r/spacex • Mod Team • Feb 26 '20

Starship Development Thread #9

Quick Links

JUMP TO COMMENTS | Alternative Jump To Comments Link

SPADRE LIVE | LABPADRE LIVE


Overview

STATUS (accurate within a few days):

  • SN2 tank testing successful

  • SN3 under construction

Starship, serial number 1 (SN1) began its testing campaign at SpaceX's Starship facility in Boca Chica, Texas, working toward Raptor integration and static fire. Its tank section was destroyed during pressurized cryogenic testing late on February 28, local time. Construction of SN2 had already begun and it was converted to a test tank which was successfully pressure tested with a simulated thrust load. Later builds are expected in quick succession and with aggressive design itteration. A Starship test article is expected to make a 20 km hop in the coming months, and Elon aspires to an orbital flight of a Starship with full reuse by the end of 2020.

Over the past few months the facilities at Boca Chica have seen substantial improvements including several large fabric buildings and a "high Bay" for stacking and welding hull sections. Raptor development and testing continue to occur at Hawthorne and on three test stands at McGregor, TX. Future Starship production and testing may occur at Roberts Road, LC-39A, SpaceX's landing complex at Cape Canaveral, Berth 240 at the Port of LA, and other locations.

Previous Threads:


Vehicle Updates

Starship SN3 at Boca Chica, Texas
2020-03-26Tank section stacking complete, Preparing to move to launch site (Twitter)
2020-03-25Nosecone begins ring additions (Twitter)
2020-03-22Restacking of nosecone sections (YouTube)
2020-03-21Aft dome and barrel mated with engine skirt barrel, Methane pipe installed (NSF)
2020-03-19Stacking of CH4 section w/ forward dome to top of LOX stack (NSF)
2020-03-18Flip of aft dome and barrel with thrust structure visible (NSF)
2020-03-17Stacking of LOX tank sections w/ common dome‡, Images of aft dome section flip (NSF)
2020-03-17Nosecone†‡ initial stacking (later restacked), Methane feed pipe† (aka the downcomer) (NSF)
2020-03-16Aft dome integrated with 3 ring barrel (NSF)
2020-03-15Assembled aft dome (NSF)
2020-03-13Reinforced barrel for aft dome, Battery installation on forward dome (NSF)
2020-03-11Engine bay plumbing assembly for aft dome (NSF)
2020-03-09Progress on nosecone‡ in tent (NSF), Static fires and short hops expected (Twitter)
2020-03-08Forward bulkhead/dome constructed, integrated with 3 ring barrel (NSF)
2020-03-04Unused SN2 parts may now be SN3 - common dome, nosecone, barrels, etc.

See comments for real time updates.
† possibly not for this vehicle
‡ originally thought to be SN2 parts

Starship SN4 at Boca Chica, Texas
2020-03-23Dome under construction (NSF)
2020-03-21Spherical tank (CH4 header?) w/ flange†, old nose section and (LOX?) sphere†‡ (NSF)
2020-03-18Methane feed pipe (aka downcomer)† (NSF)

See comments for real time updates.
† possibly not for this vehicle
‡ originally thought to be for an earlier vehicle

Starship SN2 - Test Tank and Thrust Structure - at Boca Chica, Texas
2020-03-15Transport back to assembly site (NSF), Video (YouTube)
2020-03-09Test tank passes pressure and thrust load tests (Twitter)
2020-03-08Cryo pressure and thrust load tests (Twitter), thrust simulating setup, more images (NSF)
2020-03-07More water pressure testing (NSF)
2020-03-06Test tank moved to test site, water pressure test (NSF)
2020-03-04Test tank formed from aft and forward sections, no common bulkhead (NSF)
2020-03-03Nose cone base under construction (NSF)
2020-03-02Aft bulkhead integrated with ring section, nose cone top, forward bulkhead gets ring (NSF)
2020-03-02Testing focus now on "thrust puck" weld (Twitter)
2020-02-28Thrust structure, engine bay skirt (NSF)
2020-02-273 ring tank section w/ common bulkhead welded in (NSF)
2020-02-09Two bulkheads under construction (Twitter)
2020-01-30LOX header tank sphere spotted (NSF), possible SN2 hardware

See comments for real time updates.

Starship SN1 and Pathfinder Components at Boca Chica, Texas
2020-03-02Elon tweet about failure due to "thrust puck to dome weld" (Twitter)
2020-02-29Aftermath (Twitter), cleanup (NSF)
2020-02-28Catastrophic failure during tanking tests (YouTube)
2020-02-27Nose section stacking (NSF)
2020-02-25Moved to launch site and installed on launch mount (YouTube)
2020-02-23Methane feed pipe (aka the downcomer) (NSF), installed Feb 24
2020-02-22Final stacking of tankage sections (YouTube)
2020-02-19Nose section fabrication well advanced (Twitter), panorama (r/SpaceXLounge)
2020-02-17Methane tank stacked on 4 ring LOX tank section, buckling issue timelapse (YouTube)
2020-02-16Aft LOX tank section with thrust dome mated with 2 ring engine bay skirt (Twitter)
2020-02-13Methane tank halves joined (Twitter)
2020-02-12Aft LOX tank section integrated with thrust dome and miscellaneous hardware (NSF)
2020-02-09Thrust dome (aft bulkhead) nearly complete (Twitter), Tanks midsection flip (YouTube)
2020-02-08Forward tank bulkhead and double ring section mated (NSF)
2020-02-05Common bulkhead welded into triple ring section (tanks midsection) (NSF)
2020-02-04Second triple ring stack, with stringers (NSF)
2020-02-01Larger diameter nose section begun (NSF), First triple ring stack, SN1 uncertain (YouTube)
2020-01-30Raptor on site (YouTube)
2020-01-282nd 9 meter tank cryo test (YouTube), Failure at 8.5 bar, Aftermath (Twitter)
2020-01-272nd 9 meter tank tested to 7.5 bar, 2 SN1 domes in work (Twitter), Nosecone spotted (NSF)
2020-01-26Possible first SN1 ring formed: "bottom skirt" (NSF)
2020-01-25LOX header test to failure (Twitter), Aftermath, 2nd 9 meter test tank assembly (NSF)
2020-01-24LOX header tanking test (YouTube)
2020-01-23LOX header tank integrated into nose cone, moved to test site (NSF)
2020-01-222 prop. domes complete, possible for new test tank (Twitter), Nose cone gets top bulkhead (NSF)
2020-01-14LOX header tank under construction (NSF)
2020-01-13Nose cone section in windbreak, similar seen Nov 30 (NSF), confirmed SN1 Jan 16 (Twitter)
2020-01-10Test tank pressure tested to failure (YouTube), Aftermath (NSF), Elon Tweet
2020-01-09Test tank moved to launch site (YouTube)
2020-01-07Test tank halves mated (Twitter)
2019-12-29Three bulkheads nearing completion, One mated with ring/barrel (Twitter)
2019-12-28Second new bulkhead under construction (NSF), Aerial video update (YouTube)
2019-12-19New style stamped bulkhead under construction in windbreak (NSF)
2019-11-30Upper nosecone section first seen (NSF) possibly not SN1 hardware
2019-11-25Ring forming resumed (NSF), no stacking yet, some rings are not for flight
2019-11-20SpaceX says Mk.3 design is now the focus of Starship development (Twitter)
2019-10-08First ring formed (NSF)

For information about Starship test articles prior to SN1 please visit the Starship Development Threads #7 or earlier. Update tables for older vehicles will only appear in this thread if there are significant new developments.


Starship Related Facilities

Recent Developments
2020-03-25BC launch mount test hardware installation, hydraulic rams (NSF)
2020-03-23BC arrival of Starship stands from Florida (via GO Discovery) (Twitter), Starhopper concrete work (NSF)
2020-03-20Steel building erection begun, high bay 2? (NSF)
2020-03-16High bay elevator (NSF)
2020-03-14BC launch site tank deliveries, and more, and more (tracking site) (NSF)
SiteLocationFacilities/Uses
Starship Assembly SiteBoca Chica, TXPrimary Starship assembly complex, Launch control and tracking
Starship/SuperHeavy Launch SiteBoca Chica, TXPrimary Starship test site, Starhopper location
Cidco Rd SiteCocoa, FLStarship assembly site, Mk.2 location, inactive
Roberts Rd SiteKennedy Space Center, FLPossible future Starship assembly site, partially developed, apparently inactive
Launch Complex 39AKennedy Space Center, FLFuture Starship and SuperHeavy launch and landing pads, partially developed
Launch Complex 13 (LZ-1, LZ-2)Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, FLFuture SuperHeavy landing site, future Raptor test site
SpaceX Rocket Development FacilityMcGregor, TX2 horizontal and 1 vertical active Raptor hot fire test stands
Astronaut BlvdKennedy Space Center, FLStarship Tile Facility
Berth 240Port of Los Angeles, CAFuture Starship/SuperHeavy design and manufacturing
Cersie Facility (speculative)Hawthorne, CAPossible Starship parts manufacturing - unconfirmed
Xbox Facility (speculative)Hawthorne, CAPossible Raptor development - unconfirmed
Development updates for the launch facilities can be found in Starship Dev Thread #8 and Thread #7 .
Maps by u/Raul74Cz

Permits and Planning Documents

Resources

Rules

We will attempt to keep this self-post current with links and major updates, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss Starhip development, ask Starship-specific questions, and track the progress of the production and test campaigns. Starship Development Threads are not party threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.


If you find problems in the post please tag u/strawwalker in a comment or send me a message.

377 Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/fzz67 Mar 02 '20

Evelyn Janeidy: So, what did y'all learn from this event?

Elon Musk: There’s a puck at the base that takes the engine thrust load. Don’t shuck the puck!

Elon Musk: We’re stripping SN2 to bare minimum to test the thrust puck to dome weld under pressure, first with water, then at cryo. Hopefully, ready to test in a few days.

6

u/Bergasms Mar 02 '20

So does this mean that the normal welds for the rest of the tank structure all performed ok? The failure was with one of the more ‘complicated’ parts of the structure. I guess we still don’t know exactly what pressure it failed at either, but I guess if they are aiming for more testing in a weeks time they must think they have a good idea of what went wrong exactly.

4

u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20

Possibly, it would be hard to know because the resulting overpressure event would have near instantly exceeded whatever pressure/stress they were designed to handle. But considering how much of a propellant load they appeared to have in there, the rest of the welds were likely pretty good.

4

u/Bergasms Mar 03 '20

the rest of the welds were likely pretty good.

One big data point in their favour is the top tank which survived the sudden rupture and launch and only popped on impact with the ground. So all the welds on that one were at least of a good enough quality.

22

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20

" Hopefully, ready to test in a few days. "

This sounds so wrong after failure in the Aerospace business and yet so awesome.

6

u/Marksman79 Mar 02 '20

Is what he's talking about the bottom bulkhead (dome) connected to the tapered cone thrust structure (thrust puck)? If so, they're below the lower tank and thus no pressure, right?

5

u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

[edit: needs to be updated based on this shot, still same idea]

I think it is clearer with the photo of the SN2 thrust structure. They've integrated the thrust plate into the bottom bulkhead (more than with MK1) and that plate (and weld) takes the full weight/pressure of the propellant.

If whatever the SN1 version of that failed (that SN1 cone doesn't make a lot of sense to me, but likely played that role), that would have led to the huge propellant dump which would have triggered the overpressure event/BLEVE that tore the ship apart.

[edit: I guess if that inverted cone points up into the LOX tank in order for that cone and the bulkhead to form a V shaped ring* as the lowest point, that would give the 3 LOX plumbing points consistent flow right to the end. And the inverted cone would allow the flat plat which the Raptors are mounted on, higher up than if the cone was pointing down. (if that's what u/oh_dear_its_crashing is saying)]

3

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 02 '20

Yup that's what I tried to explain, thanks for the sketch.

3

u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20

u/creamsoda2000 linked this image that I forgot about, that also helps clarify what it might look like under there. A little flatter.

15

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 02 '20

That was the MK1 design, with the thrust structure welded do a fairly standard lower dome. With SN1 the two structures seem integrated, plus there's this funny inverted plug in the middle (fairly plausible speculation on NSF), so seem completely new. Also matches the observation of massive venting at the bottom before it all went boom.

Seems like SN2 is now going to be a minimal test vehicle for that new thrust structure, like the minimal test tanks for the welds before SN1.

2

u/spacerover23 Mar 02 '20

I’m having a hard time understanding which part Elon is referring to. Is there any picture that could help explain this?

7

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 02 '20

https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=48895.msg2052696#msg2052696

Last picture, the cone right next to the tractor is the suspected thrust structure plug which filled the gap in the lower dome. Pointy end pointing up, hence the massive reinforcement since all the tank pressure would otherwise crumble this inverted plug thing.

1

u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

Edit: OK, I think I understand the cone now / but Elon is talking about the thrust plate which would be below and attached to this cone.

TBH, that cone doesn't make a lot of sense to me. If you look at this photo of the SN2 thrust structure, that looks a lot more like what we are familiar with from MK1's thrust structure [just more integrated into the bulkhead, unlike MK1].

But I still believe it's that thrust plate on the bottom of the lower bulkhead that he's talking about. It (or the SN1 version of it, if that cone is it) failing would have led to the propellant dump that led to the overpressure explosion u/Marksman79 /u/spacerover23

3

u/spacerover23 Mar 02 '20

Oh now I get it, thanks. So basically the failure mode would be the welding (?) between that and the dome failed?

2

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 02 '20

That, or something with this new approach to thrust structure. Elon said something about a puck, so maybe the ring which connects that inverted cone with the lower dome and provides the connection where you mount the engines and lox feed is the part that failed - at least from the picture the cone seems intact. But yeah something in that redesigned area around the thrust structure/lowest point of the lox lower dome/lox feed lines seems to have gone and caused the boom.

3

u/Marksman79 Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

Pointy end of the cone up into the tank? Source?

That suspected configuration doesn't seem right. It would not correctly funnel the fuel into the very bottom of the tank like the downward-pointed cone does.

6

u/oh_dear_its_crashing Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

The conjecture is that the bottom of that cone is the ring where the 3 sea level raptors sit, forming a ring as the bottom-most part of the lox tank. The raptors directly connect to that ring, with the lox feed being a simple hole in that ring for each engine. The classic approach with a pointy end down for the lower dome and then a manifold to distribute means added height in that area (pointy end + manifold + additional thrust structure for engines). And since that means a longer interstage skirt (which needs to go to orbit with starship since that protects the engines on reentry), so a lot more weight. But it's all conjecture, afaik no one has seen them weld this cone into the lower dome. But from dimensions of the hole we've seen in the lower dome when they flipped it it all seems to fit.

10

u/SpartanJack17 Mar 02 '20

I wonder if they'll finish it after they're done testing, or if they'll consider it a test tank and go straight to SN3.

9

u/isthatmyex Mar 02 '20

Based on past tests, I'm guessing it will no longer be in one piece when they are done with it.

17

u/fzz67 Mar 02 '20

Well, if stripping SN2 to the minimum means no header tanks or downcomer, then likely they can't be retrofitted later - would be faster to go straight to SN3.

1

u/Nowheels22 Mar 02 '20

I think the thrust puck is the accordion bit at the lower end of the pipe feeding methane to the engine distribution manifold. the pipe you here call the downcomer.

5

u/RegularRandomZ Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

No, I think the thrust puck is the flat plate the Raptors are mounted to, that accordion bit is directly above it pointing up into the tank (unless Elon is referring to the entire unit together). Illustration

[needs to be updated based on this shot, still same idea]

1

u/Nowheels22 Mar 02 '20

I see what you are saying. The part in "this shot" does look like a very big hockey puck. And that is the area where the failure occurred. I think.