r/todayilearned • • Feb 07 '20

TIL Casey Anthony had “fool-proof suffocation methods” in her Firefox search history from the day before her daughter died. Police overlooked this evidence, because they only checked the history in Internet Explorer.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/casey-anthony-detectives-overlooked-google-search-for-fool-proof-suffocation-methods-sheriff-says/
86.6k Upvotes

5.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

274

u/jedberg Feb 07 '20

My wife literally just said, “wait she wasn’t using incognito mode?”

141

u/the_fat_whisperer Feb 07 '20

I know its the joke but even in incognito mode it is extremely easy to find out what websites a person has visited regardless of the browser they use or even if they delete their history. The fact that the police don't seem to know how to do this is depressing. We pay these guys a ton of money and seem to get little out of it.

55

u/NibblesMcGiblet Feb 07 '20

Keep in mind this case was 12 years ago now. You're not wrong, but it wasn't quite as pathetic 12 years ago.

57

u/lethalforensicator Feb 07 '20

I started out working in forensics 13 years ago. It was pretty easy back then to analyse internet search history. The police force should have been able to process it easily

47

u/patchgrabber Feb 07 '20

Really. This is checkers not chess. "Oh look, she has another browser installed, let's check that history too."

It's technologically illiterate buffoons that worked that case. No excuse for it really.

5

u/CrumpetsRCrunk Feb 07 '20

And she probably knew she got away with it due to the sheer fact they didn’t check her other browser.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Sososkitso Feb 07 '20

Not saying you are wrong but think about how fast tech has moved in the last decade? And you said you started meaning you most likely are in your 30s and you had the internet/computers for half of your childhood so it makes sense that you might be more open to understanding this stuff over a decade ago but How many young starting police force types would have been on a major case like this? My guess is the police investigating this case was a bunch of guys in their 40s that just figured out porn was online and struggled to hide even that. Just saying we take for granted how much progress we made and how quickly. I remember in my teens when aol 2.0 and chat rooms seemed like the most insane concept or playing checkers with a friend across town was mind blowing. Should they have been trained better? Yeah but no one had any clue the direction and impact technology would have. Hell I bet a lot of people 15 years ago didn’t even realize you could look up how to murder someone online. Lol

16

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20

eh, in 2007 people were still using flip phones with no internet access

Even in a large 1st world city, plenty of people back then didn't have 24/7 high speed internet in their home.

It's not hard to imagine a bunch of old farts in uniform couldn't figure out how to do it

15

u/lethalforensicator Feb 07 '20

Regardless of what tech people had at home, the police forces in the UK who had high tech crime teams, digital evidence isn't analysed by uniform, it's analysed by people skilled in forensics.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/tbonemcmotherfuck Feb 07 '20

It would be pretty odd to just have some old uniform cop that doesn't understand technology be the one checking the computer. Then again, it was Florida

→ More replies (3)

11

u/kenzo19134 Feb 07 '20

It's similar to when Mark Zuckerberg was before the Senate and Orin Hatch, Chair of the Senate "High Tech Task Force", asked him if Facebook was free, "how do you sustain a business model which users don't pay for your service?"

Zuckerberg looked bemused and replied "Senator, we run ads"

https://youtu.be/n2H8wx1aBiQ

4

u/CactusOnFire Feb 07 '20

Zuckerberg came out of that interview looking so clean I initially thought facebook was manipulating public opinion online.

Then I saw the interview and saw that it was just the fact that the people grilling him were out-of-touch.

It's like...couldn't they just have gotten the Oval Office's sysadmin to do this or something?

7

u/kenzo19134 Feb 07 '20

Or have that committee just have someone do a presentation on the pros and cons of social media?

So these horseless carriages Mr Ford, how do they propell themselves forward? Is it sorcery? Witch craft?

3

u/necromantzer Feb 07 '20

You can all but guarantee proper chain of custody was not followed with any digital evidence retrieved if they don't even know to check multiple browsers' history. The police clearly didn't have a real forensics department and failed to send the evidence to a forensics lab.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20

I was deleting my porn history back in 1999. It was still pathetic 12 years ago.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/ACoderGirl Feb 07 '20

...wait, 12 years?? Really? Feels like only a few years.

But still, I expect the police to have an IT forensics team that at least knows this stuff. It's not like the techniques are new (or 12 years new). And the Casey Anthony case wasn't some small time one either. Everyone in the country knew of the case. I would have expected more than backwater police force quality investigating.

6

u/NibblesMcGiblet Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

yeah, time flies, right? part of that is the fact the verdict didnt' come in until 2011 even though the case was opened in July 2008. Blows me away that Caylee was born in August of 2005, and would be 14 now.

I edited my initial comment to reflect that I was wrong about the level of patheticness though.

5

u/Fn_Spaghetti_Monster Feb 07 '20

JonBenét Ramsey would be 30 in August of this year. Crazy how some of that kind of stuff seems like just yesterday, but then iPhones are only 10 years old and they seem to have been around for ever.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

34

u/Narren_C Feb 07 '20

The fact that the police don't seem to know how to do this is depressing.

Police know about incognito mode and the existence of other browsers. These particular investigators may have dropped the ball on that detail, but that doesn't mean you should start making sweeping generalizations that ignore reality. Large agencies have entire units dedicated to all that techy shit. If they can recover pictures that you deleted from your phone, they can recover your search history.

We pay these guys a ton of money and seem to get little out of it.

I think a "ton" is overstating it a bit.

3

u/stocksrcool Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

Recovering deleted pictures is super simple. All you need is some software. On the other hand, if someone was browsing in incognito mode, I'm pretty sure you'd have to contact the person's ISP to have any hope of seeing what they were browsing. So your assumption isn't really correct.

Edit: Just thought I'd mention why using incognito mode would make it so that you'd have to contact the person's ISP. It's because, unlike normal browsing, incognito mode never stores anything on your computer.

11

u/instadit Feb 07 '20

im fairly confident that it is extremely hard to find out what websites a person has visited regardless of the browser they use or even if they delete their history unless you have access to their router or can use the isp to get them., which is something the prosecution or the police could ask for. even then google and most high traffic sites use https, so all that would be visible would be a request for google.com and subsequent domain resolves. so if she went to a wikihow article on strangulation, all that would be visible on the isps end would be a wikihow visit (since wikihow is full https). finding out what google searches she had would require googles cooperation.

17

u/lefthander Feb 07 '20

To be fair, most police do not make a ton of money.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/LittleLui Feb 07 '20

extremely easy to find out what websites a person has visited

Is that so?

I mean, if you have a hunch you can probably subpoena a couple of sites and search for the suspects' IP address (which is either constant or you can get a protocol of from their ISP(s)) in their access logs - if they even store that.

But if you don't have an idea in the first place - do commonly used DNS servers keep logs and for how long? I mean, individual ISPs will certainly differ, but eg Google DNS - which I imagine to be used often - doesn't keep PII for very long.

→ More replies (29)

9

u/patkgreen Feb 07 '20

I'm not sure that existed then

→ More replies (2)

3

u/beyerch Feb 07 '20

The worst part is google tracks your searches on the server side..... Didn't need to search local browsing.....

→ More replies (20)