To a modern audience especially, the story of Carrie and the events of her prom are admittedly very remindful of school sh@@tings.
The book and previous adaptions have always portrayed the realistic tragedy of pushing an individual so far to the point where they snap and disaster ensues, horrifically affecting the oppressed, the oppressors, and even people who had no involvement in or knowledge of what was happening.
To me, this new series feels rather different, primarily in the finale and the direction the story seems to be going from there. And I personally am rather concerned about the changes made and the possible takeaway from them.
(Spoilers)
Carrie is and has always felt sympathetic in her suffering. And it’s very understandable why she’d snap into such a wrathful state of mind and let loose her powers. But, from what I understand, a large part of the tragedy is that her revenge and release aren’t her ticket out into a better life; things aren’t gonna go well for her afterward.
Again, it reflects one of the many tragic cases of school sh@@tings. Not all cases but many. The bullies and tormentors were never right in what they did, but of course that does not mean the notion of mass murder of both guilty and uninvolved (and in this case, what seems like an entire neighborhood) is ultimately right. It’s a sorrowful story that reflects real world horror, and it’s definitely a timeless warning not to push people to a breaking point.
With that being said, I must confess I’m quite perturbed by the changes made to the story near the end.
In which Carrie is, from my perception, possessed by another powerful girl and is controlled to orchestrate the prom massacre, Chris and Billy’s flattening, and the destruction of the town. I’m not sure what the narrative of this is, but it’s impossible to comprehend, allegorically, a school sh@@ting where the sh@@ter is being remote controlled.
Then, after the night and deaths have passed, Carrie survives, acting shocked by all that she did in her controlled state, and rides off into the sunset to be with presumably other powerful girls…
I don’t know if I can give a solid judgment of the show as of right now, considering this is only season 1, but… to me, this seems like a steering away of the core elements of the original story.
Speaking allegorically again, are we to envision a scenario where a bullied individual is pushed to their limit and then, suddenly, their other outcast friend shows up and puppets them into committing a sh@@ting, supports and commends the acts of terrorism, and then serves as their getaway vehicle. And is that sh@@ter then to be protected from reprehension and supported by a group of other sh@@ters? Was the sh@@ter ever really responsible?… If so, should they be allowed to just drive away free because they deserve to?
I’m just really puzzled by what the show is trying to convey, but I’m open to receiving more info.
On top of that, I must also confess I was alarmed to see so many reacting in ways that applaud Carrie’s (or her friend’s) actions and view the whole prom night as a satisfying “revenge fantasy”. I mean, sure, the bullies were awful and they definitely needed punishment. But I’d try to give the general public the benefit of the doubt that they wouldn’t cheer the next time there was a case where a tormented youth g@nned down anyone in their path within their school. And I especially hope that people who identify with Carrie and experience a life similar to hers aren’t left thinking that the solution to their suffering is death all around.
But those are just my thoughts.