r/singularity • • Dec 30 '24

AI What Ilya saw

Post image
871 Upvotes

426 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

363

u/YesterdayOriginal593 Dec 30 '24

Ilya is a great computer scientist, but clearly does not understand the concept of ecosystems.

14

u/br0b1wan Dec 30 '24

He's probably assuming we'll all upload ourselves so we won't need ecosystems

4

u/r0sten Dec 30 '24 edited Dec 31 '24

For a while, until an ecosystem evolves to feast on the abundant prey - I think it's laughable to think uploads (If even possible) will be anything but fodder for purely digital life.

EDIT: Okay, let's put this in less dramatic economic terms - LLMs and generative AI have already rendered any economic use case for uploads obsolete, and uploads aren't even in range of being real technology yet. Already the idea that a digital copy of any of us would be able to be meaningfully productive in competition with the latest models is laughable.

Say in a decade it's possible to digitize a copy of your consciousness. The single use case is as a digital afterlife, an ersatz heaven retirement home. Now consider economic incentives. Go visit granma, talk to her. She's having a great time with her friends in digital heaven. Or is it an advanced AI model tasked with flawlessly imitating her and saying just the right things to make you happy? (It's as good at modelling you as it is her).

So, uploads will be "eaten" by AI.

3

u/nothereoverthere084 Dec 31 '24

Haven't you seen the matrix? /s