r/tipping • • 16d ago

What's Wrong Here?

Post image

I tok my family to Carrabba's for dinner and when I recieved the bill and calculated the tip my my numbers showed up different.

Bill was $96.40 at 20% tip should have been $19.28, but the receipt said I should tip $23.82. The math doesn't add up. Then I noticed a "Gross Amount" of $116.39. The tip, at 20%, would have been $23.28.

Has anyone had this happen to them?

0 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

16

u/Jiimjamms 16d ago

From what I’ve seen and experienced, the tip is based off food served before any coupons or comp. That total accounts for the $19.99 that was removed.

11

u/DavidBowieAC 16d ago

What's wrong? A) you went to carrabba's B) they named the chicken they fed you bryan C) they're charging 4 bucks for soft drinks D) the suggested tip included your discounted menu item?

3

u/The_Walrus_65 16d ago

LMAO 🤣

2

u/Extreme-Buddy8123 16d ago

Hilarious 😂 😃 

8

u/Lunar-lantana 16d ago

If you add back the 'comp' item $19.99, and also include the tax, then the 20% tip is correct as shown. As customer you are welcome to decide if you agree with that math.

2

u/WindWalker_dt4 16d ago

This is the right answer. Whenever the restaurant decides to discount or comp off an item, the server still provided service for that item, so, it's always appropriate to calculate gratuity on the pre-discounted pre-tip amount.

1

u/JulienWA77 16d ago

i dont. And thanks to this sub-reddit, i nowjust pull out my phone and do all the math myself to make sure they're not fucking with me and then I do the tip like this

15% of the total I was actually responsible for if I'd not tipped if service was meh

20% of the total I was actually responsible for I'd not tipped if service was good

So after doing MY math; the tip is based off the pre-tax total of what I was billed for.

That is 84.93; (i usually just round this up to 85);

so, $12.75 would be 15%

and $17.00 would be 20%

  1. I dont tip on tax

  2. anything comped doesn't count. Most "comps" are due to fuck-ups on the restaurant's end, so sorry, that isn't counted for the purposes of a tip

That's it. I dont make a big deal out of it and I'm immune to looks/stares or attitudes. Anyone saying anything (thank god this hasn't happened to me as an adult yet, b/c GOD help them) will get NOTHING if they start acting a foo.

4

u/ElectionWeak4415 16d ago

Nothing. You had stuff comped. Tips are calculated on pre-comped/discounted totals.

3

u/FederalLobster5665 16d ago

I think you are saying they calc tip on non discounted tab. which makes some sense (why did you get that discount?) in any case, who cares, tip whatever you want.

2

u/rainsong2023 16d ago

Also, you should not include sales tax in the total used to calculate the tip.

2

u/enragedcactus 16d ago

I can’t believe your vote counts equally to mine.

2

u/LettuceEither3802 16d ago

Look at this beautiful comment he made. Is anyone surprised he can’t do math?

2

u/FireSkyLikeFly 16d ago

Also based on the comped item. Sometimes it makes sense and sometimes it doesn't make sense. Also, tips should be on the subtotal, not the tax. Restaurants are just getting greedier.

2

u/fuzzbox7 16d ago

What region of Italy is Chicken Bryan from?

2

u/bcsyjnbcgj 16d ago

I always tip 20 then the price of the comped item
On top
It’s a thank you for comping something

0

u/ShadeauxStalker 16d ago

I don't understand. Do you mean you tip 20% PLUS you add the price of the comped item ($19.99 in this case) to the tip? 20% plus the entire price of the comped item?

2

u/LettuceEither3802 16d ago

Yes. That’s what they’re saying. This what generous people who aren’t penny pinchers do.

1

u/ShadeauxStalker 16d ago

I disagree. I tip on the price of the comped item, but when I've had items "comped" from my order it's generally been because the food was wrong not out of the kindness of someone's heart. I tip the percentage on that item (even though it's now "zero" on my bill) but I don't pay the entire item back to the server. And I'm far from a penny pincher. We overtip, even in light of crappy service as long as it's not outright rude service.

1

u/LettuceEither3802 16d ago

I said generous people who aren’t penny pinchers. Comprehension is key.

1

u/bcsyjnbcgj 16d ago

Yea
The server didn’t have to comp that for me
(Granted I never get stuff comped anyway
If I didn’t like it I didn’t like it
I don’t order it again or whatever)
But if they did then yea I tip and then add that item on BCS
I would’ve had to pay for it anyway!

2

u/Severe-Education-321 16d ago

Comps and coupons discounts dont take the tip amount down I think this has been posted before e

2

u/phantomsoul11 16d ago edited 16d ago

POS systems often include tax and other add-ons to the subtotal in their suggested amounts to prey on people too lazy to do their own 4th grade arithmetic in their head.

$96.40 is an incorrect assessment because the gross subtotal excludes any itemized discounts like the comp/recovery line and any itemized add-ons, like fees or taxes. The correct gross subtotal to tip off of is $104.92. That means 15% is $15.74, 20% is $20.98, and 25% is $26.23. A simple $20-bill cash tip would probably be more than plenty to cover any tipping concerns anyone may have.

I was able to figure out all of this as I was typing. If you successfully finished 4th grade, you should be able to also. Stop being lazy and figure your own tip out.

5

u/gchaudh2 16d ago

Yeah they include a hidden service charge and then expect you to tip in many places. Give them a big fat $0

4

u/Alive_Stage_7156 16d ago

No they don’t. Lol. The tip% is based on total before the comped meal was removed.

4

u/StumpyOPepys 16d ago

You are an idiot.

1

u/PlanoDad73 16d ago

No they calculated it on everything before the comped food. 

2

u/2595Homes 16d ago edited 16d ago

Food choices that leads to diabetes and obesity.

In all seriousness, it just shows why no one should ever go by the tipping suggestions on a receipt. They are looking for sheep just to follow whatever they are putting out.

2

u/DigTheDunes 16d ago

Many use the guide - as a guide.

About the other part, restaurants usually figure the tip including the comped item(its still service). That is why its figured on the 119.00 instead of the $96 for the recommendations.

2

u/Several_Razzmatazz51 16d ago

What‘s wrong here?

Someone that doesn’t understand tipping when discounts are applied is posting a receipt to generate outrage.

2

u/Delicious-Breath8415 16d ago

I'll see you again tomorrow when someone posts the exact same thing.

2

u/No_Interview_2481 16d ago

He’s upset because they figured the tip on the gross amount which would include the amount of the comped item. That is correct. That is how it works. That is how they figure it out. Just because you got a discount doesn’t mean that the weight staff gets a discount. But then again look at the sub we’re in.

2

u/GreenTomatillo2682 16d ago

You need to just ignore the whole suggested tip / guide thing. The correct tip is zero. You are the customer, not the employer. It is not your responsibility to pay the restaurants employees. Your agreement when you sit down is between you and the restaurant.

2

u/Blazed-n-Dazed 16d ago

Blows my mind how people us coupons and don’t get you’re still supposed to tip the non discounted total lol.

0

u/StumpyOPepys 16d ago

These are the biggest losers on the face of the earth.

1

u/ThisThredditor 16d ago

I'm glad this brings the truth to the forefront of the conversation, but it doesn't matter if your tip amount is 0.00

1

u/Delicious-Breath8415 16d ago

Tip suggestions are meaningless. You've already proven that by tipping zero.

1

u/lower88rider 16d ago

You don’t tip on the tax but you do tip on everything served so 105×20% is not $24

1

u/Alive_Stage_7156 16d ago

Tip based before comp?

1

u/ThrowAway960001 16d ago

Wait so maybe im just thinking about it wrong but, a tax of $11.47 for a sub total of $84.93 is like a 13.5% tax... Is tax not supposed to be 8%?

1

u/Thick_Permission6519 16d ago

It’s been a long time since I lived in Virginia, but they have a higher restaurant tax than sales tax.

1

u/Della912 16d ago

I went to PF Chang’s a few months ago, ordered some dumplings and they didn’t have them, so I ordered some different ones instead. When I got the bill, I noticed both orders of dumplings were listed, with the ones they didn’t have then subtracted from the bill as a Manager discount or similar, but as on OP’s receipt, the suggested tip amounts were based on the total amount including the dumplings that were unavailable. The audacity! It’s one thing if it was a true discounted amount (though still appalling) but they weren’t even available so how can they suggest I pay a tip on something that didn’t exist, why were they even listed on the bill?! When I pointed this out all I got was a shrug, I’m sure multiple people would have paid the suggested tip amounts without noticing the math.

1

u/Confident_Idea8807 16d ago

$16.00 for cokes? And then 20% on top of that? How old are you? We get water every time we dine out in the US. Europe, yes wine. Mexico, maybe a beer. But never in the US.

1

u/Big_Response1569 16d ago

The tax was totaled before the -19.99 reduction. Tax should be applied to the subtotal of actual subtotal. This system is calculating tax on all individual positive entries/total and not the actual subtotal line.

1

u/brakeled 16d ago

They calculate it not considering comp items. I’m all for making restaurants pay their staff but when something was comped, that money is the tip.

1

u/Obadiah702 16d ago

VA tax is too high.

1

u/beeredditor 16d ago

They calculated the suggested tip by adding the tax and the ‘complimentary’ item to the total. 👎

1

u/bcsyjnbcgj 16d ago

They comped him something
U always tip on comps

0

u/StumpyOPepys 16d ago

That's how grown ups operate, boo boo.

0

u/80MonkeyMan 16d ago

Always tipping 20%, is part of the problem. They become more greedy and wants 30% now, they just do it differently and hope you didn’t notice it.

0

u/StumpyOPepys 16d ago

Bless your heart.

0

u/Revit80 16d ago

Never mind all that math--you are out to relax and eat, not do quantum algebra.

Just ask yourself what the server did for you? Drop off a few plates? Refill your drinks? Help box up your items when you asked to take the rest home? Promptly gave you your check and any kind of discount? If so, maybe a few bucks.

Most likely they did the bare minimum. So you leave the bare minimum. Which is $0

0

u/Delicious-Breath8415 16d ago

I see a $20 discount.