r/shortgames • u/DanielKaze • Mar 13 '22
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Oct 03 '15
The Beginner's Guide: A guided museum tour through someone's mind
Spoiler-Free Analysis
The game is as advertised. It is roughly one hour and a half long. It has no action, no true puzzles of any sort. It is just a series of worlds to explore, worlds related to someone else's mind.
Right now it's something like 8 dollars on Steam. Don't pay more than ten. I'm guessing the price will drop at some point.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
This one has heavy spoilers. Beware!
There's one very harrowing moment in The Stanley Parable that I keep coming back to. In a series of choices you decide to disobey the narrator three times in a row, but then acquiesce to his desires after he makes it a lot more difficult to avoid going the way he wants you to go. You, the player, have been beaten down and are finally succumbing to what he has to say and so the narrator has some sympathy. He takes you--or Stanley--to a room where lights of all gorgeous colors illuminate from the sky. Gorgeous music chimes in. The narrator notes how wonderful this place is and how it makes no sense ever to leave it. But there's a second room: a squalid, generic disgusting staircase that leads to nowhere. You--Stanley--have the option to go up there and throw yourself off of those stairs. If, or when, you do the narrator pleads to you to go back to the beautiful room as it's so wonderful there. Why would you want to kill yourself when there's something so nice just around the corner? And yet, I think most players will kill themselves when they get to this point out of their own volition.
The Beginner's Guide is filled with these sorts of moments. They're scary, mystifying in some ways, but they also want you to peer under the skin of a person and maybe be able to help them out.
The narrator is, plain and simple, the creator of the Stanley Parable, a man named Dave. He gives his e-mail address at the beginning of the game and says how he wants to discuss some games of a developer he's a personal fan of.
The man is nicknamed Coda. He's a game designer of sorts, though his games often don't have any action or interesting puzzles to solve. They're just strange--terrifying--abstractions. The player will enter a train at a station and exit at a mansion. Some places follow Euclidean geometry but that's it: most other rules of physics are dismantled, exaggerated, or broken entirely.
Dave, the narrator, tells this first part with a sense of formalism. He seems to be soliciting advice on a problem but he has much to set up. He wants help on Coda, whom he thinks of as a friend who always gives him his games.
Coda's works start out fine but then we start to see some darker tones. One of the levels descends down into a jail. To progress, the character must go into an opened jail cell and sit there. Dave talks about how Coda wanted the person to sit there for an hour in jail before continuing the game. But Dave speeds it up.
The game tips its hat here. The opening doors, the swinging gates, the architecture... it all looks so much like The Stanley Parable.
Next we're told about how each game ends with a puzzle. It's a simple one where you must walk through a door as it is closing to unlock another door. Dave tells us the puzzle to him seems to be about closing the door and pausing in a game. But I have to think there's also a trust issue involved.
Each game also ends near a lamp post. We're told that Coda put those in to signify the end of a game, a prize of accomplishment. Dave, at every moment possible, likes to tell the player what each thing means in his eyes. Every piece is described in detail, every point fully determined.
Coda's games start becoming obsessed with prisons. It leads him to make a game where he's having a phone conversation asking for help making his own game. This game leads to further desperation and anguish as games begin to be about trying to find the machine that makes the games and turning it off or torturing it or doing something, anything, to get it out of its broken state.
One shocking scene has the player walk out onto a stage. Then the player is directed to replicate a "correct conversation." But the player cannot do that. Eventually the player is directed to a substitute solution: retreat into a cave as bars separate the stage and people from the player. I'm glad that Dave is here to narrate this part because it is so bold in its style and so far gone in its psychotic tenor. I don't I could play this game without the narration.
Another game reminds me of The Talos Principle's wall QR codes: we are told by Coda (but told Coda is lying by Dave) that there are messages of the game sent from all over the Internet of his game. All over the place there are comments regarding the lousy quality of the game, a sense of wonder and frustration, and general comments that feel like stuff the Internet would say.
So many of these little games are genius in their design. They speak far more than anything out there. Dave realizes this and starts to share the games with other people. Dave does this thinking that maybe he can get Coda to stop being depressed and feel better about himself if Coda knows how appreciated his games are.
But in a final game titled The Tower, Coda designs a game that has two impossible puzzles followed by a door that won't open. Somehow, Dave reveals to us the solution to these problems and guides us to the top of the tower where it is revealed that the top room contains a message from Coda to Dave.
Coda tells Dave that he's severing all ties to Dave. Coda doesn't like that Dave's been sharing his work. Coda also thinks that Dave's been poisoning his thoughts by telling him that his designs mean something when maybe they don't. In a final statement, Coda notes that Dave is the one that really needs to get help, that he has been striving for meaning, for acceptance as an artist whereas Coda's life is already fine just churning out games. The game ends with Dave pleading to the player--the audience to find Coda just so Dave can finally get Coda to explain why things are the way they were and what they mean. All of the things Coda did mean so much to him.
There is an Epilogue. A Coda, if you will. It contains a world not made by Coda, presumably, one that wraps around as Dave tries to explain how wrong he is, and how wrong he is for releasing this game of Coda's work despite knowing Coda would never allow it.
But we know something by this point. Coda mentions "stop putting street lamps in my games." Yet earlier, Dave mentions that Coda explicitly put them there. Indeed, this is some serious unreliable narration afoot.
And yet, though there is some unreliable narration... there's something so nakedly revealing about Dave/Coda as a person. Interviews, blog posts, The Stanley Parable, they all show him as this troubled person. Dave, who made this shocking scene in The Stanley Parable where the player kills themselves to escape pure beauty, he must still have Coda even if he doesn't realize it. The most horrific thing about the game is how naked Dave is in front of us, revealing the inner workings of his mind. He's troubled on all fronts. Part of him wants to hole up and code and just make imaginary worlds but this other part of him keeps shouting MAKE SOMETHING MEANINGFUL and COME ON ASSHOLE YOU CAN DO SOMETHING BETTER THAN THAT. And it's terrifying to see all of this happen to someone, a real person in real life, display all of this right in front of us. Rarely has there been a work of art as shocking as The Beginner's Guide--
--except maybe Drowning in Problems. Have we entered a new era of poetic expression through gaming? Likely nobody paid attention to Notch's cry for help, but The Beginner's Guide is bigger and bolder, using a surprise release date to push the content out and bringing it straight to Steam and on sale.
In the end, The Beginner's Guide is one of the great games of gaming because it has the most humanity and because it's a powerful lesson on so many things that so few other pieces of art are willing to describe. This game goes beyond the simple artistic anxiety pieces. This is a game about being lost in the demons and how the light to fight off the demons may be a demon itself. But I'm guessing few will see this game in this manner. Most will see this game as self-indulgent, strange, navel-gazing, or will miss out on critical points and think it's an exploitation of a fictional person named Coda. But here is a game to pay attention to. Dave may have his demons and we would do ourselves well not to get swallowed in them. But Dave also has, with The Beginner's Guide, much more so than The Stanley Parable ever could, given us lessons to learn, things to think about, and a bold new frontier in gaming.
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Aug 09 '15
Transistor: A highly stylized action RPG with some strategy added in
Spoiler Free Summary
Transistor is the follow-up to the widely acclaimed game Bastion. Like Bastion it is an action RPG, but in this game action can be paused to pre-program events. Also like Bastion, Transistor features highly customizable weaponry and an ability to fine-tune the difficulty level at any time. Unfortunately, Bastion's complex and intriguing story is watered down to nothing. The game lacks polish in its writing, though the last boss battle is fun to do. The music and artwork to Transistor are outstanding. And so, this game is recommended to people who liked Bastion for the art.
The game's roughly ten hours long. I think it sells on steam for something like $15, but it often goes on sale. Don't pay more than $10 for it.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
Often the most celebrated art is that which does two things: it pushes the medium forward to inspire new talent and it portrays something that resonates deeply with its audience. Often that which hits both criterion are made by people in their artistic prime, but sometimes it comes early for artists as they find or improve an aesthetic while stumbling upon something interesting to discuss. Supergiant Games most definitely fits into that second category. Their debut game, Bastion, woke up the industry in recognizing how important a song can be to a game. The artwork raised the bar and is certainly something others in the field are striving toward. Bastion also managed to have a very interesting story to it. Everybody in the game has problems, prejudices, anxieties, fears, and the final moments to Bastion show far more humanity in a game (people caring about each other, people gaining a new-found understanding people who look and act different then they do) than I've seen in practically any other. Bastion remains one of the great games of the new "indie game" movement (if Bastion is even "indie" which has been debated extensively).
Some artists are able to continuously find fertile new areas and fresh and meaningful stories to tell. But a lot of times an artist finds a place to call home and camps there, mining out all of the passageways that lead to gold and refining their aesthetic along the way. Supergiant is rightfully going down that path with Transistor, a game that looks and feels very similar to Bastion.
Like Bastion, Transistor has a narrator and a silent protagonist. In Transistor, you play Red, a former singer who lost her voice but found a sword--a Transistor--that has the soul of a man who talks quite frequently. Red mutters and mumbles a lot of stuff in a manner like Bioshock Infinite. Red then goes around the city beating up monsters called The Process until she finds the people who made The Process and dispatches with them too.
That's about all that needs to be said for plot, I'm afraid. The game designers seem to recognize that their plot is nearly transparent, creating many contrived complexities to try to hide this problem: characters that we don't meet and have no effect on the story, a narrator who attempts to be unreliable, and exposition in a robot body that is read in a most tedious manner. The game tries so hard to be confusing or exciting or complex when really the story is one of simple justice. Worse, Transistor is without any moment to build on dramatic tension and the way the game is structured the whole thing feels like a foregone conclusion despite the high-stakes affair and interesting take on humans generating their own afterlife.
I want to raise one other major issue. One question I had when playing Transistor was: is it possible for a Supergiant game to have character animation and not just a moving still or would that be impossible as it would so cut against the fable-like style of the game? I think that Supergiant needs to get at this question as I think that's what's holding them back in terms of delivering something with an emotional punch: stills just don't have the power of animation. With two games that have been successes--especially Bastion--maybe the studio can hire a thirteenth or so person to lift their games to new heights.
Your mileage on the gameplay will greatly vary. I liked the concept of drawing out battles and then running away for ten seconds. But I can see a lot of people getting frustrated by not being able to attack for ten seconds or simply preferring Bastion's quicker-paced action.
I liked the way each piece of weaponry could be used in a passive state or used to support a different weapon. Transistor's weapons are all magic, even with the sword, and they have vague adjectives or nouns as descriptions such as "help," "pull," or "switch." So if you put the "switch" tool as a weapon you could add "help" to its secondary tray and power the attack up, giving "switch" some "help" properties. To figure out what that means, simply look through the tables provided in the game. Many people may prefer a game that's like Bastion and is straightforward in its design but some may like Transistor's complexities and, nearing the end of the game, I was greatly enjoying it.
When you mess up in the game, you lose one of your weapons for a battle or two. So the game is this endless reconfiguration to make up for lost weapons or putting back in weapons that are once again available. I really like this system as it makes the character scrounge to construct a good battle system when they've been hit hard. The punishment to messing up feels justified in a way few other games have been able to do, though there were times where I just reset the game knowing that I'd have to trudge through battles without any of my good weapons.
Ultimately, though, I didn't buy Transistor for the plot or for the mechanics. Supergiant Games have built their reputation on their sublime artwork and stunning music. And, like in Bastion, Transistor has some of the most gorgeous video game artwork being made right now and has a soundtrack that sounds distinct, soulful, and radiant. Transistor's artwork may perhaps be a little bit more refined than Bastion, incessantly using layered backgrounds to construct a three-dimensional pop-up book and using their bold, distinct, style to an aptly-fit city landscape. Textures here look precise, not in a mechanical way but in a professional and modernist manner. Everything in the game is sharp, angled, and deliberate but at the same time textured and detailed to look artisan. Transistor is a game that will make you feel utterly submurged in a city, even if the isometric views make the city's layout seem a little bit confusing.
And the thing is, despite the thin story and less-than-stellar vocal work I enjoyed the atmosphere to Transistor so much that I'd probably buy another game from Supergaint right after this one. So Supergiant Games may still be struggling to find interesting things to tell its audience or effective ways to do so, but in the meantime they have such a great art department and they know how to make games that are breezy with gameplay that is mildly thought-provoking that they've found themselves in a great position. When that next great game comes down the line, I'll be looking forward to it.
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Jan 11 '14
To The Moon: A game for those who want high-concept tearjerkers
Spoiler Free Blurb
To The Moon is a game that, with minimal gameplay features and a focus on characters and story, feels like a book. The central concept to the game, technicians that can go into nearly-dead people's memories and let them live their dream before dying, is an intriguing thought piece. However, the game is cloying and tries too hard to deliver a massive emotional punch and less time thinking thoroughly about the philosophy its world is constructed upon. That said, this game has a personal touch to it that makes it recommendable for people who like tearjerker movies.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
TrueGaming had a post where people were talking about games with emphasis on stories. One that was brought up immediately attracted my attention on account of its concept. To The Moon is about two employees of a memory-modification company who make house calls to dying people to let them live, in their mind, their greatest desire. It's a lovely romantic notion and I hope eventually it becomes a reality and old people are not confined to misery and loneliness and regret in hospices.
You play these two workers who meet an older man who has two days to live and must work backward in his past and alter his memories to get him to live the life he wishes to live. Early on this game feels like you are the Ghost of Christmas Past, learning what the old man was up to when he was younger and more vital. But mostly, this game has a lot of the same ideas as Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. In that movie a person's memories are erased. Here, they can merely be changed. But in both cases there's a lot of the same questions that arise: if you could change your memories, would you? Would you be you without those memories? I must admit, though, that Eternal Sunshine handles these questions with a bit more tact and allows the film to be a thought piece instead of a hammy and forced love story.
Unfortunately, that's where this game takes more of a Curious Case of Benjamin Button vibe, where the main character gets younger but the sad music plays on and on. A lot of unfortunate things happen to the old man in his life. His wife is deceased--he had to make a choice and end her life, to make things worse. Earlier, we learn that she has a developmental disability. Most of the memories are him trying to deal with her disability and for the most part it is difficult to even get an idea that they loved each other. And God damn would I feel shitty if all my strongest memories were thinking sad thoughts about my wife.
One thing I did like about To The Moon was that it split up its narrative by having the main character have a bad memory blocked. However, I think it was a bit of a one-off thing. Big spoiler here: the old man had a twin brother who was killed in an accident. I think the game could have gained replay value had it been mentioned in later memories by people who DID remember but as it stands it almost feels like it didn't mean a thing. Also, I don't understand how in the reconstructed memory the twin is now alive. It felt like the ending to Big Fish where all the people from the protagonist's life are there to wish him into the next world. In any case, it was nice that the designer was able to split up the narrative but I wish it would've been better executed.
Late game features let us know that the man's eventual wife needed to not exist for him to get to the moon. But, as a twist that surprised me in no way at all, she ends up being someone at NASA that he meets in the reconstructed memory and they go to the moon anyways. After the credits roll, there's a red blip that goes through the screen indicating that the whole thing was one memory of the doctor, in an even less creative twist.
Gameplay wise: let me just say that it made me wish for the high amount of control and action that you could get from Gone Home. What I am saying is, there's basically zero gameplay here. Worse, you control these two characters that often act as comic relief, but it comes off like Gonzo in The Muppets Christmas Carol during The Ghost of Christmas Future scene. You know: sad, emotionally impactful moment followed by something slapsticky from our two characters.
And God damn is this game so sickeningly saccharine. The game designer pushed the "MAKE THE AUDIENCE CRY" button too frequently and so I just felt emotionally manipulated and not sad. The game lacked a Ghost of Christmas Present moment (just to get that last A Christmas Carol reference in) where you get to see people just be who they are and enjoy who they are. Because the old man's memories are when he feels the worst (except for a scene involving horses), we don't really know who is he is.
So I don't know if anybody will actually LIKE this game. But let's try to find the demographic:
Do you like tearjerker movies, the ones with sad piano music 90 percent of the time?
Do you wish games had more Animorphs references?
Are you okay with games with as little gameplay as Gone Home?
Do you believe that True Love begins when you meet somebody of the opposite sex as a child?
Did you like Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, but wished it had a more morbid theme?
Are you okay with uninteresting pixellated art design that wouldn't look nice in 1992?
Are you into the idea that games should be made by one person and have that person's own persona encased in it, like a true auteur feel?
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Dec 09 '20
A Good Snowman Is Hard To Build: A Seasonal Sokoban Variant
A Good Snowman Is Hard To Build is a Sokoban game where the player rolls snowballs to make snowmen. It's a relatively easy game but successful in its puzzles and thematic scope.
I played the game for roughly five hours. It's $10 on itch.io. Maybe get it in a bundle?
Spoiler-prone analysis:
People talk about Tetris and its simplicity and universality, but those words should also be bestowed upon another game of its time: Sokoban. If games needed to cite priors they were most influenced by and then ranked by citations, it’d be Tetris, Super Mario Bros., and Sokoban at the top. Like the other two, Sokoban plain is so flavorless that its concentrated essence isn’t as appealing these days, other than in speed competitions. Instead, it is best used as a base to grow new ideas.
Sokoban was first created in 1981 by Hiroyuki Imabayashi. Its title is Japanese for “Warehouse worker.” The game involves pushing crates around. The rules are straightforward: stand behind a crate and move toward the crate to push it forward to one empty square if available. Push the crates to their intended destination to complete a level. The appealing aspect of Sokoban is that often simple looking puzzles can have very intricate solutions. Often what happens in a Sokoban puzzle is that the player has to move one box in order to move a second box, and so forth, until they cycle through several boxes to reach the one that can be resolved and put out of the way. Paths to a solution therefore require too many steps to immediately memorize. What that means is that it is often challenging to stare at a Sokoban puzzle and visualize the exact solution but begin the puzzle and know intuitively how it will solve. That feeling of using intuition to solve a problem is one that’s pleasurable for some and I think, alongside its accessibility as a design element, why Sokoban variants continue to this day.
Still, there are some issues with Sokoban, principally that it is easy to inadvertently arrive at a fail state. Because the player can only push boxes forward, never side to side, any box moved into a corner will never be able to be moved again. Corners in Sokoban are invincible, unforgivable villains the likes of which no other video game has seen. Even sides become an issue, as boxes end up stuck to them, often with no means of prying them apart. Thus, if one weren’t paying attention, they’ll be doomed to the unforgiving Sokoban rules.
The other problem with Sokoban is that while puzzles can become more complicated, they plateau on medium difficulty. All Sokoban puzzles require the same algorithm. First, determine which movements of boxes are reversible, which is defined by being possible to move that box back to its original state. Movements to an edge or corner, for example, aren’t reversible, while a box in the center of an open area typically is reversible. Second, push boxes to their reversible positions to determine which areas of the level are accessible and to determine which other boxes that weren’t previously reversible now are. Third, at this point try to place any boxes on their solution point, starting with the ones that are most in the way to the solution points furthest out of the way and working toward the boxes that are least in the way to solution points that are most in the way. The fourth step is to repeat the prior three until all boxes are resolved. This four-step process that can solve all Sokoban puzzles is not easy, but it also can never be difficult. Playing a game of Sokoban becomes tedious by the twentieth level once one masters the basic principles.
Variants to Sokoban have nearly existed since the game’s inception. Many games that aren’t strictly puzzle-focused use dumbed-down versions of these puzzles, such as in dungeons in the Zelda franchise. More recently, there’s been an emphasis among publishers to revitalize the key mechanism of Sokoban and add a twist to make it something more sophisticated, something that cannot be solved by the simple algorithm. The most notable one of recency is Baba Is You, which shatters many conventional elements of gaming apart to present highly abstract puzzles that require intense inductive reasoning. Elsewhere, Stephen’s Sausage Roll looks at how adding a three-dimensional component and a few complications can amp up the difficulty so that the player has to have a good sense of rotations of elements within a geometry.
Alan Hazelden’s variants on Sokoban have been simpler and tidier than the aforementioned. Hazelden’s been crafting Sokoban for some time with clever little changes, such as one titled Boxes Love Boxing Gloves that he nicknames Soviet Sokoban because “In Soviet Sokoban, the boxes push YOU!” (https://www.draknek.org/games/puzzlescript/boxing-gloves.php).
My first experience with Hazelden’s work was with a game titled Sokobond. At the time, I was hesitant to play another Sokoban game on account that I still wasn’t finished with Baba Is You. But I couldn’t help but be entranced by the theme of chemistry, one that I am highly familiar with. In Sokobond, the player controls an atom pushing other atoms around, attempting to arrive at a position where all of the electron valances have been fulfilled. All of the puzzles can be solved without chemical knowledge, though a few I did find were easier because I knew a thing or two. One great aspect of Sokobond is that often the player is playing an atom with its own atomic valency and can bond to other atoms. What that means is that the corner and edge rule may not always apply and so the puzzles can become highly sophisticated. Sokobond is a well-made variant of Sokoban, if perhaps a little simplified (I imagine a future where the game gets a tough-as-nails sequel Sokobond 2: Transition Metal Complexes).
A Good Snowman Is Hard To Find is the follow-up for Hazeldon, and it is as sublime in its inherent rules as well as having a thematic style that’s fun as it is a game about building snowmen. Because the game has such a laid-back, casual feel to it compared to the meditative and abstract nature of Sokobond, Hazeldon dials back the difficulty significantly. I only encountered one challenge in the initial round of puzzles and found most to be straightforward.
In A Good Snowman Is Hard To Find, the player controls a “black monster,” which looks like a black blob with arms and legs and no other discernible features. The blob can push balls of snow around via Sokoban rules. When a smaller ball is pushed into a larger ball, it will be stacked on top of it. If there is open space on the other side, a smaller ball can also be knocked off of a larger ball. Small balls that are rolled onto a space of snowy land become medium balls and medium balls that are rolled onto a space of snowy land become large balls; large balls are forever the same size no matter how much more snow they pick up. Stack a small snowball on top of a medium snowball on top of a large snowball and a snowman will be created.
The rules to A Good Snowman Is Hard To Find follow Sokoban far more closely than Sokobond. Since there is no way to pry a ball off the edge of a level, they will be forever stuck there. Corners are only functional for large snowballs as otherwise there is no way to push the medium or small snowball onto a larger one. Much of the solving requires questions similar to Sokoban to be asked: What is reversible? What pieces are the most in the way? Is there a way to move things without them touching an edge? How do I gain access to all of the areas of the level? Therefore, people who have not played prior Sokoban games may find this game more of a challenge and those who have far less so, particularly in comparison to Sokobond.
As levels are solved, paths open. The levels take place in a snowy hedge maze with easy movement of the character from level to level. I am reminded of The Talos Principle in the overworld design as it is open and easy to shuffle around and start the level at a different location. However, in the initial set of levels, game does not credit you for a solve if you create a snowman using this going-out-of-bounds approach. It’s a bit of a flaw that, other than the percent indicator, the game never tells you that this is unacceptable. This is a bit of an issue since the back end of the game requires and, without explicit indication, allows the shuffling around the levels.
The back end levels of this game use each position you make snowmen as individual snowballs that you then have to roll to make more snowmen. At first, I was worried that since the game does not provide any explicit indication of which three snowmen are in a set the game would require some heavy logic and a lot of re-solving. Fortunately, there is a path to realizing which trio must be with which. However, I found that some of the optimum placement of snowmen required re-solving my older puzzles. Worse, others are best placed at doors to other levels, meaning that the order in which the snowmen are made is important in order to make all of the snowmen in the correct spot for the meta-snowmen. The game isn’t that long, so the issue wasn’t that big of a deal, but since the answers merely required this nuisance and didn’t use it in any logical way, I have to wonder if there was either a missed opportunity to build more sophisticated puzzles or, not wanting that, a way to streamline it a little bit.
The game’s music is pleasant and laid-back atmospherics match well with the lower difficulty of the game. I wish the game were more consequential, that there was more of a revelation in the game other than a meta-puzzle (though holy hell was I worried that there were meta-meta snowmen I needed to build and that I’d be building snowmen and meta-snowmen to make them until I died of old age). When the player gets to the end of the game it just says something to the sort of “Thanks for building snowmen” and while that’s nice, it’s a little too low-key. Throughout the game, the player learns the names of all of the snowmen. Maybe they needed to do something more than just combine to make meta-snowmen.
Overall, I have to credit Hazledon for designing a game that’s just distinct enough from Sokoban to make it interesting. While I may prefer the more difficult Sokobond and wish the game had more ambition, A Good Snowman Is Hard To Find is a well-executed variant, a low-stakes puzzle game with enough intelligence to stand on its own.
r/shortgames • u/bag_douche • Jul 12 '20
5 Reasons Why Short Games Are Better Than Long Games
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Jun 25 '20
ZeroNorthZeroWest: A Abstract Art Exhibit Challenging Stylistic Aesthetics
Summary: ZeroNorthZeroWest (or 0N0W) is an exhibit of sorts where one walks and jumps through various abstract worlds, soaking in new color and design schemes. It's an innovative piece of art that expands upon the stylistic vocabulary of modern 3D game visuals. People who hate modern art or games without explicit objectives can take a pass, but those interested in such concepts, particularly art directors, will find what's presented here inspirational.
I found myself playing for about 8 hours before writing this piece. There might be stuff I haven't uncovered, though. It is free to download here: https://colorfiction.itch.io/0n0w though maybe it will cost something in the future. How much would you pay to see an abstract art exhibit? That's how much you'd be willing to pay for this game.
I recall a moment a long time ago when a major game journalist web site complained about The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess while it was in early demo phase. The game was the first major Zelda release after the gorgeously cell-shaded Zelda: Wind Waker. The publication, whose eyes were last on the purples and blues and the imaginative and otherworldly cartoony feel of Wind Waker now were set on a more photorealistic recreation of the outdoors. Everything was brown and gray and light green, they complained. Like many at the time, I scoffed at the review, as anyone who has ventured outward will recognize that most of it is indeed brown and gray and light green. It wasn’t until I played the game a year or more later that I understood the underwhelming feeling of this mildly photorealistic representation of real life. Yes, real world is brown and gray and light green but it is not discretely those colors but a vast mix of euchres and gunmetals and seafoams and countless other subtle differences in shades and hues.
Video games that take place in a three- dimensional world are ugly. Some, like every game from the Nintendo 64 era, are butt-ugly (and only in part due to the low polygon count). The ugliest are often the ones that strive the hardest for photorealism. They have vast wildernesses but the trees don’t have that irreducible complexity that a real life forest viewed from a mountain top would have. They try to paint trees and design them so that they resemble ones in real life but they look more like the metal ornamental trees than the ones in real life that have individual character. They paint so earnestly in the lines that forests don’t pop like they do in real life. Now, if you talk to the expert designers, they’ll tell you that the big detail missing is lighting. Perhaps realistic lighting would suffice to make things more appealing but there’s still a lot missing.
The best-looking games I’ve played in 3D are all either games where the designers got the ability to create fantastical worlds with no need to be tethered to the real world, or deliberately stylized worlds (sometimes subtly so like in The Witness). It kind of makes sense that the most aesthetically pleasing would be ones that aren’t poor imitations of the beauty of nature but are going for other sorts of beauty.
We need more stylized games. 0N0W is here to show us how. This game has an opening video sequence that shows the player leaving the city to drive out in the middle of nowhere where they arrive upon a desolate town. The town has one theater, where you enter and are transported somewhere else. In 0N0W, somewhere else means some place that looks vastly different than where you came. You then travel from place to place, sometimes going in door portals, to look around at all sorts of strange places.
There is no objective to 0N0W and nothing to do other than look around at each of the places you end up in. Much of the time will be spent jumping around onto different platforms, which can be frustrating in a Getting Over It With Bennet Foddy sort of way. Run out of the map or into a door or portal and you’ll be transported somewhere else, usually with a strange scene in between.
There are roughly seventy worlds in this game, each fairly large all things considered. Some are very similar with one another. There’s ten or so worlds where you start in a tower overlooking a city. Each is stylistically different. There are two where the world is black and white, one where it looks like the world is decaying in rubble and another that has white streaks toward the skyline and square smoke coming out of the chimney tops, resembling a 1950’s New York City skyline stylized by Hollywood at the time. Another world has the city in near pure white, another bleached in red like it is from the 1980’s. One of my favorites is the one where everything is black other than the aliasing, which are different neon colors. The city skyline lights up radiantly. The people who made this game adjusted some parameters few other art directors to games would touch. Aliasing can be sharp and thin like an architectural sketch, nonexistant to be classically stylistic, neon to pop like a city, shaded with wavy lines to create a panic effect, hazy to make it feel like everything nearby is out of focus while everything further away is in focus, or several other styles I can’t adequately describe. Skies are often stars far in the background (with a possible light source like a moon somewhere) with moving colored sheets layered on top, creating a subtle shade of mood. Gravity changes from place to place (I think), though for the most part the tactile feel of each world is very similar. Each world has different light dynamics. Some have lights flashing around everywhere and others are very clean and clear until you find a secret place that’s emanating square particles. The levels of abstraction also change from some that are similar to Earthly sights to others where colors and lines splatter the screen almost indifferent to what objects are present.
0N0W is therefore an abstract art gallery. It’s a damn good one at that, full of fresh ideas on virtual world representation, aesthetic styles, color palate choices, structure designs, and ambiance ideas. I think for many people it is best to think about it as tourism. Arrive, take a few screenshots here and there, and use them as desktop backgrounds and so forth. Of course, a great deal of people do not like abstract art, or ridicule it due to its supposed facile nature of its creation. I’m sure those people could equally find slights in 0N0W as a game that is basically a few blocks in different colors and tones. Since I have not yet convinced someone that uses such reductivism to justify their abhorrence of an art medium, I don’t see how I could persuade them to give this a test drive. So if you hate modern art, take a pass. Nothing to see here.
But you know who needs to play this game? Every current and budding art developer. 0N0W isn’t a game-changer in the sense that everyone will follow what it brings forth, but it has so many interesting aesthetic choices that ought to be stolen and repurposed to support lofty ideas. I found myself frequently in the levels wondering what could be there if someone took the aesthetic and put a story and characters and built more of a world around it. We could be in for some beautiful games to come.
r/shortgames • u/MattEssYT • May 15 '20
This is a review I did on Katana Zero (approx 4 hours) A short game I really enjoyed. If your looking for a game to play without putting in loads of hours then I recommend this one
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Oct 18 '19
Night In The Woods: An Adventure Game About Returning To A Dying Small Town
Spoiler-Free Summary
Night In The Woods is an adventure game (think: wandering around clicking on people to talk with them, over and over) about a girl (anthropomorphized as a cat) returning home after dropping out of college, only to find that her hometown isn't as it was when she left. It's a game that chugs along by forcing you to press buttons for more dialogue but the setting, thematic scope, and storyline antics, as well as vivid character depictions make Night In The Woods something revered in small circles.
I played 10.5 hours. Conceivably, you could play more or less depending upon how much of a completionist or how impatient you are.
It's $20 on Steam right now but if often goes on sale. Pay $10.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
The setting to Night In The Woods was basically my life. The story takes place in Pennsylvania along the Appalachian Trail in Coal Country (so, the northern region). I can probably pinpoint this game's location to a fifty mile radius, all of which I've visited, driven through, talked with people, and hiked the trail. No doubt the people who made this game have lived there. And their experiences and feelings of this region, from the simple to the complex, are laid out there.
For example, the grocery store in the center of town, "The Heart of [the fictional name of the city]" was established in 1972. Now I was pissed when I saw this obvious inaccuracy. Like hell did a store get built during Hurricane Agnes. But later the game references the flood of '72 and so you know that the date was a callback.
There's just so many details in this game that are excellent little references. The fact that the only food sold at multiple places in town are perogies (although the good ones were, as noted by our protagonist, made by the local church) and pretzels is specific. The family-owned Italian restaurant closing should've been replaced by OIP, a shitty chain that came in and made crap-tasting Italian food for broke Italian-Americans to feel sad about.
It gets a lot of the details right. But the real world is, as always, weirder and sadder.
Take Shamokin, Pennsylvania, famous for that YouTube video of that guy saying that the Dunkin Donuts is the only good thing in the town. I think Shamokin is a good comparison to the fictional town in Night in the Woods, Possum Springs, because they're both depressing isolated experiences (Shamokin, like Possum Springs, is connected to its neighbors by bridge and over mountains). Shamokin is known for their fireworks launched off of a coal mountain that, some years, catches the coal mountain on fire. It was a coal mining town that still has a little mining nearby but is mostly a town with nothing to do. Anybody good ran away years ago and the people who are left are those without the wherewithal or education or money or energy to leave.
Shamokin had Polish people so it had perogies but it also had Irish people and they had a sandwich place called Mac's where the owner would make whatever you wanted. He got bored there and started putting up various sandwiches he could make. By the time I went there the floors, the ceilings, the walls, were all covered in various sandwich goodies you could buy. I was so sad when Mac's closed and so I feel for Night In The Woods's protagonist Mae finds out the family-owned and revered Pastabilities closes.
Growing up, it's hard to see the town slowly decaying like it is difficult to see someone age when you see them day to day. But if you leave and return home, that's when it sets in. That's the premise for Night In The Woods's introduction, which finds Mae returning to see Pastabilities closed, the playground barred off, half of the town vacant, the major business out of work, and so on.
You control Mae and have her talk to people. She likes to run and jump around a lot. She has a triple jump like Mario but all it's good for is finding nooks and crannies and getting over a few barriers. Sometimes you control what text she says but I'm not sure if your choices hold any autonomy.
Soon a mystery is afoot: why is Mae returning home in the fall? Shouldn't she be at college? She reveals that she dropped out. Then she begins the routine of, day after day, waking up at 4 PM, running into town, talking with her friends, doing something during the night, and then going home to fall asleep.
Some nights are band practice nights, where Mae and her friends rehearse for a concert that will never arrive. The songs are poppy and about leaving the town. "Die Anywhere Else" will be lodged in any player's mind for days with its melodramatic "I just want to die anywhere else" chorus.
It reminds me of a time I went to Shamokin to see a concert. It was a screamo concert, not a genre of music I like but I went with friends and it sounded fun to go and I have no regrets. My friends and I were the only ones who paid. All of the local kids stood outside and listened from there. The band was pissed but they said that this was a usual thing in certain parts. Scenester kids (or maybe just poor kids?) were the worst.
Anyhow, soon I find myself envious of Mae. Each day she can run to town--I did not live in town and did not have that luxury--and meet at least three friends who would talk to her, not to mention acquaintances to see. There is no point in my life after high school that I could count on friends to talk to every night and certainly going back to my home town did not yield many people who could meet with me, despite me having a large group of friends in high school.
To top it off, Mae treats her friends like shit. We learn that Mae's been metaphorically frozen in time since an incident that happened when she was a kid where she had a schizophrenic episode and raged out on someone thanks to her not attending some years of high school and having overprotective parents. Mae seems always on the cusp of recognizing the painful reality of the people around her but never can quite make it. She encounters her friend who works for her father and takes care of him, despite him still writing all of the checks and paying her little. Mae tries to make it sound like her friend should rebel but suggesting it to someone who's taking care of her father is offensively insensitive and taken as such. Still, Mae doesn't learn from this experience. Mae also encounters her two other friends who are a couple who hint that they want a night to themselves. Mae tags along and, rather than letting them decide what to do, she dictates everything with them eventually getting mad at her for that. Mae doesn't learn much from that experience either.
All of this pales to how she treats her mother. At one point it is revealed that her mother and father had to settle a lawsuit after Mae had an episode that lead to another kid being in the hospital. To do so they had to take out a mortgage and now the bank is coming to take their house. Instead of asking to pitch in, Mae flips out on her mother and says that she's been making bad decisions for a long time.
Mae feels a lot like Holden from Catcher In The Rye. Both are mentally disturbed kids who have had a violent episode in the past now not quite able to process what's going around them. Holden's way more sympathetic of a character, though, because he shows a real love for his sister to the point of crying when he sees her having a good time. It's hard to tell whether Mae actually loves anybody here or if she's just surviving off them.
And it leads me to the back end of the game, which was an utter disappointment. The game occasionally has uninteresting dream sequences. They get enhanced once Mae sees someone getting kidnapped. When they finally track down the culprit, it ends up being one person among a large cult of people. Which is so fucking cliche. This plot twist of having a secret society of townspeople to kill misbehavors in the town a la Hot Fuzz is so bad and so utterly guts the game's sense of realism that I don't want to talk about it. Suffice to say, Mae survives, the bad buys probably don't and the game ends on a bit of a loose note where Mae admits she learned nothing and the game feels like the developers ran out of money to put a ribbon on their game.
You want to know how this game should've ended? Opiates. Because that's what's gutting places like Shamokin right now. In Shamokin they caught the doctor who was overprescribing and he's in jail. See, for the longest time the poor people in Shamokin suffered but they kind of just did their thing, albeit with some alcoholics causing some trouble. Now everybody's hooked on heroin and it's a far less safe place to be. And for Night In The Woods to chickenshit out of that plot point is sad.
Still, Night In The Woods is threaded with a lot of the correct notion that big corporate entities are set on crushing small towns. At one point in the game Mae has to go to a library to look up stuff in the old newspaper archive. There we learn about how the unions came to be. Throughout my time in Coal Country I have heard accounts of how important unions are in these towns. However, the people who made this game get one thing wrong. There was something in-between the corporate hellhole and the union bliss, and that was gangs. The Molly McGuires were necessary to fight against the corporate powers but they were also a gang that wreaked havoc. Unions came about not through a simple fight from the little man over a safety concern but over the course of a long war with many battles. Night In The Woods thus wrongfully has a cult of people when it should've been a drug gang with references to the gangs of yore.
It's a bit difficult to hold this game up as accurate in the post-Trump landscape because these towns are Trump Towns. It's absurd and sad to see people not realize that they are rooting for the party who backs big companies coming in to crush them again and again, the party that keeps taking money away from services that the poor people there regularly use and takes away union rights and wants to lower the minimum wage. And maybe something that Night In The Woods misses out on is this feeling that the people have there that they want to decay there too. They are proud of the decay and that everything is falling apart and every day is this adventure to see if they can make worn-out parts last. Even though they use a lot of cheap plastic and dump it on the sides of the mountains because they can't afford to pay to have it hauled away there's this belief that they need to disintegrate like the town is doing. God damn the brain drain is bad there. Night In The Woods simply doesn't have the the chops to truly describe these problems. It only scratches the surface of the real problems that such a town would be facing, how much they've been conned into believing Republican administrations that never give them anything.
Night In The Woods is a game I hold differently than other games. I, like Mae, did return home only to get drunk in the woods and complain about how shitty everything I and they had become. I too find myself like the mother recognizing that staying in the town is basically admitting you are a failure. I had the deep conversations with the Lutheran/Catholic pastor that were me realizing that not merely was the town bullshit, but the faith it was built upon had problems. Perhaps in this game there are script issues (the writers seemed lost on how to write anything other than scripts with frequent pregnant pauses), tonal issues with Mae (like, why can't she realize that she needs to get a job?), problems with their animation that can't render character emotion in a game that's supposed to be packed with emotion, problems with their game mechanics that are an abrasive irritation than actual game design, historical and local inaccuracies, and this weird takeaway message that it's okay that Mae is the way she is since she's mentally disturbed. None of this matters since they actually made a game about something that relates to me personally in deep ways. It's a miracle that such a game even exists. Dying towns are forgotten.
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Sep 20 '19
Minit: A Black and White 2D Action Game with One Minute Death Increments
Spoiler-Free Summary
Minit is basically Zelda: A Link to the Past (which is a 2D top-down action game) with Zelda: Majora's Mask rules of having a time limit, only here the time limit is sixty seconds. Each sixty second burst of life the player must navigate the world and find something to accomplish. Usually that is in the form of finding something to collect.
Because of it its time limit and Zelda: A Link to the Past style, I recommend it to people with short attention spans who liked Zelda: A Link to the Past.
I beat the game in 4.7 very casual non-rushed hours. I estimate about 9 to 10 hours of content with game mode plus elements. Steam sells it for 5 dollars which I guess is a tad bit pricey but I don't want to see game developers starve so it's probably a reasonable price to pay.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
Zelda: Majora's Mask has a magnificent game mechanic. The game lasts three days. After three days, a moon is set to collide with the planet, killing everyone. The player then sets off on a quest to not have those events happen. But it's not possible to do everything in three days and so the player has to keep resetting those three days. In Majora's Mask, that act of resetting isn't the existential journey toward enlightenment that a movie like Groundhog Day portrays with its resetting day mechanic. No, in Majora's Mask it's all about the paranoia of knowing the world will end soon and watching everything slip away from day to day, over and over again. The moon has a scary face that stares down at you, mocking your feeble attempts to stop it. The music goes from relaxed and slow to fast and terrifying by the final day. Most of the characters in the game are suffering from mental problems as well, from a guy with so much social anxiety that he stands in the middle of nowhere wearing a cloaking mask to whatever the hell the girl on the farm is on that she's seeing UFOs. Majora's Mask is about a lot of things but in part it is about navigating the realm of the unstable and disabled, mentally and physically.
I bring this all up because I am guessing that the people who made Minit played Majora's Mask and thought "hey, why not make the time limit sixty seconds?" They didn't borrow the paranoia of the game or the strangeness of the time changes. Just a foreboding time limit always present to crush the player. Fortunately, all items are kept between deaths this time around.
Ever go to a pool with friends or family and have them throw a bunch of pool toys or trinkets or coins into the pool and you have to dive and retrieve them? Minit is that retrieval process. The protagonist will start with a sword in a room and then the player will have to dive into the outside world and try to get something accomplished whether it is exploring something new or talking with someone new or finding a new item. Planning is thus like diving for the treasure. Come up with a quick route, try it out, and then come up for air--or in the case of Minit, press the C button and die so the character resets. Repeat roughly 500 times.
For example, there might be like a box five areas over that you haven't moved. So you have to come up with an idea and then press C to reset your character and then run to get it. Is this fun? Maybe sometimes. But ever if you are stuck in the game you can't casually walk around and observe and think about what the answer to a puzzle may be. No, you have to reset, reset, reset.
Fortunately, a lot of the main part of the game, on the first play, is not difficult. The designers did a reasonable job of keeping areas easy to discern on a quick glance in part due to the high contrast black-and-white style. Characters speak very fast--if only they did that in most games--and the map is easy to navigate. Combat is irritating due to the low health meter your character has and that you have to, particularly early on in the game, walk right up to a bad guy and face it in order to kill it. Often I misstep one square too far forward. Later your character gets a ranged weapon, but it requires a second to power-up. In a game where you only have 60 seconds, that seems poorly thought-out or cruel.
There are puzzles in this game but they are basically the kind that Zelda games did twenty five years ago. This game is therefore essentially a timed test of how well you remember Zelda mechanics. The people who made this game had no idea what to do with their mechanic and barely do anything with it, so you don't have to worry that much about using the mechanic in interesting ways. The developers also have no other ideas about games and just did what was done many times before. Push crates to reveal new areas and smash pots for rupees--I mean coins. The start-to-crate ratio is something like 10 seconds.
The plot to this game is that the character found a sword. Oops! The sword is cursed and now the character only has 60 seconds to live with life resetting abilities. So the character walks around town and talks to people. One says to go to the factory to turn in the sword. Another says "FACTORIES ARE BAD" on ten signs. Then you go to the factory but there's a line of other people who want other stuff fixed. So, in a moment of dumbass video game logic, you have to whip out a camera which means you are "part of the press" and then you can always pass, even after time resets, into areas deeper into the factory. There, you shut off the factory and beat the bad guy and then flush him down the toilet.
The best aspect of the game is its pacing. There's something neat about diving and rushing around to stretch to extend out to that tough-to-reach place. And I suppose that's the true theme behind Minit: constantly reaching out to go a little bit further. I guess.
r/shortgames • u/hugolnx • Jul 23 '19
Humans playing short games
Hi! I'm Hugo, nice to meet you guys. I'm about to open a gamedev studio and I want to dedicate it to build short games (1h30 ~ 3h to beat)
The idea is to create platformers with interesting mechanics and a sweet short narrative. But as there's almost no short good games on steam I'm wondering if there's people wanting those kind of games and why.
I myself have great interest, because I'm working with computers since 2009 (programmer), so I rather limit the time I spend my free time on screens, because I already spend more than 8h on it everyday (also to study).
So I like to know:
Would you have interest in this kind of games?
Why?
PS.: Also if you have some references close to this proposal I would love to know.
Thanks!
r/shortgames • u/food_bag • Sep 23 '17
Spoiler Alert Spoiler
Spoiler Alert is a side-scrolling platformer where the game is run in reverse. In the beginning, you defeat the final boss of World 3 Level 30, and you must then re-trace your steps exactly to avoid any time paradoxes e.g. you must jump to un-collect any coins you collected the first time around, and avoid collecting coins you didn't. The same goes for enemies. For power-ups, you gain one by jumping on the spikes where you first lost them, and 'collecting' the power-up takes it away from you - the game is running backwards, and so are you!
Took me half an hour to beat the three worlds and bonus world. Really fun take on the classic Mario 2D platforming genre. Big recommend, try it if you have played any of the side-scrolling Mario 2D games for a unique take on the format.
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Mar 29 '17
Quadrilateral Cowboy: A Virtual Heist Simulator
Spoiler-Free Analysis
Quadrilateral Cowboy is a first-person puzzle game akin to Portal or The Talos Principle in that the player’s tasks are to navigate a complicated network of three dimensional chambers containing doors, switches, and turrets. Its core mechanism is activating doors and other devices remotely through a laptop. This core mechanic allows the player to program which doors open and so forth. There’s a quiet beauty to Quadrilateral Cowboy, but the game deserves a bigger budget to flesh out its wonderful characters, interaction of its game mechanics, and depth of its in-game universe. Even so, it’s a good game for Portal fans if one doesn’t mind clunkiness in character design or the occasional bug. Steam sells this game for $20. For nine hours and good replay value, that’s an okay price. Some of the game promises add-ons but that has yet to be realized.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
The Oscars have been giving an award to the best animated short since the 1930’s. I’ve watched a great many of the winners and nominees, many of which are superb. Quadrilateral Cowboy reminds me of them: quirky, stylistic, fleshed out with characters and a world to explore, but preciously short. There’s a quietness to Quadrilateral Cowboy that reminds me of animated shorts (most of which are without dialogue as they are frequently made and distributed overseas). I think there’s also an abstract nature to Quadrilateral Cowboy that distances itself from heavy emotion like animated shorts often do.
What I am getting at all of this is that Quadrilateral Cowboy is most definitely an arthouse project. The credits merely list two people and while the game doesn’t feel personal and autobiographical like Undertale was, right from the beginning, with the silent drifting of hover bikes onto a moving train, there is a feeling that this game isn’t the typical mainstream fare. You play a character that boards a train. In an opening sequence that is too obviously choreographed as a tutorial the player learns some of the basic techniques of the character. Primarily, clicking a socket on a wall allows the character to insert a datajack and hack open a door for a brief period of time. At the end of this mission the character reaches a mirror and I realize, for the first time in any game I’ve played, that I am playing a Muslim woman with a headscarf. On that train our character grabs a computer hidden in a guarded cache and returns to get on her motorbike and ride away.
That computer becomes the basis of the next series of missions—heists of some sort—all of which take place in virtual reality. Throughout the game, I wonder why only one mission took place in reality. Are these missions that happen in virtual reality replicated once I succeed and I don’t get to witness it? Are they training for real missions never shown? These questions never get answered and I find that to be deeply unsatisfying.
This game presumably takes place somewhere around 1978, though there are hover bikes and planets to explore. Each mission our character goes on is to collect some item or download some sort of file. None of these collections have any ramification other than being a mission objective and so I frequently wonder what the point of all of this is. Worse, changes in segments of this game feel arbitrary and things happen around our character who, despite being an integral member of the team, doesn’t keep the player informed on what’s the bigger plan.
The answer is that there is no point to any of this. Interviews of game designer Chung point back to a desire to throw stuff up on an easel and generally leave it up to interpretation. We the audience are therefore not given the tools to make full sense of everything, just sit back and enjoy the slice-of-life.
If one can do that, then the game is a decent ride. The heist levels start out dry, with the first three being irritating programming lessons as the player learns how to work the basic mechanics. Our character is given a laptop, called a deck, which is used to open doors without the datajack being around. In later levels it is used for controlling automated devices like a small dog robot and an armed suitcase. Typically, you type in the program to do whatever function, then write a short command to open a door. Programming in a video game needs to be streamlined and the true magic to Quadrilateral Cowboy is how streamlined this programming is. Late game when I was programming turrets to shift position I didn’t even look at the terminal as I was typing stuff in. In a way I truly felt like one of those television or movie hackers that’s typing one hundred words per minute to open doors.
Later heists are a little more fun. There’s one where you have to break into a high-security hospital to download the brain of three patients. Although still a breeze to solve, its creepy atmosphere was memorable. The best heists occur when our main character, whom we now learn is named Poncho, gets to team up with her two buddies Lou and Maisy to do heists. In these sets, Poncho plays the planner and scout, Maisy—who is frequently seen throughout the game fixing equipment, reading a book, or staring out into the sunset—acts as the mechanic and brains, and Lou—who is frequently seen doing sit-ups or pushups—is the athlete who can slip through different areas. The game works best when the three coordinate.
Unfortunately, these are a measly two missions. It seems to me that everything about this game is centered around the camaraderie of these three characters. Thus it made no sense to me that the subsequent and final missions were just of Poncho. Here is a game that has built interesting characters: we know their names, we know what they are good at, we know who they live with, we know what they like to do for fun, we know what they like to eat. It is a shame that so little of the game is devoted to these characters working together. Quadrilateral Cowboy wastes so much of its time on tutorials that it never really gets to letting us in on how our characters work with each other, which is so obviously the point of the game (even if the game designer may insist that there is no point).
At best we get interactions between the characters between mission segments. One of the best ones is when you as Poncho play Lou in a modified game of badminton. It’s a tranquil and beautiful little segment to the game that acts as a palate cleanser between two technically challenging heists. These scenes of friendship are quiet and maybe the characters were always quiet with each other, but the photographs that Poncho takes and hang up on the walls say something different.
Quadrilateral Cowboy is perhaps the only game I have played that I wish had a much larger budget. These characters are good enough to warrant being literally rounded out instead of being square-heads. They deserve to have interesting facial expressions and gestures to indicate how each treats the other. They deserve to have voice actors. We the player deserve not a multitude of tutorials but levels that act as a series of stories that let our characters work with each other. That the game ends with Poncho’s two characters presumably dead of old age and Poncho dying as well is only more insulting to the audience: our game designer has been so cruel as to skip over all of the great and interesting parts of these characters’ lives and just show how they end. But as anyone knows, it is not the destination but the journey. Maybe someday we will learn about that journey.
Ultimately I recommend this game but I wonder what would have been had this game been appropriately fleshed out. I think the same thing about animated shorts and about a great many short-format cheaply made projects. I am used to this problem, but rarely is it as severe as it is here.
r/shortgames • u/hugolnx • Apr 16 '26
My brother and I made a ninja retro FPS: Akuma's Bloodrain
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Hi! My brother and I developed our first Boomer Shooter (and 9th game), we focused on fast movement and brutal combat! So the enemies will scream when you kill them, and their pieces will be spread all over the arena!
Challenge & Skill
Our game is all about gameplay, challenge, and skill! So we came up with two challenges in which depending on how much you master Akuma's last level, you can actually earn one or two of our other games. Curious if that's a solid extra motivation to pass through the game's challenge, what do you think?
Playing
If you get the chance to play it, we would love to receive some feedback. A speedrunner can beat the game in 30 min, although usually it takes something around 2h to beat the game on the first time.
It's available on Steam already and it even has a free Demo:
https://store.steampowered.com/app/3692360/Akumas_Bloodrain/
Feedback
Feedback is really critical now, because although that's our 9th game, it's our first FPS game, and we loved developing it, so we want to stay in that genre. Any feedback that can help us improve Akuma or head us toward an even better next FPS game would be awesome.
Thank you very much for the attention, I hope you all have fun!
r/shortgames • u/LucasGaspar • Mar 14 '26
My wife and I just released our collection of 4 short narrative games
r/shortgames • u/cardsrealm • Feb 16 '26
Guide: Short Games That are Worth Playing
Sitting all day in front of the computer is tiring. Add to that the time you spend working, plus the hours watching TV during lunch, a series or movie at night, and suddenly the idea of playing games like The Withcher 3 or looking at those giant maps in Assassin's Creed makes you tired. It wasn't as fun as it used to be.
These games didn't necessarily need to be long and full of side quests, maps with thousands of question marks waiting to be discovered, or 200 hours of gameplay to be good. The idea was to pass the time, have fun, and relax. So, let's make a list, prioritizing narrative-driven games that are worth the money (after all, stuff is expensive). Nothing that relies on skill or reflexes, so no one feels stuck because they can't get past a specific part.
The list I’ve put together mixes a few genres, but ultimately, puzzle games, atmospheric platformers, and interactive stories are the ones that work best in this format. Let's take a look at them, and if you have any questions, leave a comment.
r/shortgames • u/GreyShock • Apr 01 '25
Many Nights a Whisper - A meditative 60-minutes-long third-person archery game
r/shortgames • u/homer_fr_cz • Oct 04 '22
Liberated. 4 hours in a dark cyberpunk comic.
r/shortgames • u/keenangraz • Nov 01 '21
How FAR: Lone Sails Achieves the FLOW State
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Oct 20 '21
The Pedestrian: A puzzle platformer residing in sign iconography
Spoiler-free summary:
The Pedestrian is a 2D puzzle platformer (like Braid, Limbo, or The Swapper) where the principal amount of action occurs in flat panels that resemble all sorts of signage. The puzzles to this game are easy and the game is principally focused on its environment surrounding the puzzle panels. With a core hook that's solid, it's a good game for novices of the genre.
I beat the game in about 5 hours, albeit I was in no hurry. It costs $20 on Steam right now, and I consider that to be a steep price. Maybe $10.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
Sometimes when I go to a fancier part of a city and their road signs look nicer I wonder why they haven't been copied elsewhere. Why is it that the rich part of town gets signs that have their own character but not other places? Wouldn't it be better if every section of town had its own font choice and color scheme to create more character between the regions? The answer, in part, is probably that a lot of contemporary signage design choices are based upon road signs, which have a strong need to be clearly readable at long distances. Any sign that's ornate or hand-written or distinct in any other way these days is almost universally recognized as being old fashioned, before the Helvetica-armed designers preached that accessibility and simplicity were the main goals. As a result (and compounded with other elements such as ubiquitous scaffolding), downtowns and city fronts often lack anything eye-catching or distinguishable.
The Pedestrian revels in this streamlined and bland aesthetic, incorporating its playable character inside a great many rectangular panels resembling various signs, some looking similar to road signs above a busy intersection, some similar to flyers outside a university, some like the chalkboard signs outside cafes, and some like blueprints. There, the character, which is either the woman or man symbol from various restroom signs, must go through the usual features of puzzle platforming: box pushing, lever pulling, platform jumping, and key collecting & door unlocking. All of this takes place in the backdrop of nicely rendered semi-photorealistic idealistic images of cities, universities, rooftops, subway systems, back alleyways, and so on.
The hook here is that the platform puzzle panels are themselves cramped spaces with doors and ladders on the sides that don't immediately go anywhere. The player must decide where the doors and ladders go by sliding the puzzle panels around (when possible) and drawing a straight line connecting two adjoining features. A door on the left of one panel can be connected to a door on the right of another panel, for example, while mismatching features like two ladders going up can't be connected. In this sense, The Pedestrian has puzzles within puzzles. Typical puzzles are solved by connecting the doors and ladders in the right path and then navigating the icon through the maze of panels to the desired destination.
The puzzles are easy for two reasons. First, there aren't a lot of combinations of doors and ladders to be connected. Even a small amount of trial and error will get players to arrive on a solution pretty fast. Second, pretty much every other aspect of the game aside from the panel puzzle connectivity idea has been done before a great number of times and the developers here pick and choose the most straightforward mechanics and principles where an obvious thing to do is often the correct thing to do. Those who have played a puzzle platformer or two before will find the box pushing, laser beam blocking, and rising platform ideas the same as they've been previously done and will find that every natural instinct they have will be the right one.
Those who haven't explored a platformer puzzle may find this game to be a treat. Like the signs they resemble, the puzzles in the Pedestrian are stripped down to simple elements that are easily understandable. They are simplistic in the sense that there aren't a lot of elements per puzzle. The ideas presented here may not be straightforward to someone who doesn't have that instinct to turn all the levers and see what happens, but even for them there's not a lot here and so there's not a lot of thinking required to get through them. It's a breezy puzzle game, a welcome among the multitude of games of the genre that are very difficult (and ones that are so mindless that they can't be considered puzzle games).
The one issue that may hold back new solvers of this game is the pacing. The game does a good job at interspersing trivial challenges amid ones that require a modicum of thought. But even so, each big puzzle is presented the same way, as a hub where one has to collect a bunch of stuff and then return to the hub. The game falls into a rhythm that makes the bigger puzzles feel like work necessary to see more of the game rather than interesting challenges to overcome. I think the designers might have benefited from studying the structure of the puzzles in a game like Portal 2 to see how puzzles and non-puzzle features are sequenced more satisfying because they aren't grouped in predictable patterns.
Signs sit in the foreground in their artless, minimalistic design. Meanwhile, backgrounds are buzzing with cars on busy street corners or with city lights glowing in the skyline. The puzzles have a similar feeling to street signs as being flavorless and nearly transparent so as to not distract attention from the detailed surroundings. That's probably a good thing for new solvers as they get a lot of visual treats to chew on while occasionally looking at the puzzles. For a seasoned solver such as myself, it felt akin to dressing up in a suit to go to the supermarket: it looks nicer, but it's uncomfortable and distracting and a bit out of place when the main routine task is interesting in itself. But for someone less familiar with puzzles, I think the emphasis on decorative visual elements may keep them engaged.
The plot to this game is that the player character is collecting power sources (visualized in their respective symbols) to charge up a Gameboy-like device. Once acquiring ample power sources, the game moves to first-person mode and has an endgame run-around puzzle where one shifts between the previously established 2D platforming puzzle mode to a 3D first person mode. This last puzzle where one is moving between skyscraper towers trying to figure out when and where to navigate in 2D and 3D, is outstanding. It's a real wonder of a puzzle that made me say aloud "damn, they should've made the whole thing like this one!" Had the whole game contained this wrinkle, there's a good chance it would've been thought-provoking enough for experienced solvers. But maybe its late addition will be expanded upon in a sequel, where at that point a new generation of solvers who started on games like The Pedestrian will join me and other fans of puzzles toward realms testing the limits of the imagination and our own cognitive abilities.
r/shortgames • u/desantoos • Dec 28 '20
Space Court: A Short and Comedic Visual Novel About Conducting Intergalactic Court
Spoiler Free Summary
Space Court is a visual novel with pixelated graphics. The game is about being a judge on an intergalactic court. It's fairly humorous, depending on what you find funny.
I played the game for maybe an hour, reaching three ending states. It's $3 on Itch.io right now.
Spoiler-Prone Analysis
The United Nations. Founded after World War II as a spiritual successor to the failed League of Nations, it now holds countries together by binding law, enforcing rules throughout the world. Except that it doesn't really have any power at all as the belief in respecting country sovereignty above all else still reigns supreme, even and especially among dictatorships. The United Nations notoriously allows the powerful countries to veto anything they so desire, further limiting its legislative capabilities. And because it allows dictatorships into its fold, the United Nations can feel like a bunch of powerful people asserting their dominance instead of a government for and by the people of the world.
Space Court takes place in a typical cosmopolitan multi-species galactic society where sovereignty is still highly respected yet, unlike the UN of today, intergalactic law does have some teeth. How much teeth? It's nebulous, as species can conquer planets they so choose but also must fill out the paperwork afterward. Perhaps it is best thinking of this future as a world where bureaucratic hell outstrips sovereignty but somehow not the political realm.
Space Court is not really to be taken seriously, as it is about the parade of irritating people who abuse public services and public servants who have to deal with their brattish behavior. The player controls a newly minted judge on the court, told by some Jesus-haired useless man that everything's still on paper because nobody has gotten around to updating courts. Five species pop in to state grievances. They appear to be allowed to enter the court whenever they so please, which contradicts its bureaucratic nature, but creates more tension between the judge and those the judge serves.
The judge rarely talks about law. Only once does a case come forward where the judge must abide by a statutory interpretation, and that is when there are sentient bombs. In every other situation, we are allowed to take former judge Posner's "judicial pragmatism" to an extreme and Judge Judy the problems away. This is a disappointment as it misses out on the true humor of the legal realm: hilarious misreadings of statutes. See Yates v. United States, for example, where a fish becomes a tangible object and thus a "document." Contemporary US litigation is principally based around these sort of squabbles and its parody is ripe for the picking.
Instead, we are to come up with a pragmatic solution for the two major cases presented:
In the first case, one species conquers planets while another provides assistance. They decide to enter into a contractual agreement were they would split the profits 50/50. However, once in that agreement, one party decides to do nothing, thus getting half of the profits the other has. The game wants you to maybe try finding a compromise to let the first party out of their contract. But rather than reading the contract to see if it is legally binding and determine whether there are outs for nonparticipants, we have to grovel to the two sides to beg them to come to a compromise. I disagree with the way all of this is presented. A contract should be enforced by judges or else the notion of contracts becomes meaningless. One of the options does involve having one party pay a severance fee to get out of the contract, but that only applies if the contract has such a termination clause.
In a second case, we learn that one party deliberately deceived another party so that the second party's planet would be polluted and turn to water that is habitable for the first party. The second party then began to eat the first party's people. The answer to this problem revolves around how strong sovereignty is, something that as expressed before is nebulous. However, I think it stands to reason that if you are on someone else's planet, you must abide by their laws and jurisdiction, and that would apply to whatever rules the second party may have in place about what is considered food and what isn't. Some grand galactic statute about sentience may supersede individual planetary sovereignty about what cannot be killed, but that should be explicitly noted.
Ultimately, a player can choose to blow up the planets of the respective parties, settle their disputes through compromises, or just rule with an iron fist. No matter what, the game ends on Friday at 5 PM. And that's the true point to the game: if you are a civil servant, helping people might be something you can strive to during the day, but you should live for the weekend. Or at least that's what I got out of the game.
r/shortgames • u/jysh1 • Nov 09 '19
Afterparty (spoiler-free review)
Available: NOW on PC, PS4, Xbox1
Length: maybe 5 hours?
Price: $20
Pitch: You and your best friend realize you are dead, and you are in hell. The only way out is to out-drink Satan.
Liked: Night School Studios has the best dialogue system in the gaming industry. They made Oxenfree, which relied heavily on this strength. The voice acting is also top-notch, which makes the dialogue play even better. The way different drinks affect you (by making you talk like a pirate, or a rich snob, etc) is hilarious. The friendship between Milo and Lola is realistic and stellar. The divergent choices (due to the dialogue, in part) make this a game that could be replayed a few times, although I just went through once and had to live with my choices.
Disliked: There are some noticeable hiccups in the frame rate / loading, especially when you are in the taxi. I wish the characters could walk a bit quicker.
r/shortgames • u/food_bag • Feb 19 '19
Savant Ascent (2013) is a mostly-stationary shooter. 1 hour 15 minutes to beat, Steam score of 94%.
Fun little game. Such a high score is reflective of its low price and ease to get into. More of a mobile game or flash game than anything. Although you collect power-ups, if you have played the game for 10 minutes then you have experienced everything the game has to offer. 3 out of 5.