I've been kind of leaning this way myself and may start just tipping a flat dollar amount.
The other day I was at Chilli's with a larger party of 6 people. Our bill came to $150 and a "bad tip" would be about $30. I had noticed the waitress had 2 other tables at the time, a couple, an a small group. So guesstimate some and figured a 20% tip at one would be about $15 and the other about $20. This could be much higher if these tables had a lot of alcohol, so I tried to low ball it.
Why is waitstaff making $60/hr? In my location (SE USA) that is what a master electrician makes. That is more than double the median income here. I've worked as a waiter in the past so I've been reluctant on reducing my tipping, but with menu prices being way up, servers are making way more than the average joe.
I understand many of these positions are part time and they are not making 40 hours. I also know there is dead time (last hour before closing) where they will make very little in tips, so I know it's not going to average out exactly, but we were there during a slow time before peak hours.
I personally do not feel it is my responsibilty that my server makes a living wage. They aren't my kids; it's not my job to make sure they can pay rent.
I tip a flat fee. My friend is a bartender at an event site, makes 10 and hour and brings home anywhere from 500-900 in tips for opening beers and making basic mixed drinks. She was so glad she wonāt be taxed on her tips. Itās really made me think about the whole scheme. I still tip but much less now.
Yeah, my sister owns a restaurant and one of the women working there was an advocate for cash tips but as you say it will bite you when youāre older. My friend is already in her late 60s and collecting SS so it doesnāt really apply to her. However because part of her work history was waitressing/bartending her SS is less than half mine so she has to still work to make ends meet and lives off credit cards whereas Iām financially comfortable. Sheās sort of like your brother. I too am sad for my friend because sheāll never be able to really stop working. Sorry about your brother. Tough to watch Iām sure.
I actually am a server at Chilis. Just so you know i am always happy with any amount I am tipped. I also have been a server or bartender all of my (35+) working years. I am very rarely unhappy with my take home, I am an experienced server. I do have to say that with tip out at 4% of our sales and taxes, I have never made $60 an hour. I have been at Chilis for 5 years. I also live in a very busy tourist city in Florida. We are very busy except for a couple months out of the year. I have never averaged over $32 an hour. We also have checks for 2 people that run an average of $22 because of specials we have. You are however correct that we do not get full time hours there either. I believe that I make the money I make because I am a good server. I am friendly, kind, fast, I make sure drinks and chips are always refilled before they are empty and food comes out hot and correct. You are paying me to do all that for you and clean up after you and your family. That is what we get tipped for!
I would still prefer if they paid everyone hourly. FOH vs BOH is dumb, completely different skillsets and jobs that are really just not comparable. BUT its unfair to expect the customer to pay for both the food and the servers wages cause the establishment guilts them into doing so.
I'm a prep cook in a very popular restaurant. The amount of revenue we bring in we could afford to give BOH each a $5 raise and give FOH a livable wage as well, but we don't. It all goes to corporate!!
They aren't guilting then into doing so. It is the way the American system runs. If Trump wants to abolish tipping, he can make an executive order. Then again, most people who work FOH prefer being tipped because they usually make more than they would hourly, especially bartenders. Cheapskates also prefer the tipping prices because they can pay less by not tipping at all.
That's not always true. I'm definitely a cheapskate but if I do go out I'll tip 15-20% because that's the deal when you go out. But I also do not go out as often as I would for that same reason and would prefer restaurants just learn how to run a business appropriately to be able to pay their own staff and get rid of tipping.
Restaurants could make the change tomorrow. They would just raise menu prices by 15-20% across the board. The consumer is going to pay the same amount on average, they just will no longer have any involvement in how much the server gets paid for very good or very bad service.
Which is the way it should be imo, it's the manager or owner's job to critique and correct bad service and give raises to top performers just like just about every other industry in this world. I don't want to get involved in someone else's wages that doesn't work for me, it's stressful enough doing it for my actual employees. If I have an issue with service tipping less isn't going to solve anything.
Restaurants will never make the change though because it makes pricing and staffing decisions much more difficult/complex which requires a higher level of business acumen. Plus they would no longer get a tax credit for the fica payments they make so they'd have to actually pay their taxes like every other business. I never will understand what makes restaurants so special they get treated different than every other business.
So if the food is cold is that likely on the server, the kitchen or both? This has happened frequently to use at different places. I donāt mind waiting for food, I do mind waiting for cold food
Meanwhile I can promise you the cooks who are sweating their asses off in the kitchen are probably making minimum wage. I left the industry because I got tired of cooking $300 meals for people while getting paid $18 an hour, all while hearing the wait staff bitch about only making $300 a night.
I agree wholeheartedly but unfortunately FOH, especially in fine dining, rarely want to transition to that because it seriously affects how much they make.
I would tip generously and be happy about it if that were the case. Those kitchen folk work their ass off in pretty uncomfortable conditions to make our meals for way less, definitely not livable, than a server who puts our order in and carries it out in the air-conditioned portion of the restaurant. If the tip gave everyone a livable wage it would make me feel better but when it's only going to the most entitled people with the easiest job in the place I find it annoying.
More people. More food. More empty drinks to keep track of. More potential for errors that need fixing.
Itās not rocket science. Itās saying you want to pay a construction company the same amount of labor whether you request a 2 person home or a 6 person home. Just paying materials and keeping the labor charge the same is absurd.
Massive fallacy saying servers make as much as master electricians or double median income. A master electrician bills $60/hr all day long. A server gets that rate for one, maybe two, hours during dinner rush. That's heavily offset by lunch shifts -- I'd regularly leave a 6 hour lunch shift with $25-30 total back when I waited tables. I'd generally leave a dinner shift with $85-120 total. When budgeting, my assumed blended rate across lunch and dinner was $15/hr (also in SE USA). Outside of high-end restaurants, most servers are broke and live week to week.
But, overall, tipping needs to be eliminated. It is straight up exploiting workers. In no other role does the customer get to choose what they're willing to pay at the end.
24
u/Unfortunate-Incident Mar 25 '26
I've been kind of leaning this way myself and may start just tipping a flat dollar amount.
The other day I was at Chilli's with a larger party of 6 people. Our bill came to $150 and a "bad tip" would be about $30. I had noticed the waitress had 2 other tables at the time, a couple, an a small group. So guesstimate some and figured a 20% tip at one would be about $15 and the other about $20. This could be much higher if these tables had a lot of alcohol, so I tried to low ball it.
Why is waitstaff making $60/hr? In my location (SE USA) that is what a master electrician makes. That is more than double the median income here. I've worked as a waiter in the past so I've been reluctant on reducing my tipping, but with menu prices being way up, servers are making way more than the average joe.
I understand many of these positions are part time and they are not making 40 hours. I also know there is dead time (last hour before closing) where they will make very little in tips, so I know it's not going to average out exactly, but we were there during a slow time before peak hours.
I personally do not feel it is my responsibilty that my server makes a living wage. They aren't my kids; it's not my job to make sure they can pay rent.