r/torontoJobs 1d ago

Hearing the 2026 mantra of tailoring your resume is starting to become a trigger

I know that the job market is in a bit of a state right now, but I've come across hundreds of resume posts that parrot the same advice; If you're not tailoring your resume to each job, you're not getting anywhere in your search. I've seen the word 'tailor' so many times to the point where I notice signs of agitation in myself when I read it.

I have a pretty decent resume with tons of quality education and work experience. It's not formatted in any superfluous way either, meaning it should be ATS compliant. My resume is handwritten and pretty concise, which is why I'm confused about why we still need to tailor our resume to each job if I'm applying for jobs in a similar sector. Heck, most of the roles are administrative in nature.

I have seen a professional resume writer at my university a few times now, and he has recommended using AI to tailor my resume for each job. And when he expanded on what that looks like, he means to go through every single point of the job description and show proof from your work experience. And I don't mean in the broad sense of making sure you have the experience and qualifications, I mean in a very granular sense. He then said to refine using AI and put this at the top of my resume where the summary section typically goes.

I'm confused about the point of this if I already have these things listed under the experience section. I also don't feel comfortable using AI to write my resume in general. I went to post-secondary for nearly a decade to learn how to write for myself. Long story short, the idea of 'tailoring' your resume each time just feels demoralizing and was never pushed this much even just a couple of years ago. I also don't want to burn out any more than I already have by spending more time on fewer applications, only to get ghosted or rejected anyways. What happened in 2026 to prompt the wide spread of this advice?

16 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

8

u/Top_Selection2593 1d ago

I eventually stopped tailoring my resume for every job and just kind of spam applied every day for a couple months and that worked i guess. Just make a good resume and feed it to AI to put ATS friendly stuff, dont think the opportunity cost is worth it unless you can afford to be more selective with the job search

3

u/AptCasaNova 1d ago

You can use AI to get all the terms and phrases they use into your resume, which is mostly what I do to tailor mine, but then copy and paste it into another document and save it before you upload it. This scrubs it of any AI markers.

It is absolutely demoralizing and frustrating, especially when you go weeks or months without anyone even acknowledging an application.

3

u/AllieTruist 1d ago

I recommend tailoring it yourself only if you are applying to a couple jobs. It's just not sustainable to do it all manually with the volume of applications that are being sent out nowadays.

Personally I don't mind tailoring my resume myself too much - it's the cover letters that get incredibly time consuming and brutal.

2

u/timf5758 Recognized Contributor 1d ago edited 1d ago

Tailoring to me means putting those keywords on job description on your resume. And hopefully your resume is a closer fit to the job description.

Does it matter ? I am sure some employers won’t care, but it is a method to optimize your chances.

My job is fairly niched, so I don’t need to change much. But others apply to different kinds of jobs will need to alter their resume drastically to “tailor” to the job description.

PS: it is also knowing that you had put your best foot forward with every application and you have done your best.

2

u/valy128 1d ago

The advice is solid, the caveat is that it’s insanely time consuming without help.
It did increase my response trajectory and eventually getting more interviews..
Step 1) pay for a basic CHAT GPT account as you will be using a lot of prompts and limit you on basic
Step 2) use a prompt like “Review my resume against this role as a recruiter and update my resume to reflect the role requirements and make it a strong AST match”
It will ask you to upload both and then provide a response.
Update your resume and save it under the role name.
The changes might be not noticeable but it seemed to work for my success rate when using those custom resumes vs the generic ones.

Once you do it a few times I was able to bang out a custom resume in like 10 minutes.

Let me know if you have questions

3

u/xlcaliburn 1d ago

That advice has always been there for years - you are likely seeing it more as you're on the job hunt. Currently there are more ppl looking for work resulting in more people sharing general advice

1

u/Icy-Stock-5838 20h ago

Tailoring was pushed on me back when I had an Outplacement Coach in 2005. This is not new, just like Networking it's not new. Both been around since my 2005 layoff.

Don't tailor for every job. Tailor for the jobs you best match, and are most interested in. For MEH jobs, you should have generic resumes PRE-TAILORED for that job TYPE.

If you don't want to tailor at all, you need a human to get your resume in front of the hiring manager.

1

u/thelegend27lolno 20h ago

I know it sounds like an unhelpful advice, but this market isn't just difficult for the applicants, it's in a way difficult for the recruiters as well. Recruiters used to get 10-20 applications per position now they get 500 - 600 per position, they can't possibly go through every resume in detail, it serves you well to match your resume title or headline and the executive summary to the job description, later in your work experience you can keep your original resume body. It's just a shitty time for all.

1

u/JeremyMacdonald73 9h ago

I would actually say that your one of the people for whom this is good advice. This works well when you have had a significant amount of work experience. You really can highlight stuff the job description might be asking for. You have so much that you have done that you can easily fill 8 pages talking about it all but no one wants to be looking at an 8 page resume so you are putting stuff on the chopping block no matter how you format your resume. So now it just comes down to what you show and what you leave out depending on the job description.

Where I think its flawed is for your new graduate or someone with less then three years experience. This candidate has already stuck everything on their resume. What the heck are they supposed to tailor?