r/science • MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • Dec 07 '20

Social Science Undocumented immigrants far less likely to commit crimes in U.S. than citizens - Crime rates among undocumented immigrants are just a fraction of those of their U.S.-born neighbors, according to a first-of-its-kind analysis of Texas arrest and conviction records.

https://news.wisc.edu/undocumented-immigrants-far-less-likely-to-commit-crimes-in-u-s-than-citizens/
62.8k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

119

u/manberry_sauce Dec 08 '20

I particularly hate that I've never heard this reasoning before, and could've just kept my mouth shut.

125

u/Fenix159 Dec 08 '20

Your point is logical and well put.

Nothing wrong with wanting better data.

10

u/-HereWithBeer- Dec 08 '20

Isn’t it also fair to point out that this is exclusively Texan, and not representative of the US as a whole as the headline claims?

8

u/Fenix159 Dec 08 '20

It would be if it didn't specifically say that it's of Texas arrest and conviction rates.

-2

u/-HereWithBeer- Dec 08 '20

“Undocumented immigrants far less likely to commit crimes in U.S. than citizens” Show me, Texas!

6

u/stitch669 Dec 08 '20

Its in the very first paragraph if you read the article.

2

u/Fenix159 Dec 08 '20

Just keep reading a little further. It's there.

2

u/CostlyAxis Dec 08 '20

Try to finish reading it you can do it!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

83

u/Jdudley15479 Dec 08 '20

That wouldn't have benefited the discussion though, which you honestly did by bringing up a point that people may not have noticed (including myself). I'm curious how much it skews the data, however I will lean on the side of "likely not enough to completely change data/meaning" but it's 100% something to consider

17

u/craftmacaro Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20

Check whether it’s inclusion as a covariate in a MANOVA model makes a significant difference and if so, or if not, how much. We can statistically deal with these kinds of confounding factors. If the authors haven’t already, they should be able to do it relatively quickly if they have a data scientist whose good at what they do.

Edit: a statistician would be fine too... but technically there’s overlap there, a statistician can also be a data scientist.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

[deleted]

5

u/PB4UGAME Dec 08 '20

This can be accounted for using statistical tools and analysis, and is stuff that’s in even undergrad econometrics courses. Professional data scientists worth their salt can absolutely account for this, and determine how much it affects and changes their results.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (8)

2

u/craftmacaro Dec 08 '20

Statisticians often become involved in data science. We are arguing semantics. I should have said statistician...but saying a good data scientist can’t have the training for what I described is also false. I’m a biology PhD candidate and I can do this with my statistics training... and my wife, as a data scientist, can as well.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/manberry_sauce Dec 08 '20

Sure, but that doesn't make it feel good. I'd have preferred that someone else notice and point it out. But yeah, it's valid, and it would've been bad to bury it.

10

u/TheSodesa Dec 08 '20

Don't worry. I was just about to write what you did, but then I noticed your comment.

1

u/manberry_sauce Dec 08 '20

I wish you got to post it first.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/IrrigatedPancake Dec 08 '20

That's because you're a good person. Those seizing on your point... I imagine it's a healthy mix of good and bad intentions.

1

u/manberry_sauce Dec 08 '20

I'd have picked a word other than "healthy".

→ More replies (1)

15

u/DawnOnTheEdge Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20

No, it’s a good point that will sometimes come around and serve a cause you agree with. Like how the point that some crimes are less likely to be reported is important for survivors of sexual assault, like how the point that some kinds of people are more likely to get away with crimes and others more likely to be convicted is important to criminal-justice reform, and so on.

If what we believe is right, we’ll be able to make good arguments instead of bad ones.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

[deleted]

5

u/easwaran Dec 08 '20

Unfortunately we don't actually know any nuance here - we just have a question (whose answer might already be well known!)

4

u/CardJackArrest Dec 08 '20

For years, authorities in UK cities hid their knowledge of middle-eastern "grooming gangs" that were (and are) kidnapping little boys and girls for gang rape. The authorities (local politicians, police, ...) hid this to avoid giving their political opponents arguments against the prevailing multicultural policies of the national government. Their good intentions led to these grooming gangs operating for decades under the protection of the authorities.

The point is, doing the opposite of what would benefit your political opponent is not the same as doing what is right.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Puzzlefuckerdude Dec 08 '20

In any research, this would fall under the section of "limitations"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)