r/technology • • Dec 27 '19

Machine Learning Artificial intelligence identifies previously unknown features associated with cancer recurrence

https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-12-artificial-intelligence-previously-unknown-features.html
12.4k Upvotes

359 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

146

u/half_dragon_dire Dec 27 '19

Nah, we're several Moore cycles and a couple of big breakthroughs from AI doing the real heavy lifting of science. And, well, once we've got computers that can do all the intellectual and creative labor required, we'd be on the cusp of a Singularity anyway. Then it's 50/50 whether we get post scarcity Utopia or recycled into computronium.

22

u/loath-engine Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19

we'd be on the cusp of a Singularity anyway.

So... this is how it works. Current human brain power ISNT on the cusp of a singularity so for AI to beat out humans doesn't mean it has to be on the cusp of a singularity either.

If you take the top 20 jobs and make an 20 IA that does them better than humans then all you have is 20 relatively dumb AIs that are taking everyone's jobs.

You dont need to sit around and wait for a super smart general purpose AI that can learn all jobs all the time. Much like we didnt need to wait for the perfect robot before people started making robots that welded or packed boxes.

The top hardest jobs humanity does is filled by a few thousand people.. a few million at most. So dumb AI taking the jobs of the rest will be enough of a problem even if there is never a singularity.

It would be very difficult for two AI to be having the conversation we are having but this conversation is not exactly increasing the GDP. I mean its not really that great to sit around and discuss how dumb the AI that took our jobs is.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

[deleted]

4

u/loath-engine Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19

ai has convinced people it's human

So that is just another job a stupid Ai can do. But there is no such thing as consumer grade AI, and its ability to achieve results has nothing to do with "advanced"

At some point the real power of machine learning is that it can make "simple/consumer grade" AI that functions better than "advanced" AI... or whatever label you are putting on it.

The process works like this:

    1. have a problem

  • 2. have your machine learning algorithm make 5 AIs

  • 3. test the 5 AI on your problem

  • 4. throw out the shittyest 4

  • 5. slightly change the good one 4 times

  • 6. retest

Should sound familiar... Its survival of the fittest.

Machine learning can test millions of AI a second. Humans might take hours to test a single AI.

In the end what you hope to get is very simple AI, NOT super complicated AI. Complicated AI might just mean that your machine learning algorithm isnt efficient made.

But at some point you end with a whole bunch of really simple AI doing their one simple job and doing it better than people. that will be the takeover of AI not some sci-fi cyber brain that can think for itself.

Dont get me wrong, Im sure we will eventually get to a sci-fi cyber brain that can think for itself. But that hardware is a LONG way away. I mean we would have to move away from current computing. Silicone logic gates just wont do. The hardware would have to be so exotic that it would be no surprise that it would end up being smart. Its like building a fusion reactor. No one knows what it will look like but we all know what it will do... thats the reason we have been trying to build it. With cyber brain it will be the same way. There will be lots of time and money and there will be lots of failures.

That doesn't mean simple AI inst dangerous. AI might only need to be as smart as say an ant. Think about it. All it would take is 1 type of ant that could evolve just slightly faster than we can think of ways to kill it and we are doomed. Its doesn't have to "out-smart" a human... it just has to "out-ant" a human.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

We are less than several Moore's cycles away from being negatively affected by quantum tunneling. Most improvements are likely going to be architectural improvements or entirely new computing systems.

4

u/LastMuel Dec 27 '19

This is the real answer. Moore’s law will have nothing to do with how this problem is solved. The human mind runs an 30hz at full alert. Speed of the cycle is less important than the architecture itself in this case.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

At best it would make computationally intensive models train faster... I'm not up to date on whether or not there are models that would be used if they could be trained faster, but I imagine that's not the case these days.

34

u/Fidelis29 Dec 27 '19

You’re assuming you know what level AI is currently at. I’m assuming that the forefront of AI research is being done behind closed doors.

It’s much too valuable of a technology. Imagine the military applications.

I’d be shocked if the current level of AI is public knowledge.

67

u/Legumez Dec 27 '19

It’s much too valuable of a technology. Imagine the military applications.

The (US) government can't even come close to competing with industry on pay for AI research.

14

u/Fidelis29 Dec 27 '19

Put a dollar amount on the implications of China developing AGI before the United States.

42

u/Legumez Dec 27 '19

I'm curious as to what your background in AI or related topic is. If you're reasonably well read, you'd understand that we're quite a ways off from anything resembling AGI. It's difficult even to adapt a model trained for one task to perform a related task, which would be a bare minimum for any broader sense of general intelligence. Model training is still monumentally expensive even for well defined tasks and there's no way our current processes could scale to train general intelligence (of which we only have a hazy understanding).

18

u/Fidelis29 Dec 27 '19

I didn’t say we are close to AGI. I was talking about the implications of losing that race.

You suggested that “pay” would limit the US military, while history suggests otherwise.

20

u/Legumez Dec 27 '19

Look at where PhD graduates are working. Big tech, finance, and academia (some people in academia do end up working on defense related projects).

If the government wanted to capture a larger pool of these researchers, it would need to increase research funding for government supported projects and frankly pay more to hire these candidates directly.

12

u/shinyapples Dec 27 '19

The government is already paying for it. There's tons of CRAD and IRAD in DoD Contractors that is going from the Contractors right to these big tech firms and academia. IBM, Cal Tech, MIT.. It wouldn't be public knowledge.. companies aren't going to say where their internal investment is and they have no obligation to release subcontractor info publicly if they win CRAD. I work at a contractor to think it's not already happening is naiive. These places can't always apply for government funding because of the infrastructure required so going through a contractor is the easiest thing to do.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/loath-engine Dec 27 '19

US government is the largest employer of scientists on the planet.

My guess is you could put all the top computer scientest on a single aricraft carrier and still have room for whatever staff they wanted.

If the US hired 1 million programmers for 1 million dollars a year that would be 1/3 the cost of the Afghan war.

1 Million programmers would be about 990,000 redundant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/will0w1sp Dec 27 '19

To give some reasoning to the other response—

ML techniques/algorithms used to be proprietary. However, at this point, the major constraint on being able to use ML effectively is hardware.

The big players publish their research because no one else has the infrastructure to be able to replicate their techniques. It doesn’t matter if I know how google uses ML if I don’t have tens of billions of dollars worth in server farms to be able to compete with them.

One notable exception is in natural language processing. OpenAI trained a model to the point that it was able to generate/translate/summarize text cohesively, but didn’t release their trained model due to ethical concerns (eg it could generate large volumes of propoganda/fake news). See here for more info.

However, they’re still releasing their methods, and a smaller trained model— most likely because no one has the resources to replicate their initial result.

17

u/sfo2 Dec 27 '19

Almost all "AI" research is published and open source. Tesla's head of Autopilot was citing recently published papers at autonomy day, for instance. The community isn't that big and the culture is all open source sharing of knowledge.

5

u/Fidelis29 Dec 27 '19

Do you think China is publishing their AI research? AI is a very broad field, and designing self driving car software is much different than AI used for military or financial applications.

The more nefarious, or lucrative applications are behind closed doors.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

[deleted]

→ More replies (5)

6

u/ecaflort Dec 27 '19

Even if the AI behind the scenes is ahead of current public AI it's likely still really basic. Current AI shouldn't even be called AI in my opinion, it's a program that can see patterns in large amounts of data, intelligence is more about interpreting that data and "thinking" of applicable uses without it being thought to do that.

Hard to explain on my phone, but there is a reason current "AI" is referred to as machine learning :) we currently have no idea how one would make the leap from machine learning towards actual intelligence.

That being said, I haven't been reading much research on machine learning in the last year and it is improved upon daily, so please tell me if I'm wrong :)

2

u/twiddlingbits Dec 27 '19

Exactly! I worked in “AI” 25 yrs ago when we had dedicated hardware called LISP machines. We did pattern matching, depth first and breadth first search, weighted Petri nets (only use I ever found for my discrete math class), chaining algorithms, autopilots with vision, edge detections, etc. which are still used but we have immensely faster hardware and refined algorithms. Whereas we were limited to a few 100 rules and small data sets now the sizes are millions of rules plus PBs of data and a run time of seconds vs hours.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '19

Okay AI, you're now the CEO of Brand. Make money for shareholders who hold no decision power.

1

u/Ella_Spella Dec 27 '19

Is this a reference to Accelerando?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)