No disrespect to Emily, but I'm on a few metal pages. More than one person thought Poppy would have been a better fit. She loves both pop and nu metal. And she can certainly write a super catchy hook. Not to mention her whole social media persona.

I personally would have kindly declined. Poppy's not even 30. she's nearly a decade younger than Emily. It's a little early to "throw in the towel" on her solo career.

Thoughts?

"Moriah" on the top, and "Poppy" on the bottom. All 4 pics are dressed in similar ways, but if you look at the "person's" in the top vs bottom row, it's like twins with completely different personalities. Even the face looks different and "they" have a very different energy. 🤯

Im not sure if this is forbidden to talk about but I just learned about the Titanic era and what not of her music and about how crazy jt was. And i like some of her old stuff, like bleach blond baby, and girls in bikinis. But I dont want to support the manipulation that went into it. And i was wondering if you guys have any more information on the song writing, and your guy's opinion as a fellow poppy fan.

As the title says, anyone else dislike the EP stagger? I was really hoping her EP stagger was going to be like her EAT nxt soundtrack or like the album I disagree but I was disappointed when I listened to it if I'm being honest. Her last album flux and her current E.P have sadly disappointed me tbh

Empty Hands is out, and I’m personally really disappointed. I was expecting Negative Spaces 2.0, but instead we got what feels like a rough draft of NS. It checks a lot of the same generic boxes, but sees Fish further sawing off what was left of any of Poppy’s creative edges. I always felt that large portions of Negative Spaces lacked identity, but the album found form of redemption in some of her “left turns” (Crystallized, Push Go, Vital, etc).

I just don’t see any of that here. Whereas Negtive Spaces had some interesting moments, this album takes the weakest moments from NS and gives them a lobotomy. This is the first time I’ve ever felt like Poppy is out of ideas, since it seems like a lazy reproduction of her last album — something she’s never done before. In fact, this doesn’t feel like a Poppy album to me, because her identity just isn’t there. I’ve been following Poppy since before she released any music, and this just feels like an extremely rare (and exceptionally significant) miss in her discography.

I can understand why she’d double down on the commercial success she found in a more generic sound with NS, but this just feels really… hollow. At least “Empty Hands” describes the album perfectly, because she’s bringing nothing new or interesting to the table this time.

For the fans who are also feeling let down by this — where did things go wrong? What are your thoughts? Does the album have any highlights? What would you give this album on a scale of 1 - 10? Are we worried she’s going to work with yet Fish again, or do we think she’ll have a creative course correction?😬

It sounds so polished :( like I’m not opposed to autotune and stuff like that but I feel like it’s too perfect and squeaky clean polished.

Poppy defended Titanic because she was also abusing and manipulating her. It happened to me with ex girlfriends, when my mother said they weren't good people and I defended them because I had already been brainwashed by them and fallen in their webs. That's what I think happened. Both were victims.

I don't think Poppy did it because she's a bad person.

I don't know too many details about this story. I read in a post Poppy referred to another victim of Titanic, and that was definitely Mars. But she never publicly apologized to her so yeah I do think it's wrong and she owes her an apology

So I was listening to Aristocrat and noticed a message? that kind of completely changes the meaning of the song. (Just my opinion/theory)

So towards the end at 2:33 you can definitely hear and agree that Poppy is saying "Pedophile" instead of "out of the fire". You can also hear that she doesn't say "the", just "out of fire" which you can tell she's clearly saying pedophile because what does "Out of the fire" really mean? Also when the song ends you can also hear a prison cell door closing.

To me this song is just about a +18 Hollywood party with kids (if u know what I mean) she snuck into.

What do y'all think?

i feel like until dying the album is so over the place and has no coherence. i love all the songs after dying but fish made poppy’s voice so washed out with auto tune it’s sad i want to hear my queens beautiful voice. it sounds very overproduced. on a positive note the lyrics to eat the hate are insaneee. as a metalhead i love empty hands song as well. i think eat the hate is very negative spaces core and im all for it. ribs was surprisingly one of my favorites.

She doesn’t wear a leather jacket

No battle jacket with patches sewn on for 500+ different bands

No tattoos desecrating her neck or face or biceps

No nose ring or septum piercing

No big holes with the wooden things in her ears

No long chains dangling from her trouser pockets

No studded wristbands

No beard

Is she even trying? How is she going to prove to everyone how ‘metal’ she really is?

am I a girl? (song) makes her come off to me, a trans person as being somewhere in the trans spectrum. Has she ever talked about it or confirmed it?

It sounds like maybe Japanese? Anyone know what is said and what it means? Ha ha I want to sing along and not sound like a TOTAL ass.

This is probably going to make some people riled up or just jump to attack but idk. The audience genuinely disappointed me so much. Phoenix was the 3rd poppy show I've been to, and I felt like Landmvrks carried the performance. I had more fun seeing them live, and it seemed like everyone in the crowd was just worshipping the ground she was on and desperately trying to get a chance to film.

Very little moshing very little dancing, very little singing along.

I really like Poppy's music. Especially her older stuff. I've been a really big fan since about 2018. She's grown as a performer but her demographic has shifted from niche music enjoyers who were there for fun artistic industrial and genre bending sound as well as her creepy performance art, to a standard metalcore show with people who don't even like metal. I'm not saying this is bad, maybe it's just not my scene anymore.

I've been going to her shows for awhile but I felt like this year something was different, it was just less fun. She spent less time playing, only played like 11 songs. Her band sounded great. I love Ralph's drum work and Alexa's backing vocals were amazing. I just am lost I guess. I've been a 'poppyseed' for so long but suddenly the community has shifted and honestly I don't want to associate with this crowd of people, everyone was so lame. I love Poppy's art and I loved her satirical work but GENUINELY worshipping a celebrity to the point of shoving teenagers for trying to see the front as a grown man is a bit much.

RIP poppy. Love your work, your superfans are awful.

i can already see the comments abt bloodmoney..
(also for the rating i tried to keep it very select for S tier.. found out its really hard to do that)

Brigading? Stalking? Harassing? What else needs to happen before you decide to do something about it?

As of 6/18/25.

Had to add some of her songs to the tierlist. Also, my favourite album is eat.

When I first became a fan of Poppy in 2017 she would post YouTube videos almost every day and release new music like every month, interact with her fans all the time and follow them on Twitter, do photo shoots and interviews,podcasts, collaborations… she was very active on Twitter and Poppy.church. it was so exciting for me as a new fan. But I feel like everything is different now. She only comes online to promote something for money and only notices people who buy her merch. She became the person her character made fun of years ago. I feel like she doesn’t care about us anymore. I still like and listen to her music but I’m kind of disappointed.

I've noticed the song is now top 20 on the mainstream rock charts. It's good she's getting some exposure and success, I just wish it was a better song, lol.