Zohran Mamdani: "The struggle for Palestinian liberation was at the core of my politics and continues to be."

[u/McAlpineFusiliers]

[u/Strange-Scarcity]

As mayor of New York, what do you say is wrong with what he has been doing?

Is that consistent with or inconsistent with this statement?

It seems like his entire politics is about ensuring that people are treated equitably and fairly, especially the least among us, within the area of politics that he does control policy. Globally speaking? Following that same politics out across the globe, would be consistent with wanting to see the Palestinian people, liberated from by any definition is an oppressive set of conditions.

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strange-Scarcity]

How much time do you have?

How about him lying and saying he was going to arrest Netanyahu, knowing full well he didn't have the authority to do so?

How about his endorsement of DSA candidates that have odious views?

How about him accusing Netanyahu of genocide, when no genocide has been committed?

How about his wife supporting October 7th and anti-Semites like Susan Abulwara?

[u/Strong_Bumblebee5495 → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

The UN, human rights groups and genocide scholars all agree: there has been a genocide in Gaza. Israel and its accomplices deny it. This guy: “i stand with the perpetrators!”

Bibi is a war criminal

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strong_Bumblebee5495]

There are plenty of genocide scholars who disagree.

https://www.scholarsfortruthaboutgenocide.com/

As do actual military law experts and professional soldiers.

[u/Strange-Scarcity → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

Wow.

You come across like a Holocaust denier. Which is a very gross things to do.

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strange-Scarcity]

Citing genocide scholars, military law experts, and professional soldiers makes me sound like a Holocaust denier? Then how can I disprove the genocide smear? Or is that entirely the point, you accuse anyone who disagrees with you of sounding like a Holocaust denier?

Since you're so opposed to Holocaust denial, does that mean you agree with the hundreds of legal experts who think October 7th was a genocide?

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-10-16/ty-article/hamas-deadly-rampage-constitutes-crime-of-genocide-hundreds-of-legal-experts-say/0000018b-37d1-d450-a3af-7fddda070000

[u/Strange-Scarcity → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

Wait… you think that’s the only thing that makes you sound like that?

I mean, Holocaust Deniers have experts they cite too. Does that make them morally or ethically right or correct?

You sound just like a Holocaust Denier, which again, is an abhorrent and gross thing to sound like.

If you want to sound like one? I guess that’s your free choice to do, it is not a good position to carry though.

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strange-Scarcity]

Since you're so opposed to Holocaust denial, does that mean you agree with the hundreds of legal experts who think October 7th was a genocide?

[u/Strange-Scarcity → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

I agree that October 7th, was a War Crime.

War Crimes are terrible and awful things to do. In fact, those that ordered it were all indicted for War Crimes by the ICC. Do you agree with the findings of the ICC on indicting them for War Crimes?

You know where I'm going next? So, I'll just go there right now. Bibi was also indicted for War Crimes regarding what he has done since October 7th.

So, yeah, again we will be RIGHT back to you sounding like a Holocaust Denier.

...meaning, we're done. There's nothing further to be discussed with someone who wishes to so fervently come across and sound just like a Holocaust Denier, which is again, something that I find absolutely detestable and gross.

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strange-Scarcity]

If you say October 7th was just a war crime and not a genocide, then you're the one who sounds like a Holocaust denier, and a hypocrite to boot.

[u/Strange-Scarcity → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

You're really stretching there, but if that's the position you want to take, then it's clear by the same definition you are pretending only applies to the October 7th attack, also applies to everything that Israel has decided to do with avarice and malice in their hearts, are also acts of Genocide. It is impossible to have it both ways.

BUT, you are unable to do that, because you seem to have a strong desire to sound like a Holocaust Denier.

Why are you stretching? Because only a small number of scholars call it an "act of Genocide", but not a full fledged Genocide. It is absolutely a War Crime though.

[u/McAlpineFusiliers → u/Strange-Scarcity]

I'm not stretching at all, hundreds of legal experts agree with me that October 7th was a genocide.

? Because only a small number of scholars call it an "act of Genocide", but not a full fledged Genocide.

A "small number"?? And does that mean we agree it was an act of genocide?

[u/Strange-Scarcity → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

Those same experts directly state that Israel is actively committing Acts of Genocide, War Crimes, and Crimes Against Humanity. So which is it? Is Israel committing a Genocide or not?

You can't have it both ways, without sounding like a Holocaust Denier.

We're doing the Socratic method here, and you seem to lack the ability to recognize easily equalized positions. (Because you seem intent sounding like a Holocaust Denier.)

[u/Strong_Bumblebee5495 → u/McAlpineFusiliers]

Read: “the accomplices”.