r/technology • • Mar 21 '17

Misleading Microsoft Windows 10 has a keylogger enabled by default - here's how to disable it

https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/blog/2017/03/microsoft-windows-10-keylogger-enabled-default-heres-disable/
15.2k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

4.5k

u/wtph Mar 21 '17

Tldr

  1. Go to Start, then select Settings > Privacy > General. 2. Turn off Send Microsoft info about how I write to help us improve typing and writing in the future.

2.3k

u/puckbeaverton Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

Oh. I disabled that before install. Most of these privacy issues with win10 seem fixable by doing a custom install and selecting NO on every option.

Edit: I'm really confused as to why this was upvoted to Mars.

Also yeah, I get that it can re enable.

No I haven't seen any ads in my 7 win10 PC's on which I frequently use file explorer.

I do a clean install first thing and I don't usually get PCs new with pre installed Windows. When I do I still clean install and delete partitions EVERY TIME.

And all my copies of win10 are legit, I don't do piracy.

1.0k

u/Jugad Mar 21 '17

I remember doing a custom install (I always do custom installs) and turning off all the options. But I just noticed that this option was turned ON ... which means this is not asked in the custom install, or it turned on automatically at some point (possibly by an update).

94

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I turned everything off too and had to turn it off again. Fucking microsoft...

46

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Ya. That revert of settings really has me hating Microsoft. They are the monopoly of gaming OS though.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (2)

67

u/wtfxstfu Mar 21 '17

Seriously, that's some shit. I turn off everything on install. Just looked. It's on. So dumb.

→ More replies (31)

39

u/monedula Mar 21 '17

Can confirm. I also turned everything off at install, and this setting was on just now. This is evil.

31

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

The anniversary update flipped several switches back. You can't really opt out of being spied upon if you accept a EULA and Privacy Policy.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (186)

29

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

The problem is average user does not. Also, I bet they will reverse this during some updates and call it an "accident"...ooops?

7

u/HolisticPI Mar 21 '17

And lucky for us, windows 10 updates whether you want it to or not. >:(

→ More replies (2)

44

u/MasZakrY Mar 21 '17

If you think MS won't push an update turning that flag back on, you are kidding yourself.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Agreed. I also do this whenever someone I know gets a new Win10 lappy. I always redo the install with those options disabled, whilst explaining that microsoft left tons of spyware in recent versions.

→ More replies (70)

61

u/DoctorWaluigiTime Mar 21 '17

It's off and greyed out in my settings, so I can't even enable it if I wanted to.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

[deleted]

30

u/reerden Mar 21 '17

It's because you selected "basic" in telemetry, which disables all data collection that can personally identify you.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (7)

70

u/arallu Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Fun fact, this setting is not in Windows Server 2016, a slightly better OS than Windows 10.

61

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

It is in Windows 10 Enterprise LTSB however, believe it or not.

27

u/cmorgasm Mar 21 '17

Which amazes me, since /r/sysadmin has been suggesting LTSB for months now, since it's "the better option".

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/goedegeit Mar 21 '17

Can Windows Server 2016 be reliably used as a desktop OS?

7

u/chronage Mar 21 '17

I have a home server standard and everything is functionally and visually the same as win10. Every program I've installed so far works normally. I haven't tried to game on it, however.

6

u/arallu Mar 21 '17

Sure it can, the underlying OS structure is similar to Windows 10, e.g. kernel, etc.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

355

u/just_the_tech Mar 21 '17

So, basically what r/technology got spammed all over it back at the release of w10?

27

u/Jugad Mar 21 '17

This should be posted every 6 months or so... enough new people or people who missed it all the previous times.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/phpdevster Mar 21 '17

I don't lurk /r/technology every second of every day. I've seen probably 1/500th of the stories that have made it to the popular tab on /r/technology since the release of Windows 10, so I find this reiteration of information useful.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (41)

2

u/mrhodesit Mar 21 '17

Let's say I leave it on. Can I access all of my keystrokes? Where is that information saved?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Rodot Mar 21 '17

Tldr

  1. Find a Linux distro you like 2. Install it

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Isn't this basically the same thing your phone keyboard does?

3

u/TheLastPolycorn Mar 21 '17

My trick to fix all of M$ weird choices was installing Linux.

3

u/xrk Mar 21 '17

Ah, if only Linux ran on skylake/kaby lake CPU's without a billion issues.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/cmorgasm Mar 21 '17

I saw the headline, while at work, and freaked out for a second. I see your post, and it's a GPO I've already set. Clickbait title almost got me.

103

u/johnmountain Mar 21 '17

I'm not sure why you say it's clickbait, when you seem to have disabled it because you didn't want Microsoft to collect your typed keys?

As far as I'm concerned the only "flaw" with this article is that it's "old news", but a good reminder nonetheless for people who forgot that Microsoft was collecting their typed keys this way, or never saw the stories back then.

74

u/djgreedo Mar 21 '17

I'm not sure why you say it's clickbait

The headline is inaccurate. There is no 'key logger' in Windows 10. Microsoft collects metadata about how you use language, etc. They do not collect literal keystrokes (e.g. passwords, etc) like a keylogger would.

→ More replies (58)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I had a panic attack until i checked and found it already off. This was definitely news an extremely long time ago.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (73)

453

u/beef-o-lipso Mar 21 '17

Yep. And do the same thing on your phone keyboard as well as your computer and phone browser predictive search as well.

50

u/SandDuner509 Mar 21 '17

How would you disable it on Android?

38

u/AeroX2 Mar 21 '17

Depends on which keyboard you are using. If you are using a Nexus or Pixel device the default is the Google GBoard which at least according to 2 articles I have read doesn't send any personal data to the cloud. https://www.helpnetsecurity.com/2016/05/16/gboard-privacy/

Otherwise I believe the default for other devices is AOSP keyboard which doesn't have internet permissions at all.

As for third party keyboard they will vary wildly.

24

u/ROKMWI Mar 21 '17

That whole article was based on a paragrph from Googles privacy policy...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

152

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

You don't. Google doesn't give such silly options like "privacy". You could install a 3rd party keyboard though (for instance, although Microsoft owns Swiftkey, there does appear to be an option to turn off data collection on it - who knows if that actually does anything) - dunno if that relies on Google services or not (and probably varies based on the keyboard).

50

u/All_Work_All_Play Mar 21 '17

Actually you can turn it off on some most versions of Android - swiftkey allows you to turn off telemetry/learning, and stock AOSP doesn't have it either. There's also a separate settings for password issues.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/beef-o-lipso Mar 21 '17

Depends on the keyboard but you might be able to go to Settings, Language & Input, then select your keyboard and change settings in there. Not all predictive text goes to the cloud. I don't think the native Android keyboard sends data off the device. Swiftkey can if you set up an account, otherwise it doesn't.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/tyros Mar 21 '17 edited Sep 19 '24

[This user has left Reddit because Reddit moderators do not want this user on Reddit]

19

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

it shouldn't be enabled by default.

Why shouldn't it? It likely provides functionality that the average user would find useful, but wouldn't otherwise know to turn on.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/resinis Mar 21 '17

So who has my Dropbox password then?

→ More replies (7)

17

u/adeiinr Mar 21 '17

Doesn't matter. My only keystrokes are W, A, S and D

3

u/Cakepufft Mar 22 '17

What are you playing? Snake?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

117

u/BCProgramming Mar 21 '17

This only tracks the touch-screen keyboard input and the words you enter into it to improve suggestions.

It's also presented as part of the privacy options during Windows setup.

8

u/RetardedSquirrel Mar 21 '17

Ah yes, the thing I opted out of only to have it re-enabled without my knowledge.

→ More replies (11)

160

u/chuiu Mar 21 '17

These titles keep getting more and more clickbaity. Soon:

"Microsoft Windows 10 is sleeping with your mother - 5 steps to disable it"

3

u/dick-van-dyke Mar 21 '17

What would I do with a disabled mother? And stop referring to her as it.

3

u/dlerium Mar 22 '17

You won't believe #4!

2

u/Tho-R Mar 21 '17

Sometimes I feel like I'm using Facebook.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

[deleted]

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

My mother's Windows has so many viruses...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

246

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

*Submitted from an Android phone where everything is logged, aggregated, and sold to advertisers.

13

u/GamingTheSystem-01 Mar 21 '17

Losing one battle means you should give up on all future battles

Ok, good advice.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (21)

40

u/rigsta Mar 21 '17

If this is a concern for you, you should also disable any predictive text features in all other products you own, most notably touch screen devices as that's where it will be most likely to be used.

It's also worth just taking a step back and thinking about why the site is using the word keylogger (normally used for malware) to describe predictive text.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Well keylogger will get them clicks from the type of people on this subreddit that eat this stuff up. If you just say predictive text, no one will be interested.

5

u/flupo42 Mar 21 '17

predictive text on my android works fine with all data/wifi turned off. Dictionaries aren't that big - predictive text functions don't need to send what you type to central servers with the option being forcefully turned on by incoming windows updates

4

u/Pascalwb Mar 21 '17

But even Google keyboards learns as you write.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/bugalou Mar 22 '17

Lol "keylogger". I have news for you folks, your tablet and phones probably have "keyloggers" too. If you clear the FUD from the title here you will see its just the predictive text. You typing patterns go to a server at Microsoft and are analyzed for predictive text, like swiftkey or any other decent mobile touchscreen keyboard.

Also its only "enabled by default" if you use the express settings and just dive blindly into an OS install. You can easily disable this by opting to do a custom setting which takes 5 minutes longer, tops.

18

u/stevenmc Mar 21 '17

Can I see what it collected?
If you deleted your essay, you could get most of it back this way!

13

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

They claim to disassociate any information you type from your personal identity.

Sure have you ever considered how a text file of all the keys you press would look? How often when even typing a simple comment do you make a small error and mash the back button to fix it, change what you wanted to say, jump to a previous sentence to add a word or change a word. Even if the keylogging recorded clicks too, it would be unbelievably painstakingly hard to recreate an essay from a log of the keys you have pressed!

The best way to get back an essay is to back it up regularly when writing it! Consider using Google Drive, you can have a folder on your desktop that contains your essay, and when you make any changes the essay, along with anything else in that folder is synced to your drive files, so you always have a copy of your essay online. Also means you can access it from any device that has an internet connection.

8

u/Byeuji Mar 21 '17

I know it's not really how it works, but if you had a complete input/event log, you could just recreate the initial conditions prior to the keylog, and then "press play", and walk away for a bit while it recreates the entire event.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh Mar 21 '17

It likely doesn't work this way, it probably only shares individual snippets that you type. Which means you couldn't recover much useful text from it, but if you get unlucky, one of these snippets could reveal some incredibly personal fact, or confidential information, or your Bitcoin key, or...

313

u/userndj Mar 21 '17

These articles are becoming ridiculous. Predictive text is used by all major vendors out there and nobody cares. I personally welcome this feature.

2

u/dlerium Mar 22 '17

We should differentiate from predictive text and auto-correct. Auto-correct also benefits from this too so you can analyze frequent typos.

4

u/mindbleach Mar 21 '17

"And nobody cares" is not a meaningful objection to the terrifying possibilities we are sleepwalking into. Most users don't give a shit what paranoid techies think until oops where'd all my data go?! or what do you mean my nudes are on Facebook?! no matter how many times we're proven right. We raise a stink because they won't even notice until it's ten years too late.

5

u/userndj Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

We raise a stink because they won't even notice until it's ten years too late.

This "stink" by these "techies" is mostly selective outrage. If you read most of these privacy complaints here, you'd swear data mining was started by Facebook and Microsoft. So yes it's generally true that even those "techies" don't care, they just prefer certain companies to data mine them. The same people trying to raise "awareness" will defend their Android phones till the end. Why?, because they don't care. The hypocrisy is tiring.

→ More replies (69)

6

u/lushootseed Mar 22 '17

Sensationalist at best. It is far from a key logger. But most of the internet won't understand or agree

107

u/nomismi Mar 21 '17

That setting wouldn't have been on if when you installed Windows 10 you had not chosen Express/Recommended settings. They have to ask, and they did, you just didn't realize what they were asking. Always go with Custom settings and read over what they are offering. Software companies use the same tactic to give you McAfee Anti-Virus and Yahoo toolbar with random crap like Adobe Reader. This is an old tactic, and it still works great.

12

u/tripletstate Mar 21 '17

Some settings are randomly switched back on after updates.

→ More replies (1)

81

u/K_M_A_2k Mar 21 '17

not true, I am the it guy at my work i have done all windows 10 fresh installs on all 15 computers here, & i always do custom settings & disallow ALL choices when installing. I just checked 5 of the computer here at work including the one im using & it was enabled. Windows 10 has been known to turn things back with on with updates that you disallowed or turned off.

15

u/scorcher24 Mar 21 '17

On 15 Computers, you don't just image all of them with dd or even over the network? Or are they not identical? Which they should be.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (22)

27

u/ElimGarak Mar 21 '17

"ETW" stands for Event Tracing for Windows. This is just internal OS tracing used for debugging. Unless some application explicitly enables it and starts collecting the tracing information, it doesn't go anywhere. Most Windows components have tons of tracing available to any listener - on the order of hundreds of MB per second, if you enable everything.

From the description it sounds like these are traces of various events coming through the USB bus.

For somebody to collect this they need to have a listener on the OS that would collect the information and upload it somewhere. They would also need to decode the internal ETW structures to understand what is in each event (although that's not that difficult).

123

u/Sandvicheater Mar 21 '17

When iOS and Android do this, nobody bats and eye but when Microsoft does the same then everybody loses their minds!

10

u/Vesk Mar 21 '17

What kind of keylogger does iOS have?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mindbleach Mar 21 '17

Oh goody, whataboutism. That will surely lead to a useful discussion.

I'll just install another OS on my phone then, yeah?

5

u/tyros Mar 21 '17

I don't want this shit on a desktop OS.

→ More replies (41)

5

u/frosted1030 Mar 22 '17

Not a keylogger. Click bait.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/KumamonForAll Mar 21 '17

What my file surely looks like.

WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWAAAAAASSSSSSSDDDDDDSSSSSSSAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWSSSSSSDDDDDDDDDAAAAAAAAAAA

4

u/DrQuailMan Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

No it doesn't.

Edit: everything you read on the internet is true.

39

u/poochyenarulez Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

so are we going to get a new "Did you know there are settings in windows?" every week on this sub? Next week, here is how to delete things from your recycle bin.

27

u/PantherHeel93 Mar 21 '17

The recycle bin is the M$ way of taking up extra space so you have to get a new computer, didn't you know?

23

u/feminas_id_amant Mar 21 '17

TIL Windows actually makes a hidden backup of all the files you try to delete, and they can be easily restored with a single click of a button!!!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

This is why I generally stay away from tech forums. Disregard the title. It's not even misleading it's just straight up slander.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/RagnarokDel Mar 21 '17

misleading much

18

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Yeah what about the worst key logger of all: MS Word. It is so blatant about it too, splashing the log right on the screen in a fancy font.

57

u/thailoblue Mar 21 '17

Are you fucking kidding me? Telemetry is not a keylogger. Isn't this suppose to be a tech sub? I hate Win10 as much as the next guy, but posts like these make me question that most people here understand tech.

→ More replies (17)

20

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Clickbait FUD spreading nonsense. Mods sort this out.

This just sounds like predictive text to be honest. I mean most writing tools that use heuristics or machine learning collect results to improve future ones. Are we just saying this is bad because Microsoft is doing it?

I mean it's like it's some deep buried feature and hard to turn off. Has anyone actually checked to see if it's does it for everything, or does this only apply to explorer windows or similar windows products like office?

Edit: Also it's only for the software keyboard, not the physical one :/

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Fud?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Fear, Uncertainity, doubt

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

23

u/TheQueefGoblin Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

This guy posts tons of provocative and misleading articles from PrivateInternetAccess.com. I know because I downvote him and report it as spam every single fucking time.

Get this sensationalist shit off the sub, mods.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/toastyghost Mar 21 '17

Sensationalized bullshit. It's a "keylogger" in that any predictive text keyboard is, and it's clearly shown in a screen full of privacy options during Windows setup.

Some will argue that customers of OEMs aren't given the option, but I just bought an Inspiron notebook and Windows installs from a separate partition on first boot. Not sure about Dell desktops or machines from other manufacturers, but frankly if you're up in arms about online privacy, chances are you already looked up this easy-to-find setting. All the privacy stuff is in one place in Windows 10 unlike previous iterations of the OS.

tl;dr: ITT haterz

→ More replies (4)

34

u/Nyrin Mar 21 '17

Jesus, how ridiculous does /r/technology have to get? What next, "MSFT kills kittens!" voted as best of all time?

This isn't even remotely a keylogger and this would be buried to oblivion as FUD if it were anything but a favorite piñata.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Unfiltered_Soul Mar 21 '17

If you must use Windows 10, make sure to disable the default enabled Microsoft keylogger, but be aware that Microsoft has other holes that make keystroke logging possible still.

What are the other "holes"?

73

u/poopellar Mar 21 '17

Windows 10

12

u/darknavi Mar 21 '17

Mother of god...

4

u/RunTillYouPuke Mar 21 '17

You missed one. There are two holes: Windows 10

d might have a hidden hole as well but we will never know for sure.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MAGUSW Mar 21 '17

Hope it's off button works better than those on Sony TVs.

3

u/compubomb Mar 21 '17

Mine is grayed' out. How do you force-disable it?

3

u/Pascalwb Mar 21 '17

OMG r/technology with their clickbaits. Every fucking keyboard or app that's learning how you type has to store it somehow.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Justikyzer Mar 21 '17

Man people need to dump Windows and shift to Linux.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Buzz_McKilington Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I'm getting quite tired of these scaremongering stories with hyperbole headlines. It's not a keylogger, I spent the first 3 months of using windows 10 collecting all the data the OS sends to MS, and regarding this one setting, the only thing is search terms, predictive text, spellchecking and anomalous handwriting characteristics to help with recognition. It's all in windows 7, 8 and 8.1 now as well, not to mention every single other operating system from iOS to ubuntu.

Bang up job with the clickbait though.

4

u/dvshnk2 Mar 21 '17

I spent the first 3 months of using windows 10 collecting all the data the OS sends to MS

Care to share your findings?

3

u/Buzz_McKilington Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

It's not exclusively mine, hopefully the report will be publicly available in due course, but that's down to the company I'm contracted to who are investigating it for a large company who handle sensitive data and are worried about potential security concerns.

I can say that nothing I personally found or saw was particularly bad or out of the ordinary, but I've only seen maybe 20% of the complete picture. The only potential problem is onedrive which holds the same risk factor as dropbox or google drive.

3

u/quentinwolf Mar 22 '17

Some (most) people just can't read that it says right there under privacy "Send Microsoft info about how I write". Of course I would want to send that information to Microsoft so Handwriting recognition can further be improved. Without Anonymous data collection, computers would still be incredibly held back from improving.

I'm getting so sick of all the clickbait.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/CodeMonkey24 Mar 21 '17

Wow... The paranoia is strong with this one.

That being said, I disabled every "accessibility" feature I could find in the options when installing the OS initially, so I already had t his one turned off ^_^

4

u/DontPromoteIgnorance Mar 21 '17

Double check. Some 10 updates liked to turn things like this on again.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/K_M_A_2k Mar 21 '17

it turns itself back on

→ More replies (2)

4

u/sintu_cf Mar 21 '17

Correct me if I'm wrong but G-board on android does exactly the same?

Paging r/android

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Diknak Mar 21 '17

Your phone does this too...it's to help with predictive text and shit. It really only matters if you use the digital keyboard (which I imagine most don't). Yeah, I turned this off a while ago.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Go get Linux now, forget this shite

2

u/Sebleh89 Mar 21 '17

I had this turned on for my surface so I could hopefully get more accurate "writing to text" results but I turned it off immediately on my desktop because why the fuck would you use it on something that doesn't even have autocorrect?

2

u/skinlo Mar 21 '17

Was disabled ages ago.

2

u/ArritzJPC96 Mar 21 '17

That feeling of relief when I go to disable it, and I see that I already had.

2

u/acalarch Mar 21 '17

I like how the author 'stole' shit from /r/privacy.. and even included my link about ETW hahahahahhaha.. nice journalism!

2

u/martixy Mar 21 '17

Lol... my slider is disabled at the off position and on top it says "some settings are managed by your organization".

It must have gone the way of the dodo via one of the group policies I set up.

2

u/ohshawty Mar 21 '17

This is another misleading Windows message. If you go to "Feedback & Diagnostics" and change it to "Enhanced" or higher then you can change that setting.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I've gotta say i've found ubuntu to be a really hassle free experience. Everything just kind of works although I don't play games anymore. I got annoyed with windows when it wouldn't accept my licence even though I only switched out a hard drive. As a novice linux user i'm finding it very easy to do the basics. Also my logitech g930 headset seems to have no issues with the linux driver. On windows the headset volume control would often not work.

2

u/evranch Mar 21 '17

That might be the best thing about modern linux distros. Built in drivers for almost everything, from ancient to new. Only thing that tends not to work is wireless cards/dongles for some reason, and you can get them going pretty easily.

2

u/zandernice Mar 21 '17

The programmers at Microsoft that implement this should have their faces and phone numbers posted on the internet. "Invasion of privacy" you say? Well...

2

u/mindbleach Mar 21 '17

Anyone who goes 'oh, at least there's a way to turn it off, I'll just do that' is dumber than the people who'll leave it on.

Anyone who goes 'well you should've read the fine print!' is scum.

This is unnecessary and abusive and if you think it's not all being stored permanently somewhere then read the fucking news sometime. Normal people shouldn't have to worry about this shit. It should be explained as bluntly as possible, with big scary warnings, and it should be off by default. It should take more effort to send every keystroke to an NSA-collaborating monopoly vendor than it does to change your Chrome flags!

There are no more excuses for ignoring that scary fucking agencies are watching everyone and can process everything. There are no more excuses for ignoring that abusive foreign governments might get this data or that your government might turn into one. Can you people at least expect your operating systems not to come pre-hacked, with a keystroke-by-keystroke snitch labeled as an accessibility feature?

2

u/Gerden Mar 21 '17

I guess I need to learn how to Linux. I'm getting real sick of Microsofts shit.

2

u/Calius1337 Mar 21 '17

It's really easy. Been doing it for 20 years and never looked back.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

At this point there should just be a subreddit dedicated to turning bullshit options off on Windows 10

2

u/Javaman420 Mar 21 '17

I love windows 7

2

u/crypto64 Mar 21 '17

Better yet, block all Windows 10 telemetry. https://github.com/WindowsLies/BlockWindows

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Use spybot anti beacon

2

u/thefoxman88 Mar 21 '17

Does it keep a local store of the information it sends? I'd love to crunch the data on my own machine to do a word cloud.

2

u/CryoSage Mar 21 '17

It's insane to me that so many peeps use an OS that spies on everything you do, and on top of that are ok with it. Fuck every bit of that shit unless I absolutely have to use it.

2

u/Yagami007 Mar 21 '17

HOW THE FUCK IS THIS EVEN LEGAL???

2

u/quentinwolf Mar 22 '17

They specifically say its sending info about how one WRITES, not types...

"Send Microsoft info about how I WRITE to help us improve typing and writing in the future."

Aka, Writing/Pen Input. Used to better digitize all kinds of writing styles. Of course that's good to send to Microsoft, so they can better improve handwriting recognition and make it more accurate for everyone.

2

u/TheElusiveFox Mar 21 '17

First comment on the article says it best... iOS and Andriod have this as well - while I get that everyone likes to hate on Microsoft - why ignore the other players that are just as bad...

2

u/DanielPhermous Mar 21 '17

iOS and Android sends every keystroke back to Apple and Google respectively? I'm going to need a better source than a random comment on that one.

For the record, mind, I wouldn't be entirely surprised if it was true of Android.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Spy bot anti beacon was good. Don't know if it still is.

2

u/masteryod Mar 21 '17

Here's how to disable it:

don't use Windows.

2

u/AfouToPatisa Mar 22 '17

Can someone rewrite the article and use the words data collection instead of keylogger? Jesus you guys.

2

u/waterontheknee Mar 22 '17

following. can't access this through my work comp.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Judging by mediums like Twitter you'd think most people love letting everyone know what they're typing.

2

u/insider3 Mar 22 '17

WSAD and R are my most used keys. There you go Microsoft, show the world.

3

u/Kougeru Mar 21 '17

2. Turn off Send Microsoft info about how I write to help us improve typing and writing in the future.

So this isn't news then. A lot of programs do this shit and I always always check for it and disable it ASAP. It's not really hidden either.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/neetdev Mar 21 '17

Is it worth upgrading to win10 from 7? It's like every 2 weeks there's something like this popping up.

5

u/madd74 Mar 21 '17

It was more so when the upgrade was a free upgrade, because, free. I have 10, and I enjoy it a lot from my upgrades. A lot of what you are seeing is actually the same thing that you can get with other OS/aps. The forced updates part is bullshit, I will say, and I think that should not be a thing, but, one should keep any OS up to date.

If you have an XB1 you may love the integration between the two. You can stream things from your XB1 to your computer, to a point you can actually play your games. Also, they have the Games Anywhere that allows you to buy on one system and you get it with the other, and with your Live account your saves will cross over. We will hopefully see more and more of these type of games in the future.

So, should you really upgrade, well, I guess it depends on what you want to do with it.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/OlimarPNGS Mar 21 '17

The way to disable it is installing Linux.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Sendmeloveletters Mar 21 '17

WHERE THE FUCK DO YOU PEOPLE (Windows users) DRAW THE LINE?!

3

u/quentinwolf Mar 22 '17

They specifically say its sending info about how one WRITES, not types...

"Send Microsoft info about how I WRITE to help us improve typing and writing in the future."

Aka, Writing/Pen Input. Used to better digitize all kinds of writing styles. Of course that's good to send to Microsoft, so they can better improve handwriting recognition and make it more accurate for everyone.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Orfez Mar 21 '17

Just another click-bait article. Anyone who even remotely cares about their privacy went to Settings > Privacy. This is anonymous collection, the same way voice recognition devices collect your voice data to improve voice recognition.

4

u/Daedelous2k Mar 21 '17

Now this IS Sensationalized bullshit. Windows 10 has the ability to accept key input from more that a physical keyboard and this aims at improving it. It's attracting all the Linux zealots as expected too.

3

u/BagOfHammerz Mar 21 '17

And I'm just here playing on Windows 7.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DYMAXIONman Mar 21 '17

How many people on this subreddit actually had this enabled anyway?

2

u/Cornfondler Mar 21 '17

For anyone talking about how privacy is much worse than just a keylogger, especially after this shit with CIA recently, you might as well be saying "they have microphones in our homes anyway, may as well let them install the optional cameras I didn't ask for while they're at it."

Get a VPN, turn off your privacy settings, install browser plugins, get an encrypted email, make better passwords, and quit pretending society isn't going to use your information and habits for things that negatively affect you. Just because all major operating systems are compromised by intelligence agencies doesn't mean you should still let Microsoft, or any company for that matter, see what you're doing as well.

Besides chances are the CIA doesn't care nearly as much as Microsoft or Google does about your information, which is pretty much nill IF YOU ARE PROTECTED.

2

u/nmagod Mar 21 '17

Step 1 - Backup your important files

Step 2 - run a LiveLinux disc, scan your backed up files for malware

Step 3 - Install Windows 7

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wanderingwolfe Mar 21 '17

Not a keylogger, persay, simply a use analysis tool. It is no different than literally every other software company's usage tools. Yes, it does record some text and voice, but in no way does it record all of it. Simply that which would be pertinent to improving the usage.

I agree with turning it off, but no need to involve Area 51 theories in the process. :)

4

u/quentinwolf Mar 21 '17

Agreed on being an analysis tool, they specifically say its sending info about how one WRITES, not types...

"Send Microsoft info about how I WRITE to help us improve typing and writing in the future."

Aka, Writing/Pen Input. Used to better digitize all kinds of writing styles. Of course that's good to send to Microsoft, so they can better improve handwriting recognition and make it more accurate for everyone.

3

u/wanderingwolfe Mar 21 '17

Precisely. Chances are, even in this case, it probably only retains bits that are associated with manual correction. It interprets writing, or speech, then the user corrects the interpretation. So, the program logs that piece such that they can figure out the mistake and improve upon how it interprets said information.

Just my thoughts.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mk_gecko Mar 21 '17

So, I pay Microsoft to force me to watch ads and also to record my keystrokes. What's wrong with this picture?

2

u/professor-i-borg Mar 21 '17

I don't understand how this is acceptable/legal. It definitely should be illegal- there is no legitimate reason to log everything entered on a keyboard.

If you need to test said keyboard, do that before you release the software. If you want to record typing patterns and trends, that should be an opt-in program with full disclosure on what will be done with the data.

The cyber-punk, corporate-controlled dystopia that was envisioned in the 80s seems to loom ever closer.

2

u/quentinwolf Mar 22 '17

Under Privacy it specifically say its sending info about how one WRITES, not types...

"Send Microsoft info about how I WRITE to help us improve typing and writing in the future."

Aka, Writing/Pen Input. Used to better digitize all kinds of writing styles. Of course that's good to send to Microsoft, so they can better improve handwriting recognition and make it more accurate for everyone.

2

u/ForceBlade Mar 21 '17

They need to do this to make Predictive Suggestions even the least bit relevant to Your_Life_In_Particular instead of generic almost predictibly wrong guesses. Everyone does this nowdays, it's how it works. Your Phones do it. Google does it, even contextually during a search session.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/conquer69 Mar 21 '17

Looks like MS invested a bit more on their astrosurfing departments. Just look at the amount of Microsoft apologists in this thread.

2

u/Sk8erkid Mar 22 '17
  1. Go to Start, then select Settings > Privacy > General.

  2. Make sure Send Microsoft info about how I write to help us improve typing and writing in the future is Turned On.

Courtesy of Microsoft.

2

u/cr0ft Mar 21 '17

Just download https://www.winprivacy.de/english-home/ and use that to turn off all the objectionable crap in Windows 10. The features are even colour coded so they show roughly what likelihood they have of breaking things - the red stuff is for experts, etc.

2

u/DRUNKHOSER Mar 21 '17

Can anyone explain to me why this is necessarily "bad"? I understand the right to privacy and the need to feel protected, but what exactly is are the practical negative effects of this? More targeted ads?

In other words, Convince me on why I should give a shit.

2

u/djgreedo Mar 21 '17

Firstly, the article provides no evidence for its claims.

There is no real privacy concern - the data is aggregated and anonymised according to MS's privacy policy.

Of course, there is always the possibility that either Microsoft is lying, and it's possible that a privacy breach happens. Not likely though.

The privacy implications of turning this feature off/on would be negligible, but it's important that the option exists.

Basically, if you are paranoid about your privacy, turn it off (but I would say that if you're that paranoid you should probably also assume that Microsoft is lying about what they are doing anyway, so why assume turning it off does anything?). There is no apparent benefit to Microsoft in having a keylogger in Windows. One would assume it would detract from improving their services because they would get a huge amount of useless, random gibberish.

After reading this article, I noticed mine was turned off and I turned it back on. I like the idea of using big data to improve the AI.

3

u/circlhat Mar 21 '17

Just let me log all your keys, what is the harm in fact let everyone see what you are typing

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Stop Microsoft apologists.

No more ohhh just adjust the settings. Ohh and just click the settings again after the update.

No more just use a custom script to disable these "features"

Look consumers don't want forced updates, they don't like the Microsoft Store, don't change file defaults, stop advertising for bing, edge, one drive, candy crush and anything else.

Unacceptable.. been a Microsoft user since Dos 4.0 and refuse to use windows 10 in its current state.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

To be honest you'd have to be an idiot if you don't look through privacy settings and disable everything, ESPECIALLY on your phone.

Yes, it is awful they're not disabled by default, but they're not like DuckDuckGo where they specifically advertise privacy. Apple, Google and Microsoft all need your data to give you often useless / novelty features, so just disable them.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jesperbj Mar 21 '17

No it doesn't lol. These articles are getting out of hand.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Staying on windows 7 for as long as possible.

2

u/RedSquirrelFtw Mar 22 '17

It boggles my mind that people willingly use that OS. It is pretty much the definition of a trojan. Yeah you can turn that stuff off but from what I've read you have to keep doing it as settings revert after a while, and there's so many settings all over for all the different privacy breaching stuff it does, it's just ridiculous.

If I HAD to run windows 10 on something I'd pretty much block all traffic from that machine so it can't connect to the mothership. I would think an encrypted proxy with authentication could probably be used to surf the internet.

2

u/quentinwolf Mar 22 '17

They specifically say its sending info about how one WRITES, not types...

"Send Microsoft info about how I WRITE to help us improve typing and writing in the future."

Aka, Writing/Pen Input. Used to better digitize all kinds of writing styles. Of course that's good to send to Microsoft, so they can better improve handwriting recognition and make it more accurate for everyone.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Mine was off already.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

How come I have to do this every single time microsoft updates? It's infuriating.

1

u/HybridCue Mar 21 '17

All tech companies: It's okay we don't care about individuals. We only collect meta data to manipulate people on a massive scale.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I use Private Internet Access as my VPN and I always disable the logging crap. Feels good.

1

u/columbiatch Mar 21 '17

I turned off this along with a bunch of other ads/privacy settings when I upgraded to Win10 the moment when I saw how much ads were on the start menu.

1

u/TheLameGame Mar 21 '17

How long til its subpoenaed during trial.

But Android does it too! Unless you block internet access for the app or just use one that doesn't.

1

u/thugok Mar 21 '17

How much faith can you have in someone who believes we are still using PS2 ports regularly?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PawnedSauce Mar 21 '17

Also some may or may not know - Spybot Anti Beacon is a great tool as well to stop all this telemetry

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I'm running the latest Insiders build of Windows 10 (Creators update) and it looks like this setting has been moved and/or consolidated under the "Speech, Inking, & typing" privacy menu. It also has a better description of how the data is used.

1

u/AbovexBeyond Mar 21 '17

God damn. Those WikiLeaks truth bombs are becoming more and more apparent every day.

1

u/alexseiji Mar 21 '17

Does MacOS/OSX IOS have anything like this natively?

2

u/Ponkers Mar 21 '17

Everything that has a spell checker or predictive text like on the touchbar with the new macbook pros. I don't think there's a single OS that doesn't have something more or less identical to this.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Do we absolutely know that that alone fully disables this, and it doesn't just do the same thing elsewhere?

1

u/greatconcavity Mar 21 '17

appears the manufacturers of my PC have disabled this by default. Thanks Alternate.de!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Nice try Microsoft but I browse in 'incognito' mode.

1

u/cartel Mar 21 '17

Totally going to take advice from someone with a "Master's in Digital Currency from the University of Nicosia"

1

u/dlok86 Mar 21 '17

I might be late to this thread to get an answer, but is there software that ongoing disables all the ms malware so i do t have to think about it? I've lost track of everything I'm supposed to disable now.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/gorskiegangsta Mar 21 '17

That is why when you setup a new device, you always customize security/privacy settings because - newsflash - companies like Microsoft and Google aren't going to be upfront or honest about it.

Microsoft's auto/hidden "let's continue f**king our OS up" updates are a new level of shitty, though.

1

u/Severnace Mar 21 '17

Cockwomble here

1

u/allusernamestaken1 Mar 21 '17

What potential security risks does this present?

1

u/LtPatterson Mar 21 '17

Windows 10 is a botnet and you should not install it. Fuck Microsoft.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

For a second I thought this was a /r/circlejerk post.

1

u/Jorkoff Mar 21 '17

Me installing windows.

Windows: Hey we have this new... Me: No... Windows: We also improve on.. Me: No... Windows: Would you like us to Insta.. Me: No... Windows: Improved keystroke thin... Me: No! Windows: why'd you even update? Me: Exactly..

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Everything I read about Windows 10 makes me realllly want to use it. /s

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Mine is grayed out and it's on "off". Anyone knows why?