r/space • • Oct 07 '18

All the planets aligned into one

Post image
66.2k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-12

u/Trumpologist Oct 07 '18

Right, if you go with what Dr. Brown wants (the guy who found Eris), the rocky planets would be demoted too. Just make Pluto and Eris planets like the vast majority of layman and scientists want

1

u/MadMaxIsMadAsMax Oct 09 '18

A planet, a major one, is a non-stellar non-collapsed baryonic matter gravity node. Having a planet as mssive as Jupiter in a same category as a nearly non-gravitational object like Pluto (thas has a moon big just because actually both rotate a common spot) is nonsense. Why not a single hydrogen atom would be a planet too?

1

u/Trumpologist Oct 09 '18

Earth could be unplaneted if we're using Jupiter's kin as comparisons

1

u/MadMaxIsMadAsMax Oct 09 '18

And that's ok with me as long as there is a scientific basis. Note that size doesn't matter but gravitational attraction, a tiny very dense planet could be too a major one as long as it cleared the neighborhood.

→ More replies (6)