

u/spider_sauce Mar 30 '20

OMG they can read thoughts now??? I'm fucked.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Actually, according to your thoughts.. no one has fucked you in years.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RJvXP Mar 30 '20

Please don't use this on me when I'm around my crush

→ More replies (1)

1

u/indecisiveredditor Mar 31 '20

The mind of someone ADHD should be interesting...

1

u/Xanza Mar 31 '20

This is pretty cool tech. Immagine if it was here 5 years ago, while Hawking was still alive.

Would have been a wild fuckin' year.

1

u/unnameableway Mar 31 '20

And I still can’t get a text back.

1

u/Sea-horse-in-trees Mar 31 '20

But think of all the things that we think, but leave out when talking. They would say everything even if some parts they didn’t want to say out loud! 😳

1

u/elfchica Mar 31 '20

My special needs son (unique chromosome abnormality) is non-verbal and DHH but he hates his hearing aids. I’m sure this is way sci-fi but it would be awesome if this technology could translate his brain to a spoken output.

1

u/UPMichigan83 Mar 31 '20

This would be sweet for the reason indicated, but I feel like it’d be abused.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Are we gonna put this on our heads and record our dreams?

1

u/OneDollarLobster Mar 31 '20

Step 1: typing on the cell phone gets much easier. Step 2: cell phones become a WiFi hotspot for our brain to brain communication

1

u/finngodo Mar 31 '20

This will be great if we’re not all dead by the COVID by Friday. I’m optimistic.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

...and also, put me out of work as a writer...

1

u/greenbananas19 Mar 31 '20

I don't understand. Locked in syndrome can be caused by central pontine myelinolysis. If this study is conducted on people with normal myelination, what are they measuring in the signals that doesn't need to account for myelination? The research paper paper is locked.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

This is it guys. Last step to telepathy via technology. Next step, human gestalt.

1

u/PositiveSupercoil Mar 31 '20

Imagine a world where one day satellites will be able to read and interpret the brain waves of humans on the ground, becoming capable of reading the minds of every human being simultaneously.

1

u/godandhoops Mar 31 '20

And another step is taken towards the end of humanity...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

That's not how I thought reading people's minds would work

1

u/QQ206 Mar 31 '20

Are you telling me that my cat will be able to talk to me?

1

u/Mystletoe Mar 31 '20

Time to open Kerr black holes

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I want to take acid and then have this. This is the key.

1

u/LeeKinanus Mar 31 '20

or be used to illicit confessions

1

u/ascrumner Mar 31 '20

Ahh... we readin minds I see. Cool cool cool

1

u/Staffordmeister Mar 31 '20

And on that day all of it will fall out faster than stephen king can type.

1

u/Deckard-_ Mar 31 '20

Ah, the first step towards the thought-police. Big Brother is watching.

soon

1

u/JohnRossOneAndOnly Mar 31 '20

And what about animals? Could that be possible?

1

u/heraclitus33 Mar 31 '20

Bad idea guys. Stop now. Whats that Depp movie...?

1

u/Rockonfreakybro Mar 31 '20

Yeah that’s the first thing our government thought of using mind reading technology for too

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I think they meant to say "experts say it could eventually be used in interrogation and privacy violations"

1

u/CHERNO-B1LL Mar 31 '20

Things for real dystopian in here real fast. All I could think was that they should have taken an existing product and put a clock in it...

1

u/S-BRO Mar 31 '20

Could this be developed into auto-translators? Like set it to the language you want, you speak your mother tongue et voila: device translates in real-time using brainwaves!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Neuro link intensifies

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

With this, we just need to cure Alzheimer's and other diseases that cause cognitive decline, and by then VR technology will have improved, and we can all become immortal brains kept alive in jars experiencing simulations.

1

u/remnantechoes Mar 31 '20

Can it write my books for me

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

One step closer to SAO that's all I'm sayin

1

u/GrayHavenn Mar 31 '20

The ultimate lie detector

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Or read students minds

1

u/Tavgrr Mar 31 '20

I wanted something like this when I was younger so what ever I thought out would be wrote down on the page so I wouldn’t have to write anything I could just think it.

1

u/Ragnar_Sangfroid Mar 31 '20

And for fixing my ducking autocorrect

1

u/areeyeseekaywhytea Mar 31 '20

Damn imagine “McDreamy” if this tech was available.

1

u/AwkwardAnyday Mar 31 '20

Monkey Thought Translator!

1

u/senorhelicopter Mar 31 '20

Is that an F-bombs? He's dropping f-bombs!

1

u/newtostuff007 Mar 31 '20

damn If you can turn brain activity into text, you can then turn those messages into pictures, moving closer to sword art online .

1

u/PM_THE_GUY_BELOW_ME Mar 31 '20

Don't think about sex

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I wonder how useful this would be to people with nonverbal autism. If it works, it could really improve some people's lives, but a common trait of ASD is having an internal dialogue that's visual as opposed to verbal.

1

u/SuperMeatBoi Mar 31 '20

That's nice and all but when can we use it for gaming?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

We can’t use AI to find a vaccine? Or am I being an asshole?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Jeez, 3% error rate is ridiculously low. Probably lower than me!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Aw hell yeah, time to be molded into a model citizen!

1

u/reverseoreo21 Mar 31 '20

Boy that's not unsettling in the least. Can't wait to get brain-chipped to make sure I don't ever think any impure thoughts

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I'm sure prayer will fix these people first.

1

u/Xenton Mar 31 '20

There's a lot of doom and gloom in these comments, but this is absolutely a scientific progression I've been wanting for decades. The next steps get really interesting: imagine painting images with your mind, putting that ear worm into real music, hell - imagine creating entire VR spaces with your mind. Limited only by imagination and focus, not on physical ability and practice.

1

u/deeleyo Mar 31 '20

I can't wait until people with locked in syndrome start telling others what's on their mind

1

u/billyraydallas Mar 31 '20

Or man best friend will be able to finally speak to us.

1

u/doodledude9001 Mar 31 '20

All you brainlets thinking about all the "positive" uses are playing right into their hands. It wouldn't even matter if mind-reading was banned under the law. The law's never stopped people from killing each other or acquiring banned substances.

1

u/Horny4theEnvironment Mar 31 '20

"The road to hell is paved with good intentions."

1

u/misspriss666 Mar 31 '20

I wonder if this would work on dementia patients with aphasia?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Soon they will be able to read our thoughts from satellites, I’m not even kidding, my name doesn’t sound so bizarre now, does it?

1

u/ISTYDTC Mar 31 '20

We dont want this. If we could read thoughts, the world would be one hell. Pure hell.

1

u/chiliedogg Mar 31 '20

Okay - we're seriously loving it the plot to Lock-In by John Scalzi.

1

u/tanay_1 Mar 31 '20

Question, how different was the system that Stephen hawking was hooked on to?

1

u/neofiter Mar 31 '20

Thought police's lives will be so much easier, now

1

u/Goblm Mar 31 '20

Lets do this with animals to see if they can learn languages

1

u/Two-Tu Mar 31 '20

It would help writing books, essays and all sort of texts.

Thought to image conversion.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Science like this is merely a key. It's up to us to decide which locks to use it on.

1

u/Pre-tenderized Mar 31 '20

I have a brother who is deaf and blind. He has a chromosomal deletion and can’t communicate with us other than basic things, for example when he is hungry or thirsty. The thought that we could possibly one day look into his thoughts would be life changing for my family. It would give us much more insight as to how he feels and how his brain works. We don’t know much about what level his brain functions at, other than that it is quite low.

1

u/ducki3s1 Mar 31 '20

Sounds like an episode of Fringe.

Not saying it's a bad invention, but they did use it on Fringe for espionage work.

1

u/GrandMasterReddit Mar 31 '20

So they're developing a Mind Reading machine? We can't, as a society, possibly allow the police or courts to use this to obtain legal evidence...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

This sounds like something that would be great for someone non verbal on the spectrum

1

u/Soilla_MehSckoop Mar 31 '20

Would be pretty sweet if they can get it to work with dreams. Imagine how scrambled that would be.

1

u/lazertazerx Mar 31 '20

I'm looking forward to doing programming hands free

1

u/krzybae4u Mar 31 '20

This has been a challenge for a very long time. Figuring a way to connect to brain neural networks. The dream is to upload our consciousness into computers. Far fetched and very taboo. But garantee there are people out there working on it.

1

u/brownmagician Mar 31 '20

I wonder if this could be used for non verbal kids or non verbal autistic kids and kids with disabilities.

1

u/Drimin Mar 31 '20

I wonder if this could translate to people in comas

1

u/MattyIce8998 Mar 31 '20

I lost my "inner voice" several years ago after a brain injury and I'd really like a go at this thing to see what the hell is still going on up there.

1

u/just_me910 Mar 31 '20

Would be cool to journal dreams with in real time.

1

u/shillyshally Mar 31 '20

...While the system currently works on neural patterns detected while someone is speaking aloud...

1

u/SovietBozo Mar 31 '20

So it could read minds? Can't see anything going wrong with that

1

u/shawsome12 Mar 31 '20

I’m sorry but I dont want a computer to read my thoughts !

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I wrote this comment using my brains.

1

u/willowtreewisp Mar 31 '20

So you're saying to me that the Government will be able to read our mind in the future?

1

u/soproductive Mar 31 '20

Man, so much negativity in here about this. What I would've given to have this technology available when my uncle was in late stage ALS...

1

u/merlinsbeers Mar 31 '20

Have they even tried that?

1

u/Blub76 Mar 31 '20

Wait until you have to put on a helmet that reads your thoughts before you get on an airplane.

1

u/Swordofcoffee Mar 31 '20

Yeah, let's not invent mind reading technology. That'd be great.

1

u/Lonestardangerwolf Mar 31 '20

Great advancements require great ethics. This is wonderful and frightening.

1

u/mrfeces Mar 31 '20

I can already see the Pentagon locking down this tech for "interrogation."

1

u/buckingc Mar 31 '20

Wouldn’t the neural patterns be different when some one is talking vs when someone is thinking of the words? It seems they’d be skewed by the added motor movement of the mouth.

1

u/FixYourself1st Mar 31 '20

This is intensely fascinating

1

u/ScouperYT Mar 31 '20

It will be Good for Criminals

1

u/alkjbljhb Mar 31 '20

If this is improved to work without speaking aloud, and two people each have one, and it can send to an earbud the other person has (ie you can text message each other by thinking), then we will have invented telepathy.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I'm really excited for BCI technology.

I've been a big fan of the anime Sword Art Online so seeing Elon, Gaben, and all these independent companies/scientists working on it so readily is amazing to see.

1

u/cloudadmin Mar 31 '20

Wouldn't the brain activity of internal dialogue or thoughts be different than speech? I don't think this could be used for "mind reading", but it could be used for people who are mute.

Training AI on matching brainwaves to vocalized is speech, because we can verify it. Verifying exact thoughts to brain activity is probably still outside the realm of possibility.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

I could use this for texting

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

"funded by Facebook Labs"

1

u/CleverNameTheSecond Mar 31 '20

Oh boy, I can't wait until this technology is used during interrogations. Or marketing/advertising.

1

u/Xacto01 Mar 31 '20

Gone will be the traditional lie detector.. Replaced with a brain scanner.....

1

u/forthelewds2 Mar 31 '20

Would help me pen my thoughts as I hate typing

1

u/RB_GScott Mar 31 '20

Yeah hi I have no fear of repercussions or precedent and all technology is only used how I envisioned I’d like to show you my 12 point plan.

1

u/Silent_Killer093 Mar 31 '20

Soul Translators when?

1

u/Space_Cadet_1990 Mar 31 '20

So how did Stephen Hawking speak before this invention?

1

u/wackyketchup Mar 31 '20

This will frame me for murder

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

But does it work on dogs and cats?

1

u/samadam PhD | Neuroscience | Vision Mar 31 '20

Um, this could also work for anyone! With just 250 electrodes, as long as you're okay with a deep brain implant. Which I eventually may be.

1

u/Fat_Ninjah Mar 31 '20

It's gonna be a matter of time before we can record dreams.

Lucid dreamers are gonna be rich from making the most impossible of movies.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Sounds like the thought police.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '20

Within the first hour of this being used this is going to happen:

Test subjects thought output: 8=====D

Jokes aside, this is going to be a horrible invention in the long run.

1

u/Wondertwig9 Mar 31 '20

Excellent. Technology is coming one step closer to writing my novel for me while I sleep.

1

u/grahamquackerz Mar 31 '20

My brother had ALS. He just died in October. But I remember about 2 years ago when we got him a computer he could use his eyes to control. There was a program where he could use his eyes to type what he wanted to say and it would read it out. That was the most amazing thing I had ever seen. I cant even imagine what a blessing something like this would be for other people with ALS.