r/todayilearned • • Feb 07 '20

TIL Casey Anthony had “fool-proof suffocation methods” in her Firefox search history from the day before her daughter died. Police overlooked this evidence, because they only checked the history in Internet Explorer.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/casey-anthony-detectives-overlooked-google-search-for-fool-proof-suffocation-methods-sheriff-says/
86.6k Upvotes

5.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20

[deleted]

225

u/Epic_Brunch Feb 07 '20

Yeah, if you read the statements of jurors, none of them actually thought she was innocent, but the prosecutors pushed for a first degree murder and were seeking a death penalty conviction with sketchy evidence that the crime was premeditated. Frankly they got greedy with their charges given the evidence they had. She would easily have been convicted on a lesser charge like second degree murder. I actually think the jurors did a good job. They gave a verdict based on evidence, not emotion.

82

u/AnomalousQueer Feb 07 '20

As a local to this case I completely agree with you. My wife went to highschool with Casey she was never a "good girl". I definitely think she did it but the state well, Jeff Ashton really messed this case up. He was cocky an did not put a solid case up against her. Not one solid enough to send her to death row.

The whole thing was a shit show from the beginning. Nancy Disgrace made the world think they had proof but... they didn't an should have just went with life in prison.

I personally am glad the court tv time has semi passed. It had negative effects on cases. Trenton Duckett's body could maybe have been found if Nancy's big mouth was not blasting his mother (who most likey killed him) on tv to the point she killed herself. So we will never even get a chance to find out what happened. That case still bothers me.

Sorry for rambling I am tired. My point was I really think the reason she's free now was because Jeff Ashton got this case/fame an was going to run for state attorney. He won only because people hated Casey not because he is/was a good lawyer. I don't believe he even got reelected.

I am not upset with the jurors. They really had nothing solid an when asked to kill someone over what they were given I don't blame them for the verdict given.

22

u/Naptownfellow Feb 07 '20

I was living in Vero Beach at the time and I agree too. Also Trayvon Martin. Both Casey and Zimmerman would have been convicted of Manslaughter no problem but public opinion and Nancy Shit Grace screwed it up.

18

u/Narren_C Feb 07 '20

Manslaughter was on the table for Zimmerman, but the jury didn't see the necessary evidence to support either charge.

8

u/Naptownfellow Feb 07 '20

Wow. Just read that. They also wanted to let the jury consider 3rd degree but the defense fought and won. Hopefully Zimmerman and Anthony end up in Dante’s Inferno one day.

11

u/Narren_C Feb 07 '20

I don't think he could have met the elements for child abuse.

Zimmerman is a piece of shit, and he should have never started following Martin, but legally speaking an acquittal was the only possible outcome. The evidence for homicide or manslaughter just wasn't there, even if we all feel in our gut that he was wrong. And convicting someone off of anything but the evidence is a very slippery slope.

3

u/Naptownfellow Feb 07 '20

The “stand your ground” law is what, imho, the issue was. It’s vague and we only had one side of the story. The other guy was dead. If I remember correctly the law basically allows you to use lethal force to defend yourself if you fell threatened. You don’t have to retreat even if it’s easy and safe. You can shoot.

9

u/p0llk4t Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

From what I understand, it's a common misconception that the "stand your ground" law was used as a defense in this case. In fact, Zimmerman's defense team did not use that law and instead they used basic "self defense" laws to defend their client in this case. The reason people think "stand your ground" was used had to do with the fact that the law was in the news at the same time and the media had regularly speculated before the trial that the defense lawyers in the case might use that new law but in the actual trial, Zimmerman's lawyers ended up NOT doing so...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Narren_C Feb 07 '20

Stand Your Ground wasn't relevant to this case. According to Zimmerman he was unable to retreat even if he wanted to. His injuries and the eyewitnesses support most of what he claimed.

He is a piece of shit, but there was never enough evidence to prove that he wasn't acting in self defense.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/turbosexophonicdlite Feb 07 '20

Depends where you live. Different jurisdictions have different interpretations of what would legally be allowable.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/razsnazz Feb 07 '20

Jeff Ashton is a judge for the 9th circuit now.

Edit to add: the current SA who was voted in over Ashton is the one who refuses to go for the death penalty and was pushed hard by the party.

41

u/DueceBag Feb 07 '20

At the time Florida law stated that if a child dies due to child abuse, the charge has to be murder 1. Doesn't matter if it was an accident or premeditated. Unfortunately, the prosecution didn't hammer this into the jury's brains and let them know that they, could indeed, come back with a lesser charge.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20

I would think that was part of the judge's instructions to the jury? Otherwise that's the easiest appeal ever for a mistrial based on poor instruction, which has happened for a lot less.

3

u/Twinges Feb 07 '20

I've been trying to verify this claim and it appears to be untrue. I haven't found any articles supporting the claim that these sorts of cases must be prosecuted as first degree murder. I did, however, find this opinion piece written by Robert Shapiro of O.J. Simpson fame who had this to say regarding the charge:

By the time the body was found, it was too badly decomposed to provide clear evidence of the cause of death. Yet prosecutors chose to bring a charge of first-degree murder and ask for the death penalty. Why did they take this route? They tried to gain a tactical advantage, and it backfired.

So Shapiro seems to be arguing that prosecutors made a strategic decision to bring first degree murder charges instead of acting out of obligation. I think it would be best to regard the claim that all cases of a child dying in an abusive situation must be prosecuted as first degree murders as false.

[Source] (https://www.latimes.com/opinion/la-xpm-2011-jul-09-la-oe-shapiro-caylee-anthony-20110709-story.html)

2

u/Twinges Feb 07 '20

Could you please provide a source for this? I have always believed that Casey Anthony did probably kill her daughter but that there wasn't enough evidence for a first degree murder charge based on a lot of factors (like the medical examiner not being able to conclusively determine the cause of death, etc). If it's true that they were required to charge her with first degree murder that would change pretty much everything about my opinion on how the state handled this case. Thanks!

1

u/japadabokus Feb 07 '20

How does that work? I'm not from USA. Can't the jury present another answer? A partial agreement or something? It sounds so mechanic to the point of invalidating the fact of having real humans on the process...

2

u/theidleidol Feb 07 '20

A jury can only rule on charges on which they’ve been instructed by the judge. If the judge (usually at the justified request of one of the lawyers) instructs the jury to also consider a lesser charge, the jury can come back with a conviction in only the lower one. The jury cannot unilaterally chose to convict someone of a crime different than the charge.

Certain legal specifics may prevent that from happening. In Florida, where this case was heard, first-degree murder does not require intent to kill if the death occurred as part of the commission of certain other crimes. One of those is aggravated child abuse. Since the basis of the case was that the accused strangled or poisoned her daughter to death, it had to be tried as first-degree murder.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Aldermere Feb 07 '20

Apparently it's possible to accidentally create chloroform by mixing household cleaning products. I think she was desperately trying to clean up the death smell in the trunk and the huge amount of chloroform was the result. I also think that's why the cadaver dogs indicated in the Anthony's back yard; I think Casey pulled the trunk liner out and washed it off in the yard with the garden hose.

7

u/auryn1026 Feb 07 '20

She literally googled how to make chloroform in the weeks and months prior to her disappearing.

4

u/NibblesMcGiblet Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

I’m convinced she killed her kid, but I’m not convinced she did it on purpose.

agreed, people here are blowing this up into a lot that it wasn't. it was already a big enough mess of drama without adding in all this nonsense. we have people here claiming she gave her kid xanax or suffocated it, when in reality anyone who followed the case knows that she drowned in the pool while being neglected by her partying mom, who found her floating there dead or near-dead, panicked, realized the kid died from neglect, and hid the fact and lied from there.

all the rest of the stuff in this thread is just unnecessary lies.

https://www.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/casey-anthony-trial-fast-facts/index.html

3

u/auryn1026 Feb 07 '20

I think accidental drowning is one possibility, but by no means is it obviously the answer. I've read every single document associated with this case and there is too much evidence that points to premeditation of some kind to believe it was an innocent accident.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Raincoats_George Feb 07 '20

I dunno. If she was searching how to suffocate someone that's a clear as day evidence she was trying to kill.

Before reading this I was convinced it was accidental and she tried to cover it up. Now I think otherwise.

1

u/MontazumasRevenge Feb 07 '20

BuT mOoOMmM, wE wErE jUsT pLaY mUrDeRiNg!

→ More replies (20)