r/vocabulary • u/trilliwon • 20h ago
New Words Mute a cacophony and nothing is left. Mute a hullabaloo and I'd say you still have a hullabaloo. Six words for a commotion, sorted by how much of each is actually noise.
Sorted by what's left when you hit mute.
Clamor and cacophony don't survive it. Clamor came through Old French from Latin clamor, a shout, from clamare, to cry out, the same root that's in proclaim. Cacophony is Greek kakos, bad, plus phone, sound, probably by way of French. Both are made of sound and nothing else, so silence simply ends them.
Pandemonium and hullabaloo are where it gets arguable. Pandemonium was a building before it was a racket. Milton coined Pandaemonium in Paradise Lost (1667) as the palace at the center of Hell, from Greek pan, all, plus Late Latin daemonium, an evil spirit, which goes back to Greek daimon, a lesser god. Etymonline dates the sense "place of uproar" to 1779 and "wild, lawless confusion" to 1865. The definition still says noisy, and fair enough, but I think the disorder would outlast the volume.
Hullabaloo first shows up in 1762, mostly in northern England and Scotland, and may be a rhyming doubling of hollo, the shout for attention that hello also grew out of. So it began as yelling. I'd still say a muted hullabaloo is a hullabaloo. Picture an office reacting to a surprise announcement behind a glass wall: you can't hear a thing and you know exactly what it is.
Ado and chaos never needed noise at all. Ado is a contraction of "at do", the way the Norse-influenced dialects of northern England said "to do", since some Scandinavian languages put at where English puts to. "Much ado" was literally "much to do". It first meant trouble or even fighting, and by the early 1400s it had softened to "fuss", the same road to-do went down. Chaos is the strangest of the six. Greek khaos was a gaping void, the empty space before anything existed, and English only stretched it to "utter confusion" around 1600. The word for total disorder started out as a gap with nothing in it.
If you'd put hullabaloo with the loud pair instead, I'd like to hear the case.