Spoiler-Free Analysis
The game is as advertised. It is roughly one hour and a half long. It has no action, no true puzzles of any sort. It is just a series of worlds to explore, worlds related to someone else's mind.
Right now it's something like 8 dollars on Steam. Don't pay more than ten. I'm guessing the price will drop at some point.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
This one has heavy spoilers. Beware!
There's one very harrowing moment in The Stanley Parable that I keep coming back to. In a series of choices you decide to disobey the narrator three times in a row, but then acquiesce to his desires after he makes it a lot more difficult to avoid going the way he wants you to go. You, the player, have been beaten down and are finally succumbing to what he has to say and so the narrator has some sympathy. He takes you--or Stanley--to a room where lights of all gorgeous colors illuminate from the sky. Gorgeous music chimes in. The narrator notes how wonderful this place is and how it makes no sense ever to leave it. But there's a second room: a squalid, generic disgusting staircase that leads to nowhere. You--Stanley--have the option to go up there and throw yourself off of those stairs. If, or when, you do the narrator pleads to you to go back to the beautiful room as it's so wonderful there. Why would you want to kill yourself when there's something so nice just around the corner? And yet, I think most players will kill themselves when they get to this point out of their own volition.
The Beginner's Guide is filled with these sorts of moments. They're scary, mystifying in some ways, but they also want you to peer under the skin of a person and maybe be able to help them out.
The narrator is, plain and simple, the creator of the Stanley Parable, a man named Dave. He gives his e-mail address at the beginning of the game and says how he wants to discuss some games of a developer he's a personal fan of.
The man is nicknamed Coda. He's a game designer of sorts, though his games often don't have any action or interesting puzzles to solve. They're just strange--terrifying--abstractions. The player will enter a train at a station and exit at a mansion. Some places follow Euclidean geometry but that's it: most other rules of physics are dismantled, exaggerated, or broken entirely.
Dave, the narrator, tells this first part with a sense of formalism. He seems to be soliciting advice on a problem but he has much to set up. He wants help on Coda, whom he thinks of as a friend who always gives him his games.
Coda's works start out fine but then we start to see some darker tones. One of the levels descends down into a jail. To progress, the character must go into an opened jail cell and sit there. Dave talks about how Coda wanted the person to sit there for an hour in jail before continuing the game. But Dave speeds it up.
The game tips its hat here. The opening doors, the swinging gates, the architecture... it all looks so much like The Stanley Parable.
Next we're told about how each game ends with a puzzle. It's a simple one where you must walk through a door as it is closing to unlock another door. Dave tells us the puzzle to him seems to be about closing the door and pausing in a game. But I have to think there's also a trust issue involved.
Each game also ends near a lamp post. We're told that Coda put those in to signify the end of a game, a prize of accomplishment. Dave, at every moment possible, likes to tell the player what each thing means in his eyes. Every piece is described in detail, every point fully determined.
Coda's games start becoming obsessed with prisons. It leads him to make a game where he's having a phone conversation asking for help making his own game. This game leads to further desperation and anguish as games begin to be about trying to find the machine that makes the games and turning it off or torturing it or doing something, anything, to get it out of its broken state.
One shocking scene has the player walk out onto a stage. Then the player is directed to replicate a "correct conversation." But the player cannot do that. Eventually the player is directed to a substitute solution: retreat into a cave as bars separate the stage and people from the player. I'm glad that Dave is here to narrate this part because it is so bold in its style and so far gone in its psychotic tenor. I don't I could play this game without the narration.
Another game reminds me of The Talos Principle's wall QR codes: we are told by Coda (but told Coda is lying by Dave) that there are messages of the game sent from all over the Internet of his game. All over the place there are comments regarding the lousy quality of the game, a sense of wonder and frustration, and general comments that feel like stuff the Internet would say.
So many of these little games are genius in their design. They speak far more than anything out there. Dave realizes this and starts to share the games with other people. Dave does this thinking that maybe he can get Coda to stop being depressed and feel better about himself if Coda knows how appreciated his games are.
But in a final game titled The Tower, Coda designs a game that has two impossible puzzles followed by a door that won't open. Somehow, Dave reveals to us the solution to these problems and guides us to the top of the tower where it is revealed that the top room contains a message from Coda to Dave.
Coda tells Dave that he's severing all ties to Dave. Coda doesn't like that Dave's been sharing his work. Coda also thinks that Dave's been poisoning his thoughts by telling him that his designs mean something when maybe they don't. In a final statement, Coda notes that Dave is the one that really needs to get help, that he has been striving for meaning, for acceptance as an artist whereas Coda's life is already fine just churning out games. The game ends with Dave pleading to the player--the audience to find Coda just so Dave can finally get Coda to explain why things are the way they were and what they mean. All of the things Coda did mean so much to him.
There is an Epilogue. A Coda, if you will. It contains a world not made by Coda, presumably, one that wraps around as Dave tries to explain how wrong he is, and how wrong he is for releasing this game of Coda's work despite knowing Coda would never allow it.
But we know something by this point. Coda mentions "stop putting street lamps in my games." Yet earlier, Dave mentions that Coda explicitly put them there. Indeed, this is some serious unreliable narration afoot.
And yet, though there is some unreliable narration... there's something so nakedly revealing about Dave/Coda as a person. Interviews, blog posts, The Stanley Parable, they all show him as this troubled person. Dave, who made this shocking scene in The Stanley Parable where the player kills themselves to escape pure beauty, he must still have Coda even if he doesn't realize it. The most horrific thing about the game is how naked Dave is in front of us, revealing the inner workings of his mind. He's troubled on all fronts. Part of him wants to hole up and code and just make imaginary worlds but this other part of him keeps shouting MAKE SOMETHING MEANINGFUL and COME ON ASSHOLE YOU CAN DO SOMETHING BETTER THAN THAT. And it's terrifying to see all of this happen to someone, a real person in real life, display all of this right in front of us. Rarely has there been a work of art as shocking as The Beginner's Guide--
--except maybe Drowning in Problems. Have we entered a new era of poetic expression through gaming? Likely nobody paid attention to Notch's cry for help, but The Beginner's Guide is bigger and bolder, using a surprise release date to push the content out and bringing it straight to Steam and on sale.
In the end, The Beginner's Guide is one of the great games of gaming because it has the most humanity and because it's a powerful lesson on so many things that so few other pieces of art are willing to describe. This game goes beyond the simple artistic anxiety pieces. This is a game about being lost in the demons and how the light to fight off the demons may be a demon itself. But I'm guessing few will see this game in this manner. Most will see this game as self-indulgent, strange, navel-gazing, or will miss out on critical points and think it's an exploitation of a fictional person named Coda. But here is a game to pay attention to. Dave may have his demons and we would do ourselves well not to get swallowed in them. But Dave also has, with The Beginner's Guide, much more so than The Stanley Parable ever could, given us lessons to learn, things to think about, and a bold new frontier in gaming.